The Commentariat -- July 28, 2016
Afternoon Update:
Wanted: President of the United States. No experience required. Steve Benen: Not only aren't Republicans very concerned about Donald Trump asking Russia to spy on Hillary Clinton, they're not concerned about his appalling lack of experience. In fact, Marco Rubio " ma[de] the case yesterday that Trump will become more competent eventually. BuzzFeed reported: 'I view the Senate as a place that can always act as a check and balance on whoever the next president is,' Rubio said on WGN radio on Wednesday." Akhilleus: So does it worry any Republican, voter or pol or pundit or apparatchik, that they are all lining up to give a big thumbs up to a guy most of them realize couldn't start a car with the keys in the ignition?
Shame, Shame, Shame...oh, wait a minute. Maybe not. AP: "Republicans from North Carolina have apologized to Democratic vice presidential nominee Tim Kaine for mistakenly critiquing him for wearing a foreign flag during his acceptance speech. The state GOP sent out a tweet Wednesday night saying it was 'shameful' for Kaine to wear a Honduras flag during his speech at the Democratic National Convention.... Kaine's pin was actually the symbol for families with a member serving in the military. Kaine's son, a Marine, is currently deployed." Akhilleus: Honduran flag, Marine symbol, eh, it's all the same.
Aw c'mon, cantcha take a joke? Stephen Collinson of CNN: "strong>Donald Trump said Thursday that he was being sarcastic when he appeared to suggest that Russia should use espionage to find Hillary Clinton's deleted emails.... [Trump] tried to dampen controversy over his apparent call Wednesday for Russia to either stage an espionage cyber hack to find Clinton's deleted emails or to publish information it had already stolen. 'Of course I'm being sarcastic,' Trump said in a Fox News interview that aired the day after his comments at a news conference in Florida sparked a national furor and offered ammunition for Democrats who claim he's not fit to be president." Akhilleus: Oh yeah, because Donaldo is always such a barrel of laughs. A great kidder, that guy. One of the many reprehensible things about Trump is how cowardly he is. Everyone knows that he was in no way kidding when he begged Russia to spy on his opponent with an eye toward hurting her chances in a presidential election. It was only after the shit storm turned his spray tan dark brown that he decided to lie about it and hope he could get away with yet another bulshit excuse. If you're gonna play the big tough guy, it doesn't help your image to keep pretending your tough talk was just a joke. Craven, yellow-bellied jellyfish.
*****
Democratic Convention & Presidential Race
Jonathan Martin & Patrick Healy of the New York Times: "President Obama delivered a stirring valedictory address at the Democratic convention Wednesday night, hailing Hillary Clinton as his rightful political heir and the party's best hope to protect democracy from 'homegrown demagogues' like the Republican Donald J. Trump." -- CW ...
I can say with confidence there has never been a man or a woman more qualified than Hillary Clinton to serve as President of the United States of America. No one. Not me, not Bill, not anybody. -- Barack Obama (CW Note: the second two sentences were not in the prepared transcript.)
... Abby Phillip & Ed O'Keefe of the Washington Post: President "Obama's address was both a moment of reflection on his presidency, and also a one where he would project forward to the future.... Obama's full throated endorsement is a key part of Clinton's case to the American people.... His address was also a forceful rejection of the worldview presented by ... Donald Trump.... As he concluded his speech, thanking the crowd for 'an incredible journey,' Obama was joined by the person he said he was 'ready to pass the baton' to. The crowd erupted with rapturous applause as Obama and Clinton embraced onstage." -- CW ...
... CW: I swear, every time Barack Obama delivers a major speech, I think he can't make a better one. Then he does:
... Brian Beutler: President Obama's "purpose Wednesday night in Philadelphia was just as much to make the case for democracy itself so that an authoritarian and fascist like Donald Trump is not the coda to his presidency.... The election, he warned, 'is not just a choice between policies or parties, left and right, [but] whether we stay true to this experiment in self-government.'" -- CW ...
... Jonathan Chait: "Obama argues that Trump isn't American enough to be president." CW: Somewhat tangential to Chait's whole point, this graf struck me: "... the president reminded his audience of how deep his own roots in this country -- and its value system -- actually go. If Trump wins the presidency, it will be because he convinced a large number of hardworking white people in small-town America that he is their voice. But in Philadelphia, the first black president argued that he -- not Trump -- is the true inheritor of such 'salt-of-the-earth' folks' collective wisdom." -- CW ...
... ** John Cassidy of the New Yorker makes the same point, that President Obama portrayed Donald Trump as "un-American." "Trump hasn't just insulted Obama personally: Trump's entire candidacy represents an affront to everything that Obama stands for and got elected on -- hope, inclusiveness, reason, and faith in a democratic political system (even if that system is frustratingly deadlocked)." -- CW ...
... CW: The Birther v. the Brahmin. CW: On his mother's side, Trump is a first-generation "natural-born" American; on his father's side, he's a second. Barack Obama, on the other hand, had American ancestors back through colonial times. One ancestor, for instance, was born in New Jersey in 1640. So again, we can explain Trump's birtherism as a product of his own perceived "deficiency": Barack Obama's family has been American since generations before the country's founding, while the Drumpfs are recent immigrants. Drumpf overcompensates for his ancestor-envy by falsely claiming an opponent is not as "American" as he is. ...
... Ben Mathis-Lilly of Slate: Conservative pundits are shocked they loved Obama's speech. With examples. -- CW
"Be-leeeeve Me!" Ed Kilgore: "... if [Tim] Kaine wanted to prove he wasn't too nice to play the attack dog when called upon, he passed the test.... What Kaine's wild outburst of humor and venom showed more than anything is that the campaign he has joined believes that the competition to show which damaged presidential candidate is least dishonest and untrustworthy could be the ballgame":
Gail Collins: Michael "Bloomberg is not, normally, a particularly good public speaker. But he was definitely on a roll Wednesday night. He laced into Trump's 'well-documented record of bankruptcies and thousands of lawsuits and angry stockholders and contractors who feel cheated and disillusioned customers who feel they've been ripped off.'... The convention scrutinizers were presumably able to live with Bloomberg's suggestion that Democrats might be too tough on the private sector in return for having one of the wealthiest guys in the world announce that 'the richest thing about Donald Trump is his hypocrisy.'" -- CW ...
... Conservative Reihan Salam of Slate: "Republicans have built a coalition that is a far better fit for culturally conservative working-class whites than it is for the Bloombourgeoisie. If Donald Trump is any indication of where the GOP is heading, that trend will continue in the years to come." -- CW ...
... CW: Lyndon Johnson was overly optimistic when he said passage of the Civil Rights Act meant Democrats "had lost the South for a generation." But now it looks as if Republicans could end up representing only the South & some pockets of paleoconservatism in northern & western states. ...
No major party, no major party nominee in the history of this nation has ever known less or has been less prepared to deal with our national security. We cannot elect a man who exploits our fears of ISIS and other terrorists, who has no plan whatsoever to make us safer. A man who embraces the tactics of our enemies, torture, religious intolerance. You all know, all the Republicans know. -- Joe Biden ...
... Michael Crowley of Politico: "With Democrats sensing that Donald Trump is newly vulnerable on national security grounds after startling statements about Russia and NATO, Wednesday night's convention speakers blasted Trump’s fitness to be commander in chief.... 'We cannot afford an erratic finger on our nuclear weapons,' [former Secretary of Defense & CIA Director Leon] Panetta said. 'This is no time to gamble with America's national security.' Panetta followed a video presentation which a featured a montage of retired military officials and conservative foreign policy analysts -- from former Defense Secretary Robert Gates, a Republican, to Fox News pundit Charles Krauthammer — labeling Trump as 'unmoored' and 'unfit' to lead the military." -- CW
Eric Levitz of New York: "Last month, Christine Leinonen lost her only son in the massacre at the Pulse Nightclub in Orlando. On Wednesday night, Leinonen addressed the Democratic National Committee.... She shared a bill with many experienced orators, including Connecticut Senator Chris Murphy, but none spoke with more eloquence and authority than this former Michigan state trooper." Includes video. -- CW ...
... New York Times reporters track highlights of the convention. The Washington Post's liveblog is here. ...
Nick Gass of Politico: Jane Sanders tells Wolf Blizter she doesn't understand why her husband's supporters aren't backing Hillary Clinton. She said she & Bernie would be campaigning "aggressively" for Hillary. -- CW
Jim Rutenberg of the New York Times: "Hillary Clinton has so far been putting on a better television show in Philadelphia than Donald J. Trump did in Cleveland. Expectations had it the other way around. Mr. Trump is the bona fide television sensation, a former maestro of a hit reality series, and he had promised to bring some 'showbiz' to the proceedings. Yet it's Mrs. Clinton who has had the celebrities and musical acts that 'Tonight Show' bookers' dreams are made of.... And at least for the first two nights, it's Mrs. Clinton who has had the bigger ratings, by several million people." -- CW
Jenna Portnoy & Dave Weigel of the Washington Post: "Gov. Terry McAuliffe fueled new distrust of Hillary Clinton among liberal Democrats this week with a declaration that the presidential nominee was likely to reverse her position on the Trans-Pacific Partnership after the election. The Clinton campaign swiftly rejected the idea that she would waver on TPP and called her longtime friend and chairman of her 2008 campaign 'flat wrong.'" CW: Thanks, Terry!...
... Jonathan Easley of the Hill: "Hillary Clinton's campaign is furiously pushing back against a close ally's claims that the Democratic nominee will reverse her position on the Trans-Pacific Partnership if elected president. Virginia Gov. Terry McAuliffe, a longtime friend and surrogate for the Clintons, has been saying in interviews over the last 24 hours that Clinton would support passage of the Obama administration's international trade deal or seek to renegotiate it if elected president. Clinton campaign chairman John Podesta swatted down McAuliffe's claim on Wednesday. 'I can be definitive -- she is against it before the election and after the election,' Podesta told reporters. 'She is not interested in renegotiating the TPP,' he added." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Steve M. on sexuality in the presidential race. CW: For the record, I think Steve and Rebecca Traister, whom Steve cites, have it right, & Rachel Maddow's criticism of Bill Clinton's speech was off. ...
... CW: Thought I linked Traister's take on Bill Clinton's speech yesterday, but I didn't. Here's the key takeaway, apropos of Steve M.'s post: "It was a risk -- a big risk -- for an epically unfaithful man ... to begin his speech with the sentence, 'In the spring of 1971, I met a girl.' But he went for it, with a self-aware grin that suggested he knew what he was doing: challenging the perception of his wife as sexless and his marriage as an empty sham based only on a shared will to power, by laying out a picture of a flesh-and-blood woman for whom he fell hard, more than 40 years ago. He was doing it, in part, by making the joke about his horn-dog impulses, and reminding people that he had once trained them on Hillary." -- CW ...
... Patrick Healy of the New York Times has more on the "controversy" of Bill Clinton's depicting Hillary as, you know, a woman. -- CW
Ben Jacobs of the Guardian: "Donald Trump struck his most stridently isolationist notes yet on Wednesday, following up a day of controversy over his call for Russia to hack into and release Hillary Clinton's deleted emails with an assertion that Nato's principle that an attack on one is an attack on all should be conditional on every member country paying 'their fair share'. 'I want to keep Nato, but I want them to pay,' Trump told a rally in Scranton, Pennsylvania. 'I don't want to be taken advantage of ... We're protecting countries that most of the people in this room have never even heard of and we end up in world war three ... Give me a break.'... The remarks in Scranton came just hours after Trump said he would look into legally recognizing Russia's occupation of Crimea...." -- CW ...
... Unhinged U.S. Presidential Candidate Urges Russia to Breach U.S. Security. Jose DelReal of the Washington Post: "... Donald Trump on Wednesday said he hoped that Russia would hack into Hillary Clinton's email server to find 'missing' messages and release them to the public. 'Russia, if you're listening I hope you're able to find the 30,000 emails that are missing. I think you will probably be rewarded mightily by our press,' Trump said during a press conference at his Doral resort in South Florida on Wednesday. 'They probably have them. I'd like to have them release. It gives me no pause, if they have them, they have them,' Trump added later when asked if his comments were inappropriate. 'If Russia or China or any other country has those emails, I mean to be honest with you, I'd love to see them.'... [Trump] sought ... to distance himself from allegations that the Russian government hacked into the Democratic National Committee to benefit his campaign.... 'It is so farfetched. It's so ridiculous. Honestly I wish I had that power. I'd love to have that power but Russia has no respect for our country,' Trump said." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Timothy Lee of Vox: The thing is, if Trump gets elected president, he probably will have the power to hack into the private communications of his political opponents. And that's terrifying.... Trump has repeatedly signaled a willingness to use the powers of the presidency to retaliate against critics and political opponents." ...
... CW: This was my first thought, too, when I read Trump's "wish." The things Trump says publicly make Nixon's Watergate-related shenanigans look quaint. What Trump would do behind the scenes is, as Lee writes, terrifying. Jokers like Mitch McConnell obviously are kidding themselves -- and us -- when they claim the Congress, the Pentagon & other governmental agencies would keep Trump in check. Nixon used loons, losers & bunglers like the Watergate burglars & the "plumbers" to carry out his dirty tricks. If American institutions defy Trump, he will turn to sophisticated foreign operators to do his dirty work.
... Ashley Parker of the New York Times: "Donald J. Trump said Wednesday that he hoped Russia had hacked Hillary Clinton's email, essentially sanctioning a foreign power's cyberspying of a secretary of state's correspondence.... Mr. Trump's call was an extraordinary moment at a time when Russia is being accused of meddling in the U.S. presidential election.... At the news conference..., [Trump] refused to unequivocally call on Vladimir V. Putin ... to not meddle in the United States' presidential election. 'I'm not going to tell Putin what to do,' Mr. Trump said. 'Why should I tell Putin what to do?'" -- CW (Also linked yesterday.) ...
... Jen Kirby of New York provides a terrific synopsis of Trump's presser. CW: The man is either insane or he is doing everything he can to get out of the race. In either case, it's time to take him away, away. ...
... Looks Like mike pence didn't get the memo. Reuters: "... Mike Pence on Wednesday vowed there would be 'serious consequences' if the FBI determines Russia is behind recent hacking attempt and is meddling in the Nov. 8 U.S. presidential election." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... AND Paul Ryan was never in the loop. Esme Cribb of TPM: "The top spokesperson for House Speaker Paul Ryan (R-WI) had strong words in response to Donald Trump's call for Russian hackers to 'find' and release the deleted emails from Hillary Clinton's private server. 'Russia is a global menace led by a devious thug,' Ryan spokesman Brendan Buck told The Guardian. 'Putin should stay out of this election.'" -- CW (Also linked yesterday.) ...
... Update. Somebody in Trump's campaign pulled him down off the wall. Nick Gass: "Donald Trump says he was 'being sarcastic' when he suggested Wednesday that Russia should find Hillary Clinton's missing emails." CW: I don't believe him. As Jose DelReal reported yesterday, Trump several times emphatically repeated his call for foreign hackers to release Clinton's private e-mails. This wasn't a lapse; it's what he still thinks is acceptable. ...
... Lisa Hagen of the Hill: "Donald Trump said Wednesday he doesn't know Russian President Vladimir Putin, contradicting a claim he made last year that he knows the leader 'very well.' 'I never met Putin. I don't know who Putin is,' the GOP nominee said at a press conference.... 'He said one nice thing about me. He said I'm a genius,' Trump continued. 'I said thank you very much to the newspaper and that was the end of it. I never met Putin.'" -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Aaron Blake of the Washington Post: "... Trump actually said something else at his bizarre, fact-challenged news conference Wednesday that could bring a smile to Russian President Vladimir Putin's face. Here's the exchange..: 'QUESTION: I would like to know if you became president, would you recognize (inaudible) Crimea as Russian territory? And also if the U.S. would lift sanctions that are (inaudible)? TRUMP: We'll be looking at that. Yeah, we'll be looking.'... Recognizing Crimea as Russian territory is not something that basically anybody inside the American foreign policy mainstream is 'looking at.'... The official position of the U.S. government is that the Russian annexation of Crimea is illegal and dangerous.... And not only that, but a top Trump foreign policy adviser has previously said ... that Russian business interests have expressed excitement to him about the prospect of a President Trump easing sanctions." -- CW ...
... Louis Nelson of Politico: "President Barack Obama 'has been the most ignorant president in our history,'... Donald Trump said on Wednesday." CW: As we know by now, Trump tries to obscure his own deficiencies by accusing his rivals of having his own shortcomings. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... As if to prove my point ...
... Politico: "Donald Trump mixed up Hillary Clinton's running mate, Virginia Sen. Tim Kaine, with the former governor of New Jersey during a news conference on Wednesday. 'Her running mate Tim Kaine, who by the way did a terrible job in New Jersey -- first act he did in New Jersey was ask for a $4 billion tax increase and he was not very popular in New Jersey and he still isn't,' Trump said. Corrected by reporters, who suggested he might be confusing Kaine with Thomas Kean, a Republican who governed New Jersey from 1982 to 1990, Trump clarified. 'What? I mean Virginia.' The New Jersey tax increase that Trump may or may not been talking about came not under Kean, a Republican, but his successor Jim Florio, a Democrat." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ...
... Hadas Gold of Politico: "Donald Trump once again targeted NBC News correspondent Katy Tur during a Wednesday news conference, telling the reporter to 'be quiet.'... As Tur asked another question a few minutes later, mentioning Trump's poll numbers, Trump once again mocked her.... This is far from the first time Trump has picked on Tur." -- CW (Also linked yesterday.) ...
... Philip Bump of the Washington Post "decided to simply 'post the full transcript and annotate ... [Trump's] misrepresentations and falsehoods." ...
... Nahal Toosi & Seung Min Kim of Politico: "Donald Trump's call on Russia to hack Hillary Clinton's emails has shocked, flabbergasted and appalled lawmakers and national security experts across the political spectrum, with one ... William Inboden, who served on the NSC during the George W. Bush administration ... saying it was 'tantamount to treason.'" -- CW ...
... Ezra Klein: "This isn't normal behavior from a major American politician.... After he picked Mike Pence, empowered campaign chair Paul Manafort, and gave a structured convention speech, there looked to be a chance that Trump was unveiling a new, more sober persona for the general election. But he can't do it. He can't suppress his own mania for even a week.... Donald Trump, of late, has been acting pretty crazy." -- CW ...
... Jonathan Chait: "This is Trump's response to the accusation that he is unduly close to a hostile foreign power: to ask its spies to break American law in order to help him win.... When he's openly calling on them to carry out espionage on your behalf, it's not even a matter of speculation -- it's just simple fact."
Jesse Byrnes of the Hill: "A top aide to Donald Trump said Wednesday that the Republican presidential nominee 'will not be releasing' his taxes.' 'Mr. Trump has said that his taxes are under audit and he will not be releasing them,' Trump campaign chief Paul Manafort told 'CBS This Morning.'" -- CW
Annals of "Journalism," Ctd. Daniel Victor of the New York Times: "Addressing Michelle Obama's remarks about slaves having built the White House, Bill O'Reilly said Tuesday on his Fox News program that those slaves were 'well fed and had decent lodgings provided by the government.' His comments drew swift rebukes online. He fired back on his Wednesday program..., [and] attributed the criticism to 'smear merchants'...." As he characterized his comments as '... fact. Not a justification, not a defense of slavery.'... Jesse Holland..., who wrote [a book about slave in the White House]..., said ... there's no historical evidence either way on the question of how well fed the slaves were, he said. Many of the slaves lived in a structure described as a barn, Mr. Holland said." -- CW
Other News & Views
Eric Schmitt of the New York Times: "The United States is poring over a vast trove of new intelligence about Islamic State fighters who have flowed into Syria and Iraq and some who then returned to their home countries, information that American officials say could help fight militants on the battlefield and prevent potential plotters from slipping into Europe." -- CW
Beyond the Beltway
Kevin Rector & Justin Fenton of the Baltimore Sun: "Prosecutors dropped all remaining charges against three Baltimore police officers accused in the arrest and death of Freddie Gray in a downtown courtroom on Wednesday morning, concluding one of the most high-profile criminal cases in Baltimore history. The startling move was an apparent acknowledgement of the unlikelihood of a conviction following the acquittals of three other officers on similar and more serious charges by Circuit Judge Barry G. Williams, who was expected to preside over the remaining trials as well." -- CW (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
Margaret Chadbourn of ABC News: "John Hinckley, Jr., the man who shot President Ronald Reagan in 1981, has been granted 'full-time convalescent leave' and will be released from St. Elizabeth's Hospital in Washington, D.C., where he has been in treatment. A federal judge granted the leave, which will begin as early as Aug. 5, according to court documents. He is permitted to reside full-time in Williamsburg, Virginia, with his mother at her home, and his monitoring conditions were set by U.S. District Judge Paul Friedman of Washington." -- CW (Also linked yesterday.)
Way Beyond
Alissa Rubin & Adam Nossiter of the New York Times: "The question troubling France on Wednesday in the wake of the attack by a teenager who aspired to go to Syria, but settled instead for cutting the throat of a priest, is whether the crime was a result of failures by the French government, and what more could have been done to prevent it.... Questions [were] immediately raised about how a perpetrator well known to the authorities was nonetheless left free to kill.... The crime was committed during a state of emergency that already gives the government added powers to constrain potential terrorists, and ... one of the perpetrators was essentially on probation and wearing an electronic bracelet at the time of the attack." -- CW