The Commentariat -- Sept. 25, 2012
Profs. Suzanne Mettler & John Sides in a New York Times op-ed: "... nearly all Americans -- 96 percent -- have relied on the federal government to assist them. Young adults, who are not yet eligible for many policies, account for most of the remaining 4 percent.... Conservatives were less likely than liberals to respond affirmatively when asked if they had ever used a 'government social program,' even when both subsequently acknowledged using the same number of specific policies.... When Gov. Chris Christie of New Jersey noted that his father, who 'grew up in poverty,' had used the G.I. Bill..., it was in the context of a speech criticizing our 'need to be coddled by big government.' ... Instead of dividing us, our experiences as both makers and takers ought to bind us in a community of shared sacrifice and mutual support."
Andrew Ross Sorkin of the New York Times: "To say that the choice of [Tim] Pawlenty, [the former Republican governor of Minnesota,] to represent the banking industry is odd would be an understatement, but his appointment is the clearest sign yet of the flexible ethic that makes the revolving door in Washington spin faster."
Nicholas Confessore of the New York Times: "Attorney General Eric T. Schneiderman of New York on Monday rebuffed demands from Congressional Republicans to refrain from requesting tax returns and other information from tax-exempt groups that have spent heavily on campaign ads."
Presidential Race
David Lauter of the Los Angeles Times (in the Chicago Tribune): "... Mitt Romney faces a fundamental problem as the presidential campaign moves into its final phase: Voter attitudes about the state of the economy have begun to improve, and enthusiasm about voting has risen among key blocs of Democratic-leaning voters, particularly Latinos. Since the beginning of the campaign, one assumption has served as the foundation for Romney's campaign: that voters deeply upset over the state of the economy would want to fire the incumbent enough to push aside any concerns about his challenger."
Paul Waldman of American Prospect on the GOP's foreign policy problem: "Not Obama" + "America Strong!" is not much of a platform.
60 Minutes Man. Andrew Rosenthal of the New York Times: "... now I know for sure why Mr. Romney avoids getting into specifics.... When he does get specific, he doesn't make much sense.... One particularly hilarious moment came when he criticized Mr. Obama for failing to close the Guantanamo Bay detention camp.... Mr. Romney does not actually favor closing the camp.... [When asked] 'What's your big idea? he responded: 'Freedom. I want to restore the kind of freedom that has always driven America's economy. And that's allowed us to be the shining city on the hill.' His Big Idea is freedom. And quoting Ronald Reagan." CW: okay, maybe Jim Fallows is wrong [see video & link below] about Romney's great debating skills.
Jim Fallows of the Atlantic writes an excellent piece on Romney as a debater. It should worry Obama supporters. And the President himself, along with his debate prep team, should read Fallows' analysis.
Jeremy Peters of the New York Times: "... conservative 'super PACs' and other outside entities working to defeat President Obama ... operate largely from the same playbook, sharing polling data and focus group research to develop many of the same lines of attack. And they are being careful to keep their efforts consistent with the themes being emphasized by Mitt Romney's campaign." AND it's all perfectly legal! ...
... You may remember this. Attorney Trevor Potter explains how it works:
Alec McGillis of The New Republic: "Romney's arrival [in Ohio] coincides with a new ad hitting Obama for being too soft in pushing back against China's trade violations. Romney says Obama should impose tariffs on products made in China. But way back in 2009, when Obama did impose a tariff on tires made in China, Romney said just the opposite -- that in the long run tariffs are never a good idea." ...
... "Let Them Go to the Emergency Room" -- the New RomneyCare & a stunning flip-flop:
... Jonathan Cohn of The New Republic: emergency rooms "will not provide basic, ongoing care.... Romney doesn't simply want to repeal the Affordable Care Act, effectively taking health insurance away from 30 million people who, starting in 2014, are likely to get it from the law. He also wants to end Medicaid, making cuts that would leave between 14 and 27 million additional people without insurance. And he wants to change the tax treatment of employer health benefits, in ways that could make coverage more expensive or harder to get." CW: and who pays for that ER care for the uninsured? Those of us who are insured. This was stupid when George W. Bush said it. It is even more stupid coming from Romney.
Paul Krugman Expresses "Sympathy for the Doofus: ... Yes, [Mitt Romney is] a pretty bad candidate -- but the core problem is with his party, not with him."...
... Even though Romney has no sympathy for most of us. David Corn says the most damning remark Romney made in Boca tapes was this: "I'll never convince them that they should take personal responsibility and care for their lives." Corn recounts a poignant encounter with a 47-percenter a/k/a moocher.
Why Won't the Windows Open on this Gosh-Darn Plane?
When you have a fire in an aircraft, there's no place to go, exactly. And you can't find any oxygen from outside the aircraft to get in the aircraft, because the windows don't open. I don't know why they don't do that. It's a real problem. -- Mitt Romney, explaining why his wife Ann's plane had to make an emergency landing
Can we finally accept that Willard is not too bright? -- Constant Weader
Update: Aw, shucks. Supposedly Romney was joking, which Ashley Parker (Maureen Dowd's acolyte) failed to mention in her pool report. The L.A. Times picked up the story & recounted the comments as if Romney were serious because there was nothing in Parker's report to indicate otherwise. ...
... Update Update. You be the judge:
Consolation Prize: Romney still believes in cold fusion & he thinks the University of Utah "solved" that as a way to generate power conduct electricity. CW: Must have been written up in The Journal of Magical Underwear. (I apologize -- don't bother to write to tell me I'm a blasphemous fool.)
Mitt Romney & Bill Clinton are really nice to each other. (Video here.)
Congressional Races
Jamie Novogrod of NBC News: "Today's final deadline for embattled Missouri Republican Senate nominee Todd Akin to withdraw from the race is just hours away, and he has scheduled a news conference at 3:00 pm ET. Is he potentially dropping out of the contest? Not a chance, his campaign says."
Greg Sargent: Sen. Sherrod "Brown's [D-Ohio] lead in the polls should not obscure the fact that in one key way, the contest remains the most important Senate race in the country. That's because the Ohio race is providing a clearer referendum than perhaps any other Senate race on the question of whether outside money can depose an incumbent ... largely irrespective of the candidates themselves.... No other race combining this level of spending with such a clear disparity in the quality of the contenders. Brown has been a popular figure in Ohio (though Dems say his numbers have eroded a bit under the ad onslaught), while [his RTP opponent, Josh] Mandel has committed a string of missteps." ...
... Katrina vanden Heuvel of the Nation, writing in the Washington Post, champions the Senate candidacy of Elizabeth Warren: "Warren will focus on the core issues, and ask Massachusetts' voters to decide who is on their side. And if she wins -- hopefully joined by Sen. Sherrod Brown in Ohio and perhaps Rep. Tammy Baldwin in Wisconsin -- she'll not only lead a new generation of progressive reformers into the Senate, but also begin to teach Democrats how to fight for working people once more." ...
Karen Tumulty of the Washington Post: "The most closely watched Senate race in the country has taken a sharp turn off the high road. As Sen. Scott Brown (R-Mass.) and challenger Elizabeth Warren (D) enter the final phase of their exceedingly tight race, each is seeking to undermine the other on the very traits that had been considered their greatest political strengths: his independence and her character." ...
... Warren takes on Brown's repeated attacks claiming "Professor Warren" is an Affimative Action hire who exploited her Amerindian heritage. CW: I think she finally got some good campaign advice:
Greg Sargent highlights the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee's "first ad of the cycle that ties a vulnerable Republican member of Congress — Chris Gibson, in New York’s 19th district — to Romney."
Local News
Thomas Kaplan of the New York Times: Stephen M. Saland of Poughkeepsie, "one of the four Republican state senators who voted for claimed victory Monday in a close primary against an opponent critical of his vote, while another of the four [-- Roy J. McDonald of Saratoga --] appeared increasingly certain to lose his party's nomination over the issue.... One of the four Republican senators who voted for the Marriage Equality Act, James S. Alesi of Monroe County, had decided not to seek re-election. Two, Mr. Saland and Mark J. Grisanti of Buffalo, have now won competitive primaries...."
,News Ledes
AP: "WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange plans to address a meeting on the sidelines of the U.N. General Assembly via a videolink from his hideout at Ecuador's London embassy, seeking to draw new attention to his efforts to avoid extradition to Sweden over sex crimes allegations. Ecuador's mission to the United Nations said Tuesday that Assange was scheduled to speak Wednesday alongside foreign minister Ricardo Patino at a specially convened event to discuss his asylum case."
New York Times: "The housing market continues to gather strength, and the biggest gains in price now appear to be among the least expensive homes, whose values fell the most in the downturn and have weighed against any would-be recovery."
New York Times: "Libyan militia fighters assaulted a hotel in Tripoli housing members of the newly elected General National Congress on Tuesday, dramatizing the challenge the government faces in enforcing its ultimatum that all unauthorized brigades must submit to its authority or disband by the start of the day.The attack came as an American team arrived in Tripoli to investigate the death of Ambassador J. Christopher Stevens in an assault this month on the American Mission in Benghazi." ...
... AP: "One of the young Libyan rebels credited with capturing Moammar Gadhafi in a drainage ditch nearly a year ago died Tuesday of injuries after being kidnapped, beaten and slashed by the late dictator's supporters -- the latest victim of persistent violence and instability in the North African country. The death of Omran Shaaban, who had been hospitalized in France, raised the prospect of even more violence and score-settling."
AP: "Israel's defense minister [Ehud Barak] on Monday called for a broad unilateral withdrawal from the West Bank if talks with the Palestinians remain stalled, saying in published comments that 'practical steps' are needed to breathe life into the stalemated peace process."
AP: "A quiet day on Wall Street turned into the worst sell-off in three months after a Federal Reserve official said he doubted the bank's effort to boost economic growth would work. Charles Plosser, president of the Fed's Philadelphia branch, told an audience Tuesday that the Fed's effort to support the economy would likely fall short of its goals."
New York Times: "President Obama will tell the United Nations General Assembly on Tuesday that time for diplomacy to curb the looming Iranian nuclear crisis is running out, according to excerpts from Mr. Obama's planned speech provided by the White House." ...
... Update: here's the text of Obama's speech, as prepared for delivery. ...
... The Washington Post's report on the speech discusses its political implications.