The Commentariat -- May 23, 2014
Internal links, graphic removed.
Ed Snowden Day
Jonathan Weisman of the New York Times: "The House on Thursday voted overwhelmingly to rein in the National Security Agency's sweeping collection of telephone records, approving scaled-back legislation that sharply divided the technology sector and civil libertarians but united the White House, conservative Republicans and liberal Democrats. The 303-to-121 vote sent an unambiguous signal that both parties are no longer comfortable with giving the N.S.A. unfettered power to collect bulk surveillance data. A year ago, a divided House nearly voted to strip all money from the N.S.A. for such surveillance, over the protests of the Republican leadership."
Jason Leopold of the Guardian: "A top-secret Pentagon report to assess the damage to national security from the leak of classified National Security Agency documents by Edward Snowden concluded that 'the scope of the compromised knowledge related to US intelligence capabilities is staggering'. The Guardian has obtained a copy of the Defense Intelligence Agency's classified damage assessment in response to a Freedom of Information Act (Foia) lawsuit filed against the Defense Department earlier this year. The heavily redacted 39-page report was prepared in December...." The redacted report is here.
Michael Kinsley reviews Glenn Greenwald's book No Place to Hide for the New York Times: "It's a great yarn, which might be more entertaining if Greenwald himself didn't come across as so unpleasant.... In 'No Place to Hide, Greenwald seems like a self-righteous sourpuss, convinced that every issue is 'straightforward,' and if you don't agree with him, you're part of something he calls 'the authorities,' who control everything for their own nefarious but never explained purposes.... In his mind, he is not a reformer but a ruthless revolutionary -- Robespierre, or Trotsky. The ancien régime is corrupt through and through, and he is the man who will topple it." Read the whole review.
Rebecca Shabad of the Hill: "Edward Snowden will appear in his first TV interview with a U.S. news outlet next Wednesday, NBC News announced Thursday. 'NBC Nightly News' anchor Brian Williams traveled to Moscow this week for a wide-ranging interview that will air in an hourlong special at 10 p.m. ET on May 28. 'Williams' in-person conversation with Snowden was conducted over the course of several hours and was shrouded in secrecy due to Snowden's life in exile since leaking classified documents about U.S. surveillance programs a year ago,' NBC News said."
Vindu Goel of the New York Times: On Thursday Facebook "announced that it would give a privacy checkup to every one of its 1.28 billion users worldwide. Facebook ... will also change how it treats new users by initially setting their posts to be seen only by friends. Previously, those posts were accessible to anyone. And it will explain to both current and new users that setting their privacy to 'public' means that anyone on the Internet can see their photos and messages."
Ellen Nakashima of the Washington Post: "The Justice Department's decision to charge Chinese officers was approved at very high levels of government and was undertaken, officials say, because talks had brought little progress. Both efforts -- diplomacy and criminal prosecution -- are part of a broader effort by the Obama administration to hold China accountable for what officials say is a growing campaign of commercial cyberspying.... The approach dates to early 2012. At a White House meeting, 'the message was sent from the president himself,' one senior U.S. official said.... The result was a series of measures taken not only by Justice and State, but also by the departments of Defense and Homeland Security."
Brendan Sasso of the National Journal: "The House approved an amendment Thursday that would delay the Obama administration's plan to give up oversight of certain technical Internet management functions. In a 245-177 vote, the House attached the legislation to the annual defense authorization bill. Seventeen Democrats joined the Republicans in approving the measure. The House then voted to pass the full defense bill, which included a number of other amendments.' ...
... Martin Matishak of the Hill: "The leaders of the Senate Armed Services Committee on Thursday unveiled a $514 billion defense bill that differs in several ways from the version approved by the House."
Obama 2.2 Kate Zezima of the Washington Post: "President Obama is scheduled to announce Friday that he will nominate San Antonio Mayor Julian Castro as the next secretary of Housing and Urban Development. Castro will replace Shaun Donovan, who Obama will name as head of the White House Office of Management and Budget...."
Nicholas Confessore of the New York Times: "The Internal Revenue Service said Thursday that it has delayed and is revamping new rules intended to curb political activity by tax-exempt groups and that were proposed after the agency was accused last year of targeting Tea Party groups. The I.R.S. said it made the decision after receiving 150,000 comments -- both positive and negative -- about the proposal, the biggest public response to any proposed rule in its history. The decision postpones public hearings originally expected for this summer." ...
... Molly Redden of Mother Jones: "Arkansas is witnessing what may be the most expensive political ad campaign in state history: $1.5 million-worth of glowing TV spots hailing Tom Cotton, a Republican congressman who's running against Democrat Sen. Mark Pryor. The race could decide which party controls the Senate. But no one knows who's paying for this giant ad buy -- and that's partly because the group behind those ads may have flaunted IRS law in order to conceal the identities of its donors."
Jordain Carney & Stacy Kaper of the National Journal: "the sheen of shame over the VA's failures spreads across time and party affiliation. It stains the legacies of presidents as far back as John F. Kennedy and condemns past Congresses whose poor oversight allowed the problem to fester. The VA itself is also not without fault, as bureaucracy and intransigence let the department deteriorate to the point the problem became nearly impossible to fix. So who really broke the VA? In sum, it's a failure with many silent fathers." CW: Quite a helpful summary. ...
CW: I meant to post video yesterday of President Obama's Wednesday presser on the VA problem. It's here.
I don't want to be critical of the president, but he waited 23 days before he responded, and I think he should have done it sooner. -- Former Sen. Bob Dole (R-Kansas), a veterans' advocate
... Here Carney & Kaper offer some solutions for the VA's health management problems. As they write, "None of them involve floor speeches or finger-pointing." ...
... That goes for you, too, John Boehner. ...
... And you, Kevin McCarthy. ...
... Ed O'Keefe of the Washington Post: "Veterans Affairs Secretary Eric K. Shinseki said Thursday that he intends to remain on the job to address allegations of mismanagement and delayed care for military veterans, adding that he has not offered his resignation to President Obama because of the recent controversy." ...
... Paul Waldman: "The controversy over the Veterans Health Administration offers an opportunity for some positive change."
Hear that? ... That's the sound of people opening their electric bills to discover they've nearly doubled.... An 80 percent cost hike? That's something we better get used to if extreme new Obama administration power plant regulations take effect. -- Radio ad sponsored by the National Mining Association regarding EPA regulations on new coal-plant carbon emissions
Glenn Kessler of the Washington Post: "The NMA has seized upon a high-end wholesale estimate for 'full recapture' carbon capture and sequestration technologies which the EPA specifically rejected -- and then leveraged that factoid to make a wholly unsupported claim that the same increase would be reflected in retail prices. The EPA's proposed regulations, along with other factors, may boost the cost of electricity, but the NMA should not rely on such bogus, hyped evidence to make its case."
... BTW, Kessler gave Democratic Senate nominee Alison Grimes three Pinocchios for this remark, which she made during her nomination victory speech: "Never gone without a pay raise for himself, [Sen. Mitch McConnell] quadrupled his net worth on the backs of hardworking Kentuckians that can't afford it." Kessler argues that since McConnell received the bulk of his wealth from an inheritance his wife received, it has nothing to do with "hardworking Kentuckians." Really, Glenn? McConnell has taken the lead in efforts to reduce and/or repeal the "death tax." As a result, the McConnells lost little of their inheritance to estate taxes. Who takes up the slack? Well, "hardworking Kentuckians" -- and other taxpaying Americans, of course. ...
... Update: Kessler responds, "McConnell has certainly voted repeatedly to eliminate estate taxes, but in 2007 there was still a fairly hefty estate tax, so his wife would have still paid at least a million dollars in taxes on the inheritance. Don't know how much she inherited but it's between $5 million and $25 million, and there was still a 45 percent rate after a $2 million exemption in place then. So that's between $1.3 million ($5 million gift) and $10.2 million ($25 million) in taxes."
Diane Barnes of the National Journal: "A senior U.S. envoy accused Russia of giving its Syrian ally international cover for its alleged past use of chemical weapons against opponents. Ambassador Samantha Power leveled the assertion on Thursday, after Moscow and Beijing blocked approval of a U.N. Security Council proposal for the International Criminal Court to examine possible violations of international law in Syria's 3-year-old civil war. More than 160,000 people have died in the conflict, a British watchdog organization said this week."
Paul Krugman: "The truth is that the European project -- peace guaranteed by democracy and prosperity -- is in deep trouble; the Continent still has peace, but it’s falling short on prosperity and, in a subtler way, democracy.... It's terrifying to see so many Europeans rejecting democratic values, but at least part of the blame rests with officials who seem more interested in price stability and fiscal probity than in democracy."
** Gene Robinson: "What's happening in the Republican primaries is less a defeat for the tea party than a surrender by the GOP establishment, which is winning key races by accepting the tea party's radical anti-government philosophy.... The tea party's extremism and obstructionism live on." ...
... Frank Rich made the same point a couple of days ago.
CW: There is a real 47 percent. They are not Romney's lazy bums looking for government handouts. Still, most are likely in need of assistance from social services. They're the 47 percent of unemployed Americans who, according to a survey, have given up looking for work.
Marie's Pro Sports Roundup
Steve Kastenbaum of CNN: President "Obama on Thursday became the first sitting president to visit the Baseball Hall of Fame in upstate New York." ...
... BUT professional sports are great! Ask the under- or unpaid NFL cheerleaders. Julia Lurie & Nina Liss-Schultz of Mother Jones: "Jiggle Tests, Dunk Tanks, and Unpaid Labor: How NFL Teams Degrade Their Cheerleaders." Thanks to safari for the link. ...
... Maybe white sports moguls should STFU when it comes to musings on racism.
Today in Gun News. Coming to you from an undisclosed location. CW: I have learned from my various recent visits to McDonald's & Wendy's (my Internet service is down) that a prime reason for the Second Amendment is to provide old farts with an endless store of boring hunting stories. Check out the "Federalist Papers." I am pretty certain that's what the Founders had in mind. Wendy's & McDonald's may post-date Constitutional deliberations, but old farts telling endless boring hunting stories pre-date recorded history.
Senate Race
Philip Rucker & Robert Costa of the Washington Post: "After a string of humbling defeats in Republican primaries this spring, the tea party's last best hope to oust a lawmaker is in Mississippi. But things are not going well for the movement's Chris McDaniel, who is challenging longtime senator Thad Cochran. The race has been roiled over the past week by a bizarre incident in which a pro-McDaniel blogger was arrested in connection with taking an illicit photo of Cochran’s bedridden wife, Rose, who has dementia and lives in a nursing home. More arrests were made on Thursday, including a Mississippi tea party activist who is closely connected to McDaniel."
Goeff Pender & Sam Hall of the Jackson, Mississippi, Clarion Ledger: "The vice chairman of the Mississippi Tea Party and one other suspect have been arrested in connection with the photographing of the bedridden wife of U.S. Sen. Thad Cochran. Attorney Mark Mayfield, a vice chairman of the Mississippi Tea Party and an officer with the Central Mississippi Tea Party, was arrested Thursday by Madison police.... District Attorney Michael Guest confirms that Richard Sager of Laurel is the second person arrested today in relation to the Rose Cochran photo scandal.... Authorities have said John Mary of Hattiesburg has been charged with conspiracy, but he will not be kept in custody because of a medical condition."
Josh Marshall of TPM tries but can't quite figure out how "multiple people were involved and someone didn't say, 'Hey, this is f'ing crazy. I think we need to rethink this.'" Best explanation: "This is Mississippi."
CW: I thought I'd see of Charles Pierce weighed in on this. But Wendy's is my Internet connection just now, & apparently Wendy thinks Esquire is the sort of deviant publication that her customers have no business reading. I'll check tomorrow to see if Ronald McDonald has also blocked all access to Esquire. ...
... Late-Breaking Update: Pierce appreciates the entertainment value of this weird, developing story.
Beyond the Beltway
Erik Schelzig of the AP: "Tennessee has decided how it will respond to a nationwide scarcity of lethal injection drugs for death-row inmates: with the electric chair. Republican Gov. Bill Haslam signed a bill into law Thursday allowing the state to electrocute death row inmates in the event prisons are unable to obtain the drugs, which have become more and more scarce following a European-led boycott of drug sales for executions."
New York Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver (D) claims he's not that Sheldon Silver. In all likelihood, he's lying.
News Lede
AP: "In the deadliest raid yet on Ukrainian troops, pro-Russia insurgents attacked a military checkpoint Thursday, killing 16 soldiers, and the interim prime minister accused Moscow of trying to disrupt the upcoming election for a new president to lead the divided country out of its crisis."