The Commentariat -- August 4, 2019
Afternoon Update:
Rebecca Klar of the Hill: "Federal authorities are treating the shooting at an El Paso, Texas, Walmart that killed 20 people and wounded 26 more as a case of domestic terrorism and will pursue federal hate crime and firearm charges in connection with the massacre, officials said at a press conference Sunday. Patrick Wood Crusius, 21, was booked into El Paso County Jail early Sunday on capital murder charge, the El Paso Times reported. At the same Sunday morning press conference El Paso County District Attorney Jaime Esparza said his office would seek the death penalty." ...
... Caitlin Oprysko of Politico: Beto O'Rourke, "Cory Booker and Julián Castro, placed blame on Trump for his rhetoric [that encouraged the El Paso shooter]. Mrs. McC: I heard Rep. Tim O'Ryan on MSNBC do the same. I'm surprised & heartened that at least some Democrats are speaking truth to the racist-in-chief.
Trump: A Racist AND a Deadbeat. Kolten Parker of KSAT (San Antonio): "... El Paso officials have been critical of the president in recent months for his refusal to pay a $470,000 debt owed to the city for transportation and security services during his February campaign rally. For six months, the city has sent Trump's campaign invoices for services provided by city departments -- including police, buses, the health department and others -- but has not gotten a response, according to local media.... A local TV station reported two weeks before the shooting that Trump still hadn't paid the debt."
~~~~~~~~~~
Ben Collins of NBC News: "Investigators are examining a screed believed to have been posted online by the suspect in Saturday's fatal shooting at a Texas shopping mall an hour before the attack, senior law enforcement officials say. Investigators are 'reasonably confident' that the suspect, identified by police as Patrick Wood Crusius, 21, of Texas, posted the diatribe on the extremist online forum 8chan before the shooting.... The screed posted to an anonymous extremist message board railed against immigrants in Texas and pushed talking points about preserving European identity in America.... The writing presented itself as a low-cost, low preparation model for deadly attacks and envisioned the actions as part of a larger ideological war.... The author claimed to have developed those beliefs before Trump's presidency.... Law enforcement was already analyzing the document before the mass shooting began and had connected it to a person, but the writing didn't name a target, time, place, or use the suspect's name." ...
... Simon Romero, et al., of the New York Times: The authorities identified the gunman as Patrick Crusius, from a Dallas suburb. He was taken into custody after he surrendered to the police outside the Walmart. The authorities said they were investigating a manifesto Mr. Crusius, who is white, may have posted before the shooting, which described an attack in response to 'the Hispanic invasion of Texas.' 'Right now, we have a manifesto from this individual,' El Paso's police chief, Greg Allen, told reporters, though he said later that law enforcement officers were still not clear whether the gunman had posted the document. The manifesto the chief appeared to be referring to was an anti-immigrant online screed titled 'The Inconvenient Truth.' The post declares support for the gunman who killed 51 people in Christchurch, New Zealand; outlines fears about Hispanic people gaining power in the United States; and appears to discuss specific details about elements of the attack, including weapons.... 'Hispanics will take control of the local and state government of my beloved Texas, changing policy to better suit their needs,' the manifesto said. It added that politicians of both parties are to blame for the United States 'rotting from the inside out,' and that 'the heavy Hispanic population in Texas will make us a Democrat stronghold.'" ...
... Mrs. Bea McCrabbie: Assuming investigators are right about the source of the screed, this mass murderer may or may not have harbored such ideas prior to 2015, but Trump certainly exacerbated the murderer's hate-filled belief system. Trump's fingerprints might not be on the rifle, but they're on Crusius' forehead. ...
... Mary Papenfuss of the Huffington Post: "'We've had a rise in hate crimes every single one of the last three years, during an administration where you have a president who's called Mexicans rapists and criminals,' said the former Texas congressman and El Paso native [Beto O'Rourke]. 'He is a racist, and he stokes racism in this country,' O'Rourke added. 'It does not just offend our sensibilities; it fundamentally changes the character of this country and it leads to violence.'" Thanks to PD Pepe for the link. ...
... David Atkins of the Washington Monthly: "While offering the usual thoughts, prayers and condemnations of the violence itself, Republicans have for the most part been remarkably quiet not only about the crisis of gun violence but also about the motives of the shooter.... Fox News tried to blame video games.... But of course, the only Republican politician who really matters is the one whose name spelled in firearms the killer's twitter account allegedly liked in a tweet: ... Donald Trump.... Trump's ... latest tweet (before issuing the usual pabulum 'thoughts and prayers') is as follows: 'Today's shooting in El Paso, Texas, was not only tragic, it was an act of cowardice. I know that I stand with everyone in this Country to condemn today's hateful act. There are no reasons or excuses that will ever justify killing innocent people.' These are not the words of a man disgusted with the terrorist's motives. These are the words of a man disappointed in his tactics. No one says 'there are no reasons or excuses that will ever justify' unless they sympathize with the frustrations of the individual.... Moreover, it's pretty obvious that these aren't Trump's authentic words at all. When Trump actually cares about something, he tweets about it authentically and spontaneously, usually with bizarre random capitalization, grammar errors and misspellings." ...
... Richard Parker of El Paso in a New York Times op-ed: "... the El Paso massacre ... was the inevitable byproduct of the Trump era's anti-immigrant, and anti-Latino invective, which with its pervasive, vile racism has poisoned our nation.... The Trump era ... has brought us walls, internment camps and children in cages. The massacre is the outcome I have feared for years now, and I can't help but feel that its genesis lies with the president of the United States." ...
... There Was This. "The Remark Drew a Chuckle from the President"* William Cummings of USA Today, May 9: "... Donald Trump was tickled Wednesday when an audience member at a Florida rally suggested shooting migrants arriving at the U.S.-Mexican border. Trump was bemoaning the legal protections afforded migrants and espousing the need for a border wall when he asked rhetorically, 'How do you stop these people?' 'Shoot them!' someone shouted from the Panama City Beach crowd.... The remark drew a chuckle from the president, who shook his head, pointed in the audience member's direction and said, 'Only in the Panhandle you can get away with that statement.' 'Only in the Panhandle,"' he repeated to laughs and cheers from the crowd." ...
... April Glaser of Slate: "The document [attributed to the El Paso shooter] had been uploaded to the notorious, unmoderated message board 8chan at 10:15 a.m. local time, and it included a request: 'Do your part and spread this brothers!'... Soon after it was first posted on 8chan, the manifesto could be found On 4chan, another message board with scant rules about what people can or cannot share. And not long after that, it was circulating as images on Twitter and Facebook and easily findable in a Google image search.... The involvement of 8chan is becoming a familiar detail in cases of white-supremacist violence. The El Paso shooting appears to be the second one since the Christchurch massacre to draw from that killer's playbook.... [The] shootings [in Christchurch, New Zealand, Poway, California, & El Paso] appeared to have been designed to go viral -- a horrific act would catch the world's attention, and a manifesto would deliver the hate-filled payload. An anonymous, meme-filled internet backwater, 8chan has long been a place for white supremacists to indoctrinate others -- mostly young white men -- into bigoted ideologies.... Whatever is too gruesome for 4chan finds a home on 8chan. That now includes enthusiasm for a white ethnostate.... Many people come to the politically incorrect boards of 4chan and 8chan from video-game communities, where players looking to laugh at an abasing joke or chat about violent games ... can find friends."
Cora Currier of The Intercept: "A principal goal of the Trump administration's policy at the U.S.-Mexico border -- and in Central America ... -- has been to get other governments to handle the increase in migrants seeking to enter the United States.... Another way to describe these efforts is what the U.S. security establishment has long referred to as 'pushing out the border.' It's not a project that's new to the Trump administration, and it's not one that's unique to the United States, as journalist Todd Miller expounds in his latest book, 'Empire of Borders: The Expansion of the U.S. Border Around the World.'" --s
This could be the headline of at least half the stories about Trump's tweets & chopper chatter: "Trump Defends His Recent Erratic Decision with Lies." Case in point: Tax Axelrod of the Hill reports on Trump's latest fantastical tweets defending his brilliant trade-war strategy against China. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Lee Moran of the Huffington Post: "Fox News' Neil Cavuto wasted no time in fact-checking ... Donald Trump's latest claims about the tariffs his administration has imposed (and has promised to ramp up) on products imported into the U.S. from China. Trump on Friday told White House reporters that 'the tariffs are not being paid for by our people' but 'by China' because 'of devaluation and because they're pumping money in.' 'Remember this, our country is taking in billions and billions of dollars from China,' the president added. 'We never took in 10 cents from China. And out of that many billions of dollars, we're taking a part of it and giving it to the farmers because they've been targeted by China. The farmers, they come out totally whole,' [Trump claimed.] 'I don't know where to begin here,' responded Cavuto.... 'But just to be clarifying, China isn't paying these tariffs. You are. You know, indirectly and sometimes directly,' he explained.... '... this latest round of tariffs that kick in on September 1, on $300 billion worth of goods at 10%, that will most directly be felt by consumers directly,' he added. 'Because that happens on almost entirely consumer items rather than industrial-related items.... Our governments don't pay these things, you do, one way or another.'" (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Maureen Dowd: "White male privilege is out of fashion these days. Yet we are awash in nostalgia for it. Donald Trump has built a political ideology on nostalgia. And Quentin Tarantino has built a movie ideology on nostalgia. In The Los Angeles Times, Mary McNamara observed that the moral of Tarantino's new fairy tale, 'Once Upon A Time In -- Hollywood,' is, 'Who doesn't miss the good old days when cars had fins and white men were the heroes of everything?'... In The New Yorker, Richard Brody called the movie ... 'obscenely regressive,' a phrase that could easily be applied to the man in the Oval.... Both the Tarantino creation and the Trump creation feature scripted tough-guy dialogue, rough treatment of women and slurs against Mexicans. Trump's time machine is a vicious and vertiginous journey, all about punching down, pulpy fictions, making brown and black people scapegoats and casting women back into a crimped era of fewer reproductive rights. Trump has inverted all the old American ideals, soiling the image of our country in the world and reshaping it around his grievances and inadequacies. He is a faux tough guy who lets other people do the fighting for him, a needy brat who never accepts responsibility for his actions, an oaf with no trace of courage, class or chivalry." ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: MoDo's attempts to find the nexus between cultural inflection points usually fall flat, but I think she got it right this time.
Another Embarrassing Trumpisode. In Which Trump Pretends He Has Black Friends. Linda Givetash of NBC News: "The U.S. government warned Sweden of 'negative consequences' as it advocated for rapper ASAP Rocky during his trial for assault charges in Stockholm this week, according to a pair of letters released by the Swedish Prosecution Authority. Rocky was released from jail on Friday pending the verdict, with ... Donald Trump celebrating the news on Twitter. 'It was a Rocky Week, get home ASAP A$AP!' Trump said. The rapper landed back on U.S. soil Saturday, leaving behind him the looming verdict in an episode that has led to unexpected tension between the U.S. and its European ally.... A final judgment in the case is expected to be reached Aug. 14."
Kyla Mandel of ThinkProgress: "Interior Secretary David Bernhardt's ethics recusal will expire on Saturday. The ethics pledge banned Bernhardt from decisions involving his former firm's clients for two years. Bernhardt was also not able to meet with these companies, unless five or more other stakeholders were present and nothing relating specifically to the companies was discussed.... Prior to joining the Interior Department in 2017, Bernhardt worked as a lobbyist for the oil and gas industry.... He has so many potential conflicts of interest to avoid that he carries around a card listing all of them so he doesn't forget. A recent analysis by the Center for American Progress found that Bernhardt has more conflicts of interest than any other Trump Cabinet nominee." --s
Ole MacNunes Had a Farm, E-I-E-I-O. Julia Arciga of the Daily Beast: "Rep. Devin Nunes' (R-CA) campaign is suing a group of people who called him a 'fake farmer', claiming the defendants were coordinating with 'dark money' groups to hurt his campaign.... Prior to the lawsuit, the group claimed Nunes couldn't call himself a farmer since he no longer farms -- but a state judge ruled that the representative can continue to use the designation. The campaign also claimed the group was working with various political groups and The Fresno Bee's parent company, McClatchy, in a campaign against him.... The lawsuit, filed Thursday, comes after the representative sued a parody Twitter account claiming to be his cow, and McClatchy."
Presidential Race 2020
** Jonathan Chait: "Of all the institutions and norms of American government, none is more rickety than the voting process. The system's legitimacy hangs on the public's willingness to trust the accuracy of a system that is hardly a system at all.... Even more alarming than the implied weaknesses in the voting system is the political context in which they exist. President Trump has frequently either minimized or outright denied Russia's culpability in the 2016 email hacks (which Trump himself was exploiting at the time).... Republican indifference to the Russian threat gives an indication of how the party would respond in the event of a compromised election.... [Mitch McConnell] has already proved that he would prefer for his party to win with Russian help than to lose without it." ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: You might think Chait is making a Chicken Little argument here, but he presents too much GOP history to dismiss his concerns. I would be horrified, but not completely surprised, if armed U.S. marshalls, by order of President Harris, had to storm the White House in late January 2021 & remove the fat bastard by force.
Matthew Choi of Politico: "Sen. Bernie Sanders defended his rival 2020 Democratic hopeful Elizabeth Warren on Friday after Rep. Liz Cheney (R-Wyoming) went after Warren for advocating a no-first-strike nuclear policy.... Cheney, daughter of former Vice President Dick Cheney, lambasted Warren the following morning for her remarks.... 'Which American cities and how many American citizens are you willing to sacrifice with your policy of forcing the US to absorb a nuclear attack before we can strike back?' Cheney wrote Wednesday on Twitter. Friday afternoon, Sanders shot back at Cheney, sparking a heated back and forth. 'Taking national security advice from a Cheney has already caused irreparable damage to our country,' Sanders tweeted. 'We don't need any more, thanks.' Cheney responded by calling Sanders a 'commie' who "is ok with U.S. getting attacked first.'... Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) also chimed in on Friday, tweeting a gif of her exasperated face and the message: [']My face when "*Liz Cheney* of all people tries to offer foreign policy takes, as if an entire generation hasn't lived through the Cheneys sending us into war since we were kids.'"
Marina Pitofsky of the Onion Hill: "Michael Avenatti is reportedly considering a White House bid after declaring that he would not join the slate of Democratic candidates running for president in 2020.... Earlier this year, Avenatti was arrested in New York for an alleged $20 million extortion scheme against Nike. In April, federal prosecutors in California indicted the lawyer on three dozen criminal counts, including allegedly stealing money from clients and lying about his income to regulators. Avenatti has pleaded not guilty to all charges." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Nancy Cook of the Onion Politico: "The Trump 2020 campaign has been quietly reaching out to prominent African Americans about joining its latest coalition, intended to boost Republican support in the black community. The effort comes just as the president capped off a month filled with racially divisive language and Twitter taunts aimed at House Oversight Chairman Elijah Cummings and four freshman congresswomen of color." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Mrs. McCrabbie: We have never had an American president whose last name was difficult for English-readers to spell. The toughest might be Roosevelt (Dutch) & Eisenhower (anglicized German).
Presidential Races 2016 & 2020. Danielle McLean of ThinkProgress: "Sen. Cory Booker (D-NJ) claimed during Wednesday night's presidential debate that President Donald Trump won Michigan in 2016 because Republicans and Russians worked to suppress the votes of African Americans. Election experts say he's onto something.... Trump won the state by 10,704 votes." --s
Steven Greenhouse in a New York Times op-ed: "... the United States suffers from what I call 'anti-worker exceptionalism.' Academics debate why American workers are in many ways worse off than their counterparts elsewhere, but there is overriding agreement on one reason: Labor unions are weaker in the United States than in other industrial nations.... In no other industrial nation do corporations fight so hard to keep out unions.... Numerous studies have found that an important cause of America's soaring income inequality is the decline of labor unions -- and the concomitant decline in workers' ability to extract more of the profit and prosperity from the corporations they work for.... The consequences are enormous, not only for wages and income inequality, but also for our politics and policymaking and for the many Americans who are mistreated at work.... The diminished power of unions and workers has skewed American politics, helping give billionaires and corporations inordinate sway over America's politics and policymaking." ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: Greenhouse doesn't mention the confederate Supremes, who exult in quashing union rights, making them the five old boys who have done the most to maintain income inequality.
Taylor Hatmaker of The Daily Beast: "As many tech giants grow skittish about cashing in on the surveillance boom, one company [Anduril Industries] helmed by an industry iconoclast [Palmer Luckey] seems custom-built for Big Brother. The 26-year-old is best known as the designer of the Oculus Rift virtual reality headset that shepherded the futuristic technology into the mainstream. In 2014, Luckey sold his 100-person virtual reality company to Facebook for $3 billion ... after The Daily Beast revealed that he was bankrolling an unofficial pro-Trump group dedicated to 'shitposting' and circulating anti-Clinton memes.... And far from shying away from politics post-Facebook, Luckey leaned into the #MAGA-friendly ideology -- donating big money to pro-Trump outfits, and meeting with Trump cabinet officials, all while his company quietly picks up military contracts and expands its work with border patrol." --s
Hannah Natanson of the Washington Post: "It was common knowledge that the founding nuns [of the Georgetown Visitation Convent school for girls in Washington, D.C.,] owned slaves, but school lore has held that the sisters allowed enslaved children to attend Saturday school and defied the law by teaching them how to read. The 65-page report, which the school has made available online, details the businesslike efficiency with which the nuns sold scores of enslaved people to pay off debts and fund new buildings. Georgetown Visitation sisters owned at least 107 enslaved people,including men, women and children, from a year after its founding until 1862, when the federal government made slavery illegal in the District, the report found.... News of the research and its findings was published Friday by New York University professor Rachel Swarns in an opinion piece for the New York Times. The Catholic Standard ran a story about the report in November." (Also linked yesterday.)
Damian Carrington of the Guardian: "Coal, oil and gas get more than $370bn (£305bn) a year in support, compared with $100bn for renewables, [an] International Institute for Sustainable Development (IISD) report found. Just 10-30% of the fossil fuel subsidies [switched to renewables] would pay for a global transition to clean energy, the IISD said.... 'Almost everywhere, renewables are so close to being competitive that [a 10-30% subsidy swap] tips the balance, and turns them from a technology that is slowly growing to one that is instantly the most viable and can replace really large amounts of generation,' said Richard Bridle of the IISD. 'It goes from being marginal to an absolute no-brainer.'" --s
You Too May Be an Unregistered Lobbyist. Vivan Wang of the New York Times: "When Kat Sullivan rented a billboard last year in upstate New York to call for stronger protections against child sex abusers, she believed she was engaging in the democratic process, using her own time and money to make her voice as an abuse survivor heard.So she was shocked when state regulators afterward sent her a letter ordering her to register as a lobbyist. New York State defines a lobbyist as, in part, someone who spends money to influence lawmakers. But Ms. Sullivan, a registered nurse, has argued that she was exercising her rights as a citizen.... The state's ethics commission ... has warned that she could be guilty of a misdemeanor and fined more than $40,000 if she continues to refuse to register.... Few unpaid advocates spend more than $5,000 on an issue, the annual threshold for registering as a lobbyist in New York. Ms. Sullivan has said that she spent $14,000 on three billboards, plus about $2,000 on a website.... Federal law defines lobbyists by the percentage of time that they spend contacting lawmakers; New York defines them by money earned and spent. Other states have lower or higher thresholds, or exclude volunteers.... 'Almost every jurisdiction I can think of is grappling at some level with how much is covered and at what threshold,' Beth Rotman, [of] Common Cause ... said...."
Way Beyond the Beltway
China. Nick Schager of The Daily Beast: "One Child Nation is a ... heartrending documentary [that] examines ... China's one-child policy, which functioned as a systematic attack on its female population -- and which resulted in collateral damage on an international scale. In effect from 1979 to 2015, China's policy placed strict guidelines on reproduction in order to curb population growth.... The law outlined strict punishment for non-compliance: the destruction of homes, forfeiture of property and valuables, and steep fines. Those who suffered those penalties, however, got off easy, since local Family Planning Officials -- empowered by the Nationalist Party -- also had the authority to abduct women, tie them up, and force them to undergo sterilizations and abortions as late as 8-9 months into their pregnancies." Attention: disturbing content. --s
Russia. AP: "Police cracked down hard on an unsanctioned demonstration in Moscow for a second weekend in a row, detaining about 600 people protesting the exclusion of some independent and opposition candidates from September city council elections. The issue taps growing dissatisfaction with a political environment dominated by the Kremlin-aligned United Russia party, in which dissenting voices are marginalized, ignored or repressed. An arrest-monitoring group, OVD-Info, said 685 people were detained Saturday. The Russian Interior Ministry said the number was about 600. The detentions came a week after authorities arrested nearly 1,400 people at a similar protest."
News Ledes
Mass Murder America. Guardian: "Nine people have been killed and at least 16 injured in a shooting early on Sunday in Dayton, Ohio, police have said. Police said the suspect was shot and killed by responding officers.... The shooting came hours after at least 20 people were killed in another mass shooting at a Walmart in El Paso, Texas." --s ...
... According to CNN, which is liveblogging developments, the motive for this mass murder is still unknown. In later updates, Sen. Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio) said the shooter was "a young, white male," & Dayton Mayor Nan Whaley said police responded to the shooter "in less than one minute." Mrs. McC: So in less than a minute, this guy killed nine people & injured 27 others. There is no excuse for any civilian to have access to a weapon that can shoot 36 people in less than a minute. Update: "in 24 seconds." ...
... CNN Updates: "Authorities have found writings linked to Dayton, Ohio, shooting suspect Connor Betts that show he had an interest in killing people, two federal law enforcement sources told CNN. A preliminary assessment of the writings, found during the execution of a search warrant, did not indicate any racial or political motive, the sources said.... The City of Dayton has released the names of the nine deceased victims in the shooting early Sunday. Suspect Connor Betts' sister was identified as one of those killed."