The Conversation -- March 13, 2024
Marie: I meant to look for this earlier. Rep. Jerry Nadler (D-N.Y.) plays a short video at yesterday's House hearing, featuring elderly, confused & forgetful Donald Trump:
The Hur Report was revealed today! A disaster for Biden, a two tiered standard of justice. Artificial Intelligence was used by them against me in their videos of me. Can't do that Joe! -- Donald Trump on his social media platform, Tuesday night ~~~
~~~ Steve Benen of MSNBC: Donald Trump "could've simply ignored all of this and hoped that the clips went unnoticed. Instead, he drew fresh attention to the video montage and claimed that Democrats relied on 'artificial intelligence.' By pushing this defense, Trump is simultaneously (a) lying, (b) drawing attention to videos he should hope voters don't see; and (c) implicitly suggesting that the clips are so humiliating that they couldn't possibly be real, except they are, in fact, genuine and unaltered."
BUT the Confused, Elderly Man Still Begs to Debate President Biden. Amelia Neath of the Independent: Donald Trump "called himself 'Honest Don' in a recent Truth Social post in which he called on President Joe Biden to have a 'full-scale debate' with him. 'For the good of our now failing Nation, and in order to inform the American people of what is going on in our Country, we must immediately have a full-scale debate between Crooked Joe and Honest Don. I'm ready to go, ANY TIME, ANY PLACE!' Mr Trump posted on Tuesday.... [An' X user [wrote]: 'Trump calling himself Honest Don is like Jeffrey Dahmer calling himself Vegan Jeff.'" Thanks to Akhilleus for the lead.
Sapna Magesgwaru, et al., of the New York Times: "The House on Wednesday passed a bill with broad bipartisan support that would force TikTok's Chinese owner to sell the hugely popular video app or be banned in the United States. The move escalates a showdown between Beijing and Washington over the control of technologies that could affect national security, free speech and the social media industry. Republican leaders fast-tracked the bill through the House with limited debate, and it passed on a lopsided vote of 352-65, reflecting widespread backing for legislation that would take direct aim at China in an election year. The action came despite TikTok's efforts to mobilize its 170 million U.S. users against the measure, and amid the Biden administration's push to persuade lawmakers that Chinese ownership of the platform poses grave national security risks to the United States. The result was a bipartisan coalition behind the measure that included Republicans, who defied ... Donald J. Trump in supporting it, and Democrats, who also fell in line behind a bill that President Biden has said he would sign. The bill faces a difficult road to passage in the Senate...." The AP's report is here.
Tierney Sneed, et al., of CNN: "The presiding judge in the Georgia criminal case against Donald Trump and his allies has thrown out some of the charges against the former president and several of his co-defendants. The partial dismissal by Georgia Superior Court Judge Scott McAfee leaves most of the sprawling racketeering indictment intact. McAfee ruled that six charges in the 41-count indictment related to Trump and some co-defendants allegedly soliciting the violation of oath by a public officer lacked the required detail about what underlying crime the defendants were soliciting.... 'As written, these six counts contain all the essential elements of the crimes but fail to allege sufficient detail regarding the nature of their commission, i.e., the underlying felony solicited,' McAfee [wrote]. 'They do not give the Defendants enough information to prepare their defenses intelligently, as the Defendants could have violated the Constitutions and thus the statute in dozens, if not hundreds, of distinct ways.'... The new ruling did not address the ethics allegations brought against Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis by the defendants. McAfee has pledged to issue a ruling on that issue by the end of the week."
Kathleen Culliton of the Raw Story: Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene Tuesday shared with her X followers a photograph of herself smiling directly into the camera next to an announcement for ... '... a hearing on investigating the black market of baby organ harvesting.'... Greene adds, 'Join me and special guests.' The hearing, slated for March 19 at 2 p.m., will include testimony from David Daleiden and Terrisa Bukovinac, according to the announcement.... Daleiden is an anti-abortion activist ordered to pay $2 million in damages to Planned Parenthood over accusations of conspiracy and eavesdropping, according to a Reuters report from October. Bukovinac is an anti-abortion activist who appears in a 2022 feature from New York Magazine about Lauren Handy, a fellow activist who reportedly stored baby fetuses in her refrigerator until they were removed by police." Thanks to RAS for the link. ~~~
~~~ Marie: This announcement is weird on so many levels. Besides the beaming smile, MTG is wearing a dress that looks like just the thing to flounce around in at a lawn party. The announcement itself looks like a party invitation. And with "special guests"?? Witnesses called to a Congressional hearing on a serious subject are not "guests." They're supposed to be "experts," not that Miss Margie's crackpot "guests" are experts on anything. The whole thing just screams, "Wow, I'm having fun partying in Washington, D.C.! Join me!" It's not exactly breaking news that Miss Georgia Peach 1993 is not a serious member of Congress, but this is an offensive misuse of her office.
~~~~~~~~~~
The New York Times live-updated Tuesday's election results:
Michael Nicholas Nehamas: "The Associated Press named Mr. Biden the presumptive Democratic nominee after projecting his victory in Georgia, while Mr. Trump was designated the presumptive Republican nominee after he swept the G.O.P. contests in Georgia, Mississippi and Washington State."
Georgia: President Biden has won the state's Democratic primary presidential election. Donald Trump has won the state's Republican primary presidential election.
Hawaii. Donald Trump won the Hawaii caucuses.
Mississippi. President Biden has won the state's Democratic primary presidential election. Donald Trump has won the state's Republican primary presidential election.
Washington. President Biden has won the state's Democratic primary presidential election. Fuckface Von Clownstick has won the state's Republican primary presidential election.
Chris Cameron: "Donald Trump has won the Republican primary in Georgia, according to The Associated Press, winning in a state where he is under indictment on 13 charges, including racketeering, in connection with his effort to overturn the 2020 election."
~~~~~~~~~~
Glenn Thrush & Luke Broadwater of the New York Times: "Robert K. Hur, the special counsel who investigated President Biden, on Tuesday fiercely defended the disparaging assessment of the president's mental state included in his final report -- and his decision not to charge Mr. Biden with a crime. Mr. Hur, appearing before the House Judiciary Committee to answer questions about his polarizing 345-page report, cast himself as an impartial arbiter.... Mr. Hur, a registered Republican who has been slammed by Mr. Biden's allies for including his politically damaging assessment of Mr. Biden's memory, showed little emotion during the hearing, but reacted angrily when a Democrat suggested he had 'smeared' the president to bolster Mr. Trump....
"About an hour before Mr. Hur testified, Democrats on the congressional panel released a lightly redacted transcript of the five-hour interview Mr. Hur and his team conducted with Mr. Biden. It offered a more nuanced portrayal than the special counsel's damning description of the 81-year-old president as 'a sympathetic, well-meaning, elderly man with a poor memory.' While the 258-page transcript showed that on several occasions the president fumbled with dates and the sequence of events, he otherwise appeared clearheaded, with the kind of gaps in recollection not uncommon among people interviewed about events that transpired years earlier.... Democrats kicked off the hearing by playing a highlight reel of Mr. Trump's own verbal miscues and memory lapses -- and included a clip in which he said he did not remember saying he had a great memory."
Marie: Gee, nothing like this has ever happened before (Jim Comey/Hillary Clinton): a Republican DOJ official releases a report finding a Democratic nominee for president had committed no prosecutable crimes, then exaggerates the investigation's findings and trashes the nominee.
Matt Viser of the Washington Post: "A Post review of the complete 258-page Hur transcript ... paints a more nuanced portrait of the exchanges between [President] Biden and the special counsel. Biden doesn't come across as being as absent-minded as [Robert] Hur has made him out to be -- and Hur doesn't appear as crass as Biden has made him out to be.... The full transcript provides a more complete window into the back and forth between the two men, in which Biden frequently joked with prosecutors in a setting that seemed more chummy than antagonistic."
Andrew Prokop of Vox: "... the full transcripts of Hur's interviews with Biden have been released -- and they make Hur's claims about Biden's memory appear cherry-picked and exaggerated. Biden sat for more than five hours with Hur's team over two days. In that time, he said he did not recall specifics about how particular boxes ended up in his residences or offices after his vice presidency. But he engaged at length about his process for handling classified information and many other topics. Hur's claim that Biden had demonstrated some sort of general 'poor memory' hangs almost entirely on mix-ups by Biden about in what specific year several years-old events occurred. The transcript makes clear Biden remembers all those events. But it seems Biden just doesn't pay a lot of attention to which specific year stuff happened in.... Following in the footsteps of former special counsel John Durham, who labored without success to prove theories of Democratic malfeasance in the Trump-Russia investigation, he released a report that kind of swipes at his target anyway."
Anthony Adragna of Politico: Robert Hur "praised Biden during the interview for his 'photographic understanding and recall' of a house the president visited during a trip to Mongolia. Biden also used the interchange to tout his archery skills while recalling his foray into the sport during his foreign trip. He said that he's 'not a bad archer' but that due to 'pure luck, I hit the goddamn target.' The president added that 'I turned to the prime minister and handed [the bow] to him and the poor son-of-a-bitch couldn't pull it back.'" (See pp. 46-47 of the interview transcript, linked below.)
The transcript of Hur's interview of President Biden, via the House, is here.
Marie: One thing Hur purports not to understand is that people use different hooks to remember things. Like Biden, I don't much remember dates. The other day I had to figure out what year my husband died (2013). It's not that his death wasn't a significant and traumatic event in my own life; it's just that I don't naturally peg events to dates. Hur's report of Biden's "poor memory" is more a reflection of Hur's personal limitations than of Biden's memory. Hur, for instance, may have poor affective responses, so he may be more likely to remember milestones than to feel the meaning of the milestone events themselves. Thus, he was impressed with Biden's vivid recollections of a long-ago trip to Mongolia because Hur himself would not have remembered the affects of an event itself as much as he would tie it to a chronology of his own life.
Annals of "Journalism," Ctd. Another MSM Fail. Matt Gertz of Media Matters: "Major news outlets that ran dozens of stories hyping then-special counsel Robert Hur's claim that President Joe Biden evinced a 'poor memory' during their interview are now acknowledging that Hur's depiction was exaggerated after reviewing the newly released transcript.... The mainstream political press treated Hur as an impartial voice levying credible accusations, unleashing a deluge of reports calling Biden's mental acuity into question. Hur's background as a former clerk to right-wing judges and a Trump administration appointee -- and his gratuitous swipes at a Democratic president that happened to align with a yearslong GOP campaign to portray Biden as addled -- failed to raise their alarms....
"The Washington Post ran 33 reports on Biden's mental fitness in the four days following Hur's report, according to a review by Popular Information. On Tuesday, however, the Post reported that the transcript 'paints a more nuanced portrait of the exchanges between Biden and the special counsel' and that 'Biden doesn't come across as being as absent-minded as Hur has made him out to be.'... The New York Times ran 30 reports on Biden's mental fitness in the four days following Hur's report, according to Popular Information. But on Tuesday, the Times reported the transcript 'shows that on several occasions the president fumbled with dates and the sequence of events, while otherwise appearing clearheaded.'"
Alex Gangitano of the Hill: "The White House on Tuesday declared it was 'time to move on' from Robert Hur's controversial report on President Biden's handling of classified documents after the special counsel testified for hours before the House Judiciary Committee and took fire from all sides."
The New York Times live-updated the House hearing of testimony by Special Counsel Robert Hur. It looks like Gym Jordan is running the hearing, so no doubt it will all go very smoothly. And totally fairly. (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~
~~~ Marie: I couldn't stand to watch the hearing, but the Times updates are are helpful. The reporters' analysis suggests to me that Hur -- a Republican -- is bending hard toward Republicans. For instance,
Charlie Savage: "As Republicans like Representative Jeff Van Drew of New Jersey use their questioning of Hur to portray Biden's and Trump's actions as equivalent in order to disparage the charges against Trump, Hur could respond by repeating what he wrote in his report, that there are clearly 'several material distinctions' between the two cases, and the allegations against Trump, if proved, 'present serious aggravating facts' unlike the evidence involving Biden. It is notable Hur is choosing not to speak up." Emphasis added.
Glenn Thrush (pinned item): "It is not unusual for witnesses in federal cases to cite their faulty recollections in interviews with investigators, particularly about events that occurred years earlier. But Mr. Hur included references to Mr. Biden's memory that did not relate directly to retaining classified documents -- including the president's struggle to recall the year (2015) when his son Beau died." ~~~
~~~ Marie: IOW, as we all know, there's a difference between (1) conveniently repeating "I don't recall" in the way, say, Cassidy Hutchinson's Trump-paid lawyer advised her to do in order to avoid providing incriminating answers, and (2) innocently forgetting a specific date or event that may have occurred many years in the past and/or may have nothing to do with the matter at hand.
BTW, NiskyGuy notes at the top of today's Comments thread that Hur testified as a private citizen, not as a DOJ official. He quit the DOJ way back on Monday. I had been wondering why he did so: (1) something innocent, like got a great job? (2) or something more nefarious? Well, Hur is a Republican fixture, so my first guess didn't count. ~~~
~~~ Andrew Feinberg of the Independent: Robert Hur "has arranged his departure from the Department of Justice to be official as of Monday 11 March, one day before he is scheduled to appear on Capitol Hill. Instead of appearing as a DOJ employee who is bound by the ethical guidelines which govern the behaviour of federal prosecutors, he will appear as a private citizen with no constraints on his testimony.... ... [He] has surrounded himself with Republican partisans and notorious figures linked to former president Donald Trump.... In preparing for the hearing, Mr Hur has turned to William Burck, a veteran Washington lawyer with deep ties to the Republican political establishment to serve as his counsel during his testimony before the committee." Read on. Burck has a long client list & sundry associates that are nothing less than a GOP rogue's gallery. MB: Please don't try to tell me Hur ever intended to act as an honest broker in this "investigation."
Clare Foran of CNN: "Republican Rep. Ken Buck of Colorado, a hardline conservative who has clashed with his own party at times, announced on Tuesday that he will leave Congress at the end of next week. Buck criticized dysfunction on Capitol Hill in discussing his decision to leave, telling CNN's Dana Bash, 'It is the worst year of the nine years and three months that I've been in Congress and having talked to former members, it's the worst year in 40, 50 years to be in Congress.... This place has just devolved into this bickering and nonsense and not really doing the job for the American people.'... Buck's decision to step down before the end of his term will trim Republicans' slim edge to 218 seats over 213 for Democrats, with three vacancies. With that breakdown, Republicans could only afford to lose two votes to pass legislation on a party-line vote." MB: I heard on the teevee that Buck didn't bother to give Mike Johnson a heads-up. ~~~
~~~ Robert Jimison of the New York Times looks at the ways Buck's resignation could affect Colorado Congressional elections this year.
Presidential Race, Ctd.
MEANWHILE, the GOP presidential frontrunner is a stable genius. This, from a transcript of one of Trump's campaign speeches. Thanks to RAS for the link: ~~~
Never forget. It's nothing new. Trump has always been a barking lunatic.pic.twitter.com/jv0VZ2Iumz
— Michigan GOP Watch (@MiMagaWatch) March 11, 2024
Tierney Sneed of CNN: "The policy-making body of the federal judiciary is clamping down on the system that conservatives have successfully used in recent years to hamstring President Joe Biden's agenda and other federal policies, including those concerning reproductive rights. The new policy seeks to curb 'judge-shopping,' the strategy where litigants strategically file lawsuits in courthouses where the cases will be guaranteed to be heard by judges perceived to be sympathetic to their arguments.... The Judicial Conference of the United States announced Tuesday a new policy that will broaden the pool of judges who could be assigned to hear cases seeking state-wide or nationwide orders, making it more difficult to single out a particular judge, although it will still be possible to seek out a favorable pool of judges to hear cases. Under the new policy, such cases seeking nationwide or state-wide orders will go into the lottery system used by the entire district." The Washington Post's report is here.
~~~~~~~~~~
Laura Meckler, et al., of the Washington Post: "School hate crimes targeting LGBTQ+ people have sharply risen in recent years, climbing fastest in states that have passed laws restricting LGBTQ student rights and education, a Washington Post analysis of FBI data finds. In states with restrictive laws, the number of hate crimes on K-12 campuses has more than quadrupled since the onset of a divisive culture war that has often centered on the rights of LGBTQ+ youth. At the same time, calls to LGBTQ+ youth crisis hotlines have exploded, with some advocates drawing a connection between the spike in bullying and hate crimes, and the political climate." Thanks to RAS for the link. MB: There's a chicken-and-egg question here. The data show a correlation but not a clear cause-and-effect.
Wisconsin. Todd Richmond of the AP: "Republicans who control the state Senate fired eight more of Democratic Gov. Tony Evers' appointees Tuesday, including two Universities of Wisconsin regents who voted against a deal that limited campus diversity and four judicial watchdogs who wouldn't commit to punishing liberal state Supreme Court Justice Janet Protasiewicz. The Senate also fired a member of the governor's domestic abuse council after Republicans accused the body of violating open records laws and taking what the GOP considered a stance against white people, as well as a member of the deferred compensation board, which administers a state retirement program. The Senate has now fired 21 Evers appointees since the governor took office in 2019. The governor said in a statement Tuesday that he was 'apoplectic' that Republican senators keep firing his appointees for no good reason."
~~~~~~~~~~
Israel/Palestine, et al. CNN's live updates of developments Wednesday in the Israel/Hamas war are here: "The first maritime humanitarian aid shipment to Gaza since the war began is on its way to the enclave from Cyprus, according to nonprofit World Central Kitchen. As fears of famine grow in northern Gaza, the UN World Food Programme said one of its food convoys reached Gaza City for the first time since February 20.... An Israeli border police officer fatally shot a 12-year-old Palestinian boy in a refugee camp in occupied east Jerusalem, officials said." ~~~
~~~ The New York Times' live updates for Wednesday are here.
Ukraine, et al. Dan Lamothe of the Washington Post: "The Biden administration said Tuesday that it will send an additional $300 million in security assistance to Ukraine, an 'extraordinary measure' being taken as President Biden's request for billions of dollars more remains stalled in Congress. The emergency package, announced by the White House, will be funded by 'unanticipated cost savings' from contracts the Pentagon had brokered to replace weapons previously provided to Ukraine, national security adviser Jake Sullivan told reporters. The aid will include artillery shells, anti-armor weapons, antiaircraft Stinger weapons and other arms, as well as spare parts, U.S. officials said."
Paul Sonne of the New York Times: "The chief of staff to Aleksei A. Navalny, the Russian opposition leader who died last month in an Arctic penal colony, was attacked with a hammer and tear gas outside his home in Lithuania's capital late Tuesday, according to Mr. Navalny's press secretary, who said the police and an ambulance had been called to the scene. Leonid Volkov, who served as one of Mr. Navalny's top organizers, was pulling up to his house in Vilnius when the attack happened. At least one assailant smashed his car window, sprayed him with tear gas and began beating him with a hammer.... Mr. Volkov survived the attack."