The Commentariat -- August 27, 2017
Philip Rucker & Ellen Nakashima of the Washington Post: This past spring, President Trump "asked Attorney General Jeff Sessions whether it would be possible for the government to drop the criminal case against [Joe] Arpaio, but was advised that would be inappropriate, according to three people with knowledge of the conversation. After talking with Sessions, Trump decided to let the case go to trial, and if Arpaio was convicted, he could grant clemency. So the president waited, all the while planning to issue a pardon if Arpaio was found in contempt of court.... Trump's Friday-evening decision to issue his first pardon for Arpaio was the culmination of a five-year political friendship with roots in the 'birther' movement to undermine President Barack Obama. In an extraordinary exercise of presidential power, Trump bypassed the traditional review process to ensure that Arpaio ... would face no time in prison. Trump's pardon, issued without consulting the Justice Department, raised a storm of protest over the weekend, including from some fellow Republicans, and threatens to become a stain on the president's legacy.... Trump's spring inquiry about intervening in Arpaio's case is consistent with his alleged attempts to influence the federal investigation of Michael Flynn, the former national security adviser." ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: So it comes back to Trump's envy of Barack Obama. So much does. ...
Asking the Attorney General to drop a case against a political ally is the kind of thing people get impeached for https://t.co/iUC1no2YHx -- Dan Pfeiffer [President Obama's communications director] (@danpfeiffer) August 27, 2017
... Words. Matt Shuham of TPM: "House Speaker Paul Ryan (R-WI) on Saturday criticized ... Donald Trump's decision to pardon former Maricopa County, Arizona Sheriff Joe Arpaio.... 'The speaker does not agree with the decision,' Ryan's spokesperson, Doug Andres, told the Wall Street Journal. 'Law-enforcement officials have a special responsibility to respect the rights of everyone in the United States. We should not allow anyone to believe that responsibility is diminished by this pardon.'" Mrs. McC: A statement of "disagreement" issued through a spokesperson is better than nothing. Initiating impeachment proceedings would be better. ...
... On the other hand, Ryan's "disagreement" with the pardon was probably no more than a smarmy attempt to keep a few Latinos in the Republican party's tent. Conor Friedorsdorf of the Atlantic: "If the Latinos who are threatened by this action [-- the pardon --] and the decent people of all races and ethnic groups who are offended by it hold it against Republicans who support the Arpaio pardon or stay silent, the GOP will deserve every last election and vote that they lose, having flagrantly failed to stand up for the creed of liberty and justice for all." ...
... Brandon Carter of the Hill: "Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) blasted President Trump over his pardon of former Maricopa County, Ariz., Sheriff Joe Arpaio on Friday, arguing it 'undermines his claim for the respect of rule of law.' 'Mr. Arpaio was found guilty of criminal contempt for continuing to illegally profile Latinos living in Arizona based on their perceived immigration status in violation of a judge's orders,' McCain said in a statement. 'The President has the authority to make this pardon, but doing so at this time undermines his claim for the respect of rule of law as Mr. Arpaio has shown no remorse for his actions.'" (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Adam Liptak of the New York Times: "President Trump 's decision to pardon Joe Arpaio ... came late on a Friday night as a hurricane bore down on Texas. It concerned a crime some said was particularly ill-suited to clemency, and it was not the product of the care and deliberation that have informed pardons by other presidents. But it was almost certainly lawful. The Constitution gives presidents extremely broad power to grant pardons.... Mr. Trump ... used his constitutional power to block a federal judge's effort to enforce the Constitution. Legal experts said they found this to be the most troubling aspect of the pardon, given that it excused the lawlessness of an official who had sworn to defend the constitutional structure." ...
Arpaio action was appalling & political. It also sends message to witnesses in Russia investigation to keep quiet, stay loyal & get pardon. -- Adam Schiff August 26, 2017
Amanda Erickson of the Washington Post asks several experts on authoritarianism about Trump's pardon of Arpaio. Cas Mudde provides a plausible explanation for the timing of the pardon, which has befuddled others: "... the timing is probably ... more linked to the issue that predominates President Trump's mind: the Russia investigation. There are several key people in his former entourage who are at the point of caving to pressure to working with the [Robert S.] Mueller investigation. Trump has shown them that they have nothing to fear, because he can and will pardon them, irrespective of the circumstances. This, of course, is a fundamentally undemocratic position, but not so much informed by ideology but by naked self-interest." ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: Seems to me what Mudde misses is that "naked self-interest" is Trump's ideology.
... Dan Balz of the Washington Post: "President Trump has set his presidency on an unambiguous course for which there could be no reversal. He has chosen to be a divider, not a uniter, no matter how many words to the contrary he reads off a teleprompter or from a prepared script. That's one obvious message from Friday's decision to issue a pardon for controversial former Arizona sheriff Joe Arpaio. Trump has been a divisive force from the very start of his campaign for president, a proud disrupter of the political status quo.... The more he is under fire -- as he is now -- the more he returns to that strategy.... The pardon was an extraordinary act coming so early in a presidency and sets a tone both on immigration and on the president's willingness to use this power to take care of those who have been loyal to him." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Jonathan Blitzer of the New Yorker: "Even before Arpaio was found to be in contempt of court, advocates and community members in Arizona beat him at the ballot box, which showed that Trump, too, could be defeated democratically.... What ultimately mobilized the community against Arpaio was his decision to work formally and systematically with federal immigration authorities. The sheriff's department began arresting Hispanic residents with little or no pretense at all, and if they happened to be undocumented Arpaio would turn them over to Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) for deportation. 'Before then, no one really had an official agreement with ICE; there was no police agency handing people over,' [Puente director Carlos] Garcia said. 'Arpaio used to set up a perimeter around immigrant communities, and send out hundreds of officers who would arrest and detain anyone they wanted.' The Trump Administration has spent the last six months trying to force local law-enforcement agencies to collaborate with ICE as Arpaio did, and many police chiefs and sheriffs across the country have resisted."
** AP: "Active-duty transgender troops say a policy change that puts them at risk of being removed and indefinitely bars transgender people from enlisting in the military is a step backward for civil rights that will promote inequality in the armed forces.... The guidance from the White House contradicts Trump's words, Army Capt Jennifer Sims said, pointing out that the president just praised the military for its tolerance when he [spoke to] veterans in Nevada on Wednesday.... Days earlier, Trump, speaking to thousands of soldiers ... in Arlington, Virginia, denounced prejudice, bigotry and hate in the wake of violence that erupted at a rally organized by white supremacists in Charlottesville, Virginia.... A 2016 study by the Rand Corporation estimated it would cost the military $2.4m to $8.4m a year to provide gender transition-related coverage, an increase of 0.04% to 0.13% in healthcare spending for active-duty members.... It would cost hundreds of millions of dollars to discharge thousands of transgender personnel, according to a study released this month by the Palm Center, an independent research institute." ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: In other words, the cost of gender-transition coverage would be somewhere between (1) less than a single Trump weekend at one of his golf courses and (2) three Trump weekends at one of his golf courses. Trump loves to talk about military sacrifices, but he won't give up even a couple of weekends to give these military personnel the medical treatment they need. But the great irony here is that Trump's stated rationale for banning transgender military personnel -- saving tax dollars -- will instead cost hundreds of millions more than would maintaining the status quo. This is about bigotry, pure and simple; it has nothing whatever to do with cost-savings. What Capt. Sims doesn't consider is the increasingly schizophrenic nature of the Trump presidency. @realbigotDonaldTrump abuses most minorities; @scriptedDonaldTrump reads rational, presidenty speeches. This is largely new chief-of-staff John Kelly's contribution, a contribution that does not seem to be helping much. ...
... Citing Trump's July tweets banning transgender military service, former Navy diver Jennifer Detlefsen wrote on her Instagram account, "This man [Trump] is a disgrace. I've tried to keep politics out of my social media feed as much as possible, but this is inexcusable. This veteran says sit down and shut the fuck up, you know-nothing, never-served piece of shit." What is remarkable about Detlefsen's post is that she is the daughter of Secretary of the Interior Ryan Zinke, who "frequently mentioned [her] in his successful 2016 re-election campaign for the U.S. House," Jayme Fraser of the Billings (Montana) Gazette reports. Mrs. McC: I wonder if Detlefsen's tweet cost Americans a few thousand acres of national monuments. ...
... Jeet Heer of the New Republic: "Silicon Valley tycoon Peter Thiel delivered one of the most memorable speeches of last year's Republican National Convention, predicting that Donald Trump would, swiftly and without mercy, end the culture wars. How is that working out?... Far from sharing Thiel's attitude that no one should care about 'who gets to use which bathroom,' Trump has shown he cares deeply. One of Trump's first acts as president was to issue a letter withdrawing federal protection for transgender high school students who want to use bathrooms corresponding to their gender identities. In July, the president tweeted that he would reinstate a ban on transgender people in the military, and this week, he made good on the threat, issuing a directive that bars new transgender recruits, blocks funding for sex reassignment surgeries, and gives Defense Secretary James Mattis six months to decide whether to expel the thousands of transgender soldiers already serving. And these are not the only ways in which Trump is governing as a right-wing cultural warrior."
** Jill Filipovic in a New York Times op-ed (August 24): During the second presidential debate during which Donald Trump stalked her, Hillary "Clinton did what most women do when they face harassment or intimidation: She ignored it. But now she's stewing in the what-if.... Had Mrs. Clinton responded forcefully during that debate, she would most likely have faced the same penalties other women do when they speak up at work: being seen as unpleasant, aggressive and less competent.... For Mrs. Clinton, on that stage, that lack of intervention put her in the same position as so many women who are harassed in plain view of others who do nothing: all alone, second-guessing her own gut reaction.... [Trump] stalked a woman onstage while we all watched, and then he won the election. Now we expect her to be very sorry. Perhaps it's not just Hillary Clinton who should be thinking about what she could have done differently." ...
... Marie Burns: I intended to link this op-ed when the Times published it, but I took it so personally -- partly because of the recent virtual stalking & harassment to which I've been subjected -- that I thought I might write more extensively about Filipovic's essay. Every one of the people who landed on Reality Chex' do-not-comment list -- and half of them are women -- have made surly demands of me in the past and/or have criticized not my ideas but my self. They didn't just get started last week. And I've mostly endured it. Clearly, that tack did not pay off. Rather, it emboldened them. I realize that many of my contemporaries, who grew up in an age when women were supposed to know their place, have that view so imprinted in their hearts that it won't go away. At the same time, women of a certain age may also have become personal feminists; they've been beaten down, and now they feel feminism has given them permission to beat down women they perceive to be weaker than they. I've always thought following the Golden Rule was the best way to conduct one's life. I question that now. I think for women of my generation, an eye-for-an-eye may be a necessity. But, as Filipovic suggests, neither Option A nor Option B wins any prizes. The victim of harassment, no matter how bold or how timid her reaction, will always have to pay for what somebody else did to her. The Constant Weader worked for other people; Mrs. Bea McCrabbie will continue CW's work, but she won't put up with the crap some who availed themselves of her services thought was their due.
This video, which the Washington Post recently obtained. shows a protester (allegedly) firing a pistol directly into a crowd of counterprotesters:
... UPDATE. Matt Shuham of TPM: "Police have arrested a man suspected of shooting in the direction of a crowd of counter-protesters during the white nationalist rally in Charlottesville, Virginia on Aug. 12, the New York Times first reported Friday. Multiple outlets later reported that Richard Wilson Preston, 52, was one of three people against whom police had announced charges Saturday in connection with the Unite the Right rally. He was charged with discharging a firearm within 1,000 feet of a school.... Neither police nor city officials confirmed that Preston was the same man as the one shown in video provided by the ACLU of Virginia.... Preston is a well-known imperial wizard of the Confederate White Knights of the Ku Klux Klan."
Beyond the Beltway
Kristine Phillips & Andrew deGrandpre of the Washington Post: "School officials in Denver have fired a cheerleading coach amid controversy over disturbing videos of teenage girls wailing in pain while apparently being forced to perform leg splits. Denver Public Schools Superintendent Tom Boasberg announced Friday that newly hired coach Ozell Williams has been fired from his job at East High School. Williams is a Guinness World Record holder and former contestant on the NBC reality series 'America's Got Talent.' The allegations involve at least eight girls, according to Denver's NBC affiliate, KUSA. In one clip obtained by the station, a 13-year-old incoming freshman shrieks 'please stop' nine times during a span of 24 seconds. The technique, known as 'forced splits,' happened at a cheer camp last June and was captured in videos that were later provided to school officials.... A child-abuse investigation by Denver Police is ongoing."
Kristine Phillips: "Scuffles broke out on the streets of San Francisco after hundreds of people descended on the city to protest a now-canceled event by a right-wing group.... Organizers canceled the 'Freedom Rally' as city leaders braced for the kind of protest that drew extremist groups to Charlottesville, Virginia earlier this month. The pro-Trump group Patriot Prayer then planned to hold a news conference instead -- but that, too, did not happen after the city blocked the venue from the public. Meanwhile, hundreds of counterprotesters gathered at a San Francisco park on Saturday morning, according to media reports.... The event was scheduled Saturday afternoon at Crissy Field, a recreational area near the Golden Gate Bridge." ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: I have a feeling these stalwart right-wing extremists cancelled because they were too prissy to march in doggy-doo.
News Ledes
New York Times: "At least five deaths and more than a dozen injuries have been reported in the aftermath of Harvey, the hurricane that tore across the Gulf Coast of Texas over the weekend. On Sunday the powerful system, now a tropical storm, pounded the region with torrential rains that were expected to continue for days, causing catastrophic floods, according to the National Hurricane Center. The public hospital for Harris County, which includes Houston, began evacuating patients after flooding disrupted its power supply. The National Weather Service forecast rainfall of 15 to 25 inches through Friday, with as much as 50 inches in a few areas." ...
... Washington Post: "While Texas is reeling from Harvey, residents along the East Coast from the Carolinas to Cape Cod are preparing for rain, gusty winds and rough surf from what is likely to become Tropical Storm Irma. Already, the National Weather Service has hoisted a tropical storm watch for the Atlantic coast from Georgetown, S.C., to the tip of Cape Hatteras." ...
... Washington Post: "Harvey continued to pummel Texas during the early hours of Sunday morning, dropping nearly two feet of rain on Houston overnight and causing dire, and deadly, flash floods. Officials in Houston said early Sunday that a woman was found dead by her vehicle, believed to have been trapped during a flood. As midnight local time struck, police and rescue workers continue to plea with residents to stay indoors and not attempt to travel flooded roadways. 'There[s flooding all over this city,' Houston Police Chief Art Acevedo said in a livestream video early Sunday morning. 'We have one fatality, and a potential second fatality from the flood waters out here.' By 4:30 a.m. Central time, the National Weather Service had recorded 20 inches of rain in Houston, as warnings for flash flooding and tornadoes remained in place for a large swath of the state." ...
... Weather Channel: "'There is life-threatening, catastrophic flooding happening now in Southeast Harris County [Houston],' Jeff Lindner of the Harris County Flood Control District told The Weather Channel. Lindner said water had overtopped Interstate 10, that there had been more than 1,000 water rescues overnight in the Houston area and that hundreds more were stranded in cars across roadways in the area. Flash flood emergencies have been issued area where the extreme rainfall has nundated homes, vehicles and killed at least two people. There are now three confirmed deaths in Harvey." ...
... New York Times "live briefings" of hurricane news are here.