The Conversation -- October 9, 2023
Arlette Saenz, et al., of CNN: "Eleven US citizens have died in the conflict in Israel, President Joe Biden said Monday, and an unknown number remain missing. 'As we continue to account for the horrors of the appalling terrorist assault against Israel this weekend and the hundreds of innocent civilians who were murdered, we are seeing the immense scale and reach of this tragedy,' Biden said in a statement. 'Sadly, we now know that at least 11 American citizens were among those killed -- many of whom made a second home in Israel.' It is 'likely,' Biden said, that American citizens may be among those being held hostage by Hamas, and that his administration is working with Israeli officials on 'every aspect of the hostage crisis.' Biden also noted that there are American citizens whose whereabouts remain unaccounted for. 'This is not some distant tragedy. The ties between Israel and the United States run deep,' he said. 'It is personal for so many American families who are feeling the pain of this attack as well as the scars inflicted through millennia of antisemitism and persecution of Jewish people.'"
~~~~~~~~~~
Melina Delkic & Anna Betts of the New York Times: "Two years after President Biden became the first U.S. president to formally commemorate Indigenous Peoples' Day, more than a dozen states recognize some version of the holiday in lieu of Columbus Day. More than 100 cities have adopted the holiday, choosing to heed calls from Indigenous groups and other activists not to celebrate Christopher Columbus, the Italian navigator after whom the holiday is named. They say he brought genocide and colonization to communities that had been in the Americas for thousands of years. Many around the country, however, still celebrate Columbus Day or Italian Heritage Day as a point of pride.... [Indigenous Peoples' Day] is not yet a federal holiday, though lawmakers in Congress have introduced legislation that proposes to make it one. Here is more background." ~~~
~~~ Harmeet Kaur of CNN: "For centuries, the US celebrated Christopher Columbus as the intrepid explorer who discovered the Americas -- a symbol of the American ideals of entrepreneurship and innovation. The story of the Italian navigator taught to generations of schoolchildren is shrouded in mythology. But for the Indigenous peoples who inhabited the Americas long before Columbus ever arrived, Columbus and his namesake holiday represent something much more sinister: the violent colonization of their lands and the brutal treatment of their people. The movement to replace Columbus Day with Indigenous Peoples' Day has been decades in the making." First published a year ago.
Marie: Shame on me for forgetting on Indigenous Peoples' Day Randy Newman's historical perspective on my own peoples' "contributions" to the American experience. Thanks to Akhilleus for the reminder:
Annie Karni of the New York Times: Rep. Steve "Scalise [R-La.], a longtime rival to former Speaker Kevin McCarthy, is now mounting his own bid for the post. He has pitched himself as the man uniquely positioned to unite Republicans at a moment when they are deeply divided and demoralized after Mr. McCarthy's historic ouster last week. His candidacy is the culmination of a steady political climb for a deeply conservative Republican who once described himself, according to a local columnist, as 'like David Duke without the baggage.'... Under the current rules of the Republican conference, whoever receives a majority in [a] secret-ballot vote will be the party's nominee when the full House meets to elect a new speaker, now expected on Wednesday."
Aaron Blake of the Washington Post: "The fact that [Rep. Jim] Jordan [R-Ohio] is a viable [candidate for Speaker of the House] appears to be less about his own evolution than the Republican Party's.... 'I just never saw a guy who spent more time tearing things apart -- never building anything, never putting anything together,' former House speaker John A. Boehner (R-Ohio) wrote in his 2021 book, which lumped his Ohio colleague in with other 'legislative terrorists.'... For much of the 2010s, Jordan was a key leader of GOP efforts to push the government toward shutdowns while holding out for concessions.... That is relevant given that the next speaker would be thrust into an imminent shutdown debate, with the next deadline mid-November, according to the deal McCarthy cut.... But shutdowns aren't the only area in which Jordan has been to the right of his colleagues and held a hard line.... Jordan has aligned himself with [Donald] Trump in ways that even many of his fellow Republicans have been reluctant to[.]... And that's to say nothing of the personal questions." Blake details many of Jordan's, ah, shortcomings.
Where "Moderate" Means Timid or Whiney. Jennifer Rubin of the Washington Post: is tired of hearing so-called "moderate Republicans" complain about their party's flamethrowers. "It's not the MAGA Republicans who are responsible for the House's descent into chaos, nor is it the responsibility of the minority party that has been lied to by [Kevin] McCarthy and his ilk. The culprit is the famed 'moderate' Republicans we keep hearing about.... If they and a supposed majority of House Republicans want to prove they are more responsible and more serious than their MAGA counterparts, they can either advance a sober contender for speaker or, better yet, place conditions on their support for any speaker (just as the far-right did with McCarthy).... This would entail an actual commitment ... to behave responsibly. Though this sounds almost inconceivable, this should be the bare minimum required of any member." ~~~
~~~ Marie: If they're so moderate, can't they come up with a candidate for speaker who did not associate himself with the Ku Klux Klan or help engineer a coup against the U.S.? Unfortunately, the answer is probably not.
~~~~~~~~~~
Germany. Christopher Schuetze of the New York Times: "German voters handed a victory on Sunday to mainstream conservatives in a state election in Bavaria -- as well as in the smaller central state of Hesse -- while punishing the three parties running the country. While all three of the governing parties lost votes, symbolically at least, the far-right Alternative for Germany and another populist party were the evening's clear victors, notching record results in both states when compared with other western states." MB: While the article discusses the success of "conservatives" and "populists," you would not be wrong to think "Nazis," at least where it comes to "populists."
Israel/Palestine. Andrés Martínez & Isabel Kershner of the New York Times: "Israel's military acknowledged on Monday that it was still battling to drive Palestinian militants out of southern towns near the Gaza Strip and that more militants could still be crossing through breaches in the border fence, two days after an invasion that has killed hundreds and provoked furious retaliatory strikes by Israel.... More than 700 people have been killed in Israel, which has responded to the assault by striking nearly 500 targets in Gaza, leveling whole buildings that they say are linked to Hamas, the militant group that controls the territory. At least 493 Palestinians have been killed, according to authorities in Gaza.... The timing and scale of the next steps, which Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said would dstroy Hamas, were unclear because Hamas and other militants held at least 150 Israelis hostage. And Israel appears to be nowhere closer to answering key questions about how it was caught unaware by the attack on Saturday despite having some of the most extensive and sophisticated intelligence, missile defense and spying networks in the world." This is a liveblog. ~~~
~~~ The Washington Post's live updates are here. The AP's live updates are here. ~~~
~~~ CNN's live updates are here: "Israeli Minister of Defense Yoav Gallant says he has given an order for Gaza's 'complete siege.' No electricity, food, fuel or water will be delivered to the enclave, which is surrounded on three sides by Israel and Egypt. 'We are fighting barbarians and will respond accordingly,' he said on camera." MB: Nothing medieval about that.
Susannah George, et al., of the Washington Post: "Israel formally declared war against the Palestinian militant group Hamas on Sunday as it reeled from a surprise attack that killed more than 700 people, opening the way for a major escalation in fighting that already threatened to engulf the region. A swelling counterattack by Israeli forces in Gaza also killed more than 400 people, including 78 children, as residents braced for a more punishing campaign that some feared would include an Israeli ground invasion. The vote for war by Israel's cabinet could signal a wider operation -- it allows the government to expand military mobilization and deploy a more lethal range of military options. U.S. officials said Sunday that they expected Israel to launch a ground incursion into Gaza in the next 24 to 48 hours, according to people familiar with the matter. Israel also requested heightened cooperation with the United States on intelligence-sharing related to southern Lebanon...."
Michael Birnbaum, et al., of the Washington Post: "The Biden administration on Sunday scrambled to prevent Hamas's assault on Israel from escalating into a multi-front, regional conflict, deploying a U.S. aircraft carrier group to the eastern Mediterranean and rushing arms to the Israeli military in a bid to deter the Lebanon-based Hezbollah and other actors from attacking.... American citizens are probably among the hostages that Hamas is holding inside Gaza, Secretary of State Antony Blinken said Sunday. At least several Americans were killed in the attack, a senior administration official confirmed."
Tia Goldenberg of the AP: "Israel's intelligence agencies have gained an aura of invincibility over the decades because of a string of achievements.... Israel's intelligence agencies have gained an aura of invincibility over the decades because of a string of achievements.... the apparent lack of prior knowledge of Hamas' plot will likely be seen as a prime culprit in the chain of events that led to the deadliest attack against Israelis in decades.... The ferocious attack, which likely took months of planning and meticulous training and involved coordination among multiple militant groups, appeared to have gone under Israel's intelligence radar. Amir Avivi, a retired Israeli general, said that without a foothold inside Gaza, Israel's security services have come to rely increasingly on technological means to gain intelligence. He said militants in Gaza have found ways to evade that technological intelligence gathering, giving Israel an incomplete picture of their intentions." ~~~
~~~ David Ignatius of the Washington Post: compares the intelligence failures that caused U.S. agencies to fail to connect the dots that signaled the 9/11 attacks to those that caused Israeli intelligence to miss the signs that pointed toward a major attack by Hamas.
Mr. Potato Head Doesn't Care. Ursula Perano, et al., of Politico: "Sen. Tommy Tuberville is not relenting from his monthslong blockade of military nominations over the Biden administration's abortion policy -- even in the face of one of America's closest allies going to war.... [Because of Tuberville's hold on military nominations & promotions, more than] 300 nominees are in limbo, including two picks for the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and top officers slated to command U.S. forces in the Middle East. 'The severity of the crisis in Israel underscores the foolishness of Senator Tuberville's blockade,' Senate Armed Services Chair Jack Reed said in a statement Sunday. 'The United States needs seamless military leadership in place to handle dangerous situations like this and Senator Tuberville is denying it. This is no time for petty political theater, and I again urge Republican colleagues to help actively end Senator Tuberville's damaging blockade,' the Rhode Island Democrat added. 'The time for talking is over.'" ~~~
~~~ AND we all knew this was coming. Alex Griffing of Mediaite: "...Donald Trump weighed in Sunday morning on the devastating attack Hamas launched against civilians in Israel on Saturday as only he would. 'THE HORRIBLE ATTACK ON ISRAEL, MUCH LIKE THE ATTACK ON UKRAINE, WOULD NEVER HAVE HAPPENED IF I WERE PRESIDENT -- ZERO CHANCE!' Trump posted to his Truth Social platform.... 'They didn't have that level of aggression with me. They didn't have it. This would have never happened with me either,' Trump said [in a statement]. He also later in the day declared during a Cedar Rapids rally that Biden had 'betrayed Israel' by releasing $6 billion in funds to Iran in exchange for American prisoners." ~~~
~~~ Marie: Yes, yes, the lion would lie down with the lamb if I were president, too, and the dove of peace would fly over every hill and dale. I'd teach the world to sing in perfect harmony and I'd buy everybody a Coke (okay a Diet Coke). What absolute crap. ~~~
~~~ AND here's what Kristen Welker of NBC News thinks is getting tough on Nikki Haley for claiming Hamas was using money the U.S. released for Iranian humanitarian relief: "And yet, there's just no proof of that yet.... Is it irresponsible to level that charge when you really don't have any evidence of that at this point in time?" MB: Good thing she wasn't interviewing Trump again; she would have asked him if it was irresponsible to claim Hamas was afraid of him. Most Americans don't have or don't take time to follow the news closely. They figure they're being extra-good citizens if they catch a few nightly news broadcasts & tune into a Sunday morning news show. That's not really unreasonable. Well, thanks to the networks for misleading them with milquetoast & honey.
News Lede
New York Times: "The Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences was awarded on Monday to Claudia Goldin, a Harvard professor, for advancing the world's understanding of women's progress in the work force with her research. The Nobel committee announced the award in Stockholm. Ms. Goldin is the third woman to have won the economics Nobel, and the first one to be honored with it solo, rather than sharing in the prize. She has long been a groundbreaking woman in the field -- she was the first woman to be offered tenure in Harvard's economics department, in 1989." The AP's story is here.