The Commentariat -- August 15, 2021
Late Morning Update:
12 noon ET: CNN has reported on-air that the American flag over the U.S. embassy in Kabul has come down. MSNBC reports that the Taliban have entered Kabul "to prevent looting" as the police have abandoned the city.
Ahmad Seir, et al., of the AP: "Afghanistan's embattled president left the country Sunday, joining his fellow citizens and foreigners in a stampede fleeing the advancing Taliban and signaling the end of a 20-year Western experiment aimed at remaking Afghanistan. The Taliban, who for hours had been on the outskirts of Kabul, announced soon after they would move further into a city gripped by panic where helicopters raced overhead throughout the day to evacuate personnel from the U.S. Embassy. Smoke rose near the compound as staff destroyed important documents. Several other Western missions also prepared to pull their people out."
Kylie Atwood & Devan Cole of CNN: "The United States is pulling out all US personnel from its embassy in Kabul over the next 72 hours, including top officials, two sources familiar with the situation told CNN on Sunday. The withdrawal of embassy personnel marks a rapid acceleration of the process that had only been announced on Thursday, and is a situation that many State Department security officials expected would have to happen given the speed with which the Taliban has gained territory in Afghanistan in recent days."
Your Tax Dollars at Work -- for the Taliban. AFP: "The United States spent billions supplying the Afghan military with the tools to defeat the Taliban, but the rapid capitulation of the armed forces means that weaponry is now fuelling the insurgents' astonishing battlefield successes. 'We provided our Afghan partners with all the tools -- let me emphasise: all the tools,' US President Joe Biden said when defending his decision to withdraw American forces and leave the fight to the locals. But Afghan defence forces have shown little appetite for that fight and, in their tens of thousands, have been laying down their arms -- only for the Taliban to immediately pick them up.... Footage of Afghan soldiers surrendering in the northern city of Kunduz shows army vehicles loaded with heavy weapons and mounted with artillery guns safely in the hands of the insurgent rank and file.... Experts say such hauls -- on top of unacknowledged support from regional allies such as Pakistan -- has given the Taliban a massive boost."
California. Vote No! Los Angeles Times Editors, reprinted in Yahoo! News: "Removing [Gov. Gavin] Newsom and replacing him with an untested and unprepared alternative who wouldn't represent the values of most Californians would be a disaster. It would doom the state to months of political and bureaucratic dysfunction and economic uncertainty. And for what purpose?... [Newsom's shortcomings] do not justify using the extraordinary power of recall to remove a legitimately elected governor in favor of someone who may only have a sliver of support from voters.... The 46 candidates vying to replace Newsom -- most of them men, most of them Republican, and most of them utterly unqualified -- offer an endless litany of grievances that are little more than objections to his liberal policies -- policies, we may add, that were clear to everyone when 62% of voters chose Newsom in the 2018 election."
The New York Times' live updates of developments in Haiti Sunday are here: "Haitians trying to evacuate the injured packed the main airport of the earthquake-devastated town of Les Cayes on Sunday, as patients overwhelmed local hospitals and officials raised the death toll to more than 700. A magnitude 7.2 earthquake shook Haiti on Saturday morning, a devastating blow to a country that is still reeling from a presidential assassination last month and that never recovered from a disastrous quake more than 11 years ago."
Amanda Coletta of the Washington Post: "Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, betting that his standing has been improved by his government's response to the coronavirus pandemic while his main opponent has failed to gain traction with voters, on Sunday called a snap federal election for Sept. 20 in a bid to regain a majority in the House of Commons. Trudeau, first elected prime minister in 2015, has led the country for the past 21 months with a minority government. Winning a majority would mean he would no longer need to rely on opposition parties to advance his agenda and stay in power."
~~~~~~~~~~
Susannah George & Bryan Pietsch of the Washington Post: "Taliban forces entered Kabul through the city's four main gates Sunday morning, according to two Afghan security officials and civilian eyewitness accounts, in a move that could trigger the collapse of the national government and signal a return to power for the Islamist group two decades after the United States invaded Afghanistan. Taliban spokesman Zabihullah Mujahid said in a statement that the group's fighters had been instructed not to push further into the city with force. The militants had made recent gains after negotiating with local leaders. 'We want to enter Kabul with peace, and talks are underway' with the government, he said. There is an agreement that there will be a transitional administration for orderly transfer of power,' said acting Interior Minister Abdul Satar Mirzakwal on Sunday. He added that security forces were being deployed across Kabul to ensure order. The Taliban's lightning quick advance to the Afghan capital came as helicopters landed at the U.S. Embassy early Sunday and armored diplomatic vehicles were seen leaving the area around the compound, the Associated Press reported. Diplomats scrambled to destroy sensitive documents, sending smoke from the embassy's roof, the AP said, citing anonymous U.S. military officials."
Missy Ryan, et al., of the Washington Post: "The lightning collapse [of the Afghan government] is rooted in misplaced assumptions -- including a failure to account for how the U.S. departure would catalyze a crisis of confidence in Afghan leaders and security forces, enabling the Taliban blitz -- from the moment [President] Biden announced the withdrawal this spring. It is equally the product of two decades of miscalculations about transforming Afghanistan and overly optimistic assessments of progress that have plagued the war from its start.... The disintegration of the hoped-for [orderly] withdrawal scenario has left the administration racing to protect U.S. diplomats and struggling to respond to criticism from Republicans and advocates alike. It has also deepened questions about how Biden will reconcile his realpolitik, including the abandonment of women and human rights defenders, with promises to restore core values to U.S. foreign policy." ~~~
~~~ Marie: Assuming this analysis is correct, there was no path for a graceful U.S. exit from Afghanistan, assuming it's not possible to remove tens of thousands of Americans, allies, and Afghan aides from the country in the dead of a single night. So Republicans can play the "shoulda, coulda, woulda" game to their heart's content, the exit Trump precipitated was destined to end in a U.S. embarrassment.
The New York Times' live updates of developments in Afghanistan Sunday are here: "The Taliban's relentless, rapid advance across Afghanistan brought them on Sunday to the outskirts of the capital, Kabul, the last major city controlled by the government.... The U.S. military, meanwhile, has arrived in force to evacuate American diplomatic and civilian staff."
** The End of the Longest War. David Sanger & Helene Cooper of the New York Times: "In the end, an Afghan force that did not believe in itself and a U.S. effort that Mr. Biden, and most Americans, no longer believed would alter the course of events combined to bring an ignoble close to America's longest war. The United States kept forces in Afghanistan far longer than the British did in the 19th century, and twice as long as the Soviets -- with roughly the same results." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
** President Biden's statement on Afghanistan. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.) ~~~
~~~ Karen DeYoung, et al., of the Washington Post: "With the Afghan capital among the few areas left to conquer, President Biden warned that any moves to threaten American personnel or interests there would be met with a 'swift and strong' U.S. military response from thousands of American troops flooding into the city. Biden, in his first public statement since the administration on Thursday announced the deployment of 3,000 troops to aid in the evacuation of American diplomats and civilians and Afghans who have aided the U.S. government, said the force being dispatched to Kabul would grow to 5,000."
Rachel Pannett, et al., of the Washington Post: "The Taliban's blitz across Afghanistan pushed closer to Kabul on Saturday, as U.S. diplomats appealed to the militants to stop the advance or risk conflict with thousands of U.S. troops flooding into the capital to evacuate U.S. diplomats and other personnel. But in Qatar's capital, Doha, U.S. envoy Zalmay Khalilzad met with Taliban political leaders who had a message of their own: calling for an end to escalating U.S. airstrikes trying to hold the fast-moving push by Taliban forces to gain territory, occupy provincial capitals and hold key roadways. With Kabul in the Taliban crosshairs, the fate of the country's Western-allied government also hung in the balance. Afghan President Ashraf Ghani, in his first public appearance since the Taliban's stunning sweep of provincial capitals over the past week, said he was turning to the international community for help even as events appeared to be overtaking him and his administration." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
** Eyal Press in a New York Times op-ed: "Contemporary America runs on dirty work," work done -- usually by low-paid workers -- in penal & mental institutions, immigrations centers, slaughterhouses, overseas sweatshops, & drone-war facilities.... This work sustains our lifestyles and undergirds the prevailing social order, but privileged people are generally spared from having to think about it.... Though more difficult to quantify, the moral and emotional wounds that many dirty workers experience can be as debilitating as material disadvantage.... Pinning the blame for dirty work solely on the people who carry it out can be a useful way to obscure the power dynamics and the layers of complicity that perpetuate their conduct." (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
The Pandemic, Ctd.
Aya Elamroussi of CNN: "The US remains among nations with the highest rate of new Covid-19 cases, driven mostly by a surge in the South, where many states are lagging in getting people vaccinated against the coronavirus."
Sharon LaFraniere of the New York Times: "With a stockpile of at least 100 million doses at the ready, Biden administration officials are developing a plan to start offering coronavirus booster shots to some Americans as early as this fall even as researchers continue to hotly debate whether extra shots are needed, according to people familiar with the effort. The first boosters are likely to go to nursing home residents and health care workers, followed by other older people who were near the front of the line when vaccinations began late last year. Officials envision giving people the same vaccine they originally received. They have discussed starting the effort in October but have not settled on a timetable."
The New York Times' live updates of Covid-19 developments Saturday are here. (Also linked yesterday afternoon.)
California. Lexi Lonas of the Hill: "One person has been hospitalized with a stab wound after fights broke out at an anti-vaccination and anti-mask rally between demonstrators and counter-protestors in Los Angeles on Saturday.... A video of an altercation posted by television producer Alex Kimmel showed a man in camouflage punching a man in yellow shirt before he took a swing at another man with an American flag face covering. Other men can be seen pushing each other and throwing errant punches. One person can be heard in the background yelling 'unmask them all.'"
Mississippi. Nick Judin of the Mississippi Free Press: "Hours after the worst report of new COVID-19 cases in the pandemic thus far, Gov. Tate Reeves gave Mississippi a full-throated endorsement of vaccinations -- but offered inconsistent and hostile messaging on the subject of masks. 'I want to be clear,' the governor said at a press event Friday afternoon, 'I have been vaccinated. My mom's been vaccinated. My dad's been vaccinated. My grandma has been vaccinated. I believe the vaccines are safe, effective and the best tool to beat the virus.'... The governor questioned the value of masks for the vaccinated entirely Friday.... 'If you really want to virtue signal, why are you in this room? Why don't you go to your house and lock yourself up?' Reeves asked Mississippi Today's Bobby Harrison, after Harrison questioned him on his position on masking.... The governor has no training in medicine or health care; he has a bachelor's degree in economics from Millsaps College." ~~~
~~~ Ashton Pittman of the Mississippi Free Press: "An eighth-grade girl died [Saturday] morning in Raleigh, Miss., mere hours after testing positive for COVID-19. Multiple sources told the Mississippi Free Press that the student attended classes at the school most of the week, including Wednesday, before testing positive for COVID-19 at week's end.... The Raleigh student's passing came the morning after a press conference on Friday in which Gov. Tate Reeves reiterated that, unlike last year, he will not mandate masks in schools this fall.... 'If you look at those individuals under the age of 12, what you find is that it is very rare that kids under the age of 12 have anything other than the sniffles [as the result of the coronavirus],' the governor said."
North Carolina. Robert Romero, et al., of WNCT-Greenville: "NC Rep. Keith Kidwell, who serves District 79 and Beaufort County, announced on Friday that he is in the hospital after his wife was diagnosed with COVID-19. It has since been learned both have been diagnosed with the coronavirus.... Kidwell has been vocal about not wearing a mask. He is the chief sponsor of House Bill 572, which would not allow Gov. Roy Cooper to issue an executive order to require vaccination. The bill passed the NC House in May but has not moved further in the NC Senate." MB: Kidwell looks just like a GOP poohbah, with all of the quirks & biases that go with the stereotype.
Washington, D.C. Anne Tate of the Washingtonian: "Unvaccinated DC residents can now get the Covid-19 vaccine brought to them at home. Previously, only homebound residents qualified for the program, but it's now open to anyone. Both the vaccine and the delivery service are free." The article tells you what-all is involved & how you can make an appointment.
News Lede
New York Times: "Tropical Storm Grace formed in the eastern Caribbean on Saturday morning, generating tropical storm warnings for Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands and other parts of the Caribbean, and is now expected to bring heavy rain and potential mudslides to Haiti, which was hit by a 7.2-magnitude earthquake on Saturday, the National Hurricane Center said."