The Conversation -- August 17, 2023

Spirit Animals Are Attacking Jeff Clark. Josephine Harvey of the Huffington Post: "Jeffrey Clark, a former top Justice Department official under Donald Trump, is posting online about supernatural beings in the wake of his racketeering indictment in Georgia.... 'Today witches, spiritists, mediums, those with spirit animals, and Ukrainian NPCs resumed their attacks on me,' Clark wrote on X-...Twitter, on Wednesday." MB: Do you suppose Clark is working up an insanity defense?

Katherine Faulders & Jonathan Karl of ABC News: "... Donald Trump's promised press conference to refute the allegations in the indictment handed up by the Fulton County District Attorney's Office is now very much in doubt.... Trump's legal advisers have told him that holding such a press conference with dubious claims of voter fraud will only complicate his legal problems and some of his attorneys have advised him to cancel it." MB: Darn, because I thought telling more of the same lies that led to federal and state indictments was a brilliant idea. Trump should fire his lawyers for taking away his First Amendment rights. And election interference! And whatever!

Presidential Race 2024. Jonathan Swan, et al., of the New York Times: "Ron DeSantis needs 'to take a sledgehammer' to Vivek Ramaswamy, the political newcomer who is rising in the polls. He should 'defend Donald Trump' when Chris Christie inevitably attacks the former president. And he needs to 'attack Joe Biden and the media' no less than three to five times. A firm associated with the super PAC that has effectively taken over Mr. DeSantis's presidential campaign posted online hundreds of pages of blunt advice, research memos and internal polling in early nominating states to guide the Florida governor ahead of the high-stakes Republican presidential debate next Wednesday in Milwaukee.... Super PACs are barred by law from strategizing in private with political campaigns. To avoid running afoul of those rules, it is not unusual for the outside groups to post polling documents in the open, albeit in an obscure corner of the internet where insiders know to look.... But it is unusual, as appears to be the case, for a super PAC, or a consulting firm working for it, to post documents on its own website...."

~~~~~~~~~~

Peter Baker of the New York Times: "President Biden staged a day of celebration on Wednesday to herald the reduction in inflation and the Inflation Reduction Act even though experts believe one had little to do with the other. Mr. Biden hosted a boisterous ceremony in the East Room of the White House while allies and aides conducted briefings, gave speeches, published newspaper articles, sent emails, went on television and distributed talking points to mark the first anniversary of the Inflation Reduction Act, the major climate and energy law that is one of the signature accomplishments of his presidency. The fact that the anniversary came at the same time as a significant decrease in the inflation rate was more happy coincidence than anything else, say economists, who attribute it more to the Federal Reserve's interest rate increases and other factors. The legislation did plenty of important things in terms of investing in clean energy, raising corporate taxes and curbing prescription drug prices. But it was not really about inflation. As even Mr. Biden implicitly conceded last week, the name of the bill was more about political branding than policy goals."

Annie Karni of the New York Times: "Senator Chuck Schumer, the majority leader, said Wednesday that he and Speaker Kevin McCarthy had agreed that a bill to temporarily fund the government is necessary in order to stave off the possibility of an impending government shutdown on Oct. 1 and keep the government funded through early December. But his comments were also an acknowledgment that Congress remains far from reaching any agreement on spending levels that would keep the government running on a longer-term basis. 'Speaker McCarthy and I met a few weeks back, and we agreed we should do what's called a C.R. -- in other words, a congressional resolution where you just extend the existing funding for a few months so we could work this out,' Mr. Schumer said on MSNBC's 'Morning Joe.'"

Trump Crime Blotter

Olivia Rubin of ABC News: "Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis has proposed a March start date for the trial of ... Donald Trump and 18 others on charges related to efforts to overturn the 2020 election results in Georgia. The proposed pretrial scheduling order, filed on Wednesday, proposes a start date of March 4. The date is one day before Super Tuesday in the 2024 presidential race...."

This Is Irritating. Danny Hakim & Richard Fausset of the New York Times: According to the local sheriff, defendants in the case will be processed in the Fulton County Jail where "they would undergo a medical screening, be fingerprinted and have mug shots taken, and could spend time in a holding cell at the jail, weeks after the Justice Department announced an investigation for what it called 'serious allegations of unsafe, unsanitary living conditions' there.... But whether Mr. Trump himself is processed there will very likely depend on the Secret Service.... The Rice Street jail is not a place for the faint of heart, said Robert G. Rubin, a veteran defense lawyer.... In recent weeks, two inmates have been found dead at the jail. Last year, a detainee was found dead in his cell, his body covered in bites from bed bugs and other insects, according to his lawyer.... 'It's miserable. It's cold. It smells. It's just generally unpleasant,' he said, relying on his clients' past descriptions." Emphasis added. ~~~

     ~~~ Marie BTW: Yesterday, when it seemed Trump would be booked at the jail, I suggested there was a C&W song asking to be written about it, and contributor Patrick came up with some great lyrics (see Comments thread). We aren't the first to find the Fulton County jail a source of artistic inspiration. According to the Times report, "At least two songs on Spotify are titled '901 Rice Street,' the jail's address. The popular rapper Latto has a song whose title refers to Rice Street with an expletive. And a line from a Killer Mike rap goes, 'Locked in like Rice Street without a bond.'"

Aaron Blake of the Washington Post: "Donald Trump's defenses against his four indictments are, characteristically, absolutist. The phone call with Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger (R), which undergirds Trump's newest indictment, was a 'perfect phone call.' The 91 criminal charges against Trump aren't just overzealous but born of meritless 'witch hunts.' Bristling at a question about a hypothetical plea deal in Georgia, Trump said, 'We did nothing wrong.'... Increasingly, few Americans actually believe Trump did 'nothing' wrong, according to new polling. And while Republicans overwhelmingly say they don't think Trump broke the law, most -- even a very strong majority -- fault him in some measure."

Trump Revises a Toxic Racist Slur to Attack Georgia Grand Jurors. Blayne Alexander & Ryan Reilly of NBC News: "The purported names and addresses of members of the grand jury that indicted Donald Trump and 18 of his co-defendants on state racketeering charges this week have been posted on a fringe website that often features violent rhetoric, NBC News has learned. NBC News is choosing not to name the website featuring the addresses to avoid further spreading the information.... The indictment issued Monday lists the names of the grand jury members but not their addresses or other personal information. Tuesday -- after Trump posted on his social media website that authorities were going 'after those that fought to find the RIGGERS!' -- Advance Democracy said Trump supporters were 'using the term "rigger" in lieu of a racial slur' in posts.... 'These jurors have signed their death warrant by falsely indicting President Trump,' a post on a pro-Trump forum read in response to a post including the names of jurors, which was viewed by NBC News."

Alan Feuer of the New York Times: "A Texas woman has been charged with threatening to kill Tanya S. Chutkan, the federal judge in Washington who is overseeing ... Donald J. Trump's prosecution on charges of seeking to overturn the 2020 election. The woman, Abigail Jo Shry, of Alvin, Texas, called Judge Chutkan's chambers on Aug. 5, two days after Mr. Trump was arraigned on the election interference charges, and left a voice mail message attacking the judge, who is Black, with a racial slur, according to a criminal complaint unsealed on Friday. In the message, Ms. Shry told Judge Chutkan, 'If Trump doesn't get elected in 2024, we are coming to kill you, so tread lightly, bitch,' according to the complaint. She added, 'You will be targeted personally, publicly, your family, all of it.'" The AP's report is here. ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: If like me, you keep wondering what possible appeal a whiney, selfish, entitled, elderly fat man could have, Mizz Shry answers that question. Most likely, she is not a crazy person. She is the Kracken, and Donald Trump has released her. He has given her permission to degrade, threaten and even kill authority figures who irritate her. Trump has transferred power from those charged with enforcing the rule of law & normal "fairness" to individual Americans who have long felt that "fairness" means that they have the freedom and individual right to harm anyone who displeases them. Trump thought he had "an Article II where I have the right to do whatever I want," and every surly, ragtag Trumpbot believes Trump has transferred that same right to them.

Gideon Rubin of the Raw Story: "Longtime GOP operative and Donald Trump ally Roger Stone is shown hatching plans to overturn the 2020 election before the results were even known in a video obtained by MSNBC host Ari Melber. The video, which the cable network released publicly on Wednesday..., shows Stone ... dictating the plans to an associate on Nov. 5, 2020, two days after Election Day. The statement outlines plans to compel state legislatures to overturn close races by claiming election fraud." Includes video.

Kaitlan Collins & Paula Reid of CNN: "With his attorney in tow, Rudy Giuliani traveled to Mar-a-Lago in [late April] on a mission to make a personal and desperate appeal to ... Donald Trump to pay his legal bills. By going in person, a source familiar with the matter told CNN, Giuliani and his lawyer Robert Costello believed they could explain face-to-face why Trump needed to assist his former attorney with his ballooning legal bills.... But the former president ... didn't seem very interested. After Costello made his pitch, Trump verbally agreed to help with some of Giuliani's legal bills without committing to any specific amount or timeline. Trump also agreed to stop by two fundraisers for Giuliani, a separate source said.... But what has surprised those in Trump's inner circle is the former president's unwillingness to pay for Giuliani's bills, given Giuliani could find himself under intense pressure to cooperate with the federal and state prosecutors who have charged Trump."

Michael Gold & Grace Ashford of the New York Times: "A campaign associate of Representative George Santos who impersonated Speaker Kevin McCarthy's former chief of staff was charged with wire fraud and identity theft in a federal indictment unsealed on Wednesday. The aide, Samuel Miele, was arraigned Wednesday morning in Brooklyn federal court and released on $150,000 bond. He has pleaded not guilty. He was accused by federal prosecutors of sending 'fraudulent fund-raising' emails to more than a dozen potential contributors to an unnamed candidate. In those messages, he claimed to be a 'high-ranking aide to a member of the House with leadership responsibilities,' the indictment said. When Mr. Miele successfully solicited campaign contributions, he received a 15 percent commission, according to the indictment." Also linked yesterday. An NBC News story is here.

Lauren Sforza of the Hill: "A Republican lawmaker apologized Tuesday for a 'religious freedom' tweet he posted earlier that day after receiving backlash from both sides of the aisle. Rep. Max Miller (R-Ohio) asked Lizzie Marbach, director of communications at Ohio Right to Life, to delete one of her posts on X...-Twitter, that said there is 'no hope for any of us outside of having faith in Jesus Christ alone.' 'This is one of the most bigoted tweets I have ever seen. Delete it, Lizzie. Religious freedom in the United States applies to every religion. You have gone too far,' he posted on X. Just hours after that post, Miller apologized for the tweet." MB: Miller's mistake was the tone of his tweet, particularly because he's a public official, and he gives the dimwitty lady a command. But the sentiment? I'm with Miller. Marbach's tweet is a straightforward expression of religious bigotry. Also linked yesterday.

American Nightmare. Matt Berg of Politico: Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution she had not ruled out the possibility of running for the Senate. And she would consider "very heavily" (which must be like considering "very strongly") accepting the V.P. spot on a Trump ticket. Also linked yesterday.

Pam Belluck & Adam Liptak of the New York Times: "A federal appeals court panel said on Wednesday that the abortion pill mifepristone should remain legal in the United States but with significant restrictions on patients' access to it, setting up a showdown before the Supreme Court on the fate of the most common method of terminating pregnancies. The decision, which would prohibit the pill from being sent through the mail or prescribed by telemedicine, is the latest development in a closely watched lawsuit that seeks to remove abortion pills entirely from the market by invalidating the Food and Drug Administration's 23-year-old approval of mifepristone. But for now, the ruling will have no real-world effect: In April, the Supreme Court said mifepristone would have to remain available under the current rules until the appeals process concludes." Politico's story is here. ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: I see no reason to look forward to a reasonable outcome. These old fogies, none of whom has medical or scientific expertise, think that because they cannot be overruled, they should decide what doctors and scientists are allowed to determine. Power corrupts; absolute power corrupts absolutely. It is the responsibility of the first two branches of government to get together and check the absolute power of the third.

~~~~~~~~~~

Kansas. Kevin Draper & Benjamin Mullin of the New York Times: "The top prosecutor in Marion County, Kan., said on Wednesday that there was not sufficient evidence to support a raid on a local newspaper last week, and that all the devices and materials obtained in the search would be returned. Joel Ensey, the Marion County attorney, said in a statement that, in light of the insufficient evidence, he directed local law enforcement to return the seized material. Police officers and county sheriff's deputies searched the newspaper's office, the home of its owner and editor and the home of a city councilwoman on Friday -- collecting computers, cellphones and other materials. It is extremely rare for law enforcement authorities in the United States to search and seize the tools to produce journalism." See related stories linked over the past few days.

North Carolina. Rick Rojas & Anna Betts of the New York Times: "North Carolina became the latest state to block minors from having access to gender-transition care, as Republican lawmakers voted on Wednesday to override the governor's veto of a bill restricting hormone treatments, puberty blockers and surgeries for young people. The move came as the State Legislature's Republican supermajorities marshaled the votes to topple several other of Gov. Roy Cooper's [D] vetoes, reviving legislation that limits female transgender students' participation in school sports and restricts what can be taught in schools about gender and sexual orientation. North Carolina now joins about 20 other states that have enacted legislation blocking access to transition-related care for minors, with many of those laws passed this year as conservative lawmakers across the country have seized upon L.G.T.B.Q. issues." ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: I would not say that they "have seized upon L.G.T.B.Q. issues." I would say that they have cruelly seized upon a group of young people to target, and like the Supremes, have put themselves in a position to overrule the best practices of medical professionals and the natural rights of parents to participate in decisions about their children's medical treatment. I do think the government has an inherent interest in professional standards, but this is not it.

The Conversation -- August 16, 2023

Michael Gold & Grace Ashford of the New York Times: "A campaign associate of Representative George Santos who impersonated Speaker Kevin McCarthy's former chief of staff was charged with wire fraud and identity theft in a federal indictment unsealed on Wednesday. The aide, Samuel Miele, was arraigned Wednesday morning in Brooklyn federal court and released on $150,000 bond. He has pleaded not guilty. He was accused by federal prosecutors of sending 'fraudulent fund-raising' emails to more than a dozen potential contributors to an unnamed candidate. In those messages, he claimed to be a 'high-ranking aide to a member of the House with leadership responsibilities,' the indictment said. When Mr. Miele successfully solicited campaign contributions, he received a 15 percent commission, according to the indictment."

Lauren Sforza of the Hill: "A Republican lawmaker apologized Tuesday for a 'religious freedom' tweet he posted earlier that day after receiving backlash from both sides of the aisle. Rep. Max Miller (R-Ohio) asked Lizzie Marbach, director of communications at Ohio Right to Life, to delete one of her posts on X...-Twitter, that said there is 'no hope for any of us outside of having faith in Jesus Christ alone.' 'This is one of the most bigoted tweets I have ever seen. Delete it, Lizzie. Religious freedom in the United States applies to every religion. You have gone too far,' he posted on X. Just hours after that post, Miller apologized for the tweet." MB: Miller's mistake was the tone of his tweet, particularly because he's a public official, and he gives the dimwitty lady a command. But the sentiment? I'm with Miller. Marbach's tweet is a straightforward expression of religious bigotry.

American Nightmare. Matt Berg of Politico: Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene told the Atlanta Journal-Constitution she had not ruled out the possibility of running for the Senate. And she would consider "very heavily" (which must be like considering "very strongly") accepting the V.P. spot on a Trump ticket.

~~~~~~~~~~

Trump Crime Blotter

For my presidential knowledge, I am plucky and adventury,
I can never be brought down by the mischief of Jack Smithery;
Because no matter how the Jacks & Fanis try to bring me down
I am the very model of a modern presidential clown. ~~~

     ~~~ To the tune of and borrowed from the last stanza of the "Modern Major-General's Song" from Gilbert & Sullivan's "Pirates of Penzance." Thanks to contributor Patrick for the inspiration. MB: To be fair, there are hundreds of opportunities for poetic creativity in these indictments. Even as I typed it, I could feel that this next story read like the first line of a country & western song: ~~~

     ~~~ They'll be taking Trump's mugshot at the Fulton County Jail. ~~~

     ~~~ Update: We have our first stanza! See today's Comments. ~~~

     ~~~ MB: While Trump does make his perfect phone calls, sadly, it is not possible to write a perfect country and western song about him. As David Allan Coe once pronounced, the perfect C&W song must include "Mama, or trains, or trucks, or prison, or getting drunk," only one of which has much to do with Trump. The late, great Steve Goodman responded to Coe by adding a verse (in one version or another) to a song he had previously told Coe "was perfect":

I was drunk the day my mom got out of prison
And I went to pick her up in the rain
But before I could get to the station in my pickup truck
She got runned over by a damned old train.

Here is the New York Times' liveblog for Tuesday's developments in Georgia's Trump crime family indictment. ~~~

     ~~~ CNN's live Tuesday updates are here.

Ken Meyer of Mediaite: "On Tuesday morning, [Donald] Trump announced on Truth Social that he will hold a press conference next week where he will produce a 'Large, Complex, Detailed but Irrefutable REPORT on the Presidential Election Fraud which took place in Georgia.'... In a statement posted to X...-Twitter -- [Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp] flatly declared: 'The 2020 election in Georgia was not stolen.... For nearly three years now, anyone with evidence of fraud has failed to come forward -- under oath -- and prove anything in a court of law.'..." (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

     ~~~ Update. Maggie Haberman & Jonathan Swan of the New York Times: "The report..., according to people familiar with the matter, is a document of more than 100 pages that was compiled at least in part by Liz Harrington, a Trump communications aide who is often described as among the true believers in his false claims that the 2020 election was stolen from him through widespread fraud." ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: IOW, what Trump says he plans to do is exactly what Rudy did to get himself indicted in Georgia: tell big fat lies about Georgia election fraud. So, brilliant move! And, for a touch of verisimilitude, I do urge him to get the MyPillow Guy to provide charts and printouts to "back up" Trump's assertions. I can hardly wait.

Here are the 19 defendants, in alphabetical order: Robert Cheeley, Ken Chesebro, Jeffrey Clark, John Eastman, Jenna Ellis, Willie Floyd III, Rudy Giuliani, Scott Hall, Misty Hampton, Trevian Kutti, Cathy Latham, Stephen Lee, Mark Meadows, Sidney Powell, Michael Roman, David Shafer, Ray Smith, Shawn Still, Donald Trump. D.A. Willis said she planned to try them all together. MB: I hope the court seats them in alphabetical order.

Trump Stiffed His Co-Conspirators. Brian Schwartz of CNBC: "Several of the attorneys who spearheaded ... Donald Trump's frenzied effort to overturn the results of the 2020 election tried, and failed, to collect payment for the work they did for Trump's political operation, according to testimony to congressional investigators and Federal Election Commission records. This is despite the fact that their lawsuits and false claims of election interference helped the Trump campaign and allied committees raise $250 million in the weeks following the November vote.... Among them was Trump's closest ally ... Rudy Giuliani.... The revelation that [Trump] likely stiffed Giuliani, a longtime friend, is all the more striking given that much of the work Giuliani did for the Trump operation is detailed in a sprawling RICO indictment in Georgia released Monday, in which Giuliani is a co-defendant.... Today, that money raised by Trump's political operation is instead helping Trump pay his own legal bills...." Also not paid: Sidney Powell, Kenneth Chesebro or John Eastman. MB: Aw shucks, this is just Trump being Trump.

Tuesday Morning. Kyle Cheney of Politico: Trump is likely to try to move the Georgia case to federal court. And he could be successful. (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

~~~ Tuesday Evening. Tierney Sneed of CNN: "Former Trump White House chief of staff Mark Meadows is seeking to move the Fulton County, Georgia, prosecution against him to federal court so that he can try to get the case dismissed under federal law. Meadows argued in a new court filing submitted in the US District Court of the Northern District of Georgia that he is entitled to bring a federal immunity defense because the Georgia state charges against him stem from his conduct as ... Donald Trump's chief of staff. Meadows is one of 19 defendants, including Trump, who were charged on Monday in the Georgia 2020 election subversion case. Meadows' request would not move the entirety of District Attorney Fani Willis' case to federal court. Rather, it would be a defendant-by-defendant endeavor. Trump, who faces 13 charges, is also expected to try to move the case to federal court, according to multiple sources familiar with the legal team's thinking.... Willis charged Meadows with violating Georgia's anti-racketeering act known as the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, or RICO, and with soliciting a public official to violate their oath. According to the docket, Meadows' removal request has been assigned to US District Judge Steve Jones, an appointee of former President Barack Obama."

Jeff Amy of the AP: “A Georgia state agency said Tuesday that it will name a special prosecutor to consider whether the state's Republican lieutenant governor should face criminal charges after ... Donald Trump and 18 of his allies were indicted Monday for working to overturn the state's 2020 election results. Lt. Gov. Burt Jones was one of 16 Republican electors who falsely claimed that Trump won Georgia. As a state senator, he also sought a special session of Georgia's Legislature aimed at overturning President Joe Biden's narrow win in the state. But Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis was barred by a judge from indicting Jones. Superior Court Judge Robert McBurney agreed with Jones that Willis, an elected Democrat, had a conflict of interest because she hosted a fundraiser for the Democrat who lost to Jones in the 2022 election for lieutenant governor. McBurney said in a hearing that Willis' decision to host the fundraiser was a 'what are you thinking?' moment."

Maggie Haberman, et al., of the New York Times: "Just days ago, the judge overseeing ... Donald J. Trump's prosecution on charges of seeking to subvert the 2020 election admonished him against violating the conditions of his release put in place at his arraignment -- including by making 'inflammatory statements' that could be construed as possibly intimidating witnesses or other people involved in the case. But Mr. Trump immediately tested that warning by posting a string of messages on his social media website, Truth Social, that largely amplified others criticizing the judge, Tanya S. Chutkan.... Mr. Trump is now probing the limits of what the criminal justice system will tolerate and the lines that Judge Chutkan sought to lay out.... Some lawyers have said that if Mr. Trump were an ordinary citizen issuing these attacks, he would be in jail by now." MB: This is just how a bratty toddler responds to a parental warning.

Release the DMs! Alan Feuer & Maggie Haberman of the New York Times: "The federal prosecutors who charged ... Donald J. Trump this month with conspiring to overturn the 2020 election got access this winter to a trove of so-called direct messages that Mr. Trump sent others privately through his Twitter account, according to court papers unsealed on Tuesday. While it remained unclear what sorts of information the messages contained and who exactly may have written them, it was a revelation that there were private messages associated with the Twitter account of Mr. Trump, who has famously been cautious about using written forms of communications in his dealings with aides and allies.... The [newly-unsealed] papers included transcripts of hearings in Federal District Court in Washington in February ... [before] Judge Beryl A. Howell...." During the proceedings, Twitter sought to tell Mr. Trump the court had ordered the company to release the direct messages to Jack Smith. "Twitter not only lost the fight but also was found to be in contempt of court for delaying complying with the warrant. Judge Howell fined the company $350,000." Politico's story is here.

Lauren Sforza of the Hill: "Former President Trump is asking for a hold on a lawsuit related to the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol due to his federal charges. The partner of Brian Sicknick, a Capitol Police officer who died after responding to the Jan. 6 insurrection, sued the former president and two rioters charged with assaulting Sicknick earlier this year. Sandra Garza alleged that Trump and the two rioters, Julian Khater and George Tanios, are 'directly and vicariously liable' for Sicknick's death.... 'Forcing President Trump to defend this case while simultaneously defending a criminal prosecution based on related conduct would undoubtedly compromise either his right to defend himself in this case, his criminal defense, or both,' his lawyers wrote in a court filing Monday."

Trump Crime Family Made Man Pleads Not Guilty. Shawn Nottingham of CNN: "Carlos de Oliveira, the Mar-a-Lago property manager, pleaded not guilty Tuesday to multiple obstruction-related offenses tied to ... Donald Trump's alleged unlawful retention of documents after leaving office, including classified material at Trump's Florida resort." (Also linked yesterday.)

(Alleged!) GOP Criminal Misses Another Disclosure Deadline. Grace Ashford & Michael Gold of the New York Times: Rep. George "Santos ... missed the Aug. 13 deadline to file his [financial] disclosures [with the House Ethics Committee], a lapse that could lead to fines. He had already received a 90-day extension from the initial deadline.... [Rep. Santos] is facing 13 felony charges related to his finances...."

Reid Epstein & Shawn Hubler of the New York Times: "President Biden said on Tuesday that he would travel to Hawaii to inspect damage on Maui after deadly wildfires ripped through the island, killing at least 99 people and devastating an entire coastal town. 'My wife, Jill, and I are going to travel to Hawaii as soon as we can,' Mr. Biden said in a speech focused on the economy at a wind and electric power manufacturing plant in Milwaukee. 'That's what I've been talking to the governor about but I don't want to get in the way.'" (Also linked yesterday.)

David Ignatius of the Washington Post: President Biden & Secretary of State Antony Blinken are "trying to foster partnerships and norms of behavior -- in dealing with China, Russia and Ukraine, as well as new challenges such as artificial intelligence -- that are broadly based and, hopefully, sustainable.... Even at a moment when American politics seems to be in free fall, this administration has kept its feet on the ground in foreign policy. That should reassure people who care about American interests -- at home and abroad." MB: This is another example of how responsible governance garners zero votes. Far fewer Americans know about Biden & Blinken's global diplomacy than believe that Donald Trump would have prevented Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

At Baylor, Harassment of LGBTQ+ Students is A-OK. Fiona Andre of the Washington Post: "The U.S. Education Department accepted Baylor University's request for exemption from Title IX's sexual harassment provision after the private Baptist school asked to dismiss discrimination complaints filed by LGBTQ+ students that the university said were 'inconsistent' with the institution's religious values."

Michael Rothfeld of the New York Times: "The former head of counterintelligence for the F.B.I. in New York pleaded guilty in federal court in Manhattan on Tuesday to a single reduced charge of conspiring to violate U.S. sanctions and laundering payments from a prominent Russian oligarch. The plea by the former agent, Charles F. McGonigal, represented a remarkable turn for a man who once occupied one of the most sensitive and trusted positions in the American intelligence community, placing him among the highest-ranking F.B.I. officials ever to be convicted of a crime.... The conspiracy charge he pleaded guilty to was newly filed by prosecutors on Tuesday, replacing the original indictment handed up by a grand jury in January that had included more serious charges of violating U.S. sanctions and laundering money.... Mr. McGonigal still faces a second indictment brought by federal prosecutors in Washington on charges that accuse him of concealing his acceptance of $225,000 from a businessman and of hiding dealings in Eastern Europe while working for the bureau. Mr. McGonigal has pleaded not guilty to those charges but is in talks to resolve them...." (Also linked yesterday.) CNN's story is here.

Rebecca Beitsch of the Hill: "Hunter Biden attorney Christopher Clark is withdrawing from representing the president's son in a Delaware probe, pointing to a continuing legal battle over a plea agreement in the tax case that dissolved before it could be approved by a judge. Clark's notice to the court indicates he could be a witness in coming challenges over the disintegration of the deal, which the Justice Department moved to withdraw minutes after Attorney General Merrick Garland elevated Delaware prosecutor David Weiss to serve as a special counsel in the matter." (Also linked yesterday.) The New York Times story is here. ~~~

~~~ Kara Scannell of CNN: "Special counsel David Weiss said the deal his team previously reached with Hunter Biden to resolve a felony gun possession charge was never approved by a probation officer and is not binding.... Biden's lawyers on Sunday said they believed an agreement to resolve a felony gun possession charge was 'valid and binding.'"

Presidential Race 2024

The Elephant in the Room -- Is Under Indictment. Reid Epstein of the New York Times: During a speech in Milwaukee, President Biden made Sen. Ron Johnson (R-Wis.) the object of his scorn but said nothing about the presidential candidate currently out on bail in three criminal cases & awaiting booking in a fourth. "'We have the best workers in the world,' Mr. Biden said. 'It's about time Ron Johnson's friends understood that.'"

~~~~~~~~~~

Kansas. Clay Risen of the New York Times: "Joann Meyer, who spent nearly 60 years as a reporter, columnist, editor and associate publisher at The Marion County Record in Kansas, died on Saturday [link fixed] at her home, a day after the police searched the newspaper's offices. She was 98. Her son, Eric Meyer, the newspaper's publisher, confirmed the death. He said that the cause had not been determined, but that the coroner had concluded that the stress of the searches -- at her home, which she shared with him, as well as at the paper's offices -- was a contributing factor.... Mr. Meyer said that his mother was in shock after the raid...."

Yes, Massachusetts, There Is a Free Lunch. Megan Cerullo of CBS News: "Every kid in Massachusetts will get a free lunch, paid for by proceeds from a new state tax on millionaires. A new 4% tax on the state's wealthiest residents will account for $1 billion of the state's $56 billion fiscal budget for 2024, according to state documents. A portion of those funds will be used to provide all public-school students with free weekday meals, according to State House News Service. The new tax, which was approved by voters last year and went into effect in 2023, applies to Massachusetts residents with incomes over $1 million."

The Conversation -- August 15, 2023

Reid Epstein & Shawn Hubler of the New York Times: "President Biden said on Tuesday that he would travel to Hawaii to inspect damage on Maui after deadly wildfires ripped through the island, killing at least 99 people and devastating an entire coastal town. 'My wife, Jill, and I are going to travel to Hawaii as soon as we can,' Mr. Biden said in a speech focused on the economy at a wind and electric power manufacturing plant in Milwaukee. 'That's what I've been talking to the governor about but I don't want to get in the way.'"

Michael Rothfeld of the New York Times: "The former head of counterintelligence for the F.B.I. in New York pleaded guilty in federal court in Manhattan on Tuesday to a single reduced charge of conspiring to violate U.S. sanctions and laundering payments from a prominent Russian oligarch. The plea by the former agent, Charles F. McGonigal, represented a remarkable turn for a man who once occupied one of the most sensitive and trusted positions in the American intelligence community, placing him among the highest-ranking F.B.I. officials ever to be convicted of a crime.... The conspiracy charge he pleaded guilty to was newly filed by prosecutors on Tuesday, replacing the original indictment handed up by a grand jury in January that had included more serious charges of violating U.S. sanctions and laundering money.... Mr. McGonigal still faces a second indictment brought by federal prosecutors in Washington on charges that accuse him of concealing his acceptance of $225,000 from a businessman and of hiding dealings in Eastern Europe while working for the bureau. Mr. McGonigal has pleaded not guilty to those charges but is in talks to resolve them...."

Here is the New York Times' liveblog for Tuesday's developments in Georgia's Trump crime family indictment. ~~~

     ~~~ CNN's live updates are here.

Ken Meyer of Mediaite: "On Tuesday morning, [Donald] Trump announced on Truth Social that he will hold a press conference next week where he will produce a 'Large, Complex, Detailed but Irrefutable REPORT on the Presidential Election Fraud which took place in Georgia.'... In a statement posted to X...-Twitter -- [Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp] flatly declared: 'The 2020 election in Georgia was not stolen.... For nearly three years now, anyone with evidence of fraud has failed to come forward -- under oath -- and prove anything in a court of law.'..." ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: IOW, what Trump says he plans to do is exactly what Rudy did to get himself indicted in Georgia: tell big fat lies about Georgia election fraud. So, brilliant move! And, for a touch of verisimilitude, I do urge him to get the MyPillow Guy to provide charts and printouts to "back up" Trump's assertions. I can hardly wait.

Kyle Cheney of Politico: Trump is likely to try to move the Georgia case to federal court. And he could be successful.

Latest Trump Crime Family Made Man Pleads Not Guilty. Shawn Nottingham of CNN: "Carlos de Oliveira, the Mar-a-Lago property manager, pleaded not guilty Tuesday to multiple obstruction-related offenses tied to ... Donald Trump's alleged unlawful retention of documents after leaving office, including classified material at Trump's Florida resort."

Rebecca Beitsch of the Hill: "Hunter Biden attorney Christopher Clark is withdrawing from representing the president's son in a Delaware probe, pointing to a continuing legal battle over a plea agreement in the tax case that dissolved before it could be approved by a judge. Clark's notice to the court indicates he could be a witness in coming challenges over the disintegration of the deal, which the Justice Department moved to withdraw minutes after Attorney General Merrick Garland elevated Delaware prosecutor David Weiss to serve as a special counsel in the matter."

~~~~~~~~~~

** The Trump Crime Blotter -- Is Really, Really Long

The devil went down to Georgia,
He was lookin' for an election to steal.
He was in a bind 'cause he was way behind
And he was willin' to make a deal.

Kyle Cheney of Politico: "A grand jury in Georgia has indicted ... Donald Trump and 18 allies on racketeering charges for a sweeping attempt to corrupt the 2020 election by subverting Joe Biden's victory in the state. Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis leveled the charges Monday night after a two-year investigation that also tagged Trump with allegations that he conspired to derail the Electoral College process, marshaled the Justice Department to bolster his scheme, pressured Georgia officials to undo the election results and repeatedly lied about fraud allegations to ratchet up pressure. In addition to Trump, Willis charged former White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows and attorneys Rudy Giuliani, John Eastman, Sidney Powell, Jeff Clark, Ken Chesebro and Jenna Ellis, key figures in Trump's bid to subvert the 2020 election. The 98-page indictment tracks several well-known aspects of Trump's conduct in the chaotic weeks that followed his defeat in the Nov. 3, 2020 election, many of which were aired by the House Jan. 6 select committee and, more recently, in a federal indictment obtained by special counsel Jack Smith. But Willis' indictment was breathtaking in its scope and is the first to charge the coterie of Trump's enablers with crimes for their efforts to help facilitate his bid to remain in power despite losing the election." ~~~

     ~~~ Key components of the indictment, via Cheney:

"Trump's bid to assemble false slates of presidential electors to foment a controversy aimed at derailing the transfer of power.... A pressure campaign by Trump, Giuliani, Eastman and others aimed at Georgia officials with responsibilities for certifying the presidential election. The filing of false claims of fraud in court documents associated with a last-ditch lawsuit by Trump to upend the results in Georgia. A breach of sensitive election equipment by Trump-aligned officials in Coffee County, Ga.... A campaign of harassment and false claims against Ruby Freeman, an election worker who became the target of pro-Trump conspiracy theories about voter fraud."

The Washington Post's story, by Holly Bailey & Amy Gardner, is here.

Here is the indictment, via Politico. (The caption itself is four pages long.) The New York Times has an annotated version of the indictment here. ~~~

Trump and the other defendants charged in this indictment refused to accept that Trump lost, and they knowingly and willfully joined a conspiracy to unlawfully change the outcome of the election in favor of Trump. -- P. 14 of the indictment

The New York Times' liveblog of developments Monday and into the morning Tuesday is here. Reporters' commentary below, in FILO order. At the top of the liveblog, there is now a summary story, which probably will morph into a stand-alone story sometime today. ~~~

~~~ Richard Fausset & Danny Hakim: "... Donald J. Trump has until no later than noon on Aug. 25 to voluntarily surrender to authorities in Fulton County, Fani T. Willis, the district attorney, said on Monday." ~~~

~~~ Fausset: "Trump's lawyers denounced the indictment in a statement, calling the day's events 'shocking and absurd.'" ~~~

~~~ James McKinley: D.A. "Willis ... said she had no political motive for bringing the indictment, as Trump has claimed." ~~~

~~~ McKinley: "The indictment spells out 161 separate acts that prosecutors say were taken to further the alleged criminal conspiracy, including events like Rudy Giuliani's false testimony about election fraud to Georgia lawmakers in early December and ... Donald Trump's telephone call in 2020 to the Georgia secretary of state in early January to urge him to 'find' about 12,000 votes." ~~~

~~~ Fausset: "The three electors charged in the indictment are David Shafer..., the former chair of the state Republican Party; State Senator Shawn Still; and Cathy Latham, who was the head of the Coffee County Republican Party at the time."

~~~ Maggie Haberman: "At the heart of this case, as in the federal one, is lying in service of using the apparatus of government to influence events."~~~

~~~ Fausset: "Prosecutors describe the 'criminal enterprise' as one that operated not only in Fulton County, Ga., but also in other states, including Arizona, Michigan, Nevada, New Mexico, Pennsylvania, and Wisconsin, and in the District of Columbia. This underscores the power of a racketeering charge: Ms. Willis did not have to show that all of the acts took place in her jurisdiction." ~~~

~~~ Alan Feuer: "The indictment laid out eight ways the 'enterprise' obstructed the election: by lying to the Georgia state legislature, by lying to state officials, by creating fake pro-Trump electors, by harassing election workers, by soliciting Justice Department officials, by soliciting Vice President Mike Pence, by breaching voting machines and by engaging in a cover up."

~~~ Haberman: "Giuliani, who once prosecuted mobsters, has been indicted in a racketeering case."

CNN's live updates of developments Monday, and Tuesday morning, are here.

Who's Who in Georgia's (Alleged!) Criminal Elite. The New York Times has thumbnail bios of the (alleged!) perps here. The Washington Post's defendant sketches are less sketchy, than the Times'.

Aaron Blake of the Washington Post: "A core Trump defense in the federal Jan. 6 case is the idea that he was merely exercising free speech. But that defense won't work as easily in Georgia, which has a broad prohibition against making 'a false, fictitious, or fraudulent statement or representation ... in any matter within the jurisdiction of any department or agency of state government.'... The phrase 'false statement' appear[s in the indictment] more than 100 times.... Another frequently included crime is solicitation of violation of public oath by a public officer. Essentially, this amounts to asking someone to violate their sworn duties.... Unlike the federal trials (unless the rules change), [the Georgia trial] should be televised."

Oops! Just Testing! Timothy Ahmann of Reuters: "The Fulton County, Georgia, court's website briefly posted a document on Monday listing several criminal charges against ... Donald Trump that appeared related to his attempts to overturn his 2020 election defeat in the state, before taking the document down without explanation. The Fulton County District Attorney's office said in a statement that no charges had been filed against Trump. The document was dated Aug. 14 and named Trump, citing the case as 'open.'... The two-page document cites the 'Violation Of The Georgia Rico (Racketeer Influenced And Corrupt Organizations) Act,' 'Solicitation Of Violation Of Oath By Public Officer,' 'Conspiracy To Commit False Statements and Writings' and 'Conspiracy To Commit Forgery in the First Degree,' among other charges listed." (Also linked yesterday.)

Kyle Cheney of Politico: "Donald Trump slammed the judge presiding over his newest criminal case early Monday, testing her three-day-old warning that he refrain from 'inflammatory' attacks against those involved in his case. In a Truth Social post just before 1 a.m., Trump assailed U.S. District Court Judge Tanya Chutkan as 'highly partisan' and 'very biased and unfair,' citing as evidence a statement she made during the sentencing of a woman who participated in the mob that breached the Capitol on Jan. 6, 2021." Thanks to Akhilleus for the link. (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: Trump's lawyers must have read him the riot act. The last time a judge ordered him to put a lid on it, it took Trump less than 24 hours to defy the order. This time it took him like two-and-a-half whole days! Amazing! Akhilleus suspects (as do I) that we're going to be reading, "Trump D.C. Trial to Start Next Week" sooner rather than later.~~~

     ~~~ Common Dreams: "... Donald Trump on Monday told Georgia's former lieutenant governor, Geoff Duncan, not to testify before the Fulton County grand jury ... in the state's 2020 election interference case. 'I am reading reports that failed former Lt. Governor of Georgia, Jeff [sic] Duncan, will be testifying before the Fulton County Grand Jury. He shouldn't,' Trump wrote on Truth Social. 'I barely know him but he was, right from the beginning of this Witch Hunt, a nasty disaster for those looking into the Election Fraud that took place in Georgia.'... 'This is witness tampering and obstruction of justice,' wrote Glenn Kirschner, an NBC News legal analyst. 'Trump indicates he knows a witness is about to testify before the grand jury, and he states -- unequivocally and directly -- "he shouldn't.'... I expect we'll see these crimes charged.'" ~~~

     ~~~ Kirschner also noted on MSNBC that judges in his criminal trials have specifically warned him against tampering with witnesses, and said his engaging in witness tampering could lead to his bail's being revoked. MB: Trump does seem to want to go to jail where, with any luck, he could be taped for a campaign video clutching the bars and screaming, "Joe Biden stole my freedom of speech!"

Jamie Gangel & Jack Forrest of CNN: "Nearly a dozen Republican-appointed former judges and high-ranking federal senior legal officials on Monday endorsed the January 2, 2024, trial date proposed by special counsel Jack Smith in his 2020 election interference criminal case against Donald Trump. The amicus brief was submitted to the United States District Court for the District of Columbia as a project of the Democracy 21 Education Fund in the January 6, 2021, case against Trump. It comes as the former president and his team look to push the case until after the election, though the final decision on a trial date will come down to presiding Judge Tanya Chutkan. Her decision is likely to come by the end of this month. The brief, which stresses a speedy trial is in the American public's interest, amounts to a considerable rebuke of Trump's legal team's calls for the proceedings to be drawn out. The Republican credentials of its authors fly in the face of the former president's repeated argument that his trial's timeline is a partisan exercise against him."

Jonah Bromwich of the New York Times: "The New York judge [Juan Merchan] presiding over the criminal case against Donald J. Trump in Manhattan has declined to remove himself from the proceedings, a loss for the former president...." (Also linked yesterday.)

Michael Schmidt of the New York Times: "Hunter Biden told a federal judge late Sunday that the Justice Department was trying to renege on a major part of his deal with the government -- his agreement to enroll in a diversion program for gun offenders -- that he signed and granted him broad immunity from future federal prosecutions. The move, included in a court filing by Mr. Biden's lawyer, Christopher Clark, is the latest salvo in the back and forth between Mr. Biden and David C. Weiss, a Trump appointee who is leading the long-running investigation into the president's son's conduct. Shortly after Attorney General Merrick B. Garland elevated Mr. Weiss to special counsel, government lawyers said in court papers on Friday that they and Mr. Biden were at an impasse over plea negotiations and that no agreement had been reached.... But in the filing late Sunday, Mr. Biden rebutted prosecutors' claim, saying that he had signed the agreement in court last month and that he planned to abide by it.... In June..., both sides announced that they had reached a deal." (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: Something is weird here, and I don't think it's Hunter. Clark & Weiss are both attorneys experienced in the fields in which they're working, so I don't see how they could so royally cock this up.

The Double Life of an FBI Spy. Michael Rothfeld, et al., of the New York Times: "Apart from his outward image as a wholesome and responsible G-man..., there was another, less visible side to [Charles McGonigal], federal prosecutors and his former colleagues say. He held off-the-books meetings with foreign politicians and businessmen and accepted illicit payments while doing favors for associates, according to federal indictments filed against him in two states earlier this year.... A close look at Mr. McGonigal's life and career reveals an arc that appears ... to be a quintessentially American story about greed.... Now, Mr. McGonigal, 55, appears set to become one of the highest-ranking F.B.I. agents ever to be convicted of a crime." Reads like a "B" spy movie: sleazy Russian oligarchs, shady Albanian wheeler-dealers, Paul Manafort (of course!) extra-marital affair with a "connected," vengeful woman. (Also linked yesterday.)

Presidential Race 2024

He Was For It Before He Was Against It Hours Later. Maggie Astor of the New York Times: "Robert F. Kennedy Jr. said Sunday that he supported a federal ban on abortion after the first trimester of pregnancy, then quickly backtracked -- underscoring both his ideologically uncomfortable position within the Democratic primary field and the deep salience of abortion in next year's election. Mr. Kennedy, who is running against President Biden, made his comments at the Iowa State Fair after an NBC News reporter asked whether he would sign a bill codifying the right to abortion once protected by Roe v. Wade." (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

     ~~~ David Cohen of Politico: Kennedy's campaign said he "misunderstood the question." MB: That's funny, because here's his answer: "I believe a decision to abort a child should be up to the women during the first three months of life.... Once a child is viable, outside the womb, I think then the state has an interest in protecting the child." Ali Vitali of NBC News: "So you would cap it at 15 weeks?" Kennedy: "Yes, three months." I don't think it was the question he misunderstood; I think he misunderstood Democratic voters' antipathy to a federal abortion ban, something about which his "campaign," in the form of someone living on Planet Earth, informed him. (Also linked yesterday.)

Arkansas. Dana Goldstein of the New York Times: "... the Arkansas Department of Education warned schools on Monday -- the first day of classes in many districts — not to offer Advanced Placement African American Studies. Like Florida, which refused to approve the class, the department suggested that the course violated state law. In Arkansas, new legislation, passed in March, prohibits 'teaching that would indoctrinate students with ideologies' such as critical race theory. In Little Rock, students at Central High School -- the site of a battle for school desegregation in 1957 -- had already enrolled in the Advanced Placement course when the district received word from the state over the weekend that it could be offered only for 'local credit.' That appears to mean that the state will not help students at six high schools pay the $98 fee to take the end-of-course A.P. exam, which is necessary if students wish to earn college credit for the class.... In a statement, the Little Rock School District said that it would 'explore options that will allow our students to fully benefit from this course' despite the decision, and that it would 'decide the next steps within 24 to 48 hours.'" ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: We should all be stunned by the fear, hatred & bigotry at the heart of those responsible for depriving Central High students of a course on the importance of their own school to American history. They call themselves educators; they call themselves legislators; she calls herself governor. They are all dishonorable.

Kansas. Katie Robertson of the New York Times: "A lawyer for The Marion County Record, a Kansas newspaper that was raided by the police late last week, demanded that the town's Police Department not review any information on the devices it seized until a court hearing could be scheduled.... The searches were part of investigation into how a document containing information about a local restaurateur found its way to and was handled by The Record -- and whether the restaurant owner's privacy was violated in the process. A search warrant issued by a judge on Friday morning cited potential violations of laws involving identity theft and the illegal use of a computer.... A spokeswoman for the Kansas Bureau of Investigation said that as of Monday the bureau was the lead law enforcement agency investigating the incidents in Marion County."

Montana Kid Power! Mike Baker of the New York Times: "A judge in Montana ruled on Monday that young people in the state have a constitutional right to a healthful environment, finding in a landmark case that the state's failure to consider climate change when evaluating new projects was causing harm. The case, brought by a group of young Montana residents ranging in age from 5 to 22, is the first of its kind to go to trial in the United States.... In her ruling, Kathy Seeley, a district court judge, found that the state's emissions 'have been proven to be a substantial factor' in affecting the climate." (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: How do you suppose Clarence, Sam & Neil feel about that? And will John Roberts write a deciding opinion arguing that, "The way to stop climate change is to stop talking about climate change"?

In yesterday's Comments, RAS has some good news for Oregon voters: ~~~

~~~ Oregon. Sharon Zhang of TruthOut: "For years, Oregon Republicans have been blocking bill after bill in the state legislature through a drastic tactic: skipping town to break quorum. Now, Oregon officials are saying that the Republicans who have obstructed votes this way at least 10 times are going to be barred from running for re-election in 2024. This week, Oregon Secretary of State LaVonne Griffin-Valade confirmed that she intends to enforce Measure 113, which disqualifies lawmakers with more than 10 unexcused absences from serving in office next term. The measure passed in 2022 by a landslide, with nearly 70 percent of voters in favor." (Also linked in yesterday's Comments.)

Tennessee. Kyle Melnick of the Washington Post: "A former Tennessee state senator was sentenced Friday to nearly two years in prison for violating campaign finance laws while running for Congress -- charges the Republican once described as a 'witch hunt' before he pleaded guilty to them. Brian Kelsey, who unsuccessfully tried in March to take back his guilty plea, was sentenced to 21 months in prison after a hearing in the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee. He was accused of concealing the transfer of $91,000 to a national political organization that supported Kelsey's 2016 congressional campaign. The 45-year-old can no longer run for state office, according to his attorney." (Also linked yesterday.)

Marie: Oh, my stars! Whoevah would think a lovely Christian Representative of the People would use foul language & show disrespect for the law? ~~~

~~~ Texas. Patrick Svitek of the Texas Tribune: "Newly released video shows U.S. Rep. Ronny Jackson, R-Amarillo, being slammed to the ground by police and angrily confronting a state trooper with profanity during a hectic altercation late last month at a rodeo outside Amarillo. 'You are a fucking full-on dick!' Jackson told the trooper after being brought off the ground, according to bodycam footage provided by the Department of Public Safety. 'You better recalculate, motherfucker!'... Jackson tweeted Monday night that he was 'glad' the video was out and criticized the authorities for 'incompetence,' singling out the Carson County sheriff, Tam Terry.... His office has emphasized he was 'not drinking,' though the sheriff's report challenges that assertion." Includes short video & link to longer video. The audio is mostly missing from the video the Texas Tribune obtained in an FOIA request. ~~~

     ~~~ Marie: Of course I'm not a doctor, but I'm damned sure this is not how I would react if I were trying to convince someone I was a competent medical professional qualified to help a person in distress. My interpersonal skills are somewhat wanting, but I'm pretty sure that screaming "You are a fucking full-on dick!" is not persuasive. It's hardly surprising that the sheriff isn't convinced Ronny was sober. Ronny has a history; this was not his first rodeo.