The Commentariat -- May 7, 2019

Afternoon Update:

Nicholas Fandos, et al., of the New York Times: “The White House stepped in on Tuesday to stop Donald F. McGahn II, the former White House counsel, from handing over documents subpoenaed by House investigators because President Trump may want to assert executive privilege over them. The current White House counsel, Pat Cipollone, instructed the House Judiciary Committee to redirect to the White House its requests for the records, which relate to key episodes of possible obstruction of justice identified by Robert S. Mueller III, the special counsel. His move was certain to enrage Democrats who are increasingly at odds with the Trump administration over access to witness and records that they say they need to conduct legitimate investigations. 'The White House provided these records to Mr. McGahn in connection with its cooperation with the special counsel's investigation and with clear understanding that the records remain subject to the control of the White House for all purposes,' Mr. Cipollone wrote in a letter to the committee's chairman, Representative Jerrold Nadler, Democrat of New York."

New York Times Editors: "As to whether Congress may obtain a president's tax returns, there is no ambiguity: Federal law empowers the chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee to submit a written request to the Treasury Department, which oversees the Internal Revenue Service, for 'any return or return information.' The Treasury secretary then 'shall furnish' the requested information to the committee so that it may conduct its legislative functions. Perhaps that statute is not clear enough for Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin. The secretary on Monday rebuffed just such a request.... The Treasury secretary cited no authority for this stonewalling, which is consistent with the Trump administration's broad resistance to congressional oversight and the president's push to quash any investigation into his finances."

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: Trump either gambled or was assured that Mueller would not indict him for any of his bad acts, which probably figured into his decision to take his then-lawyers' advice to allow White House staff like McGahn to cooperate with Mueller. Now, as the stakes rise to impeachment, he is cutting off all, or nearly all, cooperation.

Adam Edelman of NBC News: “FBI Director Chris Wray said Tuesday that he would not describe the federal government's surveillance, such as that conducted on ... Donald Trump's 2016 campaign, as 'spying,' as Attorney General William Barr has. During a Senate Appropriations subcommittee hearing, Wray was asked by committee member Sen. Jeanne Shaheen, D-N.H., about Barr's statement last month that 'spying did occur' on the Trump campaign.... Barr had also said he was "reviewing the conduct" of the FBI's Russia probe during the summer of 2016.... 'I was very concerned by his use of the word spying, which I think is a loaded word,' Shaheen said. 'When FBI agents conduct investigations against alleged mobsters, suspected terrorists, other criminals, do you believe they're engaging in spying when they're following FBI investigative policies and procedures?' 'That's not the term I would use,' Wray replied. 'So I would say that's a no....' Asked if he had 'any evidence that any illegal surveillance' into the Trump 2016 campaign occurred, Wray said he did not." Mrs. McC: Barr is Wray's boss.

Catie Edmundson of the New York Times: "Senator Mitch McConnell, the majority leader, called on Congress on Tuesday to move on from the Mueller report and issued his own verdict from the Senate floor: 'Case closed.'... Mr. McConnell's speech pointed up the profound gap between the Republican-controlled Senate and the Democrat-controlled House. House Democrats are locked in an escalating fight with President Trump, who is trying to slam shut House investigations of all sort."

In short order, the entire planet could be like a crime scene with the gigantic carbon footprints of Trump and his industry donors all around the body. -- Akhilleus, in today's Comments

~~~~~~~~~~

The Trump Scandals, Ctd.

** Alan Rappeport of the New York Times: "The Treasury Department said on Monday that it would not release President Trump's tax returns to Congress, defying a request from House Democrats and setting up a legal battle likely to be resolved by the Supreme Court. Steven Mnuchin, the Treasury secretary, wrote in a letter to Representative Richard E. Neal, Democrat of Massachusetts and the chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee, that Mr. Neal's request for the tax returns 'lacks a legitimate legislative purpose' and that he was not authorized to disclose them. The decision came after weeks of delays as Mr. Mnuchin said that his department and the Justice Department needed to study the provision of the tax code that Democrats were using to seek six years' worth of the president's personal and business tax returns." ...

     ... Mrs. Mcrabbie Note to Steve, you arrogant prick: Congress, being the legislative branch and all, decides what constitutes "a legitimate legislative purpose." Plus which, there's a law that sez the IRS must turn over tax returns to the Congress upon request. Plus which, for the last half-century, every other major party presidential nominee has released his (or her!) tax returns. We all want to know what Trump is hiding. And you have to show us.

** Matt Zapotosky of the Washington Post: "More than del>370 450 former federal prosecutors who worked in Republican and Democratic administrations have signed on to a statement asserting special counsel Robert S. Mueller III's findings would have produced obstruction charges against President Trump -- if not for the office he held. The statement -- signed by myriad former career government employees as well as high-profile political appointees -- offers a rebuttal to Attorney General William P. Barr's determination that the evidence Mueller uncovered was 'not sufficient' to establish that Trump committed a crime.... 'We emphasize that these are not matters of close professional judgment,' they [wrote].... To look at these facts and say that a prosecutor could not probably sustain a conviction for obstruction of justice -- the standard set out in Principles of Federal Prosecution -- runs counter to logic and our experience.' The statement is notable for the number of people who signed it -- 375 as of Monday afternoon -- and the positions and political affiliations of some on the list.... Among the high-profile signers are Bill Weld, a former U.S. attorney and Justice Department official in the Reagan administration who is running against Trump as a Republican; Donald Ayer, a former deputy attorney general in the George H.W. Bush Administration; John S. Martin, a former U.S. attorney and federal judge appointed to his posts by two Republican presidents; Paul Rosenzweig, who served as senior counsel to independent counsel Kenneth W. Starr; and Jeffrey Harris, who worked as the principal assistant to Rudolph W. Giuliani when he was at the Justice Department in the Reagan administration. The list also includes more than 20 former U.S. attorneys and more than 100 people with at least 20 years of service at the Justice Department -- most of them former career officials. The signers worked in every presidential administration since that of Dwight D. Eisenhower." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...

     ... Here's the full statement, with a list of signatories which is being updated. BTW, the list is searchable, if you're looking for your favorite prosecutor. Update: Looks as if the number of signatories is up to 566 as of 5:30 am ET Tuesday. ...

... Kevin Drum: "It's not even a close call. This is the mirror opposite of what happened to Hillary Clinton. In his press conference, James Comey said that case also wasn't a close call. Clinton might have made some mistakes, but it was clear that she didn't knowingly violate any laws. But that made no difference to Republicans. The chanted 'Lock her up' regardless, just as they'll refuse to do anything about Trump even though he is guilty. Hell, Trump is straight-up retweeting white nationalists these days and Republicans won't even suggest that maybe he should stop. Still, if DOJ won't prosecute, Congress can still initiate impeachment proceedings. What else should be done in the case of a president who, unquestionably and deliberately, has serially violated the law and shows no signs of stopping?" ...

... Martin Longman in the Washington Monthly: "If Pelosi stands in the way, she'll be putting 'our whole system of justice at risk.' At least, that's what these ... former prosecutors are saying." ...

Nicholas Fandos & Charlie Savage of the New York Times: "The House Judiciary Committee will vote Wednesday to hold Attorney General William P. Barr in contempt of Congress, after the Justice Department appeared to miss a Monday deadline to negotiate the delivery of Robert S. Mueller III's full report, along with key evidence collected by the special counsel. Democrats said the vote could still be avoided if the Justice Department changes course, but Monday's announcement sets up another dramatic escalation in a growing dispute between the legislative and executive branches. If the full House follows suit and votes to hold Mr. Barr in contempt of Congress, it would be only the second time in American history that a sitting member of a president's cabinet has been sanctioned by lawmakers that way. The Judiciary Committee's chairman, Representative Jerrold Nadler of New York, said the vote would occur at 10 a.m. A 27-page report accompanying the vote notice on Monday recommends that Mr. Barr 'shall be found to be in contempt of Congress for failure to comply with a congressional subpoena.'" The report includes a good summary of the Republican House's holding former AG Eric Holder in contempt. (Also linked yesterday.) ...

... Kyle Cheney & Andrew Desiderio of Politico: "The Justice Department on Monday tried to head off a contempt of Congress proceeding against Attorney General William Barr, offering House Judiciary Chairman Jerry Nadler (D-N.Y.) the chance to negotiate about the committee's subpoena for special counsel Robert Mueller' unredacted report. In a letter to Nadler, Assistant Attorney General Stephen Boyd invited the chairman to a negotiation session on Wednesday to discuss an' acceptable accommodation' that would potentially give more lawmakers access to a less-redacted version of the report, in addition to 'possible disclosure of certain materials' cited in Mueller's report.... Nadler said he would put the contempt proceedings on hold if the Justice Department engages in a 'good-faith' effort to give Democrats access to the requested information."

Amber Phillips of the Washington Post: "In an interview published in the New York Times over the weekend, House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) accused President Trump of something remarkable: She feared he would not be willing to give up power peacefully in 2020 if the election were close.... Like clockwork, Trump showed the world the very next day why Pelosi had reason to be privately worried about this for years.... Trump tweeted Sunday that his first two years were 'stolen' (actually, he originally said they were 'stollen' before he fixed his tweet) by special counsel Robert S. Mueller III's investigation.... I guess we need to say this: Giving a president extra time to be president because there was a legitimate investigation related to his conduct is a remarkably undemocratic idea." ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: What is really remarkable is that Trump is laying the groundwork not to leave office under any circumstance other than over his cold, dead body. He had previously said he would enlist his buddies on the Supreme Court to intervene if Congress tried to impeach him, even tho the Court has no authority to rule on impeachment. He has already claimed the 2016 vote count was rigged, & he really won the popular vote. If by some nearly-impossible chance the Senate were to convict & remove him from office or if he should lose the Electoral College in 2020, I think it's highly likely he would look for ways to combat either result. Even if he manages to serve a full two terms, I think he'd ask for the stollen & try to stay on after January 2025. And perhaps he could. By then, he would certainly own the Supreme Court. I'm not crazy; I'm looking at leading indicators. ...

... Chris Cillizza of CNN: "... Trump has a long record of making wholly unsubstantiated claims about election results. And that includes doing so in an election -- 2016 -- in which he won! It's not much of a stretch then to imagine that Trump, if he does come up short in the 2020 election, wouldn't be willing to simply go quietly into that good night.... If you think that's overstating things, it's worth noting that Trump has repeatedly 'joked' about changing the Constitution to allow him to serve more than two terms as president." ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: AND there's this, which I'd been thinking about as well. Steve M.: "... Trump is a lifelong resident of New York City -- a place where the two mayors who preceded the current mayor [Giuliani & Bloomberg ]both sought to sidestep the law and have their terms extended. One [Bloomberg] succeeded." ...

... ** Dahlia Lithwick of Slate: "... the notion that Democrats should somehow circumvent a president who evinces no respect for the law by persuading him that this time he lost for realz strikes me as demented. Donald Trump won't accept a 2020 presidential election loss, whether it's by a large margin or a small one, for the same reason he never accepted his 2016 popular vote loss -- None of this is news to Nancy Pelosi, but unfortunately, putting one's faith in the elections system makes even less sense today than it did in 2016. As Jamelle Bouie observes, we are now in the epicenter of an all-out vote suppression crisis that has become an all-out democracy crisis.he doesn't like it, and so he won't let it be true.... Time and time again, people who had access to both information and power opted to take the less draconian path because they believed that there would still be a free and fair election and that Trump would not win it. We know how that turned out.... The Rule of Law still matters, and we shouldn't abandon it because this small problem of Donald Trump might go away in 2020." ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: Lithwick seems to be seeing reality a lot more clearly than is Pelosi.

Michael Tackett & Maggie Haberman of the New York Times: "Two people close to Mr. Trump said he had been moving toward an objection to Mr. Mueller testifying over the last few days as a counter to the call from some Democrats to impeach Mr. Barr for how he handled his own testimony last week to Congress." ...

... Michael Balsamo & Jonathan Lemire of the AP: "Special counsel Robert Mueller was expected to step down days after concluding his investigation in March. Yet he remains a Justice Department employee -- and the department won't say why. That's just one of the complications at play in the high-stakes, secret negotiations over whether Mueller will testify before Congress. Whatever role Mueller now has, keeping him on the Justice Department payroll offers one clear advantage to ... Donald Trump's administration: It makes it easier for Attorney General William Barr to block Mueller from testifying before Congress.... As a private citizen, Mueller could decide whether to accept an invitation to appear or, if he declines, whether to attempt to resist any effort to subpoena him.... The president stewed for days about the prospect of the media coverage that would be given to Mueller, a man Trump believes has been unfairly lionized across cable news and the front pages of the nation's leading newspapers for two years, according to three White House officials and Republicans close to the White House. Trump feared a repeat -- but bigger -- of the February testimony of his former lawyer and fixer, Michael Cohen, which dominated news coverage and even overshadowed a nuclear summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong Un in Vietnam." ...

... Update. Staff Says Trump Doesn't Know What He's Doing. Darren Samuelsohn, et al., of Politico: "When ... Donald Trump contradicted his own attorney general and declared on Sunday that special counsel Robert Mueller 'should not testify' before Congress, he caught his inner circle by surprise. A day later, more than a dozen people from Trump's close orbit downplayed in interviews the prospect that the president's weekend tweet about Mueller should be taken as an official warning. Trump does not actually intend to assert executive privilege and block the special counsel from testifying as soon as next week, they said, before the one House committee with the power to begin impeachment proceedings against the president. Like so many other controversies ignited by Trump's social media feed, this one may be more bluster than a live-wire legal showdown."

Jordyn Hermani of Politico: "Donald Trump's former personal lawyer Michael Cohen said Monday that 'there still remains much to be told' about the president, as his feud with his ex-boss continues. Cohen ... did not elaborate. He heads to federal prison in Otisville, N.Y., Monday to begin a three-year sentence for a series of tax fraud and lying charges." (Also linked yesterday.) ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: So Michael Cohen is in jail now, & the guy who directed Cohen to commit some of the illegal acts that landed him there is sitting in the Oval Office.

Jason Leopold & Anthony Cormier of BuzzFeed News: "The Department of Justice on Monday released a new version of special counsel Robert Mueller's report..., shedding light on why significant portions of the 448-page document were redacted.... The new version was released by the Department of Justice in response to a Freedom of Information Act request and a subsequent lawsuit filed by BuzzFeed News and separately by the Electronic Privacy and Information Center.... This new version of the report clearly states which information was withheld because it would interfere with ongoing law enforcement proceedings, which 'would disclose techniques and procedures for law enforcement investigations or prosecutions,' and which was withheld on national security grounds.... BuzzFeed News and EPIC will now have the opportunity to challenge the legitimacy of the redactions and argue ... that overwhelming public interest compels the disclosure of additional information in the report."

Josh Marshall: "I need to return to the fact that the country's biggest paper reported this week that the President's personal lawyer [Rudy Giuliani] is conducting unofficial diplomacy abroad, apparently mixed with his own private business and investments, in which he offers friendly treatment from the President of the United States in exchange for those governments targeting the President's political enemies. This was reported and it wasn't the biggest story of the week.... The stakes are much higher, the danger much greater, when the colluding candidate is also the President of the United States [who] ... is already on to entirely new kinds of corruption and bad acting made possible by holding the presidential bundle of powers.... In this particular case it's Rudy Giuliani with the now-outgoing government of Ukraine and Joe Biden and his son....[T]his effort to get the government of Ukraine to whip up investigations into Biden ... is almost certainly just the tip of the iceberg. This requires tons more attention." -s

Kevin Freking of the AP: "... Donald Trump has pardoned a former U.S. soldier convicted in 2009 of killing an Iraqi prisoner, the White House announced Monday. Trump signed an executive grant of clemency, a full pardon, for former Army 1st Lt. Michael Behenna, of Oklahoma, press secretary Sarah Sanders said. Behenna was convicted of unpremeditated murder in a combat zone after killing a suspected al-Qaida terrorist in Iraq. He was paroled in 2014 and had been scheduled to remain on parole until 2024. A military court had sentenced Behenna to 25 years in prison. However, the Army's highest appellate court noted concern about how the trial court had handled Behenna's claim of self-defense, Sanders said. The Army Clemency and Parole Board also reduced his sentence to 15 years and paroled him as soon as he was eligible."

Ana Swanson & Keith Bradsher of the New York Times: "President Trump's top economic advisers on Monday accused China of reneging on previous commitments to resolve a monthslong trade war and said Mr. Trump was prepared to prolong the standoff to force more significant concessions from Beijing. Mr. Trump, angry that China is retreating from its commitments just as the sides appeared to be nearing a deal and confident the American economy can handle a continuation of the trade war, will increase tariffs on $200 billion worth of Chinese goods on Friday morning, his top advisers said.... Mr. Trump's decision to potentially upend an agreement that many expected to be finalized this week in Washington appears to be a political calculation that staying tough on China will be a better proposition in the 2020 campaign." ...

... CNBC: "Stocks fell on Monday after ... Donald Trump said that the U.S. will hike tariffs on goods imported from China, but managed to recover a good chunk of those losses around late-morning trading. At 11:13 a.m. ET, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was down 235 points while the S&P 500 traded 0.9% lower. The Nasdaq Composite pulled back 1%. The Dow was down as much as 471 points, while the S&P 500 traded down 1.2% at its lows. The Nasdaq was briefly down 2.2%." (Also linked yesterday.) ...

     ... CNBC Update: "Stocks recovered the bulk of their earlier losses on Monday as investors bet China and the U.S. will still strike a trade deal despite ... Donald Trump's threat to hike tariffs on Chinese imports over the weekend. The Dow Jones Industrial Average ended the day down just 66.47 points at 26,438.48, while the S&P 500 closed 0.4% lower at 2,932.47. Th Nasdaq Composite was down 0.5% at 8,123.29."

Andrew Desiderio of Politico: "The leaders of the House Foreign Affairs and Financial Services Committees are accusing the Trump administration of violating a law requiring a report on human rights abuses in Russia. Rep. Eliot Engel (D-N.Y.), the chairman of the Foreign Affairs panel, and Rep. Maxine Waters (D-Calif.), the Financial Services chairwoman, on Monday said the Trump administration is four months late to a deadline requiring a report on the U.S. government's efforts to impose sanctions on human rights abusers in Russia." --s ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: So surprising. In their long conversation last Friday, Don should have asked Vlad if there were any human rights abuses in Russia; then he could tweet the answer to Engel & Waters. Job well-done.

Steve Holland of Reuters: "At a ceremony in the sun-splashed White House Rose Garden, Trump made the 43-year-old [Tiger] Woods the fourth, and youngest, professional golfer to receive the nation's highest civilian honor, [the Presidential Medal of Freedom,] after Arnold Palmer, Jack Nicklaus and Charlie Sifford." See yesterday's Commentariat for context.

Climate Change May Alarm You, But Pompeo Sees Opportunities! Davis Richardson of the (New York) Observer: "Secretary of State Mike Pompeo appeared at the Arctic Council Ministerial Meeting in Finland to discuss the United States' commitment to the Arctic region. While much of the secretary's speech addressed the growing threats of Russia and China in the region, he also called the Arctic's melting ice caps 'new opportunities for trade' -- despite warnings from scientists that the shrinkage is caused by climate change and could become irreversible. 'Steady reductions in sea ice are opening new passageways and new opportunities for trade,' Pompeo told the room. 'This could potentially slash the time it takes to travel between Asia and the West by as much as 20 days. Arctic sea lanes could come before -- could come [sic] the 21s century Suez and Panama Canals.'"

Alan Pyke of ThinkProgress: "Mortgage lenders will find it easier to discriminate against prospective borrowers under the latest quiet sabotage of financial industry rules proposed by the Trump administration. The new rollbacks take a two-pronged approach to undermining a relatively new system that's helped journalists and watchdogs identify prejudicial lending practices they characterize as modern-day redlining. During the Obama administration, the CFPB played an instrumental role in earning settlements against banks accused of racial discrimination. These changes would do harm to the agency's continued ability to be a cop on this particular beat." --s

Josh Gerstein of Politico: "Eight former top lawyers for the House of Representatives are backing a House lawsuit seeking to block ... Donald Trump from spending billions of dollars of federal funds on a border wall without any specific authorization from Congress. Attorneys who served a bipartisan set of speakers over the past four decades filed a brief Monday urging U.S. District Court Judge Trevor McFadden to rule that the House has standing to pursue the border wall suit and that the dispute is a proper one for the courts despite the reluctance of many judges to weigh in on fights between Congress and the president."

Lee Fang of The Intercept: "Rep. Ed Royce, a senior Republican who, at the time, chaired the Foreign Affairs Committee, gave a speech on the House floor in November 2017 imploring his fellow lawmakers to maintain support for the Saudi Arabian-led war in Yemen.... Royce had received talking points earlier that day from a lobbyist retained by the kingdom of Saudi Arabia, according to federal disclosure forms, in order to undermine congressional opposition to the Yemen war.... On Thursday, the Senate is scheduled to attempt to override President Donald Trump's veto of the War Powers Act resolution calling for an end to U.S. support for the war in Yemen.... The talking points provided to Royce are among the many hidden ways in which Saudi money has quietly influenced the debate." --s ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: Royce, facing strong opposition in his Orange-LA counties California district, announced his retirement in 2018.

Presidential Race 2020

Enthusiasm, Curbed. Chuck Todd, et al., of NBC News: "Democrats had two advantages that fueled their midterm victories in November 2018 -- an edge in enthusiasm and success with independent voters. Six months later, just one of those advantages remains. In the latest NBC News/Wall Street Journal poll, 75 percent of Republican registered voters say they have high interest in the 2020 presidential election -- registering a '9' or '10' on a 10-point scale -- versus 73 percent of Democratic voters who say the same thing. That's quite a change from the 2018 cycle, when Democrats held a double-digit lead on this question until the last two months before the election, when the GOP closed the gap but still trailed the Dems in enthusiasm." ...

... Eli Yockley of the Morning Consult: "Joe Biden's stock continues to rise among the Democratic primary electorate. Morning Consult's latest 2020 tracking data measured an increase of 4 percentage points from the previous week in the share of voters who picked him as their first choice for the party's presidential nomination. It gives the former vice president a 10-point bump in the two polls conducted since he launched his bid for the presidency last month, an upward swing unmatched by any other candidate in the race. Four in 10 likely Democratic primary voters ranked Biden as their first choice in the primary, up from 36 percent in the prior week, cementing his early status as the front-runner amid attacks on his progressive bona fides from Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.)." ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: Therein, IMO, lies both cause & effect of Democratic voters' drop in enthusiasm. If Biden is the Democrats' candidate, it will be 2016 all over again. Hillary Clinton & her pals like then-DNC Chair Debbie Wasserman Schultz put their thumbs on the scale in 2016; now it looks as if the rank-and-file may be doing that job for Biden, even as the field this time around is filled with interesting, competent candidates. Odd. Of course, it's early days.

The Party of Deplorables. Stephanie Mencimer of Mother Jones: "For people who really believed President Donald Trump could be toppled by a significant primary challenge in the 2020 election, a new poll from NBC News and the Wall Street Journal should set them straight: 90 percent of Republicans polled think Trump is doing a great job as president... [N]early 70 percent of Democrats think the [Mueller] report failed to clear the president of wrongdoing, while only 11 percent of Republicans see it that way.... Trump's signature domestic achievement, his massive tax cut bill, remains highly unpopular ... even less popular with voters than Obamacare[.]" --s

Congressional Race 2020. The White People's Rifle Association. Kate Riga of TPM: "Carolyn Meadows, the new president of the National Rifle Association who harkens from Georgia, was dismissive of freshman Rep. Lucy McBath's (D-GA) victory in her 2018 race, saying McBath only won due to her status as a 'minority female.' 'There will be more than one person in the race, but we'll get that seat back,' Meadows said of the sixth district seat, per the Marietta Daily Journal. 'But it is wrong to say like McBath said, that the reason she won was because of her anti-gun stance. That didn't have anything to do with it -- it had to do with being a minority female. And the Democrats really turned out, and that's the problem we have with conservatives we don't turn out as well.'" ...

     ... Caitlin MacNeal of TPM: "... McBath responded with a series of tweets about her campaign's focus on gun control.... McBath noted that she was pushed to run for Congress after her son was murdered and that it was central to her campaign, pushing back on Meadows' argument that McBath didn't win due to her push for gun control."

Congressional Race 2018. Matt Shuham of TPM: "A staffer [Lauren Creekmore] for former Rep. Scott Taylor's (R-VA) 2018 re-election campaign has been indicted on election fraud charges, though the special prosecutor investigating the scandal said in a press release Monday that his ongoing probe has been hampered by 'the lack of cooperation of key individuals.'... Taylor's campaign had engaged in signature forgery ... to get former Democratic congressional contender on the ballot as an independent.... TPM broke the news in August that Taylor had personally tried to bury the signature forgery story." --s ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: Taylor lost his re-election bid in 2018 to Democrat Elaine Luria.

Juan Cole: "Avery Thompson [of] Popular Mechanics reports that in the month of April for the first time in US history, the country produced more electricity with renewables than with coal.... Back in 2010, burning coal provided the world 45 % of its power generation. In 2018, that figure had drooped to 27 percent. At the same time, the share of renewables in power generation in the US has grown to 18% (including hydro)." --s ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: That's progress in spite of Trump, his EPA, his Energy Department, his Interior Department, & the rest of his irresponsible, antediluvian administrative apparatus.

Joshua Specht, in the Guardian, has a long read on how: "Exploitation and predatory pricing drove the transformation of the US beef industry -- and created the model for modern agribusiness." --s

Kyla Mandel of ThinkProgress: "Around the world, nature is in decline at an unprecedented rate and many of Earth's ecosystems face a catastrophic level of risk, according to a new report summary released Monday by the United Nations. This 'ominous' trend is due entirely to human activities.... While the risk of one million species going extinct has already grabbed headlines around the world, the report summary contains a slew of other stunning facts. Here are some of the numbers you may have missed." --s

"Annals of Journalism," Womp Womp Edition. Josh Kovensky of TPM: "Infamous alt-right troll Chuck Johnson's website GotNews filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy last month, according to a California federal court filing from the closed-down site.... The troll site must supply the list of creditors by Wednesday, and that list will offer a peek into who thought it was a good idea to finance Johnson." --s ...

... Anna Merlan of Splinter: "Recently referred to as a 'race-baiting troll' by the Boston Globe, Johnson's GotNews was a hive of misinformation, and outlandish, often provably false claims. Over time, both the site and Johnson's personal Facebook page -- now also deleted -- were increasingly filled with addled racist propaganda and Holocaust denialism; among other things, Johnson questioned whether six million Jews really died during the Holocaust and said on Reddit that he agreed 'about Auschwitz and the gas chambers not being real.') Johnson was also the first person banned for life from Twitter after he tried to raise funds to 'take out' black civil rights activist DeRay McKesson, comments which both the site and McKesson took as a threat.... What was more outlandish than any of Johnson's claims, however, was his increasingly less-fringe place in Washington D.C. political circles." Mrs. McC: Read on. The Trump administration is filled with wackos, starting at the tippy-top, of course.

Silvia Borrelli of Politico: "A top Catholic Cardinal objected to Steve Bannon's plans to create a training school for nationalists in a former Carthusian monastery.... [Bannon] wants to set up the alt-right academy at Trisulti Charterhouse in Collepardo, around 70 kilometers southeast of Rome. But according to a letter obtained by Politico, Cardinal Renato Maria Martino raised objections to using the monastery for political purposes. He wrote to Benjamin Harnwell, Bannon's close associate in Italy who is spearheading the project, on January 29, 2019 demanding that there be no 'distortions or modifications' to the original plan. The original idea was to create an apolitical Catholic study and training center.... Locals in Collepardo, the closest town to the Trisulti abbey, marched in protest at Harnwell's and Bannon's plans in March. The scheme was also challenged last month by Italy's Democratic Party leader, Nicola Zingaretti, who is also the governor of the Lazio region, where the monastery is located." ...

... Matt Stieb of New York: "... Cardinal Martino isn't the only authority to contest Bannon's pivot to create a 'gladiator school for culture warriors.' The Italian culture ministry has reportedly told lawyers to determine if there are grounds to cancel the authorizations given to [Bannon's lovely project], with possible irregularities in the paperwork." ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: In Italy, there are many ways to skin a cat: if the locals don't like you -- and they don't -- good luck with getting building permits for even the most insignificant repairs. This is an historic site, & you'll need permits to replace a broken roof tile or do minor electrical upgrades. Under the circumstances, crossing palms just might not work out for you. You & your crazy buddies could find yourselves plotting in the dark while raindrops keep falling on your heads.

Beyond the Beltway

Tennessee. Joel Ebert & Natalie Allison of the Tennessean: Tennessee "House Speaker Glen Casada's top aide has a history of sending sexually explicit text messages and making inappropriate advances toward former interns, lobbyists and campaign staffers, according to documents obtained by the USA TODAY Network - Tennessee. Copies of text messages sent from a cellphone number associated with Cade Cothren, 32, show Casada was included on some of the staff member's derogatory comments toward women. The texts also show Casada, R-Franklin, participated in some of the sexually charged messages objectifying women.... Revelations about Cothren's inappropriate sexual advances and text messages come after Casada's chief of staff admitted to using cocaine in the legislature's office building. Cothren is also facing scrutiny over racist text messages.... In recent days, Casada repeatedly has vouched for Cothren, including Monday.... Update: Cade Cothren announced his resignation Monday night, following the publication of this story."

Way Beyond

China. Lily Quo of the Guardian: "[M]ore than two dozen Islamic religious sites that have been partly or completely demolished in Xinjiang since 2016, according to an investigation by the Guardian and open-source journalism site Bellingcat that offers new evidence of large-scale mosque razing in the Chinese territory where rights groups say Muslim minorities suffer severe religious repression.... In the name of containing religious extremism, China has overseen an intensifying state campaign of mass surveillance and policing of Muslim minorities.... Researchers say as many as 1.5 million Uighurs and other Muslims have been involuntarily sent to internment or re-education camps, claims that Beijing rejects." --s

Israel-Palestine. Isabel Kershner of the New York Times: "A tentative cease-fire between Israel and Palestinian militant groups in Gaza appeared to have taken hold Monday morning, bringing a short but deadly bout of cross-border fighting to an end as abruptly as it had started. At least 22 Palestinians, including militants and children, were killed in Gaza over the weekend, and four Israeli civilians died in the fighting." (Also linked yesterday.) ...

... Dov Waxman in Informed Comment: "Dead on arrival. That's what almost every expert predicts will be the fate of the Trump administration's long-awaited peace plan to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. As the author of the new book, 'The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict: What Everyone Needs to Know,' I share this view.... About the only thing the Trump administration's peace plan has going for it is the fact that nobody expects it to succeed. With expectations so low, there's less risk that the likely failure of the plan will trigger another round of Israeli-Palestinian violence." --s

Myanmar. Simon Lewis & Shoon Naing of Reuters: "Two Reuters journalists jailed in Myanmar after they were convicted of breaking the Official Secrets Act walked free from a prison on the outskirts of Yangon on Tuesday after spending more than 500 days behind bars. The two reporters, Wa Lone, 33, and Kyaw Soe Oo, 29, had been convicted in September and sentenced to seven years in jail.... They were released under a presidential amnesty for 6,520 prisoners on Tuesday. President Win Myint has pardoned thousands of other prisoners in mass amnesties since last month."

Russia. Henry Meyer & Ilya Arkhipov of Bloomberg: "[P]ockets of disquiet rarely seen in the Vladimir Putin era are now putting ... depressed towns in the Russian hinterland on the political radar. The catalyst ... is health care. Doctors and other hospital staff in the region have been leading protests over the president's broken promises of better pay and the threat of clinics closing.... Nationwide support for Putin is stable [above 60 percent] after falling dramatically last year.... Concern, though, that traditionally loyal sections of the population are turning against the authorities raised an alarm in the government.... Protests used to be confined to the big cities. Now they're in the Putin heartlands.... Federal statistics released in March showed that more than a third of Russians can't afford to buy two pairs of shoes a year." --s

The Commentariat -- May 6, 2019

Late Morning/Afternoon Update:

** Matt Zapotosky of the Washington Post: "More than 370 former federal prosecutors who worked in Republican and Democratic administrations have signed on to a statement asserting special counsel Robert S. Mueller III's findings would have produced obstruction charges against President Trump -- if not for the office he held. The statement -- signed by myriad former career government employees as well as high-profile political appointees -- offers a rebuttal to Attorney General William P. Barr's determination that the evidence Mueller uncovered was 'not sufficient' to establish that Trump committed a crime.... 'We emphasize that these are not matters of close professional judgment,' they [wrote].... To look at these facts and say that a prosecutor could not probably sustain a conviction for obstruction of justice -- the standard set out in Principles of Federal Prosecution -- runs counter to logic and our experience.' The statement is notable for the number of people who signed it -- 375 as of Monday afternoon -- and the positions and political affiliations of some on the list.... Among the high-profile signers are Bill Weld, a former U.S. attorney and Justice Department official in the Reagan administration who is running against Trump as a Republican; Donald Ayer, a former deputy attorney general in the George H.W. Bush Administration; John S. Martin, a former U.S. attorney and federal judge appointed to his posts by two Republican presidents; Paul Rosenzweig, who served as senior counsel to independent counsel Kenneth W. Starr; and Jeffrey Harris, who worked as the principal assistant to Rudolph W. Giuliani when he was at the Justice Department in the Reagan administration. The list also includes more than 20 former U.S. attorneys and more than 100 people with at least 20 years of service at the Justice Department -- most of them former career officials. The signers worked in every presidential administration since that of Dwight D. Eisenhower."

Nicholas Fandos & Charlie Savage of the New York Times: "The House Judiciary Committee will vote Wednesday to hold Attorney General William P. Barr in contempt of Congress, after the Justice Department appeared to miss a Monday deadline to negotiate the delivery of Robert S. Mueller III's full report, along with key evidence collected by the special counsel. Democrats said the vote could still be avoided if the Justice Department changes course, but Monday's announcement sets up another dramatic escalation in a growing dispute between the legislative and executive branches. If the full House follows suit and votes to hold Mr. Barr in contempt of Congress, it would be only the second time in American history that a sitting member of a president's cabinet has been sanctioned by lawmakers that way. The Judiciary Committee's chairman, Representative Jerrold Nadler of New York, said the vote would occur t 10 a.m. A 27-page report accompanying the vote notice on Monday recommends that Mr. Barr 'shall be found to be in contempt of Congress for failure to comply with a congressional subpoena.'" The report includes a good summary of the Republican House's holding former AG Eric Holder in contempt.

Jordyn Hermani of Politico: "Donald Trump's former personal lawyer Michael Cohen said Monday that 'there still remains much to be told' about the president, as his feud with his ex-boss continues. Cohen ... did not elaborate. He heads to federal prison in Otisville, N.Y., Monday to begin a three-year sentence for a series of tax fraud and lying charges."

CNBC: "Stocks fell on Monday after ... Donald Trump said that the U.S. will hike tariffs on goods imported from China, but managed to recover a good chunk of those losses around late-morning trading. At 11:13 a.m. ET, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was down 235 points while the S&P 500 traded 0.9% lower. The Nasdaq Composite pulled back 1%. The Dow was down as much as 471 points, while the S&P 500 traded down 1.2% at its lows. The Nasdaq was briefly down 2.2%."

Isabel Kershner of the New York Times: "A tentative cease-fire between Israel and Palestinian militant groups in Gaza appeared to have taken hold Monday morning, bringing a short but deadly bout of cross-border fighting to an end as abruptly as it had started. At least 22 Palestinians including militants and children, were killed in Gaza over the weekend, and four Israeli civilians died in the fighting."

~~~~~~~~~~

Brad Plumer of the New York Times: "Humans are transforming Earth's natural landscapes so dramatically that as many as one million plant and animal species are now at risk of extinction, posing a dire threat to ecosystems that people all over the world depend on for their survival, a sweeping new United Nations assessment has concluded. The 1,500-page report, compiled by hundreds of international experts and based on thousands of scientific studies, is the most exhaustive look yet at the decline in biodiversity across the globe and the dangers that creates for human civilization. A summary of its findings, which was approved by representatives from the United States and 131 other countries, was released Monday in Paris." Mrs. McC: And Donald Trump is President* of the United States.

The Trump Scandals., Ctd.

So the Coup Begins, Not with a Bang but a Fruitcake. Quint Forgey of Politico: "... Donald Trump on Sunday floated the idea of extending his constitutionally limited time in office, complaining online that two years of his first White House term were 'stollen' as a result of special counsel Robert Mueller's investigation. 'I now support reparations -- Trump should have 2 yrs added to his 1st term as pay back for time stolen by this corrupt failed coup,' Jerry Falwell Jr., a conservative religious leader and Trump ally, tweeted in a message reposted by the president. Trump echoed Falwell's sentiment in a pair of tweets an hour later, writing online: 'Despite the tremendous success that I have had as President, including perhaps the greatest ECONOMY and most successful first two years of any President in history, they have stollen two years of my (our) Presidency (Collusion Delusion) that we will never be able to get back.'" ...

     ... Mrs. Bea McCrabbie: What with Müeller & Drumpf & Stollen, this is a particularly Germanic moment in American history. And it won't be over till ..

Michael Tackett of the New York Times: "President Trump said on Sunday that the special counsel, Robert S. Mueller III, should not testify before Congress, setting up another confrontation with Democrats over presidential authority and the separation of powers. On Twitter, he argued that Mr. Mueller's report on Russian interference in the 2016 election, which found no conspiracy between Moscow and Mr. Trump's campaign but did not exonerate the president on possible obstruction of justice, was conclusive and that Congress and the American people did not need to hear from Mr. Mueller. 'Bob Mueller should not testify,' he said. 'No redos for the Dems!' That puts the president at odds ... with his own attorney general, William P. Barr." ...

     ... As Jonathan Chait notes, isn't it odd that Trump doesn't want to hear the testimony of the man who "totally exonerated" him?

Will Bunch of the Philadelphia Inquirer: "... the most significant development for Trump's 2020 reelection bid is something ... that came into clear focus over the course of the week: The president has a plan for survival. It involves essentially shredding the Constitution, demolishing the government of 'checks and balances' that was envisioned by the Founders, and promoting a crisis that will leave Americans angry and, at least psychologically, poised for a civil war. That sounds scary but the scariest part is: It just might work: Not for the nation, of course, but for Trump, which in Trumpland is the only outcome that matters.... Phase 1 -- Barr's slow and clearly Trump-biased rollout of Mueller's findings like they were Russian nesting dolls, which gave the president room to claim 'total exoneration' by a report that explicitly stated he was not exonerated -- is over and was largely a success. Phase 2 -- that massive retaliation, doubling down on the very concept of 'obstruction' -- is underway."

James Reston, Jr., in a New York Times op-ed: "On July 30, 1974, nine days before President Richard Nixon resigned, the House Judiciary Committee added a third article to its impeachment charges against the president. The first two had dealt with obstruction of justice and abuse of power; Article III charged that Nixon had failed to comply with eight congressional subpoenas related to the Watergate investigation. Now, with President Trump and William Barr, his attorney general, refusing to cooperate with congressional investigations, the Democrats in the House should take yet another lesson from Watergate. They are reportedly already preparing impeachment articles on obstruction of justice; they should add failure to comply with Congress to the list.... Nancy Pelosi ... recognized [this] on Thursday. 'Ignoring subpoenas of Congress, not honoring subpoenas of Congress -- that was Article III of the Nixon impeachment,' she said.... President Trump's assertion that there is nothing left to learn from congressional hearings -- which, unlike the Mueller investigation, would be televised -- may be correct. But that is beside the point; it is up to Congress, not him, to decide."

Michael Conway, who served as counsel to the U.S. House Judiciary Committee in the impeachment inquiry of Richard Nixon, in an NBC opinion piece: "The House Judiciary Committee grappled 45 years ago with the same thorny issue that it faces this week: how to respond to an executive branch defiantly refusing to comply with congressional subpoenas.... Because the current Congress has not authorized an impeachment inquiry, the ability of the House to enforce its subpoenas or to punish [AG William] Barr is sharply circumscribed.... Only by instituting an impeachment proceeding will Congress be equipped to act on the evidence that [Robert] Mueller intended to convey to it. And by not acting, a dangerous precedent will be set, relegating Congress to subservience to the president as a forever-unequal branch of government.... House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and today's congressional leaders can find guidance from the actions of Congress during Watergate." ...

... House of Cards. digby: "The Republicans cheapened impeachment in the Clinton case, probably for a reason. They knew that if they could demonstrate it as a rank partisan act it would lose much of its 'nuclear' power. It probably succeeded in doing that to some extent. But impeachment over a cover-up of a betrayal of the country, criminal or not, is very different than impeaching someone over a lie in a civil case about a personal sexual matter. The first is the very definition of a high crime or misdemeanor. The second isn't. The Democrats are making themselves appear to be as nakedly partisan as the Republicans were in 1998, by doing the opposite. They are going on television and giving interviews in which they wring their hands and express their fears that impeaching the president will harm them politically. Why they think it's a good look to show themselves as self-serving pols in light of this assault on the constitution is beyond me.... The only reason one can say that Trump shouldn't be impeached on the basis of the Mueller Report, as well as his rank corruption and unfitness, is that you believe the citizens of this country have no sense of ethics and morality and will punish you for doing it." Mrs. McC: Nancy Pelosi, take note.

"Peak Trump." Matt Ford of the New Republic: "... Trump seems more eager than ever to test the electric fences of American democracy. His predilections will take root in more favorable soil than ever. Attorney General Bill Barr has made clear over the past few weeks that he will be the loyal functionary whom Trump has long sought to install atop the Justice Department. White House advisor Stephen Miller oversaw a similar purge of the Department of Homeland Security last month, ousting Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen and other top officials in favor of more hardline figures who could execute the president's legally dubious vision for border security. And with the threat of special counsel Robert Mueller now receding, even Trump's personal lawyers are eager for a Thermidorian response.... Trump's behavior toward the prospect of electoral defeat was already troubling when he was a candidate. It's far more worrying now that he commands the federal government and routinely describes the Russia investigation as an 'attempted coup.' Trump is notoriously unpredictable; he's as likely to make an empty threat as to indulge his most dangerous impulses. But his presidency is trending in the wrong direction."

Ana Swanson of the New York Times: "President Trump, emboldened by a strong American economy and wary of criticism that an evolving trade deal with China would not adequately benefit the United States, threatened on Sunday to impose more punishing tariffs on Chinese goods in an attempt to force additional concessions in a final agreement. Mr. Trump, in a tweet, warned that he would increase tariffs on $200 billion in Chinese goods at the end of this week and 'shortly' impose levies on hundreds of billions of dollars of additional imports. Dozens of high-level Chinese officials are arriving in Washington this week for what was expected to be a final round of negotiations toward a trade agreement, at least in principle. It was a familiar pattern for Mr. Trump, who has routinely turned to tariffs to help speed negotiations and win concessions from America's trading partners." ...

... Chas Danner of New York provides an essential translation of the Times report: "President Trump threatened China with an almost hilariously dramatic trade war escalation on Sunday, days before a Chinese delegation of more than a hundred people arrive in Washington to iron out a final deal. Signaling his impatience with what he claimed was a slowdown caused China's efforts to renegotiate the plan, Trump tweeted that he will more than double the current U.S. tariffs on some $200 billion of Chinese goods (from 10 to 25 percent), as well as add a new 25 percent tariff on another $325 billion worth of Chinese goods -- and it will all happen on Friday, unless China does the deal. (The trade talks don't even start until Wednesday.) Regarding any efforts to renegotiate the deal, Trump insisted 'No!' He also falsely claimed that the higher tariffs his administration enacted -- which are paid by the U.S. companies importing Chinese goods and then usually passed along as higher costs to U.S. customers -- were paid by China directly to the U.S., incurred little cost to Americans, and were 'partially responsible for our great economic results.'"

All the Nastiest People, Ctd. Zolan Kanno-Youngs & Michael Tackett of the New York Times: "President Trump on Sunday named a former Obama administration official who has embraced some of Mr. Trump's hard-line positions on border security as the head of Immigration and Customs Enforcement, part of a broad effort to force federal agencies into a more aggressive crackdown on migrants. The pick, Mark Morgan, served as the Border Patrol chief the last three months of the Obama administration, and was previously the head of internal affairs at United States Customs and Border Protection. He will lead the agency that arrests, detains and deports people who are in the United States illegally, after Mr. Trump last month withdrew his previous nominee, Ronald D. Vitiello, saying he wanted the agency to go in a 'tougher direction.' 'I am pleased to inform all of those that believe in a strong, fair and sound Immigration Policy that Mark Morgan will be joining the Trump Administration as the head of our hard working men and women of ICE,' Mr. Trump said in a tweet. ...

     "... Matthew T. Albence, who became the acting director last month after the departure of Mr. Vitiello, who had been serving in that role, will stay on pending Mr. Morgan's confirmation. In a tweet Sunday night, Mr. Trump wrote, 'Matt is tough and dedicated and has my full support to deploy ICE to the maximum extent of the law!"

... Matt Stieb of New York: "Despite the rare prospect of a Trump administration official who has served under a Democratic president, Morgan's recent comments on immigration certainly line up with the president's impression of the border crisis. In an interview with Fox News on April 15, Morgan rejected the notion that Trump manufactured the crisis on the border and agreed with his proposal to release migrants in Democratic sanctuary cities.... The decision to nominate Morgan as ICE director was — like so many maneuvers by the president -- a surprise to those closest to him.... Albence is known for an August 2018 quote comparing ICE detention to 'summer camp.'" ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: Once again Trump proves he does not understand the difference between "impulsive" & "decisive." Also, he thinks pushing people around like so many cheap chess pieces reflects power when in fact his "staffing" decisions are functions of his essential cruelty & narcissism.

Karoun Demirjian & Paul Sonne of the Washington Post: "Secretary of State Mike Pompeo on Sunday confirmed that the Trump administration is making contingency plans for U.S. military intervention in Venezuela, but he refused to say whether the administration would seek congressional authorization first. When asked directly on ABC's 'This Week' whether President Trump believes he has the power to intervene without seeking approval from Congress, Pompeo declined to answer." ...

... BUT What if Putie Doesn't Like It? Aidan McLaughlin of Mediaite: "Fox News anchor Chris Wallace confronted Secretary of State Mike Pompeo on Sunday over ... Donald Trump's defense of Russia's involvement in Venezuela.... Trump told reporters this week that the Russian president is 'not looking at all to get involved in Venezuela.' 'For weeks, you and [John] Bolton have talked about -- and called out Russian interference in Venezuela,' Wallace said. 'So which is it? Is Putin propping up a dictator in our own backyard or is Putin looking for something positive in Venezuela?' '[The] President's been very clear on this,' Pompeo replied.... 'He said -- I think it was in a tweet several weeks back. The Russians have to get out. That remains our view.' Wallace followed up," & Pompeo stuck to his story that "the president told the world, that every country must get out, including the Russians." ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: Pompeo is merely reconfirming what we already know: that when those who confront or disagree with Trump are in positions to stand up to a bully, he leaves his tin saber on the mantel & abandons even his own threats, showing not the slightest hint of strength. Whatever you think of Juan Guaido's efforts to unseat Maduro, you can bet Guaido has figured out Trump is a paper tiger & the U.S. a wholly unreliable ally. ...

... Matt Stieb: "On Sunday, the Russian Embassy stated on Facebook that the hour and a half conversation between [Putin & Trump] was initiated by President Trump.... Assuming the Russian Embassy's information is true, it now appears that the president is actively seeking out the advice of Putin, preferring the word of the autocrat to that of his own intelligence community and their briefs that he doesn't read."

Quint Forgey: "The U.S. military is deploying the USS Abraham Lincoln Carrier Strike Group and a bomber task force to the Central Command region in the Middle East to send a 'clear and unmistakable message' to Iran, national security adviser John Bolton said in a statement Sunday. The action, confirmed by the Defense Department, comes 'in response to a number of troubling and escalatory indications and warnings,' Bolton said, and is intended to convey 'to the Iranian regime that any attack on United States interests or on those of our allies will be met with unrelenting force.'"

Medlar's Sports Report

Trump to Award Tiger Woods Presidential* Medal of Emoluments. Annie Karni & Kevin Draper of the New York Times: "Ever since Tiger Woods arrived on the public stage as a golf phenom at the age of 21, Donald J. Trump has been cultivating him as a celebrity who could add a sheen to his properties around the globe.... Mr. Trump has named a villa after him at the Trump National Doral Miami. He has also gone into business abroad with Mr. Woods, announcing in 2014 that the golfer would design a course in Dubai as part of a luxury residential megaproject that would be managed by the Trump Organization. On Monday, Mr. Trump ... will present Mr. Woods with the Presidential Medal of Freedom in honor of his Masters victory last month.... The medal, which is considered the nation's highest civilian honor, is typically given near the end of the recipient's career to honor a lifetime of achievement.... By honoring him, the president leaves the appearance of using his office to reward a business partner.... [Trump] He prides himself on having stuck with Mr. Woods through a serial philandering scandal that derailed his professional and personal life." Mrs. McC: Well, that wouldn't bother Trump, would it?

Felicia Sonmez of the Washington Post: "President Trump on Sunday blamed the result of the Kentucky Derby on 'political correctness,' arguing that the horse that crossed the wire first should not have been disqualified. 'The Kentuky Derby decision was not a good one,' Trump said in a tweet, misspelling the word 'Kentucky.' 'It was a rough and tumble race on a wet and sloppy track, actually, a beautiful thing to watch. Only in these days of political correctness could such an overturn occur. The best horse did NOT win the Kentucky Derby - not even close!'... Maximum Security appeared to win Saturday's race by 1¾ lengths. But then two jockeys objected, and after stewards reviewed video of the race, they disqualified the apparent winner in a unanimous ruling, handing the victory to Country House, a 65-1 shot. The review focused on a moment when Maximum Security barged to his right and impeded the paths of two other horses at the top of the backstretch." ...

     ... Mr. McCrabbie: Maybe His Majesty enjoys the sport of kings, or maybe he just prefers a "tough" sounding-name like "Maximum Security" over the pastoral, gentle name "Country House." Bea thinks Kentuky stollen is made with burbun.

Thanks to Aunt Hattie for finding the headline of the week, on Sunday, no less: "Donald & Melania Trump Wish a 'Feliz Cinco de Mayo' After Threatening More Troops to Mexico Border." Subhead: "Hours later, Trump also announced the new head of ICE."

No Honor Among Grifters. Trump Ally Rips off Trump. Alayna Treene, et al., of Axios: "A political organization run by David Bossie, President Trump's former deputy campaign manager, has raised millions of dollars by saying it's supporting Trump-aligned conservative candidates -- but has spent only a tiny fraction of that money supporting candidates.... There's a vast difference between what the Presidential Coalition is telling its donors and how it actually spends their money. And as [the campaign watchdog Campaign Legal Center] writes, 'Not only do these dubious practices mislead and potentially even prey upon vulnerable populations, but they also drain resources away from more effective political groups' -- including Trump's campaign." Mrs. McC: Bossie has had a long, infamous career as an anti-Clinton activist; probably his most lasting -- and odious -- legacy will be the Supreme Court's Citizens United ruling supporting Bossie's hit job "Hillary: the Movie." ...

Bossie Specializes in Scamming the Elderly. Alayna Treene, et al., of Axios: "About two-thirds of the contributions made to David Bossie's Presidential Coalition in 2017 and 2018 came from donors giving less than $200 in a single year. And of the donors identified in its tax forms, most said they were retired.... Axios reached out to more than a dozen of these donors, most of whom were retired. They all said they thought their money was going toward supporting the president."

Presidential Race 2020. AP: "Democratic presidential candidate Pete Buttigieg and his husband, Chasten, joined the large crowd at former President Jimmy Carter' Sunday school class in rural South Georgia. At Carter's invitation Buttigieg stood and read from the Bible as part of the lesson at Maranatha Baptist Church in Plains. Carter told the audience that two other Democratic presidential candidates, Sens. Cory Booker of New Jersey and Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, had previously attended his classes."

Way Beyond the Beltway

Israel/Palestine. David Halbfinger & Isabel Kershner of the New York Times: "Fighting between Israel and Gaza escalated rapidly on Sunday in the worst combat since the last full-blown war in 2014, with Palestinian rocket and missile attacks killing four Israeli civilians and Israeli forces taking aim at individual Gaza militants. Gaza officials said the two-day death toll for Palestinians had reached 22. At least nine militants and as many civilians were killed on Sunday alone. The civilians included a pregnant woman, a 12-year-old boy and 4-month-old girl, health officials said. The outbreak of violence appears to have begun on Friday, when a sniper wounded two Israeli soldiers, a violent but localized expression of Palestinian impatience with Israel's failure to alleviate dire humanitarian conditions in Gaza. By Sunday, it had mushroomed into an all-out display of firepower by both sides. The Israel army said Gazans had launched 600 projectiles in two days, with the territory's secretive armed factions letting loose hundreds of rockets that had long been hidden away in arsenals."

The Commentariat -- May 5, 2019

** Maureen Dowd: "At many of the most consequential moments in American history, I have watched officials bend over backward to be equitable..., ceding the ground to malevolent actors who use any means to achieve their ends, including flattening and sliming the proponents of 'fairness.' Now that Joe Biden is running for president in a post-#MeToo era, he says he always believed Anita Hill. But as chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, he acted more like a Republican collaborator.... Priding himself on his comity with his Republican colleagues, Biden set up the rules to favor [Clarence] Thomas.... Jim Comey also got tangled up on the issue of fairness, with disastrous results. Afraid that he would be blamed if it was discovered that the F.B.I. had been secretly investigating the woman expected to be the next president, the then-F. B.I. chief violated his own agency's norms to announce that he was reopening the inquiry into Hillary Clinton's emails on the cusp of the election. But he did not tell the public that the F.B.I. was also looking into the Trump campaign's ties to Russia.... President Obama got similarly wrapped around the axle.... Obama choked after the diabolical Mitch McConnell warned the White House that, if it went through with a plan to publicly shame Moscow, he would regard that as a partisan act. And finally, we have the unfortunate Robert Mueller.... [Bill] Barr ... spoke of Mueller dismissively, like an errant errand boy who threw a silly snit after failing to complete the task he was given."

Elections 2020

Shane Goldmacher of the New York Times: "There is no disagreement among Democrats about the urgency of defeating Mr. Trump. But Mr. Biden's singular focus on the president as the source of the nation's ills, while extending an olive branch to Republicans, has exposed a significant fault line in the Democratic primary.... Many on the left believe that Mr. Biden's nostalgia for a bygone era of comity, compromise and civility -- while appealing -- is misplaced, or even naïve.... And it has thrown into stark relief one of the fundamental questions facing the Democratic electorate: Do Democrats want a bipartisan deal-maker promising a return to normalcy, or a partisan warrior offering more transformative change?" ...

     ... Mrs. Bea McCrabbie: Goldmacher, & some whom he interviewed, have grasped what is wrong with Biden's presidential aspirations. It isn't that he is too old in years; it's that he is too married to the way things were when he was in his prime. We've already had one disastrous presidential election (2016) in which two old geezers ran against each other on their singular time-warped ideas; it would be terrible to go thru another. Countries prosper on innovation, expansion -- and luck. Luck is not enough.

Glenn Thrush of the New York Times: "Speaker Nancy Pelosi does not believe President Trump can be removed through impeachment -- the only way to do it, she said this week, is to defeat him in 2020 by a margin so 'big' he cannot challenge the legitimacy of a Democratic victory.... 'We have to inoculate against that, we have to be prepared for that,' Ms. Pelosi said during an interview at the Capitol on Wednesday.... Ms. Pelosi ... offered Democrats her 'coldblooded' plan for decisively ridding themselves of Mr. Trump:... 'Own the center left, own the mainstream,' Ms. Pelosi, 79, said.... Ms. Pelosi remains committed to avoiding impeachment, but it is clear that she is losing patience.... Ms. Pelosi laced Wednesday's conversation with scathing descriptions of Mr. Trump's fitness to serve as president, taking issue with his 'attention span' and his 'lack of knowledge of the subjects at hand' during their negotiating sessions -- and saying his behavior 'degrades' the country and 'dishonors' the Constitution." ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: Pelosi is right in one particular: it will probably take armed guards to get Trump out of the White House (wearing restraints, one hopes). But as to policy, people want security, which the American people have not enjoyed in the 21st century. The promise of security comes only through hope -- "Yes, We Can" -- not Trumpian fear & security-stripping policies. That hope for security does not necessarily come from middle-of-the-road, tried-and-failed policies. As for impeachment, I still think the process itself, not the Senate trial, is what will matter. Congressional oversight will only further expose Trump's bad acts; remember that it was the last of the seven or eight House Benghaaazi! investigation that produced the E-Mails!

... AND don't kid yourself. If Democrats aren't investigating the hell out of Trump, here's a preview of the kind of stories that often will be at the top of the fold:

Toluse Olorunnipa of the Washington Post: "For President Trump's reelection effort, 'Investigate the investigators!' is becoming the new 'Lock her up!' Trump and his allies, seeking to amplify claims that the FBI spied on his 2016 campaign, are seizing on news reports and statements by Attorney General William P. Barr to launch a political rallying cry they view as an antidote to special counsel Robert S. Mueller III's findings. Dismissed by critics as an outlandish conspiracy theory, so-called 'spygate' is fast becoming a central feature of the Trump campaign as it seeks to go on offense in the wake of a report that identified 10 instances of potential obstruction of justice by Trump. The campaign is publicly calling for criminal investigations into former FBI officials, making 'spygate' fundraising pitches and selling spy-themed merchandise. The goal, officials said, is to turn the Russia probe into a political winner that could help him secure another term."

Trump-Generated Disinformation May Dwarf Any Russian Interference on His Behalf. Hunter Walker of Yahoo! News: "Trump's [re-election campaign] team is vowing to put together a more-than-$1 billion machine that will dwarf the guerilla operation he had early in the 2016 cycle. The president is also coming into the race with key structural advantages and experience running a powerfully influential Facebook advertising blitz.... This more formalized, professionalized, and, frankly, massive iteration of the Trump campaign will still include some of the hallmarks of the president's last run, including a hyper-focused Facebook advertising offensive and raucous rallies. Microtargeted Facebook ads were widely seen as one of the key factors behind the president's surprising 2016 victory. Trump's presence on the social network dwarfed that of ... Hillary Clinton. Data from Facebook revealed Trump had about 5.9 million ads on the platform compared to approximately 66,000 for Clinton." ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: Many radio & TV stations have standards, & they won't run blatantly false campaign ads. As we know, the same cannot be said for social media. But I think the Trump campaign could do worse than just generating the expected lies. While it's true that in 2020 Russia (or hackers working for some other country) could compromise American voting machines -- especially because the Trump administration is doing little or nothing to prevent it -- I think the larger danger might be homegrown: that is, from Trump campaign shenanigans. I would not put it past Trump to indirectly hire hackers (through cutouts) to change machine-generated voting machine results. The Trump campaign could do what Russia did in 2016, but even more effectively. Back in the day, Democrats were famous for stuffing ballot boxes & inspiring the saying, "Vote early and often." The rumor persists that Nixon really won Illinois & Texas in 1960, but for ballot-box stuffing by Chicago Mayor Richard Daley & friends of Lyndon Johnson.

Best Reason to Nominate Elizabeth Warren: Kate McKinnon:

Senate Race 2020. Emily Cochrane of the New York Times: "Senator Michael B. Enzi, Republican of Wyoming, said on Saturday that he would not seek re-election at the end of his term, the third Republican senator to do so ahead of the 2020 campaign. Mr. Enzi, 75, who leads the Senate Budget Committee, has held his seat since 1997, making him the longest-serving Wyoming senator in modern times.... It is unclear if Representative Liz Cheney, the No. 3 House Republican who once challenged Mr. Enzi in a primary race, will take another shot at the seat -- a decision that would reshape Republican leadership in the House. Mr. Enzi, in his remarks, said he could see Ms. Cheney becoming speaker one day." (Also linked late yesterday afternoon.)

Lorin Reisner in Bloomberg Law: "According to what can be termed the 'Mueller Doctrine...,' a special counsel is prohibited from concluding that a sitting president committed a crime... even if the evidence supported that conclusion.... A corollary of the Mueller Doctrine, which reserves exclusively to Congress the authority to conclude that a sitting president committed a crime, reveals serious falsehoods in the letter sent by Attorney General William Barr to Congress on March 24.... In [his] letter [to Congress], Barr asserted that the special counsel's decision not to reach any legal conclusions on obstruction, 'leaves it to the Attorney General to determine whether the conduct described in the report constitutes a crime.' That is a false description of the conclusions of the Mueller Report. The report could not be clearer that it is the responsibility of Congress -- and not the attorney general or any other representative of the DOJ -- to determine whether a crime was committed by the president. Second, Barr concealed that his determination was inconsistent with the report while publicly portraying his 'summary' as consistent." ...

     ... Mrs. McCrabbie: I would enjoy seeing Bill Barr running around with his pants on fire. I mean, I don't want him to be injured any more seriously than the equivalent of a bad sunburn, but still....

Annals of "Journalism," Ha Ha Ha

Lois Beckett of the Guardian & agencies: "Donald Trump criticized social media companies after Facebook banned a number of far-right figures, declaring that he was 'monitoring and watching, closely!!' The president, who tweeted and retweeted complaints, including complaints from rightwing figures themselves, on Friday and Saturday, said he would 'monitor the censorship of AMERICAN CITIZENS on social media platforms'. On Saturday, Trump tweeted harsh criticism of mainstream news organizations such as the Washington Post and New York Times, while lashing out against social media platforms for banning the editors of ... Infowars. Trump retweeted multiple tweets denouncing the social media bans from an Infowars editor, as well as a one from far-right activist Lauren Southern, who has been banned from entering the UK for being deemed 'not conducive to the public good'. Southern was part of a 2017 far-right expedition that hired a ship to attempt to interfere with operations to rescue refugees in the Mediterranean."

Kevin Poulsen of the Daily Beast: "When it comes to putting disinformation in front of American eyeballs, Vladimir Putin has long been able to count alt-right social media stars like Alex Jones and Mike Cernovich as reliable allies. Now the One America News Network, a pro-Trump cable news and commentary channel, is joining them in embracing some of Moscow's most vile fake news.... The network has a history with fake news. Last year it reported that California lawmakers were considering a bill to outlaw the sale of Bibles in the state, and ... earlier work includes a segment pushing the noxious Seth Rich conspiracy. The networks recent hires include notorious Pizzagate pusher Jack Posobiec, who joined as a political correspondent.... One of the channel's most ardent and credulous viewers happens to be President of the United States. 'It's a great network,' Donald Trump said during a 2017 news conference.... Last month he tweeted an old conspiracy claim, discredited in 2017, that the U.K.'s signals intelligence agency helped President Obama spy on his campaign, after seeing a segment about it on OANN."

News Lede

New York Times: "Forty-one people were killed on Sunday when a Russian passenger jet made an emergency landing at a Moscow airport, trailing a gigantic plume of flame and black smoke and skidding to a stop on fire. A Russian law enforcement agency, the Investigative Committee, reported that 40 passengers and one crew member lost their lives. There were 78 people on the plane. Videos showed passengers who had escaped the aircraft on exit slides running away from the burning plane on the tarmac as travelers inside the Sheremetyevo airport looked on aghast."