The Commentariat -- October 19, 2020
Afternoon Update:
Michael Schmidt & Nicole Perlroth of the New York Times: "The Justice Department on Monday announced indictments of six Russian military intelligence officers in connection with major hacks worldwide, including of the Winter Olympics and elections in France as well as an attack in 2017 aimed at destabilizing Ukraine that spread rapidly and was blamed for billions of dollars in damage. Prosecutors said the suspects were from the same Russian unit that conducted one of the Kremlin's major operations to interfere in the 2016 American election: the theft of Democratic emails.... The case was another effort by Trump administration officials to punish Russia for its meddling in other countries' affairs, even as President Trump has adopted a more accommodating stance toward Moscow. The charges did not address 2020 election interference; American intelligence agencies have assessed that Russia is trying to influence the vote in November."
Dana Rubenstein & David Goodman of the New York Times: "... nearly three weeks into [New York City's] in-person school year, early data from the city's first effort at targeted testing has shown ... a surprisingly small number of positive cases [of Covid-19]. Out of 16,348 staff members and students tested randomly by the school system in the first week of its testing regimen, the city has gotten back results for 16,298. There were only 28 positives: 20 staff members and eight students. And when officials put mobile testing units at schools near Brooklyn and Queens neighborhoods that have had new outbreaks, only four positive cases turned up -- out of more than 3,300 tests conducted since the last week of September.... The absence of early outbreaks, if it holds, suggests that the city's efforts for its 1.1 million public school students could serve as an influential model for school districts across the nation."
Morgan Chalfant of the Hill: "President Trump derided Anthony Fauci as a 'disaster' and claimed that Americans have tired of the novel coronavirus during a call with campaign staff on Monday. 'People are tired of COVID. Yup, there's going to be spikes, there's going to be no spikes, there's going to be vaccines. With or without vaccines, people are tired of COVID,' Trump said, according to audio of the call obtained by The Hill. 'I have the biggest rallies I have ever had and we have COVID. People are saying whatever, just leave us alone. They're tired of it.' Trump then accused Fauci ... of providing inconsistent advice about the coronavirus pandemic and claimed baselessly that if he had followed all of Fauci's advice the United States would have '700,000 to 800,000 deaths right now.'" Blah-blah. ~~~
~~~ Michael Sherer & Josh Dawsey of the Washington Post:"'People are tired of listening to Fauci and these idiots,' Trump said, baselessly suggesting that Fauci's advice on how best to respond to the outbreak was so bad it would have led to the deaths of hundreds of thousands more people.... Trump also argued that the American people were no longer interested in taking precautions to prevent the spread of the coronavirus, even as the number of confirmed cases has been rising in a majority of states.... The call, which some reporters were invited to listen in on, appeared to have been motivated by recent news stories about internal concerns about the president's reelection chances and division within the president's team.... 'I go to a rally I have 25,000 people,' Trump said, greatly exaggerating the size of his crowds while making a comparison with Democrat Joe Biden. 'He goes to a rally, he has four people.'... Trump, phoning in from Las Vegas, sounded angry and defiant on the call and made a range of startling accusations and comments, including that Biden should be 'in jail.' 'He's a criminal,' Trump said, without offering evidence what crime he had committed.... Trump made a number of dubious or false statements...." Blah-blah.
Dr. John Barry, in a New York Times op-ed, takes a balanced look at how herd immunity would work -- or not.
Charles Kaiser, in the Guardian, reviews David Rothkopf's book Traitor, which is about Donald Trump. "'Trump is despicable,' he writes. 'But beyond his defective or perhaps even non-existent character, there are the near-term and lasting consequences of his actions. We must understand these to reverse them, and we must understand how easily Russia achieved its objectives in order to prevent such catastrophes in the future.'... Rothkopf provides an important roadmap through the massive evidence of collaboration between the Trump campaign and the Russian secret services -- including 272 contacts between 'Trump team members and Russian-linked individuals...'... Rothkopf is appropriately harsh about the shortcomings of Robert Mueller, including his failure as special counsel to secure an in-person interview with the president and his refusal to indict the president for any of the crimes his report describes, including as many as 10 counts of obstruction of justice."
Spencer Ackerman & Will Sommer of the Daily Beast: "The FBI is investigating the purloined laptop materials from Joe Biden's son as part of a possible foreign disinformation operation, a congressional source told The Daily Beast -- an investigation at odds with a statement from President Trump's director of national intelligence. John Ratcliffe, the director of national intelligence, told Fox Business on Monday that the dissemination of materials from Hunter Biden's alleged laptop was not part of a Russian disinformation campaign.... But that assessment gets out in front of the FBI, which took custody of the laptop and an external hard drive as early as in December, according to the New York Post. The bureau, according to the congressional source, is looking into the provenance of the material. And among the questions they're seeking to answer is whether the laptop dump is part of what the intelligence community's counterintelligence chief has already described as a Russian disinformation effort targeting the 2020 election."
Annals of Journalism, Ctd. Too Phony for Fox. Colby Hall of Mediaite: "... Fox News was first approached by Rudy Giuliani to report on a tranche of files alleged to have come from Hunter Biden's unclaimed laptop left at a Delaware computer repair shop, but that the news division chose not to run the story unless or until the sourcing and veracity of the emails could be properly vetted.... Giuliani ultimately brought the story to the New York Post, which shares the same owner, Rupert Murdoch. The tabloid has been exhaustively covering the contents of the laptop.... Some of Fox News' top news anchors and reporters have distanced themselves from the story. During an on-air report that largely focused on how social media platforms handled this story, Bret Baier said, 'Let's say, just not sugarcoat it. The whole thing is sketchy.'"
Suspended Animation. Laura Wagner of Vice: "The New Yorker has suspended reporter Jeffrey Toobin. Sources tell VICE it's because he exposed himself during a Zoom call last week between members of the New Yorker and WNYC radio. Toobin said in a statement to Motherboard: 'I made an embarrassingly stupid mistake, believing I was off-camera. I apologize to my wife, family, friends and co-workers.... I believed I was not visible on Zoom. I thought no one on the Zoom call could see me. I thought I had muted the Zoom video,' he added.... Toobin's Conde Nast email has been disabled and he has not tweeted since October 13. He did, however, appear on CNN, where he is the network’s chief legal analyst, on Saturday. 'Jeff Toobin has asked for some time off while he deals with a personal issue, which we have granted,' CNN said in a statement." ~~~
~~~ Mrs. McCrabbie: Toobin is a good reporter & analyst, but he is, well, a dickhead, so his "inappropriate behavior" is, after all, appropriate. See, Jeff, on Zoom you can tell when the video is off because there's a slash across the video symbol. Also, there's a little screen -- usually at the top of the page -- that shows just your name on a black screen & not a video of your dick. So good work. And, really, why would anybody flash his colleagues?
~~~~~~~~~~
Presidential Race, Etc.
The Washington Post's live updates of election developments Sunday are here. The page is free to non-subscribers: "... Joe Biden is campaigning Sunday in North Carolina, where he held an afternoon event encouraging supporters to vote early and a virtual meeting with African American faith leaders.
A Campaign Dedicated to Distracting the Candidate. Maggie Haberman & Alexander Burns of the New York Times: "Among some of Mr. Trump's lieutenants, there is an attitude of grit mixed with resignation: a sense that the best they can do for the final stretch is to keep the president occupied, happy and off Twitter as much as possible, rather than producing a major shift in strategy. Often, their biggest obstacle is Mr. Trump himself. Instead of delivering a focused closing message aimed at changing people's perceptions about his handling of the coronavirus, or making a case for why he can revive the economy better than Mr. Biden can, Mr. Trump is spending the remaining days on a familiar mix of personal grievances, attacks on his opponents and obfuscations."
Jonathan Martin of the New York Times: "In the week since he restarted in-person campaigning, Mr. Trump has continued to prove he is his own biggest impediment by drawing more attention to himself each day than to Mr. Biden. The president is blurting out snippets of his inner monologue by musing about how embarrassing it would be to lose to Mr. Biden -- and how he'd never return to whatever state he happens to be in if its voters don't help re-elect him. He's highlighting his difficulties with key constituencies, like women and older voters, by wondering out loud why they've forsaken him, rather than offering a message to bring more of them back into his camp. And perhaps most damaging, to him and other Republicans on the ballot, he is further alienating these voters and others by continuing to minimize the pandemic and attacking women in positions of power. A new low point came on Saturday, when Mr. Trump held a rally in Muskegon, Mich., where he demanded that Gov. Gretchen Whitmer reopen the state and then said 'lock them all up' after his supporters chanted 'lock her up!' It was a stunningly reckless comment from a president whose own F.B.I. this month arrested 14 men who it said had been plotting to kidnap Ms. Whitmer, a Democrat, and were captured on video with an array of weapons allegedly planning the crime." ~~~
~~~ Ben Kamisar of NBC News: "Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer on Sunday accused ... Donald Trump of inciting 'domestic terrorism' against public officials working on containing the coronavirus, pointing to comments he made just days after law enforcement foiled a plot to kidnap her. Whitmer has been a frequent target for Trump during the pandemic -- he's previously criticized her state's coronavirus-related restrictions as too strict and called on people to 'Liberate Michigan.' The day after Trump encouraged his supporters at a rally in the state who were chanting 'lock her up' as an attack on Whitmer, the Democrat governor responded with a plea to lower the political volume." ~~~
~~~ Dean Obeidallah in a CNN opinion piece: "Joe Biden's exasperated comment summed up what so many of us feel. 'What the hell's the matter with this guy?' said Biden Friday of Donald Trump's continuing attacks on Michigan Governor Gretchen Whitmer, even after the recent announcement of an alleged right-wing terrorist plot to kidnap and possibly kill her. 'It's despicable,' said Biden.... The charges [against the 14 rightwingers] paint a jaw-dropping plan that included tactical training at a home adorned with a Confederate flag, surveillance of Whitmer's house -- a mother of two daughters and three step-sons -- and plans to use explosive devices. And the defendants' words about Whitmer, per the authorities, should make your hair stand on end. Examples: 'Have one person go to her house. Knock on the door and when she answers it just cap her ... at this point. F**k it.' Another stated, 'Snatch and grab, man. Grab the f**kin' Governor. Just grab the bitch. Because at that point, we do that, dude -- it's over.'... [At his Moskegon rally,] Trump ... downplayed the terror plot against Whitmer, saying, 'I guess they say she was threatened.' 'I guess' she was threatened?! The defendants were charged by federal and state officials. Trump went on to slam Whitmer -- who said he'd encouraged domestic terrorists -- for blaming him for the plot, leading to his followers again chanting, 'Lock her up.'" ~~~
(~~~ Reality Interlude. Lois Beckett of the Guardian interviews gun-control activist Josh Horowitz: "Horowitz spoke to the Guardian about how mainstream the idea of insurrection has become in American politics, and why lawmakers have failed to challenge it for decades." Horowitz: "There's a belief among some American gun owners that the second amendment is highly individualized and was placed in the constitution as an individual right to fight government tyranny.... When the NRA says, 'Vote Freedom First', it's not 'Vote self-defense first'. They mean you get to decide when the government becomes tyrannical.... There is a big racial element to this. White men, especially, are feeling that the political reins of power are pulling away from them, and their grip on power is falling away. Guns are a way to exercise power.... Power over policy. Power over people.... The biggest problem is Republican elected officials, and the Republican who consistently use the insurrectionary idea and cheer on this type of behavior." ~~~)
~~~ Quint Forgey of Politico: "Lara Trump, a senior adviser to ... Donald Trump’s reelection campaign, on Sunday defended her father-in-law&'s suggestion that Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer should be imprisoned alongside his other political rivals. In an interview on CNN's 'State of the Union,' Lara Trump insisted the president was merely 'having fun at a Trump rally' when he criticized Whitmer, a Democrat, at a campaign event this weekend.... At the president's rally Saturday in Muskegon, Mich., after he demanded that Whitmer loosen her state's coronavirus-related restrictions, attendees erupted into chants of 'lock her up.' The president did not attempt to dissuade the crowd, instead saying: 'Lock them all up.'" Mrs. McC: Of course Trump was just "having fun." Because Trump, who lacks a sense of humor, thinks threatening women is hilarious. ~~~
~~~ Speaking of Hilarious. Alayna Treene of Axios: "President Trump's team is telling him ahead of Thursday's final debate: Stop interrupting Joe Biden. And try to be more likable.... Trump will tell more jokes and try, if he can stay on message, to strike a softer tone. At the same time, aides expect Trump to keep going after Biden's son Hunter." Mrs. McC: LOL, I'm sure.
David Mikkelson of Snopes: "On Oct. 17, 2020, Eric Trump ... tweeted a picture of a palatial-looking home valued at approximately $1.6M, asserting that it was the current residence of ... Joe Biden and questioning how Biden could have legitimately purchased such a property on his former salary of $174,000 per year[.]... Eric Trump was wrong on all counts: the pictured home was not currently owned by Joe Biden, it was not his current residence, and the property was -- at one time -- not outrageously outside Biden's price range. The pictured estate was a 5-bedroom, 10,000-square-foot former DuPont mansion..., which was formerly owned by Biden. Way back in 1974, Biden (then a freshman U.S. Senator and a recent widower) was able to purchase the property for a mere $185,000 because the abandoned home was badly run-down and in need of major repairs. After fixing up the home and living in it for two decades, Biden sold it in 1996 for $1.2 million...."
Senate Races. Money, Money, Money, Money! Aaron Blake of the Washington Post: Democratic Senate candidates' "dominance in third-quarter fundraising is virtually unprecedented. It was led by South Carolina's Jaime Harrison ($57 million), Maine's Sara Gideon ($39.4 million) and Arizona's Mark Kelly ($38.7 million).... But even setting aside those record hauls, every Democratic Senate candidate running in the 15 races considered competitive outraised his or her Republican opponent. Combined, they raised more than $370 million, compared with about $150 million for the GOP candidates: an average of $25 million for the Democratic candidates and $10 million for the Republicans." ~~~
~~~ Georgia Senate Race. Greg Bluestein & Maya Prabhu of the Atlanta Journal-Constitution: "Republican U.S. Sen. David Perdue inadvertently sparked a movement that benefited his rival’s campaign when he mocked the pronunciation of Democratic vice presidential nominee Kamala Harris' name. Perdue delighted the crowd Friday at ... Donald Trump's rally in Macon when he butchered the California senator's name multiple times, saying: 'Kamala? Kamala? Kamala-mala-mala? I don't know. Whatever.' But the repeated mispronunciation, which his campaign claimed was not purposeful, competed for media attention with Trump's remarks in Georgia and led to searing criticism on the airwaves and the campaign trail. By Sunday evening, Democrat Jon Ossoff said he raised more than $1.8 million from at least 42,000 donors from Perdue's viral moment. And the #MyNameIs hashtag trended on Saturday as social media users shared the meaning of their names — along with criticism of Perdue."
The Trumpidemic, Ctd.
The New York Times' live updates of Covid-19 developments Sunday are here.
Extraordinary. Allan Smith of NBC News: "Twitter on Sunday removed a tweet from one of ... Donald Trump's top Covid-19 advisers, [Dr. Scott Atlas,] which falsely claimed that masks don't work to prevent the spread of coronavirus.... Later Sunday, the coordinator of the Trump administration's testing response, Dr. Brett Giroir, the assistant secretary for health at the Department of Health and Human Services, tweeted: "#Masks work? YES!... Last month, an NBC News reporter overheard Dr. Robert Redfield, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, telling a colleague in a phone call that Atlas is arming Trump with misleading data. 'Everything he says is false,' Redfield said during a phone call made in public on a commercial airline.... Trump has leaned on Atlas in recent months, preferring his advice over that of other advisers, like Dr. Anthony Fauci.... Trump ... attended a crowded church service in Nevada on Sunday. He and his aides didn't wear masks at the ceremony, which was held indoors with over 200 people in attendance, many of whom also forwent face coverings."
Americans Die; Atlas Shrugs. Yasmeen Abutaleb, et al., of the Washington Post: "As summer faded into autumn and the novel coronavirus continued to ravage the nation unabated, Scott Atlas, a neuroradiologist whose commentary on Fox News led President Trump to recruit him to the White House, consolidated his power over the government's pandemic response.... Discord on the coronavirus task force has worsened since the arrival in late summer of Atlas, whom colleagues said they regard as ill-informed, manipulative and at times dishonest.... The result has been a U.S. response increasingly plagued by distrust, infighting and lethargy, just as experts predict coronavirus cases could surge this winter and deaths could reach 400,000 by year's end." Mrs. McC: I'll bet most Trumpbots would swear they would never vote for a mass-murderer. Well, they did & they will again. And mike pence is as much to blame as Trump is.
Paul LeBlanc of CNN: "Dr. Anthony Fauci said he is 'absolutely not' surprised ... Donald Trump contracted Covid-19 after seeing him surrounded by people not wearing face masks and flouting best public health practices. Fauci ... said during an interview on CBS' '60 Minutes' that aired Sunday, 'I was worried that he was going to get sick when I saw him in a completely precarious situation of crowded -- no separation between people, and almost nobody wearing a mask.... When I saw that on TV, I said, "Oh my goodness. Nothing good can come out of that, that's got to be a problem,'" he continued. 'And then sure enough, it turned out to be a superspreader event.'"
Erica Werner of the Washington Post: "House Speaker Nancy Pelosi D-Calif.) said Sunday that an economic stimulus deal must be struck within 48 hours in order for Congress to pass legislation before Election Day, but she noted that significant differences still divide her and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin.... Pelosi and Mnuchin spoke for 75 minutes on Saturday and agreed to speak again on Monday.... The White House and Pelosi appeared to be at odds more over the substance of the package and not the dollar amount.... 'Nancy Pelosi doesn't want to approve anything because she wants to bail out poorly run Democrat states,' Trump said in [an] interview. 'And we don't want to do that.' Pelosi has called for more money for states and cities, but Republican local leaders are among those who have asked for more aid, not just Democrats."
"Arbitrary and Capricious." Spencer Hsu of the Washington Post: "A federal judge on Sunday formally struck down a Trump administration attempt to end food stamp benefits for nearly 700,000 unemployed people, blocking as 'arbitrary and capricious' the first of three such planned measures to restrict the federal food safety net. In a scathing 67-page opinion, Chief U.S. District Judge Beryl A. Howell of D.C. condemned the Agriculture Department for failing to justify or even address the impact of the sweeping change on states, saying its shortcomings had been placed in stark relief amid the coronavirus pandemic, during which unemployment has quadrupled and rosters of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program have grown by more than 17 percent with more than 6 million new enrollees.' A CNN story is here.
Trump Blocks Refugees Who Helped the U.S., Even Those at Risk. Zolan Kanno-Youngs of the New York Times: "The Trump administration had reserved 4,000 slots for Iraqi refugees who had helped American troops, contractors or news media or who are members of a persecuted minority group in the fiscal year that ended Sept. 30. It ultimately admitted only 161 Iraqis -- or 4 percent -- to the United States, the lowest percentage of the four categories of refugees the administration authorized for resettlement last year. While the coronavirus pandemic caused refugee flights to be canceled for months, immigration lawyers also cited the lasting effects of President Trump's initial refugee bans and expanded vetting of those fleeing persecution. Of the 5,000 slots reserved for victims of religious persecution, 4,859 were filled -- a reflection, perhaps, of the administration's political priorities."
Beyond the Beltway
Virginia. Ian Shapira of the Washington Post (Oct. 17): "More than a half century after the Virginia Military Institute integrated its ranks, Black cadets still endure relentless racism at the nation's oldest state-supported military college. The atmosphere of hostility and cultural insensitivity makes VMI -- whose cadets fought and died for the slaveholding South during the Civil War and whose leaders still celebrate that history -- especially difficult for non-White students to attend, according to more than a dozen current and former students of color.... Now the school is under pressure from some alumni and students to remove or relocate its Confederate statues -- including one of [Confederate Gen. Stonewall] Jackson -- and reconsider its long-held reverence for the Confederacy. Until a few years ago, freshmen were required to salute the Jackson statue, which sits in front of the student barracks." Mrs. McC: This is a horrifying story from start to finish. If you have a WashPo subscription, I recommend you read it -- and weep. retired Gen. J.H. Binford Peay III, the school's superintendent, a thoroughly confederate guy who has to be older than I am, should be fired at once.