The Commentariat -- Oct. 31, 2014
Internal links, defunct video, photos & graphics removed.
Robert Bukaty of the AP: "Maine health officials obtained a 24-hour court order restricting Kaci Hickox's movement after the nurse repeatedly defied the state's quarantine for medical workers who have treated Ebola patients. A judge granted the order Thursday limiting Hickox's travel, banning her from public places and requiring a 3-foot buffer until there's a further decision Friday." ...
... Nobel Laureate Backs Christie. Claude Brodesser-Akner of NJ.com: Nobel Prize-winning immunologist Bruce Beutler "reviewed [New Jersey Gov. Chris] Christie's new policy of mandatory quarantine for all health care workers exposed to Ebola, and declared: 'I favor it.'... "It may not be absolutely true that those without symptoms can't transmit the disease, because we don't have the numbers to back that up.... Even if someone is asymptomatic you cannot rely on people to report themselves if they get a fever. You can't just depend on the goodwill of people to confine the disease like that -- even healthcare workers. They behave very irresponsibly,' said Beutler.'" Beutler said of nurse Kaci Hickox, "It doesn't matter that she was afebrile -- she should be quarantined for 21 days." Beutler said he would be "a little stricter" than Christie's policy requires. ...
... Mark Santora of the New York Times: "New York officials announced on Thursday that they would offer employee protection and financial guarantees for health care workers joining the fight against the Ebola outbreak in three West African nations. The announcement was an effort to alleviate concerns that the state's mandatory quarantine policy could deter desperately needed workers from traveling overseas." ...
... Dan Mangan of CNBC: "New York City's health department said a doctor being treated for Ebola 'cooperated fully' with officials, dismissing a report that he initially lied about his movements." ...
... Charles Pierce: "I can't be the only one who thinks that the conservative nattering about Ebola is starting to reek of the same reckless pot-stirring that made the Terri Schiavo episode such a highlight of conservative intellectual activism.... And when you think of wanking, you think of the strong and steady hand of "Bobby" Jindal, the governor of Louisiana who, on Thursday, managed to dig up Irony and kill it again by warning people who have worked with Ebola overseas not to come to his state to attend...wait for it ... a conference on infectious tropical diseases." ...
... Andy Borowitz: "President Obama is coming under increasing pressure to apologize for a controversial remark that he made on Tuesday, in which he said that the nation's Ebola policy should be based on facts rather than fear. While the anti-fear tenor of Mr. Obama's comment was offensive enough to some, the President made matters worse by suggesting that science would play the leading role in guiding the nation's Ebola protocols...."
Coral Davenport of the New York Times on why Republicans keep saying they're not scientists. "'It's got to be the dumbest answer I've ever heard,' said Michael McKenna, a Republican energy lobbyist who has advised House Republicans and conservative political advocacy groups on energy and climate change messaging. 'Using that logic would disqualify politicians from voting on anything. Most politicians aren't scientists, but they vote on science policy. They have opinions on Ebola, but they're not epidemiologists. They shape highway and infrastructure laws, but they're not engineers.'"
Tom McCarthy & Dan Roberts of the Guardian: "The secretary of state, John Kerry, has condemned as 'disgraceful' a description of the Israeli prime minister, Binyamin Netanyahu, as 'chickenshit', attributed to an unnamed US official. Kerry said on Thursday that the reported comments did not reflect his view or the view of President Barack Obama, adding that the language was 'disgraceful, unacceptable and damaging'."
There is no right more basic in our democracy than the right to participate in electing our political leaders. -- Chief Justice John Roberts ...
... Linda Greenhouse: That's what Roberts wrote "in April of this year. His subject then was the right to spend money in politics, not the right to vote. If people conclude that the current Supreme Court majority cares more about the first than the second -- surely a logical inference — the court will have entered a dangerous place. And so -- as a conservative justice once realized in another context -- will the country." ...
... CW: I don't think you can beat the irony of Roberts' writing in McCutcheon v. F.E.C. (the $$$ case) when contrasted with his decision to allow the Texas voter suppression/poll tax statute to stand this election cycle. Roberts knows what he's doing. His decision on Texas strongly suggests that he believes the "the right to participate in electing our political leaders" extends only to citizens who can pay for it. The Texas case has not come before the Court for a full decision yet, but informed observers don't have high hopes that voters' advocates will prevail. ...
... Messin' with Texas Ain't Over Yet. Richard Hasen in TPM: "The very last sentence ... of the ... opinion issued earlier this month by a federal district court striking down Texas's strict voter identification law ... may be its most important. The court ended its opinion with a dry statement promising a future hearing on 'plaintiffs' request for relief under Section 3(c) of the Voting Rights Act.' That hearing ... has the potential to require Texas to get federal approval for any future voting changes for up to the next decade.... It may be much more important than the ruling on the voter ID law itself.... Despite the recent Supreme Court order letting Texas use its voter ID law in this election, the case is far from over, and in fact the most important ruling in the case is yet to come. Voters may get their protection from discriminatory laws yet." Read the whole post. ...
... Jamelle Bouie of Slate: "Mississippi has poor social outcomes and a threadbare safety net. It also has -- and has long had -- the largest black population in the country. And it's where slavery was very lucrative, and Jim Crow most vicious. This is not a coincidence. In Mississippi -- as in the rest of the South -- white supremacy brought a politics of racist antagonism.... What we see in Mississippi -- and, in varying degrees, the country writ large -- is what was wrought by white supremacy. A society where the racial caste system is still intact but justified by other means." ...
... Ed Kilgore: "... you can't expect people to look at a place like Mississippi and unsee the threads that tie together generations of white conservatism, and unthink the judgment that once again 'state's rights' and 'sovereignty' mean powerlessness, poverty, sickness and even an early grave for a big portion of the population."
Emily Atkin of Think Progress: "A libertarian think tank has sued the White House over a video that claimed global warming might be tied to last year's extreme cold spell, commonly referred to as the 'polar vortex.' The Competitive Enterprise Institute's lawsuit filed Wednesday says White House Office of Science and Technology director John Holdren was wrong when, in the January video, he cited a 'growing body of evidence' linking the so-called 'polar vortex' to climate change." ...
... CW: Maybe John Boehner, who is once again looking for a lawyer to sue President Obama for shredding the Constitution or something, should hire the CEI's lawyers, who seem to be able to file the most frivolous of suits against the White House.
Gail Sullivan of the Washington Post lists a number of reasons why Apple CEO Tim Cook's coming out as gay is important. CW: I'll have to admit I thought "meh" when his Bloomberg Businessweek op-ed hit the ether, but Sullivan changes my mind.
Paul Krugman: "... the West has, in fact, fallen into a slump similar to Japan's -- but worse. And that wasn't supposed to happen. In the 1990s, we assumed that if the United States or Western Europe found themselves facing anything like Japan's problems, we would respond much more effectively than the Japanese had. But we didn't, even though we had Japan's experience to guide us." ...
... Michael Sauga in Der Spiegel elaborates on Krugman's theme: "... the crisis of capitalism has turned into a crisis of democracy. Many feel that their countries are no longer being governed by parliaments and legislatures, but by bank lobbyists, which apply the logic of suicide bombers to secure their privileges: Either they are rescued or they drag the entire sector to its death." An excellent piece (4 pp.); thanks to Unwashed for the link. ...
Annals of "Journalism," Ctd. Shaun King of Daily Kos: "When Don Surber, editorial columnist for Charleston's Daily Mail, called [Ferguson, Mo. police shooting victim] Mike Brown an 'animal' who deserved to 'be put down,' and referred to protestors as 'packs of racists,' [in a Facebook post] he crossed a line.... Today Surber was fired by the Daily Mail for his incendiary comments...." Brad McElhinny, editor & publisher of the Daily Mail, announced Surber's dismissal in a blogpost on the paper's site.
Charles Pierce remembers Tom Menino, Boston's longest-serving mayor, who died Thursday: "Menino was a puzzlement only to those delicate souls who mistake syntax for intelligence. He became mayor just as Boston was emerging from the very last vestiges of its parochial past -- insular neighborhoods which did not welcome outsiders, which might simply mean someone who moved there from another parish in Dorchester." ...
... President Obama remembers Tom Menino.
Jon Stewart welcomes a new advertiser to the "Daily Show":
November Elections
Gregor Aisch & Josh Katz of the New York Times take a deep dive into the numbers. ...
... Nate Cohn of the New York Times: "The polls have generally underestimated Democrats in recent years, and there are reasons to think it could happen again. In 2010, the polls underestimated the Democrats in every competitive Senate race by an average of 3.1 percentage points, based on data from The Huffington Post's Pollster model. In 2012, pre-election polls underestimated President Obama in nine of the 10 battleground states by an average of 2 percentage points."
Nate Cohn: "Democratic efforts to turn out the young and nonwhite voters who sat out the 2010 midterm elections appear to be paying off in several Senate battleground states. More than 20 percent of the nearly three million votes already tabulated in Georgia, North Carolina, Colorado and Iowa have come from people who did not vote in the last midterm election, according to an analysis of early-voting data by The Upshot." ...
... CW: Want to help? Make Tuesday "Take a Lazy Democrat to Lunch Day." And swing by her polling place on the way to the restaurant.
Brian Beutler: Democrats have known since their big wins in 2008 that 2014 would be a tough year for Senate Democrats, so stop blaming President Obama. "... even a good, well executed campaign strategy usually can't overwhelm the basic nature of the electorate."
Mike Dorning & Lorraine Woellert of Bloomberg News: "The U.S. economy has posted its strongest six months of growth since 2003, news that usually would be a boon to the party in power heading into congressional elections. Yet President Barack Obama and Democrats haven't been able to take credit for the gains. On Election Day, they're at risk of losing control of the Senate, though it is the Republicans who have blocked measures aimed at strengthening growth. That's because Americans say they don't feel the progress in their daily lives and they blame both parties for the political deadlock in Washington. The U.S. government's failure to address the economy's main weakness -- stagnant middle-class earnings -- damages Democrats the most."
... See also this piece by Emily Mahaney of Glamour magazine, where this video -- produced in support of the Planned Parenthood Action Fund's Women Are Watching campaign -- first appeared.
Joe Coscarelli of New York: "If you've ever wondered where the endless font of gun-nut paranoia comes from, try the National Rifle Association's magazine, America's 1st Freedom. In a special election issue headlined 'Chaos at Our Door? A Dangerous World Is Closing In' and illustrated with an Islamic State fighter, NRA chief fearmongerer Wayne LaPierre writes a column warning Americans to 'Vote Your Guns in November.'... 'On Election Day, Tuesday, Nov. 4, we will defend our right to defend ourselves because we have no other choice. We will vote our guns! We will vote our freedom! And we will prevail!" That might be the scariest idea of all." ...
... Hannah Levintova of Mother Jones lists seven "big gun fights to watch on election day.... The National Rifle Association, continuing a long-running strategy of campaign spending, earmarked over $11 million for this year's elections -- but for the first time in decades the nation's leading gun lobby is facing some truly formidable opposition."
Margaret Hartmann: "After days of constant campaigning, Senator Elizabeth Warren has mixed up Vermont and New Hampshire, Michelle Obama has called Representative Bruce Braley "Bruce Bailey," and now Mitt Romney has flubbed the position of North Carolina's Republican Senate nominee. While introducing Thom Tillis on Wednesday, Romney described him as 'a man who as secretary of state has demonstrated what he can do to make things happen for the people of this great state.' Tillis is actually the state House speaker." CW: Luckily. nobody's paying attention to the midterms.
Red States/Blue States. Monica Davey of the New York Times: "... Republicans are hoping to add Iowa and Arkansas to the states entirely under their control as well as to break the Democrats' lock on power in places like Colorado and here in Minnesota. Democrats view the governors' races in Wisconsin, Kansas and Michigan as among their best hopes of defeating a Republican incumbent and regaining at least some voice in those Republican-held state capitals, and are pouring energy and money into final efforts to get out the vote. The trend toward one-party control of statehouses has made the states a testing ground for party policies in an era of gridlock in Washington."
Colorado. Why I Hate Polls. Quinnipiac University: "With strong support from men, U.S. Rep. Cory Gardner, the Republican challenger in the Colorado U.S. Senate race, leads U.S. Sen. Mark Udall, the Democratic incumbent, 46 - 39 percent among likely voters, with 7 percent for independent candidate Steve Shogan, according to a Quinnipiac University poll released today. Another 7 percent are undecided." ...
... Denver Post: "A poll conducted this week shows Gardner [R-Personhood] at 46 percent and Udall [Uterus (D)] at 44 percent -- a narrow edge within the four-percentage-point margin-of-error. ...
... PPP: "Mark Udall and Cory Gardner are both getting 48% of the vote, with just 4% of voters remaining undecided."
Kentucky.
Mitch McConnell's going to go to the wire, because he is vehement about not standing for anything. And he has a good long track record about not standing for much other than keeping the campaign dollars flowing. And that is not inspiring to ordinary Americans, to conservatives, even to base Republicans. -- Ken Cuccinelli (RTP), former Virginia attorney general
Louisiana. Chuck Todd & Carrie Dann of NBC News: "Louisiana Democrat Sen. Mary Landrieu said Thursday that the issue of race is a major reason that President Barack Obama has struggled politically in Southern states.... Noting that the South is 'more of a conservative place,' she added that women have also faced challenges in 'presenting ourselves.'... The comment prompted a fiery response from Louisiana Republican Gov. Bobby Jindal, who called it 'remarkably divisive.' 'She appears to be living in a different century,' he said in a statement." CW: Bobby Jindal appears to be living in a different world a/k/a Right Wing World, where reality is too inconvenient to credit. "The issue of race," as Landrieu delicately puts it, is a major reason for everything in the South. See Jamelle Bouie's post above. ...
... The Cluelessness of the Chuck. Charles Pierce: "Notice, however, that my man Chuck Todd then follows up with a question designed to take the sting out of Landrieu's outburst of inconvenient truth. 'What's interesting there is other Democratic folks that I've talked to in the Senate they use different language,' Chuck Todd said on Thursday's broadcast of NBC's Nightly News. 'Mark Pryor told me the president just doesn't understand rural America.' Let's all chip in and buy my man Chuck Todd an Enigma machine."
Maine. Jim Fallows on the three-way gubernatorial race. Fallows is the classiest of fellows.
Nebraska. Serial Killer Endorses GOP Candidate. Allisa Skelton of the Omaha World-Herald: "Convicted killer Nikko Jenkins endorsed U.S. Rep. Lee Terry during a court appearance Wednesday. His shackles clanked as he waltzed to his seat and said: 'Vote for Lee Terry, guys. Best Republican ever.'... Terry has linked his Democratic opponent, State Sen. Brad Ashford, to Jenkins' release from prison and his killing spree."
New Hampshire. Tim Buckland of the New Hampshire Union Leader: "U.S. Sen. Jeanne Shaheen and former Massachusetts Sen. Scott Brown got in the last punches in what was the final round of their debates before Tuesday's election." ...
... Where in New Hampshire Is Sullivan County? Scott Brown isn't sure. But ObamaCare:
... Margaret Hartmann of New York: "The exchange gave the impression that Brown didn't know where Sullivan County was, which is particularly bad since there are only ten counties in the state. However, Pindell apologized after the debate upon learning that Brown was right, sort of. Sullivan County is both north and west of Concord, and Mount Sunapee is partially located there (though the ski area is in Merrimack County). ...
... CW: When you contrast Brown's response to the question with Shaheen's, it's obvious that Shaheen knows her New Hampshire geography intimately & knows the various regional issues. Brown, on the other hand, said he's "been there," where "been there" seems to mean "skiied Mount Sunapee which is right close to Sullivan County."
Presidential Election
Harold Meyerson of the Washington Post writes a terrific column on Hillary Clinton's attachment to big banks. "In the winter of 1932-1933, as President-elect Franklin Roosevelt was assembling his Cabinet, he was lobbied to appoint a leader of the J.P. Morgan investment bank, then headquartered at 23 Wall St., to a top post at Treasury. Roosevelt refused -- categorically. 'We simply cannot go along with 23,' he told an aide. Roosevelt's refusal should become a standard to which Democratic activists hold all their presidential candidates."
Ted Cruz: Republicans Must Nominate a Wacko-Bird. Jonathan Topaz of Politico: "Sen. Ted Cruz on Thursday took a thinly veiled shot at Jeb Bush, saying that Republicans will ensure a Hillary Clinton presidency if they run a more moderate candidate in 2016. Appearing on CNBC, the Texas Republican and tea party favorite was asked about Bush and said that presidential candidates from the party's establishment wing -- like Arizona Sen. John McCain in 2008 and former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney in 2012 -- consistently fail to turn out millions of voters.... A Washington Post/ABC News poll earlier this month showed Bush leading a crowded GOP primary field, with Cruz finishing in ninth." CW: Cruz also noted that no GOP presidential nominee named Ted Cruz had ever lost the presidency.
Paul Waldman on Chris Christie's "persona": "... you know where you don't get too many chances to show what a tough guy you are? Iowa. Campaigning for the caucuses is an interminable process of trooping from living room to senior center to VFW hall, meeting people in small groups, looking them in the eye and asking them for their votes.... Being tough just isn't part of that show, and if the biggest part of Christie's appeal is that he can talk like an extra from Goodfellas when somebody challenges him, he isn't going to get very far." ...
... CW: In Iowa, New Hampshire, wherever, Christie will be viewed as an outsider. If he roughs up the locals -- even the dimwitted locals -- the neighbors will take it personally. In New Jersey, Christie may be a jerk, "but he's our jerk." That won't be the case when he moves out-of-state. If Christie can't control himself -- and neither Waldman nor I thinks he can -- his presidential aspirations will be toast. Also fun to watch: the debates (which the Republican National Committee is planning to limit). Will Chris Christie order Ted Cruz to "sit down & shut up"? Will he punch out Marco Rubio? Will he grab Rand Paul by the hair?
Beyond the Beltway
Stephen Deere of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch: "If a behind-the-scenes effort is afoot to force out Chief Thomas Jackson and disband his police force, neither he nor his department is going quietly -- nor quickly.... On Wednesday, U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder called for 'wholesale changes' within the Ferguson Police Department, while speaking at a public forum in Washington. He declined to offer any specific recommendations, noting that Ferguson police were still under a U.S. Department of Justice investigation.... Jackson called it 'irresponsible' for Holder to comment about conclusions Justice Department investigators analyzing his department have made while their investigation is ongoing, especially while 'he is telling others to "shut up" about leaks.'"
News Ledes
Reuters: "The ringleader of a beating ritual that led to the death of a Florida college marching band member was convicted on Friday of manslaughter and felony hazing, the first case to go to trial in an incident that drew national attention to hazing abuses. A jury convicted percussionist Dante Martin, 27, for his role in a November 2011 ritual involving the Florida A&M University's celebrated 'Marching 100' band that led to the death of Robert Champion, a 26-year-old drum major." ...
... CW: Why are these college students so old?
Los Angeles Times: "Virgin Galactic's SpaceShipTwo, part of a commercial space venture founded by British billionaire Richard Branson, crashed during testing Friday, according to a Mojave Air and Space Port spokesperson and the FAA. At least one person was killed." MSNBC is saying two were injured as well.
New York Times: "Less than a day after restricting the movements of a nurse who treated Ebola victims in West Africa, a judge in Maine has lifted the measures, rejecting arguments by the State of Maine that a quarantine was necessary to protect the public. Within an hour of the decision, state troopers who had been parked outside the nurse's house for days had left. The order, signed on Friday by Judge Charles C. LaVerdiere, the chief judge for the Maine District Courts who serves in Kennebec and Somerset counties, said the nurse, Kaci Hickox, 'currently does not show symptoms of Ebola and is therefore not infectious.' The order requires Ms. Hickox to submit to daily monitoring for symptoms, to coordinate her travel with state health officials, and to notify them immediately if symptoms appear. Ms. Hickox has agreed to follow the requirements." Thanks to James S. for the link.
AP: "Eric Frein, 31, appeared gaunt and battered as he answered yes or no questions and listened as a judge read the criminal complaint detailing the Sept. 12 attack that killed Cpl. Bryon Dickson and critically wounded Trooper Alex Douglass."
Washington Post: "Russia agreed Thursday to resume selling natural gas to Ukraine, ending a cutoff.... The stopgap deal will secure critical energy supplies for Ukraine through March and will also help assure European countries that their own natural gas supply will not be disrupted during chilly winter months."