The Ledes

Friday, November 27, 2015.

AP: "Malian special forces have arrested two men over last week's attack on a luxury hotel in the capital that killed 19 people, according to a statement distributed Friday morning. The statement identified the two Malians, both arrested in Bamako, but provided no other details on their background or their potential roles in the attack."

The Wires

Weekly Address

The President's Weekly Address

Nearly four centuries after the Mayflower set sail, the world is still full of pilgrims – men and women who want nothing more than the chance for a safer, better future for themselves and their families, What makes America America is that we offer that chance. -- President Obama
White House: "In this week's address, the President wished everyone a happy Thanksgiving, and reflected on America’s history of welcoming men and women seeking a safer, better future for themselves and their families":

The Ledes

Thursday, November 26, 2015.

Guardian: "Sex abuse allegations against priests at St John’s Abbey in Minnesota were revealed in stark detail on Tuesday with the release of confidential documents concerning five priests accused of child sex abuse."

Reuters: "A 23-year-old Indiana man has pleaded guilty to breaking into a medical museum and stealing preserved human brains that he then sold online. David Charles, of Indianapolis, pleaded guilty to six charges including receiving stolen property and burglary in a Marion county court. Magistrate Amy Barbar sentenced him to one year of home detention and two years of probation, county prosecutor spokesman Anthony Deer said."

White House Live Video
November 27

11:00 am ET: Michelle Obama accepts delivery of the White House Christmas tree

Go to


Domenico Montanaro of NPR with everything you never wanted to know about the strange tradition of presidential "pardons" of turkeys.

Frank Rich reviews "Carol," the film based on Patricia Highsmith's 1952 novel The Price of Salt, published under a pseudonym. As usual, Rich goes deep.

New York Times: "Ta-Nehisi Coates won the National Book Award for nonfiction Wednesday[, Nov. 18,] night for “Between the World and Me,” a visceral, blunt exploration of his experience of being a black man in America, which was published this summer in the middle of a national dialogue about race relations and inequality.... The fiction award went to Adam Johnson for 'Fortune Smiles.'..."

Slate: Carly Simon told People magazine that "You're So Vain" is about Warren Beatty. CW: Somehow I think I knew that a long time ago.

Guardian: "Gawker, the gossip website..., is giving up on reporting gossip in order to refocus on politics and 'to hump the [2016 presidential] campaign'. The site, founded by British journalist Nick Denton in 2003, announced on Tuesday that Gawker was steering in a new direction that would “orient its editorial scope on political news, commentary and satire'.”

Washington Post: Actor "Charlie Sheen confirmed on Tuesday that he is HIV-positive, as rumored in recent days by an onslaught of tabloid stories. Sheen told Matt Lauer on the 'Today' show that he is going public with his illness for multiple reasons, including that he’s been blackmailed for upwards of $10 million since he was diagnosed four years ago."

Public Service Announcement

Washington Post (October 26): "A research division of the World Health Organization announced on Monday that bacon, sausage and other processed meats cause cancer, and that red meat probably does, too. The report by the influential group stakes out one of the most aggressive stances against meat yet taken by a major health organization, and it is expected to face stiff criticism in the United States."

New York Times (October 20: "The American Cancer Society, which has for years taken the most aggressive approach to [breast-cancer] screening, issued new guidelines on Tuesday, recommending that women with an average risk of breast cancer start having mammograms at 45 and continue once a year until 54, then every other year for as long as they are healthy and likely to live another 10 years. The organization also said it no longer recommended clinical breast exams, in which doctors or nurses feel for lumps, for women of any age who have had no symptoms of abnormality in the breasts."

... For about $880,000, you can purchase Julia Child's excellent little house in Provence; her kitchen is intact, except for the stove.

New York Times: "Archaeologists have over the years cataloged the rocks [forming Stonehenge], divined meaning from their placement — lined up for midsummer sunrise and midwinter sunset — and studied animal and human bones buried there. They have also long known about the other monuments — burial chambers, a 130-foot-tall mound of chalk known as Silbury Hill and many other circular structures. An aerial survey in 1925 revealed circles of timbers, now called Woodhenge, two miles from Stonehenge." With slide show.


New York Times: "In an overheated art market where anything seems possible, a painting of an outstretched nude woman by the early-20th-century artist Amedeo Modigliani sold on Monday night for $170.4 million with fees, in a packed sales room at Christie’s. It was the second-highest price paid for an artwork at auction."

Artist's rendering of the main exhibition hall of the planned wing of the American Museum of Natural History in New York City. CLICK ON PICTURE TO SEE LARGER IMAGE.New York Times: "In designing its $325 million addition on Columbus Avenue, the American Museum of Natural History has opted for an architectural concept that is both cautious and audacious, according to plans approved by its board on Wednesday. The design ... evokes Frank Gehry’s museum in Bilbao, Spain, in its undulating exterior and Turkey’s underground city of Cappadocia in its cavelike interior. The design, by the architect Jeanne Gang for the new Richard Gilder Center for Science, Education and Innovation, aims to unite the museum’s various activities, solve its notorious circulation problems and provide a multistory showcase for the institution’s expanding role as a hub for scientific research and scholarship.”

New York Times: "... Jon Stewart has signed a production deal with the premium cable channel HBO, the channel announced on Tuesday. As part of the arrangement, Mr. Stewart will work on some digital short projects that are expected to appear on HBO’s apps like HBO Now and HBO Go. Mr. Stewart could also pursue movie or television projects with the network. The contract covers four years."

Guardian: "Facebook has announced plans to water down its controversial 'real names' policy, after lobbying from civil liberties groups worldwide."

If you'd like to know whatever happened to former NYT food columnist Mark Bittman, the Washington Post has the answer.

Jennifer Senior of the New York Times reviews Notorious R.G.B., by Irin Carmon & Shana Knizhnik: "It’s an artisanal hagiography, a frank and admiring piece of fan nonfiction."

Digital Globe photo, via NASA, republished in the New York Times. CLICK ON PHOTO TO SEE LARGER IMAGE.... New York Times: "Satellite pictures of a remote and treeless northern steppe reveal colossal earthworks — geometric figures of squares, crosses, lines and rings the size of several football fields, recognizable only from the air and the oldest estimated at 8,000 years old. The largest, near a Neolithic settlement, is a giant square of 101 raised mounds, its opposite corners connected by a diagonal cross, covering more terrain than the Great Pyramid of Cheops.... Described last year at an archaeology conference in Istanbul as unique and previously unstudied, the earthworks, in the Turgai region of northern Kazakhstan, number at least 260 — mounds, trenches and ramparts — arrayed in five basic shapes."

New York Times: "In a landmark study, scientists at Delft University of Technology in the Netherlands reported that they had conducted an experiment that they say proved one of the most fundamental claims of quantum theory — that objects separated by great distance can instantaneously affect each other’s behavior. The finding is another blow to one of the bedrock principles of standard physics known as 'locality,' which states that an object is directly influenced only by its immediate surroundings. The Delft study, published Wednesday in the journal Nature, lends further credence to an idea that Einstein famously rejected. He said quantum theory necessitated 'spooky action at a distance,' and he refused to accept the notion that the universe could behave in such a strange and apparently random fashion." CW: Everything is relative, Al.

Gizmodo: On Halloween, "a rather large asteroid — discovered less than three weeks ago — is set to to fly past the Earth at a distance not seen in nearly a decade.... NASA says that 2015 TB145 will safely pass by the Earth and continue to following along its exceptionally eccentric and high-inclination orbit — which may explain why it wasn’t discovered until only a few weeks ago. During the flyby, the asteroid will reach a magnitude luminosity of 10, so it should be observable to astronomers with telescopes."

For $299,000 you could buy the house where Bruce Springsteen wrote "Born to Run." It looks like a dump prone to flooding every time it rains, but it's a block-and-a-half from the Jersey shore beach.

New York Post: "During his time in the White House, President Richard Nixon — pug-nosed, jowly, irascible, charmless-yet-devoted husband to Pat — was known to awkwardly hit on middle-aged female staffers. In 'The Last of the President’s Men' (Simon & Schuster), veteran journalist Bob Woodward quotes Alexander Butterfield, Nixon’s deputy assistant, about the commander-in-chief’s sad seduction techniques."

The Washington Post thought it would be great journalism to feature Donald's Digs in their weekend edition.  You'll be happy to know that Trump's taste runs to the gaudy & garish. You can take the boy out of the boroughs but you can take the boroughs out of the boy. I'd call Donald's style Early Modern Lottery Winner. Here's a sampling:

... There's much more where that came from. Ugh. Here, by contrast, is the study in Michael Bloomberg's New York City pad. Bloomberg is quite a few $$BB richer than Trump.

CW: I've completely ignored the buzz about the film "Steve Jobs," so this was welcome:

... Sharon Shetty in Slate: "As the latest attempt to mine every last bit of meaning from the life of Apple’s late founder, Danny Boyle and Aaron Sorkin’s Steve Jobs will probably make lots of money and spark lots of debate. For those preemptively exhausted by that debate, there’s Conan O’Brien’s less controversial take on a tech biopic: Michael Dell":

AND contributor D. C. Clark was kind enough to remind us of Eva Cassidy:

Contact the Constant Weader

Click on this link to e-mail the Constant Weader.


The Commentariat -- July 25, 2012

Fed Thinks about Thinking about Doing Something. Binyamin Appelbaum of the New York Times: "A growing number of officials have concluded that the Federal Reserve needs to expand its stimulus campaign unless the economy soon shows signs of improvement." ...

... Ezra Klein: for one thing, the Fed could "begin buying huge numbers of mortgage-backed securities with the simple intention of bringing the interest rate on a 30-year mortgage down to about 2.5 percent and holding it there for one year, and one year only. The message would be clear: If you have any intention of ever buying a house, the next 12 months is the time to do it."

... Fire Tim Geithner. Jia Lynn Yang & Danielle Douglas of the Washington Post: "Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner has said that he sounded the alarm four years ago to regulators about problems with the benchmark interest rate known as Libor. But Geithner, who was then head of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, did not communicate in key meetings with top regulators that British bank Barclays had admitted to Fed staffers that it was rigging Libor, according to people familiar with the matter. Instead, regulators at the Commodity Futures Trading Commission and the Justice Department worked largely without the Fed’s help to build a case against Barclays. That work has culminated in a massive scandal rocking the banking industry on both sides of the Atlantic." ...

... CNBC: "Former Citigroup Chairman & CEO Sanford I. Weill, the man who invented the financial supermarket, called for the breakup of big banks in an interview on CNBC Wednesday.... He essentially called for the return of the Glass-Steagall Act, which imposed banking reforms that split banks from other financial institutions such as insurance companies."

Robert Pear of the New York Times: "The Congressional Budget Office said Tuesday that the Supreme Court decision on President Obama's health care overhaul would probably lead to an increase in the number of uninsured and a modest reduction in the cost to the federal government when compared with estimates before the court ruling. Of the 33 million people who had been expected to gain coverage under the law, 3 million fewer are now predicted to get insurance, the budget office said...." ...

... Jonathan Cohn of The New Republic, once again: "The [Affordable Care Act], when fully implemented, will dramatically reduce the number of Americans without health insurance. It will also reduce the deficit. This last part remains a big deal, if only because so many conservatives -- and, yes, so many members of the public -- refuse to believe it. Over and over again, you hear people saying that Obamacare will run up the deficit. The CBO, which is our most reliable guide on such matters, begs to differ."

Charles Lane of the Washington Post: Europeans tut-tut about the U.S.'s lax gun laws, but "All told, European Union members shipped just under a million handguns to the United States in 2010. Their domestic markets may be limited by gun control, but Europe's small-arms makers can still get rich, and create jobs, thanks to the Second Amendment." Among those are the Glock, the Walther P22 & the Sig Sauer P232, mass-murders' weapons of choice.

New York Times Editors on companies in the business of background-checking: "The federal government clearly needs to step in. It should require companies to be federally registered, outline standards for accuracy, make sure that job applicants have a reasonable time to respond to erroneous reports and seek monetary and other penalties from companies that flout the law."

Rod Nordland of the New York Times: "... Al Qaeda and other Islamic extremists are doing their best to hijack the Syrian revolution, with a growing although still limited success that has American intelligence officials publicly concerned, and Iraqi officials next door openly alarmed. While leaders of the Syrian political and military opposition continue to deny any role for the extremists, Al Qaeda has helped to change the nature of the conflict, injecting the weapon it perfected in Iraq -- suicide bombings — into the battle against President Bashar al-Assad with growing frequency."

Stupid Voter Tricks. Larry Bartels in the Monkey Cage: the hot, dry summer could hurt President Obama at the polls because voters punish the party in power when the weather is bad. CW: Bartels is right. I've been more worried about the weather's effect on the election than on the price of corn.

Another Illegitimate GOP Presidency. Harold Meyerson: "If voter suppression goes forward and Romney narrowly prevails, consider the consequences. An overwhelmingly and increasingly white Republican Party, based in the South, will owe its power to discrimination against black and Latino voters, much like the old segregationist Dixiecrats. It's not that Republicans haven't run voter suppression operations before, but they've been under-the-table dirty tricks, such as calling minority voters with misinformation about polling-place locations and hours. By contrast, this year's suppression would be the intended outcome of laws that Republicans publicly supported, just as the denial of the franchise to Southern blacks before 1965 was the intended result of laws such as poll taxes."

Kate Nocera of Politico: "It’s not exactly the Ron Paul revolution in full. But on Wednesday afternoon, a small piece of his grand vision will hit prime time, when a great majority of the House will vote to pass his Audit the Fed bill. To understand how remarkable this moment is -- coming near the end of Paul's congressional career -- consider this: When Paul first introduced his bill a decade ago, it was written off as another piece of his far-flung libertarian worldview."

Just Wow! ("a surprising move since the seat could be in play for Republicans.") --

Presidential Race

Horserace. Mark Murray of NBC News: "In the presidential horserace, Obama leads Romney by six percentage points among registered voters, 49 percent to 43 percent. That's a slight change -- within the margin of error – from last month’s poll, which showed Obama ahead by three points, 47 percent to 44 percent." But both men's negatives are up. "Romney would be the first GOP presumptive presidential nominee since 1996 to head into his nominating convention with a net-negative favorable/unfavorable score." ...

... Nate Silver: "... as of Tuesday afternoon, President Obama's lead in the RealClearPolitics average of national polls was 1.3 percentage points over Mitt Romney. But Mr. Obama led by a mean of 3.5 points in the RealClearPolitics averages for the 10 states (Ohio, Virginia, Florida, Pennsylvania, Colorado, Iowa, Nevada, Michigan, New Hampshire and Wisconsin) that are most likely to determine the election outcome."

     ... Rachel Weiner of the Washington Post: "President Obama is pushing back on ... Mitt Romney's 'You didn't build that' attacks in a new ad. It's a sign that the White House is worried that the quote, while taken out of context, is doing the president real damage." ...

... Adam Serwer or Mother Jones: "The problem [with Romney's 'you didn't build that' meme] is that the real-world examples Romney keeps seizing on include people who got help from the government. As ABC News' Jake Tapper reported Monday, the star of a recent Romney ad hitting Obama over 'you didn't build that' had received millions in government loans and contracts. Romney stopped in Costa Mesa, California Monday to meet with a 'roundtable' of small business leaders, held in front of a sign that says 'We did build it!' Naturally, it turned out that at least two of the companies represented ... had received hundreds of thousands of dollars in government contracts." Ditto at a Boston Romney event."

Secret Mitt, Con'd. Maureen Dowd: "Mitt's casting a shadowy silhouette, hiding his fortune in foreign tax havens, hiding tax returns, destroying and hiding records as head of the Olympics and as governor, hiding a specific sense of where he would take the country."

New York Times Editors: "Mitt Romney [had a chance] to show that he could be a better international leader than President Obama, who has already proved himself in that field. He fell far short." ...

... Michael Crowley of Time: "Mitt Romney has a commander-in-chief problem." ...

... Daniel Drezner of Foreign Policy: "After the [Romney VFW] speech, Chuck Todd tweeted that 'The Romney VFW speech felt like it was aimed at GOP voters, not swing voters.' I'd agree. Foreign policy doesn't matter that much to swing voters, but rhetoric like this is a great way to appeal to and energize the base. If Romney were to actually follow through on this speech, then the consequences would range from insignificant to quite serious. But it could be that Romney simply doesn't care about foreign policy all that much, and is using these kind of speeches strictly as a tool to cater to key political constituencies."

... Heather Hurlburt of Democracy Arsenal pulls five big lies from Mitt's VFW speech. Via Greg Sargent.

We are part of an Anglo-Saxon heritage, and he [Romney] feels that the special relationship is special. The White House didn't fully appreciate the shared history we have. -- Romney Adviser. CW Translation: he's black.

... Same batch of advisers, still on the same topic: "The advisers, who 'spoke on the condition of anonymity because Mr Romney's campaign requested that they not criticise the President to foreign media,' were unable to provide the Telegraph with 'detailed examples of how policy towards Britain would differ under Romney,' other than restoring the bust of Winston Churchill to the Oval Office." CW: Excellent foreign policy initiative, and a reminder that Obama replaced the Churchill bust with a bust of Abraham Lincoln -- associated with freeing American slaves (wow, they were black, too!). So, um, would Romney ditch the bust of Lincoln, the first Republican president, & replace it with a representation of a "foreigner" (okay, Churchill's mother was American, but still)?? ...

... AND as Judd Legum of Think Progress reminds us, "The comments were the latest attack by the Romney campaign on Obama's multi-cultural heritage. Last week, Romney campaign co-chair John Sununu said Obama didn’t understand the 'American system' because he 'spent his early years in Hawaii smoking something, spent the next set of years in Indonesia.' Sununu also said Obama needed to 'learn how to be an American.' (Sununu later apologized for that remark.) Later that day Romney called Obama's policies 'extraordinarily foreign.'" CW: clearly, Team Romney has decided that racism is a winning campaign tactic, & they are keeping at it.

Go for the Gold, Mitt. Priorities USA has a new anti-Romney ad that will run in swing states. It's Olympics-oriented, and it's funny:

Jeff Zeleny of the New York Times: "A Republican group backed by the casino magnate Sheldon Adelson is starting a new effort in battleground states to win over Jewish voters who could be persuaded to turn away from President Obama and support Mitt Romney. The group, the Republican Jewish Coalition, plans to begin a multimillion-dollar advertising campaign in the coming weeks called 'My Buyer's Remorse,' targeting voters in Florida, Ohio and Pennsylvania, aides said. The campaign uses testimonials from people who say they regret supporting Mr. Obama because of his economic policies and his posture toward Israel...."

Wells Tower's GQ piece is mostly about a journalist's life on the road with Mitt. It's inconsequential really, but an enjoyable read. "I'm thinking how emotionally fatiguing it would be to spend all day, every day telling America it can be rescued by rich men and hymns and keeping secret for the quiet room his real worries for the land he wants to govern. Secrets are exhausting."

Right Wing World

Kevin Drum of Mother Jones: "The mountain of idiocy building up around 'you didn't build that' has just about reached wrist-slitting proportions, both because of the sheer rapturous levels of dishonesty surrounding the quote itself and because of the ensuing, more intellectually-minded dishonesty that's now dedicated to proving that the government has never done anything for anybody -- not no how, not no way. The latest is Gordon Crovitz, who has decided to see if he can con the Wall Street Journal's readership into believing that government research dollars had virtually nothing to do with the invention of the internet."

CW: I haven't followed the Mike Huckabee Chick-fil-A to-do, but Dana Milbank has the particulars. Well, I don't eat at Chick-fil-A anyway, and Huckabee -- along with Chick-fil-A's president Dan Cathy -- have provided me with a few more good reasons to stay away.

Local News

Stupid Democrat Tricks. Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel: "State Sen. Tim Cullen quit the Senate Democratic caucus Tuesday, saying Senate Democratic leader Mark Miller had snubbed him by refusing to give him a meaningful committee chairmanship.... The flap comes just a week after Democrats took control of the Senate after winning a recall election last month in Racine County. Miller then ascended to majority leader and restructured the committees."

News Ledes

Politico: "Timothy Geithner came under fire Wednesday from lawmakers who wanted to know what he did to head off the now-emerging Libor manipulation scandal when he was president of the New York Federal Reserve Bank in 2008 -- when red flags were first going up. Appearing before the House Financial Services Committee to present the Financial Stability Oversight Council's annual economic report, Geithner told members of the panel that he had taken the 'fully appropriate' actions by alerting regulators in both the U.S. and the U.K." Uh-huh.

Washington Post: "Greenland's surface ice cover experienced a broader thaw during a three-day period this month than in nearly four decades of satellite record-keeping.... About half of the surface of Greenland's ice sheet melts on average each summer. But between July 11 and 13, roughly 97 percent of the the sheet -- from its coastal edges to its 2-mile-thick center -- experienced some thawing."

AP: "Britain is suffering a far deeper recession than thought, official figures showed Wednesday in a development that is likely to increase the pressure on the government to ease up on its tough austerity approach."

Washington Post: "Japan posted its biggest first-half trade deficit on record, according to government figures released Wednesday, highlighting the economic consequences as this nuclear-averse country imports fossil fuels to meet its energy needs."

Reuters: "Protesters broke windows of least a half-dozen storefronts in Anaheim on Tuesday and five people were arrested in the second major clash between police and demonstrators since an officer shot dead an apparently unarmed man. Tom Tait, mayor of the southern California city, had called on Monday for a state and federal review of the shooting of the man, a suspected gang member."

Guardian: "Ghana's president, John Evans Atta Mills, has died suddenly, aged 68."

AP: "North Korea state TV is reporting for the first time that leader Kim Jong Un is married."

Reader Comments (16)

I just shared this on Krugman's blog, but I thought I'd reproduce it here, among my favorite people:

I have a very small business that I built from the ground up. The investment capital was the money in my pocket (which was so very little that I considered giving up my rented house to live in my car in the early days of the business), and the sweat equity was all my own.

Ten years later, my business is still not big, but I do employ twelve people part-time and we offer our services all over Maine. As far as I know, I have never been the beneficiary of any tax legislation or received any subsidies.

That being said, I have no idea why building one's own business should make one mean toward others who do not have the wherewithal to do so themselves. I support social services that provide for those who are trapped by poverty, and I support services (and the under-appreciated people who provide them) to those who would lift themselves out of poverty.

I believe that most of today's Democrats have become GHB RINOs and that very few, including Bernie Sanders (who, ironically, ...), represent the ideals of fairness toward which I aspire.

I believe that for our society to function correctly, we need working roads and bridges. I believe that we need health research that is untainted by association with drug companies, education that is untainted by association with primitive mythologies, and even space exploration, which helps us understand that no one will rescue us if we trash our planet.

I am a job creator, albeit a very minor one. Strange Romney didn't ask me to testify.

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterJack Mahoney

@ Jack Mahoney: And you're why I like Reality Chex. It's not only the easy access to far more information and entertainment than I could or would ferret out on my own that Marie provides, it's the high level of commentary and the sense of genuinely fine people, like you, people one would like to meet and know, who produce it. Thanks.

I would add only two thoughts. As social beings, we humans do NOTHING by ourselves. We are not bred alone, we do not grow up alone, we do not learn alone and even hermits do not live entirely alone. Tarzan, remember had furry friends.

The extreme Republican meme, ala Ayn Rand, is that there is no society, only individuals. It's dumb, but that's what many on the Right seem to think, I believe for three reasons. One, because as I said, it's dumb, it's an easy notion to sell to the simple minded; two, because it feeds the ego of the financially successful who think all the important things in life are inside their own skin; and three, as long as the majority thinks of themselves as individuals, never banding together for strength, they will remains isolated and weak, never any match for the rich and powerful. Divide and conquer, as the current cliche has it, on steroids.

In short, it's not just the roads and bridges, the teachers, the fire departments, all traditional government services at issue in the current Romney--Obama debate. Present day Republicans don't just want to pretend government has no useful social function; they deny sociology itself.

They do not believe that much of human reality is socially constructed. Ironically but predictably they don't grasp that essential truth even as they withdraw from a world they don't like and construct an increasingly hallucinatory reality of their own, that gated haven for rich white folks who pay no taxes at all.

The second thought is no so esoteric. It's about guns. In the midst of all the breast-beating about weapons that ritualistically follows the latest mass murder, let us not forget that we ourselves export hundreds of millions of dollars, perhaps billions of dollars of weaponry each year to countries itching to kill many many more than we blow away internally each year. If our own gun laws, bad as they are, a mild case of the flu, the international weapons trade is pancreatic cancer. Unfortunately, like too many cancers, it's good for business.

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterKen Winkes

My latest election bumper sticker:

Mitt Romney: draft dodger, tax dodger, truth dodger!

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterCalyban

If Romney wins and Churchill's bust is brought back, it will be a symbol of relevant character: A large anthology could be compiled of the contemptuous things said about Winston from the 1900s to the 1940s, by colleagues and friends as well as enemies; at times contempt shaded into hatred. One of my favorites was the verdict of Sir Basil Bartlett, "the actor baronet" to the popular newspapers––and a very astute observer. "Winston Churchill is making inflammatory speeches again," he wrote in his dairy in May 1936, months before the abdication fiasco, and went on with this:

"He is a curious character. A sort of Mary Queen of Scots of modern politics. He is bound to emerge historically as a romantic and glamorous figure, but he is surrounded by corpses. No one who ever served him or been in any way connected to his career, has ever survived to tell the story."

Somehow that rings some bells, doncha think?

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterPD Pepe

@Jack Mahoney. Yeah but. Your business has received numerous government contracts, and those contracts have enhanced your reputation, earning you private clients, too. When you and your clients meet, you-all get to the meeting via government-built roads & bridges, as you point out. When you buy pencils for your business, they weren't made by the neighbor across the field; they were made someplace else & came to you on government-built infrastructure. Safety and fire officers help keep your business safe. If some of your business is conducted online, well, Al Gore had a hand in that. If privately-run utilities and services more-or-less work and more-or-less provide the services & products advertised, that's partly because some government regulators require them to function properly & keep their thumbs off the scales. So when you flip the switch & the lights go on & when you buy a ream of paper that has 500 sheets instead of 493, you can thank government. If your bank goes belly-up, the rest of us will bail it out -- again. If Kinkos screws you, you can sue them in a government court.

You're as smart as you are because of who you are, but in some way, at some time, the government contributed to your education even if you went to private schools.

Mind you, I don't see anything wrong with most of that (a few caveats on the bank & crappy court system parts). I'm just sayin'. We benefit from government programs more than most of us realize. We only notice the government when it doesn't work or when it works against us, which is of course way too often. It isn't just the direct help that Mitt's "independent small businessmen against government" received. It's all the indirect aid, too.


July 25, 2012 | Registered CommenterThe Constant Weader

FOR KATE–– who has had it up to here, I offer a similar feeling during the Bush years when my fomenting prevented me from composing:


Total silence for almost a year—
she’s simply left—disappeared.
Searching through debris I find
nary a trace—only a whiff of ennui.

Fed up to here with the world’s wars,
atrocities & incompetence
I suppose.

Have some brewed tea, I say,
it might give you a lift.
Then a whisper—faint, but decisive:

I have nothing left
to give.


Sometimes we just need to take a breather, walk away, play somewhere else and before you know it you're back in the fray because that's who you are––you just can't help it.

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterPD Pepe

Marie, I was trying to be a bit metaphorical, saying that even if it were true that I built the whole thing out of my own sweat and clothespins and duct tape, I would still understand that we're all in this together. I'm sorry if I gave a different impression. I understand that a big reason the air I breathe isn't dirtier is because government, love it or hate it, usually stands up for me. Except maybe lately in Maine and Ohio and Wisconsin and Michigan and Florida and Texas.

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterJack Mahoney

Charles Fried, a law professor at Harvard, opens his 1978 book “Right and Wrong” with these words: “A good man does not lie. It is this intuition which brings lying so naturally within the domain of things categorically wrong”. Fried, you may recall, served as Solicitor General under Reagan so he’s no card carrying liberal. But he also has written a book ripping Bush for his predilection to torture other human beings. As a moralist he has always struck me as being as near a Kantian as you’ll find today. Kant’s moral theory is girded by his concept of deontology, the idea of duty. To Kant, there is never an excuse to lie. It is a moral imperative. It is the definition of Kant's Categorical Imperative, a matter of moral duty.

That same year, 1978, Sissela Bok, who specializes in moral and ethical philosophy, wrote a book on Lying in which she examines the damage liars can cause in both public and private settings. The biggest damage, however, is in the public domain.

For Bok, a lie is a statement, known by the liar to be false and made with the express intent of deceiving the listener(s) in order to achieve some advantage or gain for the liar.

She was talking about Mitt Romney.

Bok’s analysis is complex but let me boil it down, especially the part concerned with lying to the public. Bok posits that a system of veracity, entered into and enjoyed by all members of a society has numerous benefits for all. The most important is our ability to assume a certain level of trust. Why this is so important is demonstrated by a simple thought experiment. Consider a society in which everyone lied or could lie with impunity. No one could trust anything or anybody. Without being able to confirm, first hand, the veracity of any statement, no useful knowledge would be available. The society would quickly disintegrate. No contracts could be trusted, no books could be believed, everything one heard or read would have to be questioned.

But living in a world where truth is valued and members of a society try to tell the truth as a matter of course makes that world a much more habitable place. Being able to assume a level of trust in what you read and hear makes so many things possible. Certainly there are exceptions, but for the most part, if you read that the sun is 93 million miles from the Earth, you don’t have get out a tape measure and see for yourself. If someone tells you that Abraham Lincoln was president during the Civil War, you don’t have to wonder if you’re being had.

This is a perfect world for the liar. In a world where no one trusts anything, the liar is just one of many whose lies don’t necessarily accrue any benefit to him or her. But in a world where trust is the norm, a willful, scheming liar can make reap enormous personal benefits for himself at the expense of everyone else. What allows this person to lie so skillfully and willingly? Simple. In Bok’s analysis, members of the society who place a premium on veracity, on telling the truth, don’t think that they are more deserving than everyone else. They see themselves as members of the group, not as someone special for whom rules do not apply. You see where this is going.

Romney has ALWAYS considered himself special, always above the law, too good for the rules of normal, average people. So willful lies allow him to take something which is not deserved and do it in the most cynical and mendacious manner: the trust of others. He hasn’t earned it but he gets it anyway, because, he believes himself to be better than everyone else and hence above silly moral imperatives like telling the truth. That truth telling stuff is for "you people." not for the likes of Willard. Morality is what he says it is.This is how he can so easily burn successful businesses to the ground, fire the employees, take their pensions and fill his pockets with their futures while leaving them in the dirt. This is how he can lie so easily on a regular basis.

Still, one might wonder how such a self-proclaimed religious man—a bishop in his church—can lie so easily, free from concerns of morality or ethics or religious sanctions against lying from the almighty. Wonder no more. It appears that the Mormon faith has a very clever trick for dealing with those it considers outsiders or who would stand in their way or might impede their progress or question their methods. It’s a little technique called (I kid you not) “Lying for the Lord.” According to LSD elder Boyd Packer, the current President of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, the same position once held by Brigham Young, “Some things that are true are not very useful.” So, when confronted with uncomfortable truths about the church or the faith the answer is simple.


LSD missionaries, according to a number of personal recollections, when faced with difficult questions about some of the odder aspects of their faith are trained to dissemble, misdirect, anything but tell the truth, to Lie for the Lord. Willard was an apt pupil it seems.

So Romney has two reasons for lying like he does. He views himself as special and not bound by any commonly accepted understanding of morality or the ethical treatment of others, AND God told him he could. According to Charles Fried’s definition of a good man, Romney is a flop. But does he care?

It must be grand to be so special.

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterAkhilleus


I’ve never heard that quote about Churchill but at various times during his career he was indeed a polarizing figure who attracted both praise and contempt. One thing I will give the old boy is his way with words. His speeches may have been inflammatory but they were bits of genius at times. One reason Romney is no Winston Churchill. Another is that Churchill for all his self promotion and cantankerous ways retained a sense of perspective about himself. Clement Atlee, a sometime colleague but most often opponent of the war-time prime minister noted that Churchill was a very fortunate man, and one of the things that tempered his more abrasive side was the fact that he, Churchill, never failed to say so. That’s something you’ll never hear cross Romney’s lying lips.

Everything he has he got on his own. Luck, family, connections, insider information, had nothing to do with it.

Churchill also had the common touch, something unusual for a guy from the ranks of the nobles. A story about one of his most famous moments that still makes the rounds claims that Churchill followed the “We shall fight them on the beaches…” speech with “we’ll throw bottles at the bastards if that's all we have left.” This coda was apparently clipped by a quick fingered BBC engineer. Still, the fact that the story, apocryphal or not, has legs is an indication that Churchill, a complicated man, could actually have said such a thing. Romney? Not so much. In fact, Romney trips over words almost as frequently as Bush. Yesterday when trying to rip Obama for making political hay over the Bin Laden killing, he murdered what could have been a good line by pronouncing “word” as “whorl”. Duh.

None of this suffices, however, to obscure Churchill’s dark side. Will we ever know the real story behind the bombing raid on Coventry? Did Churchill really allow Brits to perish when he knew beforehand that the raid was coming? There’s his complicit involvement in the fire bombings of Dresden as well. No wonder George W. Bush had that bust of Churchill in the Oval Office. But it’s likely that Bush, like Romney, knew only snippets of Churchill’s life, preferring to focus on the self-promoting blustering bomb dropper.

Simple ideas are so much more appealing to the right. Complexity is just too exhausting. One more reason Romney wouldn’t care that he was replacing a bust of Lincoln with that of a foreign politician. Oh yeah, the other is likely racism. Didn’t Lincoln free the slaves? Damn! Was he crazy? Didn’t he realize that rich people need servants? Even better if you can chain them up and don't have to pay them. What was he thinking? The idea!

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterAkhilleus

The New Yorker, the talk of the town, column has two old quotes that I don't want weaders to miss.
Adlai Stevenson said of Eisenhower's supporters,"If they will stop telling lies about the Democrats, we will stop telling the truth about them ."
In 1994 Romney ran against Kennedy for the Senate." I am pro choice" the Senator said. "my opponent is multiple choice".
Some things never change, the Republicans are still lying and Mitt is still "multiple choice".

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterCarlyle

Re: accepting exceptional exceptions. I liked your comment, Jack Mahoney. I am without a doubt the world's worse businessman but I admire the guys and gals that have the heart and mind for running a small business. I like them even better if they are honest business people. I think Marie was reminding us that the knee bone is connected to the thigh bone and of course the thigh bone is connected to the hip bone etc. I thought you conveyed that yourself but I read at a congressman's level so what the hey. I've worked for honest contractors and I've walked away from guys who would put their mother in leaky coffins.
Some where in distant past I thought I remember a prof stressing that a governments job is to provide a secure marketplace for the fair exchange of goods and ideas. We've fallen away from that ideal in my opinion.
Re: Lay my body down; P.D. sometimes I just want to quit and cry and die but I refuse to give in to the fuckers.

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterJJG

I only wish they were "LSD" missionaries. People all over the world would be having more fun with the latter day saints if they had been spreading the word through chemicals.

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterVictoria

@Akhilleus. Wonderful riff on lying and the Romneybot. Truth-telling does, indeed, undergird trust and trust's absence in our present society has much to do with mendacity's prevalence.

You have one explanation: groups that consider themselves special, somehow apart from, better than, in conflict with others can more easily justify lying, but I would go farther and look at the elements of the way we live that keep us apart. I mentioned one earlier, the emphasis on the individual, which is tied to our notions of a primitive capitalism that pits every one of us against everyone else. When one is always trying to gain advantage and competition is seen as more advantageous, more socially useful, than cooperation, our economic organization alone builds high walls between us and makes us strangers to one another.

Next, I'd mention our sheer numbers and mobility. Outside our immediate families, we seldom know anyone very well. Certainly we are not directly dependent on them or they on us. Handshakes mean little because we are removed socially and geographically from those we do business with and when that is not the case, we can always avoid further contact with those whose trust we abuse. Hence there is no social, yet alone legal, cost for lying. Corporate bosses do not know us, politicians have little direct contact with their constituents; we don't even know our doctors very well. Because there is little personal, direct contact with the people who supply our needs, our intercourse with them is mediated by long supply lines, bureaucracies and legalistic, abstract contracts, both figurative and literal, that often disappoint. We have warranties galore but little that we can trust.

I would not blame Republicans for all the lies we hear, but I would suggest the Right's view of the world, that is one of individuals and small, isolated groups in constant competition with one another (to the victor go the spoils), does make lying easier to justify and more common.

What I do not understand is why, when all the polls tell us that everyone knows trust is on a permanent? leave of absence, anyone believes anything that someone who has been caught lying publicly time and again (like the Romneybot) says.

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterKen Winkes


Ha! Great idea. In fact it does seem that many current GOPers have discovered one of Timothy Leary's old stashes. They've been demonstrating the effects of increasingly altered states. Too bad Leary's not still around. He'd have made a hell of a VP for Romney...take some of the starch out of his campaign. Hey. He was a Harvard too guy wasn't he?

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterAkhilleus


Excellent points. I think your suggestion that an over-emphasis on the power of the individual and the role of unbridled competition leads to a curt dismissal of the importance of collective action and social connections deserves more careful consideration.

Here again I would raise the problem, for the right, of an appreciation of complexity, pluralistic societies, and an ability to accept and negotiate the resultant paradoxes of the modern world. Instead we get pre-approved ideological formulas of the sort that, when
flagged words like "collective" or "co-operation" appear in the crosshairs the Ideology Genie whispers "SOCIALISM" into their cauliflower ears.

Progress stymied. Mission Accomplished.

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterAkhilleus

Ken Winkes: "I would go farther and look at the elements of the way we live that keep us apart. I mentioned one earlier, the emphasis on the individual, which is tied to our notions of a primitive capitalism that pits every one of us against everyone else. When one is always trying to gain advantage and competition is seen as more advantageous, more socially useful, than cooperation, our economic organization alone builds high walls between us and makes us strangers to one another."

You forgot to mention television. I'm old enough to remember when there WAS no television, and people congregated for lots of reasons, and got to know one another and trust one another. Schools, churches (not necessarily religion), dances, plays, etc. were social occasions for everyone. And doesn't TV emphasize competition and the individual?

I'm always surprised that no-one ever seems to realize what TV has done to our society.

July 25, 2012 | Unregistered CommenterBonnie
Comments for this entry have been disabled. Additional comments may not be added to this entry at this time.