The Commentariat -- July 29, 2015
Internal links & defunct video removed.
Afternoon News:
Richard Perez-Pena of the New York Times: "A University of Cincinnati police officer was indicted on murder charges on Wednesday in the fatal shooting of a driver this month. In the indictment handed down by a grand jury in Hamilton County, the officer, Ray Tensing, is accused of killing the driver, Samuel DuBose, during a traffic stop near the campus on July 19. At a news conference, the county prosecutor, Joe Deters, said that Officer Tensing 'purposely killed' Mr. DuBose after the officer lost his temper. The death of Mr. DuBose, who was black, at the hands of Officer Tensing, who is white, joined a string of recent episodes ... that have raised hard questions about law enforcement use of force, and the role of race in policing."
Chris Brennan & Jeremy Roebuck of the Philadelphia Inquirer: "U.S. Rep. Chaka Fattah [D] and four associates were indicted Wednesday on racketeering conspiracy charges stemming from several alleged schemes to misuse campaign funds and hundreds of thousands of dollars in federal grant money to further their political and financial interests. The five schemes include accepting a $1 million illegal loan for Fattah's failed 2007 mayoral campaign from a 'wealthy supporter' and then repaying some of it using "charitable and federal grant funds" that passed through a nonprofit founded and controlled by Fattah, U.S. Attorney Zane David Memeger said at a news conference."
*****
Joby Warrick of the Washington Post: "The Obama administration has decided to give states more time to comply with proposed regulations that will require dramatic cuts in greenhouse-gas pollution from power plants, people familiar with the plans said Tuesday. The Environmental Protection Agency will give states an additional two years -- until 2022 -- to begin phasing in pollution cuts, even as the agency toughens the standards that many states will ultimately have to meet."
Michael Shear of the New York Times: "Jonathan J. Pollard, who was sentenced to life in prison in 1985 for passing classified documents to the Israeli government, will be released on parole in November after 30 years in prison, a government panel decided on Tuesday. Mr. Pollard's lawyers announced the decision of the United States Parole Commission on Tuesday afternoon, and officials at the Department of Justice confirmed that Mr. Pollard had been granted parole." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Carol Morello of the Washington Post: "Secretary of State John F. Kerry on Tuesday defended the Iran nuclear agreement as a 'strong deal' before skeptical members of Congress who expressed concern that it will eventually give Iran the freedom to build nuclear weapons and finance mayhem in the region. Appearing before the House Foreign Affairs Committee, Kerry told lawmakers that it is a 'fantasy' to think that sanctions can prevent Iran from building nuclear weapons should it choose to do is." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... William Saletan of Slate presents arguments on why Kerry should STFU. Kerry is revealing way too much, Saletan says. ...
... Eugene Scott, et al., of CNN: "The longest-serving Jewish member currently in Congress announced Tuesday that he'll back the Iran nuclear deal, saying it is the best way to protect Israel. 'I believe that Israel, the region, and the world are far more secure if Iran does not move toward possession of a nuclear weapon. I believe the Agreement is the best way to achieve that,' said Democratic Rep. Sandy Levin in a statement. The support of a veteran Jewish representative, who has served Michigan for 33 years, could be significant in building momentum for Democratic backing of the deal." ...
... CW: Levin's statement ends with a poignant remembrance:
Each Member of Congress will bring both private and public life experiences to address this difficult issue. I along with my brother and late sister when we were in our teens experienced with our parents great personal joy when President Truman announced U.S. recognition of Israel. It was something that we could take hold of amidst the unfolding horrors of the years before. Israel's security has and always will be of critical importance to me and our country. I believe that Israel, the region, and the world are far more secure if Iran does not move toward possession of a nuclear weapon. I believe the Agreement is the best way to achieve that. In my view, the only anchors in public life are to dig deeply into the facts and consult broadly and then to say what you believe.
Mike DeBonis of the Washington Post: "A Republican congressman has filed a request to oust House Speaker John A. Boehner (R-Ohio) in a new and unusual challenge to his leadership from the GOP's right flank. Rep. Mark Meadows (R-N.C.) on Tuesday evening filed a 'motion to vacate the chair,' which, if successful, would force the election of a new speaker. Such a challenge has never before succeeded in the House, and only once before -- 105 years ago -- has it been attempted."
Ted-o-thon Cut Short. Dana Milbank: "Finally, Senate Republicans are standing up to the bully who terrorized them the past two and a half years.... In a broader sense, Republican senators seem to be growing in confidence that they can defy what remains of the tea party and affiliated conservative groups...."
** Jim Rutenberg in the New York Times Magazine on the "Republican activists who have systematically dismantled" the Voting Rights Act. CW: Thanks again, Supremes.
Gardiner Harris of the New York Times: More than 167,000 people petitioned the White House, arguing that Edward Snowden was "a national hero and should be immediately issued a full, free and absolute pardon." In a statement, the White House said no, thank you.
Jennifer Haberkorn of Politico: "A new undercover video released by opponents of Planned Parenthood on Tuesday includes graphic depictions of a technician sorting through the tissue collected after an abortion.... 'This video really shows such extremely disturbing violations of patient privacy and dignity,' Dawn Laguens, executive vice president of the Planned Parenthood Action Fund, said on a call with reporters. A new Hart Research survey released by the group showed voters don't support congressional defunding efforts.... The Obama administration's top health official, HHS Secretary Sylvia Mathews Burwell, on Tuesday deferred questions on the investigations to DOJ and suggested her department is not conducting its own review of Planned Parenthood." ...
... Jennifer Haberkorn & Anna Palmer of Politico: "House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) earlier this week called to halt Planned Parenthood's federal funding while Congress investigates whether the organization broke a federal ban on profiting from fetal tissue donation. The Senate plans to hold a vote on a defunding amendment from Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) and others that is likely to fail." ...
... CW: If you're not a friend of Planned Parenthood, you're not a friend of women. It's that simple.
Ashley Parker of the New York Times: "... Facebook, already a major player in past cycles, has been working to expand its digital dominance in the political realm. Facebook -- which has 189 million monthly users in the United States -- has pitched its tools and services to every presidential campaign in the 2016 race, not to mention down-ballot races, to showcase new features as candidates seek to reach and recruit new supporters and potential donors.... Facebook has rolled out several tools since the last presidential election to help campaigns reach voters more efficiently and effectively." CW: You must find the "tools" the campaigns are using to be invasions of privacy.
A Marine Corps lieutenant colonel is relieved of her commend, & the Marine Corps Gazette subsequently decides not to publish her essay criticizing the Corps' treatment of female Marines. C. J. Chivers of the New York Times has the backstory, & publishes the essay. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Anne Barnard of the New York Times: Turkey's President Recep Tayyip "Erdogan's stance [against Kurdish militants] presents a complication for the United States and other NATO allies. Under alliance rules, they are bound to protect Turkey from threats, and they have long listed the Kurdish militant group that fought a long insurgency in Turkey, the P.K.K., as a terrorist organization. But they are eager not to let the Kurdish issue overshadow the international fight against Islamic State militants who have seized much of Syria and Iraq and sought to inspire attacks around the world."
** Annals of "Journalism," Ctd. The New York Times' "Very Good Sources." Norm Ornstein in the Atlantic: "... the huge embarrassment over the story claiming a criminal investigation of Hillary Clinton for her emails -- leading the webpage, prominent on the front page, before being corrected in the usual, cringeworthy fashion of journalists who stonewall any alleged errors and then downplay the real ones -- is a direct challenge to its fundamental credibility. And the paper's response since the initial huge error was uncovered has not been adequate or acceptable.... Someone should be held accountable here, with suspension or other action that fits the gravity of the offense." Ornstein suggests that the government leakers, whoever they might be (Trey Gowdy), had been shopping around the criminal investigation story & the reason the Times scooped the others is that the Times didn't check its facts. ...
... Jonathan Allen of Vox has more. The Times story, he says, results from "a bureaucratic turf war between the [state] department and the intelligence community" as to what is classified or "senstive" & what is not, a disagreement which the IGs asked the DOJ to mitigate, not litigate; in other words, a boring story.
Presidential Race
Zaid Jilani of AlterNet: "Of all the arguments the Democratic establishment has thrown out against Bernie Sanders' candidacy, perhaps the most recurring one revolves around electability. 'Sure, you agree with him,' they argue, 'but he can't win.' A just released CNN poll finds Sanders out-polling all of the GOP's major candidates, though pretty much tied with Jeb Bush." ...
... Also, Too. Tuck Chodd & Mark Murray of NBC News: " The Unpopularity Contest: The numbers inside the new NBC-Marist poll tell a story beyond the horesraces in Iowa and New Hampshire. They underscore how most of the top presidential candidates are unpopular right now with the general-election audience in both states. And that's especially true for Democratic frontrunner Hillary Clinton and (not much surprise here) Donald Trump. The one exception? Bernie Sanders."
AP: "Hillary Clinton says she will not take a position on the Keystone XL pipeline until she becomes president, citing her work on the issue as secretary of state. Clinton told voters in New Hampshire on Tuesday that she will not 'second-guess' Barack Obama's pending decision on the pipeline. She said that would not be the 'right thing to do' because the government's review of the project started during her tenure at the State Department." ...
... Alexa Corse & Shane Harris of the Daily Beast: "There is a two-month gap in Hillary Clinton's emails that coincides with violence in Libya and the employment status of a top Clinton aide, Huma Abedin.... 'There are gaps of months and months and months,' Republican Representative Trey Gowdy, chairman of the Select Committee on Benghazi, said in a March 8 interview.... In a statement to reporters, Clinton spokesperson Nick Merrill noted, 'More emails are slated to be released by the State Department next week, and we hope that release is as inclusive as possible.'"
Jim Newell of Salon plays “If I Were A Conservative Voter." Turns out I would love Ted Cruz who always tells me that the Bible & the Constitution justify my righteous anger at Washington RINO sellouts, & I would not be fond of elitist snob Jeb! who hangs with CEOs & regards me as a hapless rube who needs civilizing.
Mike Allen of Politico: "Fox News is opening its 5 p.m. debate to all the announced Republican candidates who fail to make the cut for the Aug. 6 prime-time event, removing a requirement that participants reach at least 1 percent in polling. The change amounts to an insurance policy for candidates who were in danger of being disqualified from the vital first debate ... -- Carly Fiorina, former New York Gov. George Pataki and Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.).... The 9 p.m. debate will include the 10 candidates with the highest average in national polls, as determined by Fox News. The 5 p.m. forum will now include all the rest." ...
... CW: If I had to vote in the GOP primary, I'd vote for Lindsey Graham, & not just because he represents my last chance to be FLOTUS. Knowing as I do that Lindsey would love to lead us into World War III, I still think he's the best-qualified GOP presidential candidate & the only one who meets the minimum IQ threshold (as it appears in Article II of the Constitution:
No Person except a natural born Citizen, or a Citizen of the United States, at the time of the Adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the Office of President; neither shall any person be eligible to that Office who shall not have attained to the Age of thirty five Years and who shall not have attained an Intelligence Quotient of at least One hundred, and been fourteen Years a Resident within the United States.)
Erik Wemple updates Donald Trump's media strategy in the wake of his consigliere's threats against a Daily Beast reporter. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Ed Kilgore: "... almost immediately, (a) Ivana Trump came to her ex-husband's defense, hinting that she might have exaggerated..., and saying he'd be a great president, blah blah blah; and (b) some Trump spox disclaims any association with [gangster lawyer Michael] Cohen's comments to the Beastly duo. For dessert, somebody discovered an old tweet with Cohen posing between two 'great Americans,' Hillary Clinton and Patrick Kennedy, and [Donald] Trump fans are beginning to speculate that he tried to sabotage Trump on Hillary's behalf! So ... it gets turned into a story ... about one a them gold-digging women who make up rape allegations they later abandon, and the lyin' liberal loser journalists -- perhaps in league with Hillary! -- who use that to smear The Donald." ...
... ** McKay Coppins of BuzzFeed: "Was this really the best goon money could buy? Cohen's outburst was, in fact, emblematic of the loyalists who have long populated The Donald's inner circle. Trump's key lieutenants tend to fit the same consumer profile as his discount luxury-brand targets: They are men with middle- and working-class roots; lacking in elite credentials; mesmerized by made-for-TV displays of lavish wealth." CW: Entertaining reading that incidentally backs up my assessment [offered a few days back] of the source of Trump's popularity. ...
... John Cassidy of the New Yorker is sticking with his earlier prediction: "Sooner or later, Trump's act will start to seem old, even to G.O.P. voters."
Rebecca Berg in Real Clear Politics: "Scott Walker has insisted he will be able to 'compete anywhere in the country' ... but, at a private event in St. Louis on Sunday, Walker said he does not plan to compete in Florida, contradicting his own public assertions that he would not skip that primary." Via Paul Waldman.
Alex Isenstadt of Politico autopsies Rand Paul's campaign. CW: Don't worry, Li'l Randy. I'm sure you'll pick up a lot of votes with your effort to defund Planned Parenthood. BTW, there's a reason your supporters are overwhelmingly male. What's up next? A move to repeal of the 19th Amendment?
Terrence Dopp of Bloomberg: "Residents in U.S. states that have legalized marijuana should toke up while they still can, New Jersey Governor Chris Christie said. 'If you're getting high in Colorado today, enjoy it,' Christie, a Republican campaigning for the 2016 presidential nomination, said Tuesday during a town-hall meeting at the Salt Hill Pub in Newport, New Hampshire. 'As of January 2017, I will enforce the federal laws.'" ...
... EXCEPT, digby points out, Christie now is also a states' rights guy. Also a God guy. CW: I'm a little confused about whether or not Christie thinks God backs the Second Amendment. I could look it up, but I don't care much about Chris Christie's theological musings. ...
... CW BTW: I found out the other day that some confederates -- like the chair of Oklahoma's Republican party -- object to the pledge of allegiance because of the "one nation, indivisible" part. I supposed the "United" part of "United States" rankles these patriots, too. Confederates are also Pre-Constitutionalists.
Mika Brzezinski is often pretty silly & shallow. Not this time:
... ** Unsurprisingly, Israelis are offended, too. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Beyond the Beltway
Reuters: "Los Angeles city council has voted unanimously to ban the possession of large-capacity gun magazines, following San Francisco to become the second major city in California to take that step. The law prohibits Los Angeles residents from possessing a handgun or rifle magazine that fits more than 10 rounds."
Jesse McKinley of the New York Times on how & why prison worker Joyce Mitchell helped two murderers escape from an upstate New York prison.
News Ledes
Guardian: "The Federal Reserve on Wednesday continued to pave the way for an increase in interest rates as early as September. The US central bank left its key interest rate unchanged at near zero -- where it has been since the 2008 financial crisis -- but once again signalled that rates will rise later this year. While the Fed chair, Janet Yellen, has left little doubt that rates will rise this year, the Fed left itself wiggle room as it has set no timetable and said rates would only be raised if the economy continues to improve and unemployment continues to fall." ...
... The Fed's statement is here.
New York Times: "A large object that appeared to be an airplane part washed up Wednesday on the shore of Réunion, a French island in the Indian Ocean, prompting speculation that it might be debris from Flight 370, the Malaysia Airlines jetliner that disappeared in March 2014." ...
... AP UPDATE: "Air safety investigators have a 'high degree of confidence' that aircraft debris found in the Indian Ocean is of a wing component unique to the Boeing 777, the same model as the Malaysia Airlines plane that disappeared last year, a U.S. official said Wednesday."
New York Times: "After months of speculation, Afghan officials announced Wednesday that they were now certain that the Taliban's reclusive leader, Mullah Muhammad Omar, died in Pakistan in 2013."
Guardian: "Binyamin Netanyahu ... has approved the immediate construction of hundreds of settlement units in the occupied West Bank and East Jerusalem in an effort to stave off a growing threat posed by pro-settler parties in his rightwing coalition government. The issue was brought to a head on Wednesday by a supreme court ruling that two buildings in the West Bank settlement of Beit El -- built on private Palestinian land without permits -- should be destroyed, despite Netanyahu's opposition."
Washington Post: "An Albuquerque 911 dispatcher has resigned after audio was released of him hanging up on a 17-year-old as she tended to a friend who was shot at the party. The victim, 17-year-old Jaydon Chavez-Silver, later died.... Emergency responders had already been dispatched to the house before [the dispatcher] hung up." Includes 911 audio.
Minneapolis Star Tribune: "A big-game hunter from the Twin Cities found himself at the center of an international firestorm Tuesday over the death of a beloved lion in Zimbabwe, but said he regrets killing the animal and believed his guides were leading him on a legal hunt.... Earlier Tuesday, the Telegraph newspaper of London identified [dentist Walter] Palmer as the hunter who shot Cecil and reported that he paid $54,000 for the hunt. The Telegraph said the lion was illegally lured out of Hwange National Park, where it had protected status, and onto a neighboring game farm, where Palmer was on safari." ...
... Salon: Yelp contributors are whacking Palmer.