The Commentariat -- Dec. 1, 2013

The first Obama administration was focused too much on saving the banks and Wall Street. There's going to be a big populist push on whoever's running for office to espouse these kinds of progressive policies. -- Sen. Tom Harkin (D-Iowa)

The Washington Post discovers Elizabeth Warren. AND Bernie Sanders says he'll run for president if no other progressives do. ...

... Steve Coll of the New Yorker: "The grassroots left, which seemed scattered and demoralized after the Occupy movement fizzled, has revived itself this year -- with help from union money and professional canvassers -- by rallying voters around the argument that anyone who works full time ought not to be at risk of poverty.... The movement has momentum because most Americans believe that the federal minimum wage -- seven dollars and twenty-five cents an hour, the same as it was in 2009 -- is too low. A family of four dependent on a single earner at that level -- making fifteen thousand dollars a year -- is living far below the federal poverty line."

Lena Sun of the Washington Post: "Administration officials announced Sunday that they had met their Saturday deadline for improving HealthCare.gov after completing a series of hardware upgrades and software fixes to the troubled Web site. A progress report released Sunday morning by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services said: 'While we strive to innovate and improve our outreach and systems for reaching consumers, we believe we have met the goal of having a system that will work smoothly for the vast majority of users.'" ...

... Sheryl Gay Stolberg & Michael Shear of the New York Times: "The story of how the administration confronted one of the most perilous moments in Mr. Obama's presidency -- drawn from documents and from interviews with dozens of administration officials, lawmakers, insurance executives and tech experts working inside the HealthCare.gov 'war room' -- reveals an insular White House that did not initially appreciate the magnitude of its self-inflicted wounds, and sought help from trusted insiders as it scrambled to protect Mr. Obama's image." ...

... Kathleen Sebelius, in a Huffington Post column, shares "some consumer friendly tips for individuals looking for quality affordable health insurance." ...

... Tim Egan: "The Republican Party started a failure campaign earlier this year.... With the disastrous rollout of the federal exchange, Republicans now smell blood. A recent memo outlined a far-reaching, multilevel assault on the Affordable Care Act. Horror stories -- people losing their lousy health insurance -- will be highlighted, and computer snafus celebrated.... It's hard to remember a time when a major political party and its media arm were so actively rooting for fellow Americans to lose."

Anthony Faiola of the Washington Post: "... the Guardian is being called to account by British authorities for jeopardizing national security [by publishing classified documents which Edward Snowden leaked to the paper]. The Guardian's top editor, Alan Rusbridger, is being forced to appear before a parliamentary committee on Tuesday to explain the news outlet's actions. The move comes after British officials ordered the destruction of hard drives at the paper's London headquarters, even as top ministers have taken to the airwaves to denounce the outlet. Scotland Yard has also suggested it may be investigating the paper for possible breaches of British law."

Henry Blodget, in Slate: No, rich people don't create jobs. Consumers with money to spend create jobs.

CW: This weekend, the Washington Post ran a column by Dana Milbank in which Milbank argues that restoring the draft & forcing all Americans to serve would make for better government because, um, ex-soldiers make better lawmakers. I didn't link the column because I thought it was stupid. Milbank notes that we currently have the lowest percentage of veterans in Congress since World War II & we haven't had a war vet president since Pappy Bush. Steve M. of NMMNB notes a little flaw in Milbank's theory: "Was Milbank nodding off in Philosophy 101 when his professor explained what a post hoc fallacy is? The number of people using rotary telephones is also at the lowest point in living memory -- and the condition of Congress is about as likely to be influenced by that societal change as it is to be influenced by the decline in military service among members of Congress.... What I think is the real reason we have a terrible government: the fact that heartland whites from outer-ring suburbia and exurbia have been encouraged for decades not to believe that other Americans are really their fellow citizens."

Frank Norris of the New York Times: "... the banking industry, which seems to have no desire to stand behind its loans, as well as consumer advocates and the housing industry" are all lobbying to gut the provisions of Dodd-Frank that force mortgage lenders to have "skin in the game"; i.e., to shoulder some of the risk for loans. One of the major causes of the financial meltdown of 2008 was, after all, the fact that mortgage lenders didn't seem to care if the mortgages they sold were ever paid off.

Jack Healy of the New York Times: "Crime has soared [in Montana & North Dakota oil country] as thousands of workers and rivers of cash have flowed into towns, straining police departments and shattering residents' sense of safety.... Amid all of that new money, reports of assault and theft have doubled or even tripled, and the police say they are rushing from call to call, grappling with everything from bar brawls and shoplifting to kidnappings and attempted murders. Traffic stops for drunken or reckless driving have skyrocketed; local jails are spilling over with drug suspects."

Ah, Capitalism. Ross Douthat figures out how to integrate Pope Francis's exhortation into his own conservative framework. CW: Douthat's effort necessarily includes aspects that stretch logic to the breaking point, but Francis does manage to snap Douthat out of any Ayn-Randian fantasies. It will be fun/infuriating to watch Paul Ryan integrate Francis's exhortation into the Ryan Plan for the Poor.

Fresco in the catacomb of Priscilla in Rome. Reuters photo.Philip Pullella of Reuters: "Proponents of a female priesthood say frescoes in the newly restored Catacombs of Priscilla prove there were women priests in early Christianity. The Vatican says such assertions are sensationalist 'fairy tales'. The catacombs, on Rome's Via Salaria, have been fully reopened after a five-year project that included laser technology to clean some of the ancient frescoes and a new museum to house restored marble fragments of sarcophagi." ...

... More News about Ladies & the Spirit of Christmas. Karen Araisa of NBC Philiadelphia: "One woman apparently used a stun gun on another after an all-out brawl inside of the Franklin Mills Mall in Northeast Philadelphia." With video of these lovely ladies duking it out.

News Ledes

Karzai Still Crazy. Reuters: "Afghan President Hamid Karzai accused his U.S. ally on Sunday of withholding military supplies to press him to sign a bilateral security deal that will shape the U.S. military presence after most foreign troops leave in 2014."

Los Angeles Times: "In hopes of ensuring that the next man on the moon is Chinese, Beijing launched a rocket carrying a buggy-like vehicle that is expected to roam and explore the moon's surface for three months."

New York Times: "More than 100,000 people took to the streets of Kiev on Sunday, and thousands more rallied in other cities across Ukraine, to demand the resignation of President Viktor F. Yanukovich, the largest outpouring of fury so far over his refusal to sign far-reaching political and trade accords with the European Union."

New York Times: "At least four people were killed after a Metro-North Railroad train derailed Sunday morning in the Bronx along the Hudson River, officials said. A total of 67 people were injured -- 11 critically...."

The Commentariat -- Nov. 30, 2013

Sharon LaFraniere, et al., of the New York Times: "As the Obama administration's weekend deadline for a smoothly functioning online marketplace for health insurance arrives, more than a month of frantic repair work is paying off with fewer crashes and error messages and speedier loading of pages, according to government officials, groups that help people enroll and experts involved in the project. But specialists said weeks of additional work lie ahead, including a major reconfiguration of the computer hardware, if the $630 million site, Healthcare.gov, is to accommodate the expected flood of people seeking to buy health insurance." ...

... Juliet Eilperin & Amy Goldstein of the Washington Post: "Administration officials are preparing to announce Sunday that they have met their Saturday deadline for improving HealthCare.gov, according to government officials, in part by expanding the site's capacity so that it can handle 50,000 users at once. But they have yet to meet all their internal goals for repairing the federal health-care site, and it will not become clear how many consumers it can accommodate until more people try to use it."

Jeremy Peters of the New York Times: A November 1 ruling by the D.C. circuit, comparing "contraception to 'a grave moral wrong' and sid[ing] with businesses that refused to provide it in health care coverage" was the straw that broke the donkey's back & caused Senate Democrats to revise the filibuster. "All the more glaring, Democrats believed, was that they had allowed confirmation of the conservative judges now ruling in the abortion cases. Republicans were blocking any more appointments to the court of appeals in Washington, which issued the contraception decision."

The final tipping point was this month, when the minority launched a campaign to block President Obama from appointing anyone, regardless of experience and character, to three vacancies on the D.C. circuit court, This constituted an attack on the balance and integrity of our courts. -- Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Oregon)

Herein lies the reason you vote for Democrats, even when they aren't the best candidates. -- Constant Weader

CW: AND some Democrats do have a heart. Lucy McCalmont of Politico: "On Black Friday, one of the busiest shopping days on the year, a group of seven Democratic lawmakers came out in support of Wal-Mart employees who are protesting the company to improve labor standards. 'Across the country, there are countless Wal-Mart workers who are paid poverty wages, cannot get enough hours, and have erratic work schedules that make it difficult to survive,' said the statement, issued by Sens. Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio) and Ed Markey (D-Mass) and Reps. Jan Schakowsky (D-Ill), Judy Chu (D-Calif.), William Lacy Clay (D-Mo.), Gwen Moore (D-Wis.), and Jim McDermott (D-Wash.)." ...

... Allison Kilkenny of the Nation: "Walmart employees and supporters protested in cities all across the country on Black Friday in opposition to Walmart's low wages and poor treatment of workers. In some cases, protesters volunteered to engage in acts of civil disobedience and were arrested by police." ...

... Walton Abbey. Sadhbh Walshe in the Guardian: "Whatever it is that we find so charming about ["Downton Abbey"]..., we should try to keep in mind that the rampant inequality it celebrates is not something we should be hankering after. America has its own real-life upstairs/downstairs thing going on at the moment, best embodied by the Walton clan, who own the lion's share of Walmart Stores, Inc." CW: Actually, I think the series makes pretty clear that no matter how stuffy Lord Grantham & Lady Mary are, the "rampant inequality" is coming to an end & a number of the characters, even among the swells, celebrate that. More on WalMart below.

Ellen Nakashima of the Washington Post: "Key senior administration officials have advocated splitting the leadership of the nation's largest spy agency from that of the military's cyberwarfare command.... At a White House meeting of senior national security officials last week, Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper Jr. said he was in favor of ending the current policy of having one official in charge of both the National Security Agency and U.S. Cyber Command.... Also, officials appear inclined to install a civilian as director of the NSA for the first time in the agency's 61-year history."

Unfriendly Skies. Peter Baker & Jane Perlez of the New York Times: "On the same day that China scrambled fighter jets to enforce its newly declared air defense zone, the Obama administration decided to advise American commercial airlines to comply with China's demands to be notified in advance of flights through the area."

Christopher Drew & Danielle Ivory of the New York Times: "A scandal involving the Navy's ship supply network, until now focused on the Pacific Fleet, has spread to another contractor working for Navy ships in the waters off the Middle East, Africa and South America. The Justice Department is looking into allegations that the company, Inchcape Shipping Services, with the help of subcontractors, overcharged the Navy by millions of dollars.... Inchcape, which is owned by the government of Dubai, was suspended this week from winning new federal contracts...."

Kevin Liptak of CNN: "President Obama paid a visit Friday to a group of activists who have been fasting for weeks in the hopes of pressuring Congress to pass new immigration laws. The President and his wife, First Lady Michelle Obama, visited the group on the National Mall to lend support for the cause." With video.

MEANWHILE, Josh Romney, a son of the First Runner-up in the 2012 Presidential Beauty Content makes sure everybody knows he's a hero. There could be a President Romney yet, people. Lucy McCalmont reports.

Abby Phillip of ABC News: "The first family might choose to stay in Washington, D.C., after President Obama leaves office in 2016, the president and first lady Michelle Obama told ABC News' Barbara Walters in an interview. By then, their eldest daughter Malia will be in college, and their youngest daughter Sasha will still be in high school as a sophomore. 'So we've gotta -- you know we gotta make sure that she's doing well ... until she goes off to college,' the president said. 'Sasha will have a big say in where we are.'"

Jonathan Zimmerman argues in the Washington Post against the presidential term limit.

Michelle, Malia & Sasha Obama accept the White House Christimas tree:

... Americans Go to WalMart to Honor the Baby Jesus

Jay Hart of Yahoo! News: "By midnight [Friday morning], #WalmartFights was trending on Twitter. Attached were pictures and videos and Vines of all sorts of violence and chaos and other nonsense. None of this is a surprise. It was expected, which is why police were at the ready at your local Walmart." ...

... Lacy Donohue of Gawker: "According to a Walmart press release, Thanksgiving was a day of record-breaking sales, sales that were 'bigger, better, faster, cheaper and safer than ever.'." Safer, huh? Let's examine the video evidence":

     ... A WalMart Theologian. CW: No doubt the woman who calls fellow-shoppers "motherfuckers" was thinking of the Virgin Mary & the Trinity. The Gawker piece has more videos of Thanksgiving Day fights. ...

... Sometimes deadly weapons are involved. In a Virginia WalMart parking lot, one man brandishes a rifle & his adversary cuts him to the bone with a knife. The men were fighting over a parking space. Police arrested them both, who of course also missed their chance to battle it out inside the store over big-ass teevees. This is why Christians believe in heaven, where there are no WalMarts & no parking lots so no assholes threatening to kill you over a parking space. Because Jesus gives everybody a big-ass teevee. Or so I hear. ...

     ... The gun-knife incident reminded contributor James S. of this:

Right Wing World *

Jeb Bush Joins the VaticanGate Truthers. Lucy McCalmont (apparently the only Politico reporter working this weekend): Former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush claims President Obama closed the U.S.'s embassy to the Vatican. Bush is "hopeful" the move -- which didn't occur -- isn't "retaliation for Catholic organizations opposing Obamacare." The embassy didn't close; it just moved to another site for security & cost-savings reasons. CW: Even rumors of Obama administration actions are evidence of sinister motives. Besides, I'm pretty sure the reason Obama shut down the U.S. embassy to the Vatican is that he's a Muslim. ...

... Daily Caller: Leading Roman Catholic wingnuts are furious:

It's not just those who bomb churches and kill Catholics in the Middle East who are our antagonists, but it's also those who restrict our religious freedoms and want to close down our embassy to the Holy See. -- former Boston Mayor Ray Flynn, Bill Clinton's ambassador to the Vatican & an alleged Democrat (Flynn endorsed George W. Bush for president in 2000 & Republican Scott Brown for Senator in 2010)

"Revisionaries." Mariah Blake of the Washington Monthly: Crusading right-wing Christian fundamentalists continue to exert undue influence over the nation's textbooks. Besides the usual creationist, anti-climate change nonsense, their agenda includes aggrandizing Ronald Reagan, "rehabilitat[ing] Joseph McCarthy, bring[ing] global-warming denial into science class, and downplay[ing] the contributions of the civil rights movement," airbrushing out George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, the New Deal, & of course Martin Luther King, Jr., & Thurgood Marshall.

Travis Gettys of the Raw Story: "A birther preacher is pushing the conspiracy theory that Miriam Carey, who was shot to death Oct. 3 after police said she tried to ram her car into a barrier outside the White House, was the mother of President Barack Obama's illegitimate child. Rev. James David Manning, pastor of Atlah World Missionary Church who believes the president was born in Kenya, claims that Carey's family has called for a paternity test to determine whether the woman's 15-month-old daughter was fathered by the president." CW: As I have said before, there is a rational explanation for even events that on their face seem irrational. Thanks to the Rev. Manning for making sense of Carey's seemingly bizarre actions. I predict Donald Trump will launch an all-out effort to prove Manning's thesis, an effort that will end only when President Obama says, "I did not have sex with that woman."

* Where even the "moderates" are crazy, Reagan was a deity & Obama is responsible for everything bad.

News Ledes

Guardian: "The United States has moved to end the tense standoff with Afghan president Hamid Karzai over his refusal to sign a security pact between the two countries by formally apologising for a US drone strike in Helmand province that killed a toddler and injured two women. The apology was delivered in a phone call to Karzai late on Thursday by marine General Joseph Dunford, the top US and Nato commander in Afghanistan." ...

     ... Washington Post Update: "After its longest war in history, the United States is suddenly contemplating having to dismantle the bulk of its counterterrorism infrastructure in the region [of Afghanistan] and abandon Afghanistan's fledgling security forces. A wholesale withdrawal would also shut down the foreign-aid pipeline that keeps the Afghan state afloat and sharply limit any enduring U.S. diplomatic presence."

New York Times: "North Korea accused an elderly American veteran of war crimes, and released a video Saturday of him confessing to 'hostile acts' during the Korean War and while he was a tourist there last month. The veteran, Merrill Newman, 85, of Palo Alto, Calif., who has been held since Oct. 26, appeared on the video dressed in a blue American-style shirt and wearing rimless spectacles as he read excerpts from the apology from several sheets of white paper."

AFP: "EU leaders slammed Russia on Friday for meddling in its affairs after Ukraine rejected a landmark accord with the European Union designed to draw the ex-Soviet state into the Western fold. The snub by Ukraine highlighted a worsening EU-Russia tug-of-war over former Soviet satellites in eastern Europe."

Reuters: "Italian Prime Minister Enrico Letta said on Friday he would call a new confidence vote in parliament to confirm his government's majority after the withdrawal of Silvio Berlusconi's Forza Italia party from the ruling coalition."

AFP: "China and India are among countries that have dodged US sanctions by cutting back on Iranian crude, Washington said Friday as it pledged to 'aggressively' enforce such punitive measures despite a recent nuclear deal with Tehran."

The Commentariat -- Nov. 29, 2013

Amy Merrick of the New Yorker posts some myths about Black Friday. Hint: the deals aren't that great. ...

... Black Friday Is Not About You. Derek Thompson of the Atlantic: "When you hit the stores this weekend, remember that shopping is a sport, this is its Super Bowl, and retail corporations are better at playing than you." ...

... Steven Greenhouse of the New York Times: "For retail workers nationwide, who earn a median pay of about $9.60 an hour, or less than $20,000 a year, holiday shopping sprees are most often enjoyed by customers on the opposite side of the counter." ...

... What's Wrong with This Picture? From the front page of the online New York Times:

     ... One of the suggested gifts: a $60,000 traveling desk/trunk. It is quite nice. Maybe some of those McDonald's workers will buy out the trunks to take on their round-the-world cruises.

... Mike DeBonis & Reid Wilson of the Washington Post: "Efforts in Congress to raise the national minimum wage above $7.25 an hour have stalled. But numerous local governments ... driven largely by Democrats ... are forging ahead, in some cases voting to dramatically increase the pay of low-wage workers. The efforts, while supported by many unions, threaten to create a patchwork of wage rates that could mean workers in some areas will be entitled to vastly less than those working similar jobs nearby. The campaigns reach from coast to coast."

Paul Krugman: Is ObamaCare bending the cost curve as the law was intended to do? "The answer, amazingly, is yes. In fact, the slowdown in health costs has been dramatic.... And the biggest savings may be yet to come. The Independent Payment Advisory Board, a panel with the power to impose cost-saving measures (subject to Congressional overrides) if Medicare spending grows above target, hasn't yet been established, in part because of the near-certainty that any appointments to the board would be filibustered by Republicans [CW: and pundits like Mark Halperin] yelling about 'death panels.' Now that the filibuster has been reformed, the board can come into being." ...

... David Morgan of Reuters: "The Obama administration says it is on target to make its problematic health insurance website work smoothly for the 'vast majority' of users by this weekend, but some Americans who want coverage by January 1 may not be able to get it - even if they successfully navigate the portal and sign up for a plan. The problem, according to insurance industry officials and other specialists, is that the administration is behind schedule in building a computer program needed to help insurers verify the names, insurance plan choices and other details of those who sign up for health coverage under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act...." ...

... Abby Goodnough of the New York Times: Especially in states which have accepted the Medicaid expansion available under the ACA, but in other states as well, a shortage of doctors -- and of specialists in particular -- is a looming problem, largely because many doctors won't accept Medicaid patients because the program pays them such low reimbursement rates. ...

... Maeve Reston of the Los Angeles Times: "In Oregon, a state envied for its high tech, sign-ups under the new federal healthcare law have been anything but. About 400 newly hired workers in Salem are processing paper applications by the thousands for health insurance under President Obama's law....Meanwhile, at the headquarters of Cover Oregon, the agency set up by the state to run its transition under the Affordable Care Act, dozens of software engineers have fanned out at long tables on the first floor, trying to untangle the technical problems that have made Oregon the only state with a health insurance exchange that has yet to go online." ...

... Margaret Carlson of Bloomberg News: Maybe President Obama thinks he's too damned smart to dither with the "details" of ObamaCare. ...

... Josh Marshall of TPM on why the ACA will survive, no matter what. "Nothing will happen on the legislative front that Obama doesn't approve of. This is a cardinal fact.... The [insurance] carriers themselves have huge incentives to make the system work.... By early next year you will have millions of new people enrolled in Medicaid, large numbers of people who have health care covered who couldn't get it at any reasonable price before who now have coverage and you will have large numbers of people who have care that is better or cheaper and often both than it was before.... I do not think anyone will be able to claw that back.... Obamacare is good policy." ...

... Steve M. is not convinced. The right really believes in a country of "makers" and "takers," & the takers are just not full citizens in the view of the right. "... the right's efforts to dehumanize the less well off would make it a lot easier than we think just to strike millions of people from the health care rolls. I think the right-wing worldview is headed more and more in Mitt Romney's direction -- it just won't have Richie Rich as its figurehead in the future."

Greg Weston & Ryan Gallagher of CBC News, with Glenn Greenwald: "Top secret documents retrieved by U.S. whistleblower Edward Snowden show that Prime Minister Stephen Harper's government allowed the [N.S.A.] to conduct widespread surveillance in Canada during the 2010 G8 and G20 summits.... The briefing notes, stamped 'Top Secret,' show the U.S. turned its Ottawa embassy into a security command post during a six-day spying operation by the National Security Agency while U.S. President Barack Obama and 25 other foreign heads of government were on Canadian soil in June of 2010. The covert U.S. operation was no secret to Canadian authorities." ...

... Ian Austen of the New York Times: "Canadian opposition politicians expressed shock and anger on Thursday over a report that the National Security Agency conducted widespread surveillance during a summit meeting of world leaders in Canada in June 2010."

Ben Goad of the Hill: "Guns that cannot be detected by X-ray machines will no longer be banned if Congress does not renew the decades-old prohibition by Dec. 9. The 1998 Undetectable Firearms Act will sunset that day, ending the prohibition at a time when new technology has made it easier than ever before to manufacture plastic guns with 3-D printers. Gun control activists warn that a lapse would allow anyone with a few thousand dollars to build a homemade gun that would be undetectable at airports, government buildings or schools. 'That threat was little more than "science fiction," when Congress overwhelmingly backed the ban 25 years ago,' said Rep. Steve Israel (D-N.Y.), who is pressing legislation to renew the law."

Humor Break. Joshua Keating of Salon Slate writes a "report" on Thanksgiving, employing the "tropes and tone" the American press uses in describing similar events in other countries. Here's the lede paragraph: "Washington, D.C. On Wednesday morning, this normally bustling capital city became a ghost town as most of its residents embarked on the long journey to their home villages for an annual festival of family, food, and questionable historical facts. Experts say the day is vital for understanding American society and economists are increasingly taking note of its impact on the world economy."

News Ledes

TPM: "A 28-year-old alleged 'former Exalted Cyclops' of the Ku Klux Klan and his mother have both been arrested and are facing federal charges relating to a 2009 cross burning in a predominantly African-American neighborhood in Ozark, Ala."

AFP: "US-led NATO forces in Afghanistan on Friday vowed to investigate an airstrike that President Hamid Karzai said killed a two-year-old boy, as acrimony deepens over a deal to allow US troops to stay in the country after 2014." ...

... Washington Post: "The [U.S.-led] coalition acknowledged the incident on Friday, saying that a child was apparently killed during an operation targeting 'an insurgent riding a motorbike.'"

AFP: "China's state media called Friday for 'timely countermeasures without hesitation' if Japan violates the country's newly declared air zone, after Beijing sent fighter jets to patrol the area following defiant military overflights by Tokyo. Japan and South Korea both said Thursday they had disregarded the air defence identification zone (ADIZ) that Beijing declared last weekend, showing a united front after US B-52 bombers also entered the area."

AP: "An Italian court has accused ex-Premier Silvio Berlusconi and his lawyers of tampering with evidence by paying off witnesses in a trial related to his notorious 'bunga bunga' parties. Citing testimony and telephone wiretaps, the Milan court said Berlusconi convened about a dozen young women to his Milan mansion on Jan. 15, 2011 to meet with his lawyers after the women's homes were searched as part of the police investigation into the parties. From then on, the judges wrote, the women began receiving 2,500 euros each month from Berlusconi and subsequently they offered unusually identical testimony in court denying that the parties had sexual overtones."