The Commentariat -- July 7, 2019
Afternoon Update:
The Counterfactual World of Trump & Troupe. Chris Rodrigo of the Hill: "President Trump on Sunday accused the media of reporting 'phony and exaggerated accounts' of conditions at migrant detention centers along the border in the wake of two bombshell reports from the Department of Homeland Security's (DHS) watchdog. 'The Fake News Media, in particular th Failing @nytimes, is writing phony and exaggerated accounts of the Border Detention Centers,' Trump tweeted.... The reports from the DHS Office of Inspector General (OIG) covered the conditions at facilities near El Paso, Texas, and in the Rio Grande Valley. The government watchdog found severe overcrowding, migrants being held too long and dirty conditions at many of the facilities. A group of lawyers who visited a Border Patrol station in Clint, Texas, made similar claims about the treatment of migrants. The Trump administration has denied reports and images of the conditions in detainment facilities." Mrs. McC: Sunday afternoon, Trump gave a chopper presser in which he elaborated on his phony charges. I'll get a report on that when one becomes available. ...
... Quinn Owen of ABC News: "Acting Department of Homeland Security Secretary Kevin McAleenan said he did not accept reports of unsanitary conditions and limited food and water at U.S. Border Patrol stations, calling the situation at the border 'extraordinarily challenging' for the department, in an interview on ABC's "This Week" Sunday.... For months, McAleenan has raised alarms about the potential for disastrous conditions on the southern border while maintaining his agency has upheld government standards for housing detainees, despite evidence to the contrary. He said on Sunday that the food and water at one facility in Clint, Texas, that has faced scrutiny were 'adequate' and that migrants in holding centers had access to showers and clean living quarters.... Conditions were so severe at facilities in the Rio Grande Valley that one CBP manager described it to federal investigators as a "ticking time bomb" in the report made public this past week."
David Kirkpatrick & David Sanger of the New York Times: "Iran said on Sunday that within hours it would breach the limits on uranium enrichment set four years ago in an accord with the United States and other international powers that was designed to keep Tehran from producing a nuclear weapon. The latest move inches Iran closer to where it was before the accord: on the path to being able to produce an atomic bomb." Mrs. McC: Thanks, Trump!
Mary Papenfuss of the Huffington Post: "An artist blasted by the Anti-Defamation League for creating a 'blatantly anti-Semitic cartoon' has been invited to the White House by ... Donald Trump. Cartoonist Ben Garrison proudly tweeted his invitation to join a 'Social Media Summit' this coming Thursday at the White House.... Trump's Social Media Summit is expected to address the president's complaints that social media platforms' policies against threats and hate speech are blocking conservative voices.... Two years ago, Garrison created an inflammatory cartoon depicting Jewish billionaire philanthropist George Soros using puppet strings to control then-Gen. H.R. McMaster, who was serving as Trump's national security adviser at the time, and retired Gen. David Petraeus. The image was a nod to an anti-Semitic conspiracy theory that a secretive international Jewish cabal controls the world. In the cartoon, Soros is being controlled by a hand labeled the 'Rothschilds,' a famous Jewish banking family. The ADL wrote at the time that the 'thrust of the cartoon is clear: McMaster is merely a puppet of a Jewish conspiracy.'"
Jamie Ehrlich of CNN: "Newly independent Rep. Justin Amash, the only congressional Republican to have publicly argued that ... Donald Trump has engaged in impeachable conduct, told CNN that high-level party officials have thanked him behind closed doors for his stance on impeachment proceedings against Trump. 'I get people sending me text messages, people calling me, saying "thank you for what you're doing,'" Amash told CNN's Jake Tapper in a wide-ranging interview on 'State of the Union' Sunday....In the same interview, Amash said House Speaker Nancy Pelosi should start impeachment proceedings against Trump. 'From a principled, moral position, she's making a mistake. From a strategic position, she's making a mistake,' Amash said."
Edward Helmore of the Guardian: "Congressional approval for funds for the Trump administration to spend at the southern border has triggered open warfare between a 'squad' of high-profile progressive House Democrats and party leaders they accuse of caving to a White House determined to mistreat migrant children.... On Saturday [Speaker Nancy] Pelosi [said] in a New York Times interview, [with Maureen Dowd, also linked below] taking aim at The Squad for voting against 'our bill'. 'All these people have their public whatever and their Twitter world,' she said. 'But they didn't have any following. They're four people and that's how many votes they got.' In a tweeted response, [Rep. Alexandria] Ocasio-Cortez said: 'That public "whatever" is called public sentiment. And wielding the power to shift it is how we actually achieve meaningful change in this country.' She also defended her use of social media. The progressive-moderate split is becoming more evident and bitter."
~~~~~~~~~~
Maureen Dowd interviews Nancy Pelosi.
New York Times reporters paint a devastating picture of the now-infamous migrant camp in Clint, Texas. It's difficult to read. "Outbreaks of scabies, shingles and chickenpox were spreading among the hundreds of children who were being held in cramped cells, agents said. The stench of the children's dirty clothing was so strong it spread to the agents' own clothing -- people in town would scrunch their noses when they left work. The children cried constantly. One girl seemed likely enough to try to kill herself that the agents made her sleep on a cot in front of them, so they could watch her as they were processing new arrivals."
"They" Made Trump Hire Undocumented Workers. Nicholas Bogel-Burroughs & Miriam Jordan of the New York Times: "After months of silence, President Trump responded on Friday to reports that the Trump Organization has employed dozens of undocumented immigrants by saying that he doesn't know whether the organization does or not. 'I don't know because I don't run it,' Mr. Trump said when asked if he was confident that undocumented immigrants were no longer working at his golf courses. 'But I would say this: Probably every club in the United States has that because it seems to be, from what I understand, a way that people did business.... But we've ended -- whatever they did, we have a very strict rule that, those rules are very strict,' Mr. Trump said...." (Also linked yesterday.) ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: In fairness to the slackard children of America, "The dog ate my homework" is a far more plausible excuse than "I don't run it" when in fact he did "run it," right down to picking the fabrics & colors of the uniforms of the undocumented workers he hired. Democrats should run ads, ad nauseum, in Trump country featuring Trump's former undocumented employees -- the "foreign" bastids who are taking their job & making America brown again (which is what it was before we white European imperialists crashed & trashed the land between the shining seas).
What is the top political problem facing the country? Maybe you're thinking income inequality, or the environment, or healthcare or education or, well, Trump. According to Trump himself, however, your concerns are misplaced: "Our most difficult problem is not our competitors, it is the Federal Reserve!"
Isabel Oakeshott of the Daily Mail: "Britain's Ambassador to Washington has described Donald Trump as 'inept', 'insecure' and 'incompetent' in a series of explosive memos to Downing Street. Sir Kim Darroch, one of Britain's top diplomats, used secret cables and briefing notes to impugn Trump's character, warning London that the White House was 'uniquely dysfunctional' and that the President's career could end in 'disgrace'.... He also says that he doesn't think Trump's White House will 'ever look competent'.... In a memo sent after [Trump visited the U.K.], Sir Kim warned that while Trump and his team had been 'dazzled' by the visit, and the UK might be 'flavour of the month', Trump's White House remained self-interested: 'This is still the land of America First'." ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: Other media outlets are accepting this report as credible, even tho it comes from the Daily Mail. Also too, the government more-or-less verified the accuracy of the leaked cables: "The Foreign Office last night said that the British public 'would expect our Ambassadors to provide Ministers with an honest, unvarnished assessment of the politics in their countries'. A spokesman added: 'Their views are not necessarily the views of Ministers or indeed the Government. But we pay them to be candid, just as the US Ambassador here will send back his reading of Westminster politics and personalities."
I thought Ivanka was amazing at the G-20. The foreign leaders loved her. They think she's great. -- Donald Trump, to reporters Friday
Uh, how exactly would Trump know this? Does he think other heads of state are going to say, "Why did you bring your dimwitted daughter?" -- Mrs. Bea McCrabbie
Masha Gessen of the New Yorker: Media reviewers gave Trump a pass on his July Fourth speech, calling it "inoffensive," "not a complete authoritarian nightmare," and "tame." "Campaign slogans and glaring Trumpisms were not the only things absent from the speech. Immigrants were missing. Trump's most recent predecessors presided over Fourth of July naturalization ceremonies. A rhetorical link between the holiday and immigration has long seemed unbreakable.... That immigrant story is, of course, the story the Trump Administration has demonstratively abandoned.... Trump has retired the myth of America as a nation of immigrants because he staked his election campaign and his legitimacy as president on the demonization of immigrants -- and on mobilizing Americans for a war against immigrants.... Trump spoke like the leader of a country under siege.... Trump has reframed America, stripping it of its ideals, dumbing it down, and reducing it to a nation at war against people who want to join it." Thanks to Anonymous for the link.
Well, now, Treasury Secretary Steve Mnuchin epitomized the American dream when he took in a poor immigrant woman. Still, some of you will come away with the impression that Steve & the Immigrant somehow have missed the spirit of the holiday:
Thanks to Hattie for this inspiring holiday portrait. (And, no, these people really have no idea how ridiculous they are.)
Presidential Race 2020
Christian Vasquez of Politico: "Joe Biden apologized Saturday for his remarks about working with segregationists during his time in the Senate, but again stopped short of saying that it was wrong to work with them amid a defense of his broader civil rights record. 'Now was I wrong a few weeks ago, to somehow give the impression to people that I was praising those men who I successfully opposed time and again? Yes, I was. I regret it. I'm sorry for any of the pain or misconception that I caused anybody,' the former vice president and Democratic presidential candidate said to cheers during a speech to a mostly black audience in Sumter, South Carolina. Biden continued: 'But did that misstep define 50 years of my record for fighting for civil rights, racial justice in this country? I hope not. I don't think so. That just isn't an honest assessment of my record. I'm going to let my record and character stand for itself and not be distorted or smeared.'" ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: It took Biden a mere two-and-a-half weeks to apologize, and in the meantime he defended his remarks on numerous occasions. ...
... Em Steck & Andrew Kaczynski of CNN: "... on the sidelines of the re-litigated fight over busing ... was another candidate who waded into the busing debate in the 1970s on the opposite side of Biden: Massachusetts Sen. Elizabeth Warren. In her first law review article, published in 1975 in the Rutgers Law Review and recently unearthed by CNN's KFile, Warren sharply criticized a Supreme Court ruling in the case Milliken v. Bradley, writing that it made it easier for school districts to stop busing students in northern cities. Warren's law review article sheds light on a previously unexplored early career stance on busing that contrasts with Biden's approach during the same time period. Biden defended his past position in an exclusive interview with CNN this week.... [Warren's] first article, according to Justin Driver, a professor of law at Yale School of Law, showed a remarkable understanding of the complexities in education law. It was an 'extremely accomplished piece of scholarship by a student, said Driver."
Gabriel Sherman of Vanity Fair: "What is a problem for the [Trump] campaign ... is the escalating cold war between Jared Kushner and Donald Trump Jr. for control of the reelection, five sources close to the White House told me in recent days. Brad Parscale is the nominal campaign manager -- but Jared and Don Jr. ... are jockeying to be the ultimate decision makers.... Paranoia about Kushner has set in among Don Jr.'s allies. According to one person close to Don Jr., his advisers were alarmed by Don Jr.'s now-deleted tweet questioning Senator Kamala Harris's race. They worried Kushner would push the scandal to damage Don Jr.... 'Don doesn't want to give Jared any excuses to delegitimize him,' the person told me." --s
Senate Race 2020. Sheryl Stolberg of the New York Times: Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) "may be in trouble because of two men: Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh and President Trump.... Ms. Collins, who coasted to a fourth term in 2014 with 68 percent of the vote, will be difficult to beat. But the polarization that has swept the nation is seeping into Maine as well.... In an interview, Ms. Collins said she would decide in the fall if she would seek re-election. For now, she is behaving like a candidate. She had raised $4.4 million for her 2020 campaign as of March, according to federal elections data, money she will need: After her Kavanaugh vote, a crowdfunding campaign raised over $4 million to donate to her eventual opponent. Last week, she drew a formidable challenger: Sara Gideon, the speaker of the Maine House."
Annals of "Journalism," Ctd. Rebecca Traister of New York: The pundits who cover politics are way behind the times. "The problem here is not simply that [Chris] Matthews and [Donny] Deutsch still have their high-paid media jobs, despite lengthy records of mediocre analysis, grotesque speech about women, and relative cluelessness about race. I's that their jobs are crucial to how the story of the presidential race will be told to the millions of people who watch them.... Altogether, what's emerging is a view of a presidential commentariat that -- in terms of both ideas and diversity -- is embarrassingly outpaced by the candidates, many of whom appear smarter, more thoughtful, and to have a nimbler grasp of American history and structural inequities than the television journalists being paid to cover them." Thanks to Anonymous for the link. ...
... Mrs. McCrabbie: Traister seems unaware that this is scarcely a new phenomenon. The suits run the networks, and they always have picked "news analysts" who reflect what the suits imagine is "safe" and "inoffensive." Even when the analysts have been edgy, even when their gigs followed stellar journalistic careers, the front office has been extremely uneasy about them. Bill Paley made Edward R. Murrow (assuming the biopic film "Good Night, and Good Luck" is accurate) "pay for" his Joe McCarthy exposé by interviewing Marilyn Monroe & Liberace. Vietnam War protests had been at the forefront for years before David Brinkley & Walter Cronkite somewhat timidly questioned our Southeast Asian military adventure. The MSM will never be cutting-edge; that's why we call it "mainstream." ...
... This is hardly a problem unique to political analysis. As Elizabeth Berry & Chi-hui Yang wrote in a New York Times op-ed last week, "... those who have for decades been given the biggest platforms to interpret culture are white men.... Yet the most dynamic art in America today is being made by artists of color and indigenous artists."
Patricia Mazzei & William Rashbaum of the New York Times: "Jeffrey E. Epstein, a billionaire New York financier long accused of molesting dozens of girls, was arrested on Saturday and charged with sex trafficking by federal prosecutors, an extraordinary turn of events in a long and sordid criminal case. Two people with knowledge of the charges said on Saturday night that Mr. Epstein had been arrested in the New York area and was in federal custody.... Mr. Epstein, 66, had avoided federal criminal charges in 2007 and 2008 in a widely criticized plea deal whose lenient terms continue to roil the Justice Department and are facing new scrutiny in the #MeToo era. Before the plea deal, Mr. Epstein, a former hedge-fund manager, had been friendly with Donald J. Trump, former President Bill Clinton and Prince Andrew, the Duke of York.... The plea deal that protected Mr. Epstein from federal charges was signed by the top federal prosecutor in Miami at the time, Alexander Acosta, who is now President Trump's labor secretary."
Way Beyond the Beltway
Israel. Juan Cole: "Hagar Shezaf at the Israeli newspaper of record, Haaretz ['The Land'], reveals that a secretive Israeli agency has been systematically going through the country's archives, including local repositories, and removing and classifying documents having to do with repressive and embarrassing Israeli actions toward Palestinians and Palestinian-Israelis.... The Israeli classification program is betting that the history of 1948 can be erased simply by withholding the Israeli documentation. Hierarchies of knowledge privilege state archives over the oral histories of the powerless and oppressed. Nevertheless, the Palestinians themselves, and their family histories, are the best archive for knowing about their expulsion, and for knowing about the conditions of Apartheid under which some 5 million still live." --s
U.K. James Cusick of OpenDemocracy: "In October 2016, Boris Johnson, the recently-appointed [British] foreign secretary ... was invited to the luxurious Umbrian villa of his wealthy friend, Evgeny Lebedev -- the Russian owner of London's Evening Standard newspaper.... During his stint as London's mayor, Boris had been to the 17th-century villa four times..., using his friend's private jet to fly there and back to London.... Boris's host [is] the son of a wealthy Russian oligarch and former KGB agent.... Meanwhile the Sunday Times recently carried a story claiming the former foreign secretary had been branded 'a security risk by a senior cabinet minister who was close to Theresa May, but is backing Hunt for the leadership.' [T]he Sunday Times quoted the cabinet minister in conversation with another unnamed cabinet minister: 'There will be things in his private life that we don't know about ... there's the danger that people leak what they have over him or blackmail him with it.'" --s
Corinne Redfern of the Guardian: "Sex trafficking is an enormously lucrative business. Academic Siddharth Kara advises the United Nations and the US government on slavery and has shown through his own research that sex trafficking is disproportionately lucrative compared with other forms of slavery. He estimates that sex trafficking creates half of the total profits generated globally by modern slavery, despite only accounting for 5% of all trafficking victims worldwide.... While prostitution is legal [in Bangladesh], trafficking and forced labour are not.... The Bangladesh government estimates that 100,000 women and girls are working in the country's sex industry and one study reports that less than 10% of those had entered prostitution voluntarily.... Here, a triumvirate of powerful institutions -- government, police and religion -- watch over and approve the rape, enslavement and abuse of hundreds of thousands of prepubescent girls." --s
News Lede
New York Times: "... the United States women's soccer team claimed its fourth Women's World Cup title on Sunday, beating the Netherlands, 2-0, in Lyon, France, to repeat as world champions.... Plans were already underway, team officials said, for a parade and celebration of the team's championship in New York sometime this week.... The current team sued its own federation for gender discrimination earlier this year, part of a longrunning fight for pay equity from U.S. Soccer.... That the pro-American crowd insid the Stade de Lyon on Sunday chanted 'Equal Pay!' as the game ended was no accident."