The Commentariat -- April 17, 2013
All in all, this was a pretty shameful day for Washington. -- Barack Obama ...
... President Obama just lashed out at the Senate & the gun lobby. I'll get up video when it becomes available. Update: C-SPAN has the video here. The President begins speaking about 5 min. in. ...
... John Bresnahan of Politico: "A visibly angry President Barack Obama blasted the Senate's rejection of a bipartisan proposal to expand background checks on gun sales, a vote that essentially ends any hope for major gun control legislation for the time being."
NEW. Alexander Bolton of the Hill: "The Senate delivered a devastating blow to President Obama's agenda to regulate guns Wednesday by defeating a bipartisan proposal to expand background checks. It failed by a vote of 54 to 46, with 5 Democrats voting against it. Only 4 Republicans supported it. Democratic Sens. Mark Pryor (Ark.), Max Baucus (Mont.), Heidi Heitkamp (N.D.), Mark Begich (Alaska) and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (Nev.) voted against it. Reid supported the measure but voted against it to preserve his ability to bring the measure up again. GOP Sens. John McCain (Ariz.), Susan Collins (Maine), Pat Toomey (Pa.) and Mark Kirk (Ill.) voted yes."
NEW. C-SPAN2 is carrying the Senate "debate" (& upcoming) vote. Right now (@3:42 pm ET) Ted Cruz is saying something, so naturally I have the sound off. Update: I tuned in about an hour later, & Cruz was speaking again. Total camera hog.
NEW. Amy Davidson of the New Yorker writes an eloquent piece on "The Saudi Marathon Man."
Francis Wilkinson of Bloomberg News: "We weigh the senseless carnage in Boston (death toll thus far: 3) against the senseless carnage of domestic gun violence (annual death toll: 30,000) and wonder why American society mobilizes with such impressive force against the smaller threat [link fixed] while shrugging at the larger one. (Gun violence produces the same number of victims as the Sept. 11 attacks almost every month, year in and year out.)"
... CW: what Wilkinson doesn't discuss -- and it is an important factor -- is the difference in our sense of personal control. Generally speaking, we think we are smart enough to stay away from gun-wielding loons, but we feel everyone is vulnerable to random terrorist attacks. It's the same reason people who suffer from fear of flying feel safe driving a car even though "There are more than 30,000 motor-vehicle deaths each year, a mortality rate eight times greater than that in planes." ...
... Heather Hurlburt, director of the National Security Network, in USA Today: "... the bombs killed fewer people than guns, automobiles or saturated fats in America today. Terrorists in Iraq killed 10 times as many people today as the Boston murderer(s) managed to do.... Not turning on each other, or our institutions, or our own freedoms, whatever the truth behind these terrible attacks proves to be ... can we keep it up?" ...
... Brian Beutler of TPM on the networks making a big story out of whether or not the President said "terrorism." CW: let me add that at the forefront of the enthusiasm for presidential rhetoric was NBC News' ever-brilliant UpChuck Todd.
David Nakamura of the Washington Post: "A bipartisan group of lawmakers formally filed an 844-page immigration bill on the Senate floor early Wednesday morning, setting the stage for months of public debate over the proposal." ...
... Nakamura & Aaron Davis of the Post: "Leading Capitol Hill opponents of a Senate proposal to overhaul the nation’s immigration system are coalescing around a strategy to kill the bill by delaying the legislative process as long as possible, providing time to offer 'poison pill' amendments aimed at breaking apart the fragile bipartisan group that developed the plan, according to lawmakers and legislative aides." ...
... Jeff Mason of Reuters: "President Barack Obama put his weight behind legislation unveiled by a bipartisan group of senators on Tuesday to reform the U.S. immigration system and urged lawmakers to advance it quickly. 'This bill is clearly a compromise, and no one will get everything they wanted, including me. But it is largely consistent with the principles that I have repeatedly laid out for comprehensive reform,' Obama said in a statement after being briefed by two of the senators involved in crafting the bill, Democrat Chuck Schumer and Republican John McCain."
... This Zucks. Peter Wallsten, et al., of the Washington Post: FaceBook lobbied itself into a carveout on the immigration bill, a provision which will allow it & other big tech companies to hire cheap foreign labor in lieu of U.S. workers.
Ed O'Keefe of the Washington Post: "Supporters of a bipartisan background check plan were struggling Tuesday to find enough support as Senate leaders neared a deal to allow votes on other proposed changes to gun legislation.... The Senate will begin voting Wednesday on nine proposed changes to federal gun legislation, including efforts to expand background checks, ban assault weapons and increase funding for mental health programs." ...
... David Firestone of the New York Times: "Like many lawmakers who are opposing the Manchin-Toomey amendment for background checks, [Sen. Jeff] Flake [R-Arizona] needed an excuse to say no, so he simply invented one.... Many lawmakers of both parties would rather hide behind these flimsy excuses than offend the gun lobby and the credulous voters who follow it, putting passage of Manchin-Toomey in serious doubt." CW: they're not just lapdogs of the NRA; they are lying for the NRA & they know it.
I honestly just didn't believe GOP Senators would turn their back on 90% of Americans. I was naive. -- Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.)
... Steve Benen: "Republicans don't just intend to defeat the measure; they intend to filibuster it. I stress the distinction because today isn't a vote on the Toomey/Manchin amendment; it's a vote on whether to have a vote." Benen also exposes Sen. Dean Heller's (R-Nev.) ridiculous "objections" to the Manchin-Toomey amendment.
... ** The Internet Gun Bazaar. Michael Luo, et al., of the New York Times: "With no requirements for background checks on most private transactions, a Times examination found, Armslist and similar sites function as unregulated bazaars, where the essential anonymity of the Internet allows unlicensed sellers to advertise scores of weapons and people legally barred from gun ownership to buy them.... The examination of Armslist raised questions about whether many sellers are essentially functioning as unlicensed firearms dealers, in contravention of federal law."
Believe it or not, the second-biggest politics-related story on the Intertoobz Tuesday was about a couple of Harvard professors who fucked up big-time, which might upset the Very Serious People who relied on the professors' fucked-up data. But it won't upset the VSPs because their only interested in "facts" that justify or support their previously-held beliefs. The easiest-to-understand exposition comes from Matt Yglesias of Slate.
... The most thorough is by Mike Konczal. ...
... Paul Krugman cuts to the chase: "... this is embarrassing and worse for [the professors]. But the really guilty parties here are all the people who seized on a [previously] disputed research result, knowing nothing about the research, because it said what they wanted to hear." Krugman has a follow-up post here; the full response from Profs. Reinhart & Rogoff is here. ...
... Dean Baker: "If facts mattered in economic policy debates, this should be the cause for a major reassessment of the deficit reduction policies being pursued in the United States and elsewhere. It should also cause reporters to be a bit slower to accept such sweeping claims at face value."
Krugman recommends Barry Ritholtz's "12 Laws of Goldbuggery." Here No. 7 (in part): "Gold is the ultimate currency.... Get yourself some gold coins and a Glock and you will be just fine when the whole world goes to shit."
Maureen Dowd writes a book report on Mark Mazzetti's book, The Way of the Knife, which examines the CIA's killer drone program: "President Obama, who continued nearly every covert program handed down by W., clearly feels tough when he talks about targeted killings, and considers drones an attractive option. As Mazzetti says, 'fundamental questions about who can be killed, where they can be killed, and when they can be killed' still have not been answered or publicly discussed."
Somini Sengupta of the New York Times: "The White House on Tuesday threatened to veto a House bill that would allow private companies to share information about computer security threats with government agencies, signaling once again how difficult it is to balance civil liberties and security interests in the digital era."
Local News
AP: "Republican Gov. Jack Dalrymple signed into law a measure that outlaws abortions after 20 weeks of pregnancy based on the disputed premise that at that point a fetus can feel pain. The law signed Tuesday is the latest among a raft of measures passed in North Dakota this session that are meant to challenge the U.S. Supreme Court's 1973 Roe v. Wade ruling that legalized abortion up until viability, usually at 22 to 24 weeks." ...
... Tara Culp-Ressler of Think Progress: North Dakota State Rep. Bette Grande, a primary backer of the bill, claims that the law "will effectively convince women that they don't want to have an abortion after all." ...
... Kat Stoeffel of New York: "As for all the women who don’t change their minds, the ongoing trial of Philadelphia abortion provider Kermit Gosnell is a good reminder of what happens when women can't access abortions, either because they can't afford them or laws restrict them: They get them illegally and in life-threatening conditions."
Congressional Race
Let's See How the Bickersons' Divorce Is Going. Bruce Smith of the AP: "Former South Carolina Gov. Mark Sanford's ex-wife has accused him of trespassing at her home in violation of their divorce settlement, and a judge set a hearing two days after the Republican will stand for election in his effort to mount a political comeback by winning a vacant congressional seat.... The complaint says Jenny Sanford confronted the former governor leaving her Sullivans Island home on Feb. 3 by a rear door, using his cell phone for a flashlight." According to Jenny Sanford's attorney, Mark Sanford repeatedly trespassed, despite his ex-wife's asking him to desist. CW: I'm guessing that sneaking into his former wife's house in the middle of the night is just one of the things that God told Mark would be A-okay. ...
... UPDATE. Cameron Joseph of the Hill: "National Republicans are abandoning former South Carolina Gov. Mark Sanford (R) in the wake of his latest personal controversy, saying they won't help his House campaign in light of recent allegations from his ex-wife that he'd trespassed in her home." ...
... UPDATE. The Super Bowl Made Him Do It. Alex Isenstadt of Politico: "Former South Carolina governor and congressional candidate Mark Sanford admitted Wednesday that he entered his ex-wife's home in early February -- an apparent violation of the terms of their divorce settlement -- but said he did it so his son wouldn't have to watch the Super Bowl alone."
News Ledes
AP: "The wife of a former North Texas judge was charged with capital murder after confessing to her involvement in the three shooting deaths of the local district attorney, his wife and an assistant prosecutor, authorities said Wednesday. Kim Williams was arrested early Wednesday, a day after she told investigators that she and her husband, Eric Williams, were involved in the shootings of the Kaufman County district attorney, his wife and one of his prosecutors, according to documents in the case."
The Hill: "Authorities said Wednesday they had intercepted a letter to the White House that tested positive for ricin poison. The Secret Service acknowledged the letter addressed to President Obama contained a suspicious substance, and the FBI later said tests showed it was ricin, the same deadly toxin sent in a letter addressed to Sen. Roger Wicker (R-Miss.). The Wicker letter was made public on Tuesday.... Fox News reported that like the letter to Wicker, the letter to Obama was sent from Memphis, Tenn. Fox News said the letters to Obama and Wicker contained similar language and are signed identically." ...
... New York Times UPDATE: "Federal agents arrested a man on Wednesday who is suspected of sending letters believed contaminated by the poison ricin to President Obama and a Republican senator, according to two officials with knowledge of the case. The suspect was identified as Paul Kevin Curtis of Corinth, Miss."
Boston Globe: "An official briefed on the Boston Marathon bombing investigation said today that authorities have an image of a suspect carrying, and perhaps dropping, a black bag at the second bombing scene on Boylston Street, outside of the Forum restaurant." ...
... Washington Post: "Graduate student Lingzi Lu, who came to the United States from China to study mathematics and statistics, was identified Wednesday as the third person killed in the Boston Marathon bombings."
... NEW. The New York Times The Lede has updates; the latest, at 3:07 pm ET, is that the Boston Federal Courthouse has been evacuated.
** NEW. New York Times: "Investigators have found video footage of a man who they believe may have planted the deadly bombs at the Boston Marathon, a person briefed on the matter said Wednesday, saying that they had pinpointed the image on video that was captured shortly before the blast." ...
... Fox News Atlanta has crime-scene photos of fragments of the suspected bomb device -- pressure cookers -- in the Boston Marathon bombings, & a related story. ...
... The Boston Globe's lede story on developments in the investigation & public reaction to the bombings is here. ...
... AP: "Law enforcement agencies pleaded Tuesday for the public to come forward with photos, videos or any information that might help them solve the twin bombings that killed three people and wounded more than 170...."
Reuters: " Two rockets fired from Egypt's Sinai peninsula struck Israel's Red Sea resort of Eilat on Wednesday, causing no casualties or damage, the Israeli military said, in an attack claimed by Islamist militants.... Israel deployed an Iron Dome anti-rocket battery in Eilat some two weeks ago.... But on Wednesday, the system did not intercept the incoming missiles 'for operational reasons', the spokeswoman said, without elaborating. The attack was carried out a day after Israel celebrated its 65th anniversary."
AP: " Margaret Thatcher, Britain's Iron Lady, was laid to rest Wednesday with a level of pomp and protest reflecting her status as a commanding, polarizing political figure. Queen Elizabeth II, prime ministers and dignitaries from 170 countries were among the mourners at St. Paul's Cathedral, where Bishop of London Richard Chartres spoke of the strong feelings the former prime minister still evokes 23 years after leaving office." The Guardian is liveblogging the funeral.