The Commentariat -- June 4, 2013
A meritocracy is a system in which the people who are the luckiest in their health and genetic endowment; luckiest in terms of family support, encouragement, and, probably, income; luckiest in their educational and career opportunities; and luckiest in so many other ways difficult to enumerate--these are the folks who reap the largest rewards. The only way for even a putative meritocracy to hope to pass ethical muster, to be considered fair, is if those who are the luckiest in all of those respects also have the greatest responsibility to work hard, to contribute to the betterment of the world, and to share their luck with others. As the Gospel of Luke says (and I am sure my rabbi will forgive me for quoting the New Testament in a good cause): 'From everyone to whom much has been given, much will be required; and from the one to whom much has been entrusted, even more will be demanded.' -- Ben Bernanke ...
... The full text of Bernanke's Princeton commencement address is here. ...
... ** Paul Krugman on Ben Bernanke's view of meritocracy (and why he favors a top tax rate of [at least] 73 percent). CW: A must-read, which raises the question: is Ben Bernanke the only Republican socialist?...
... Oh. Kevin Drum thinks maybe Bernanke is no longer a Republican.
Juliet Eilperin of the Washington Post: "President Obama will nominate two female lawyers and an African-American federal judge to serve on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit Tuesday, according to a White House official, in an effort to help reshape the federal judiciary before leaving office. The president will nominate veteran appelate lawyer Patricia A. Millett; Georgetown University Law Center professor Cornelia T. L. Pillard; and Robert L. Wilkins, a judge on the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, according to the official.... Iowa Sen. Charles Grassley, the top Republican on the Senate Judiciary Committee, made it clear Monday Obama's nominees will face serious resistance." The New York Times story, by Michael Shear, is here. ...
... CW Update: in his nominating remarks, President Obama thoroughly smacked down Senate Republicans for obstructing his nominees & falsely accusing him of court-packing.
... ** Steve Benen: "... let's emphasize how uncontroversial this is -- there are vacancies on an important federal bench, so the president is sending qualified nominees to the Senate for consideration. Republicans are characterizing this as a scandalous power-grab, while many political reporters are describing this as Obama thumbing his nose at his political rivals. In reality, it's neither -- presidents filling judicial vacancies is basic American governance. It's Civics 101. That today's announcement is seen as somehow remarkable is evidence of just how broken the process has become." Read the whole post.
Natsha Lennard of Salon on the Bradley Manning trial.
Craig Whitlock of the Washington Post: "The nation's military chiefs have told Congress in writing that they oppose or have strong reservations about a controversial bill that would reshape military law by taking sexual-assault cases out of the hands of commanders, setting up a likely clash with lawmakers who are pushing the idea. In a rare joint appearance, the uniformed leaders of the Army, Navy, Air Force and Marine Corps, as well as the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, are scheduled to testify Tuesday before a Senate panel about what the Pentagon has described as an 'epidemic' of sex crimes in the ranks.... In an interview Monday, [Sen. Kirsten] Gillibrand [D-N.Y.] said the service chiefs' reluctance to weaken commanders' legal authority is inconsistent with their acknowledgment that most victims of sexual assault in the military do not trust their superiors to protect them or take their cases seriously."
Jeremy Peters of the New York Times: "The death of Senator Frank R. Lautenberg of New Jersey poses new complications for the White House and Democrats on Capitol Hill as they try to push their agenda through a Senate where even a single vote can derail legislation. So crucial was Mr. Lautenberg's reliably liberal vote in a Senate where his party held a 55-45 majority that Democratic leaders twice asked him in recent weeks to return to Washington to vote despite his failing health." ...
... David Halbfinger of the New York Times: "The death of Frank R. Lautenberg on Monday has left Gov. Chris Christie of New Jersey with [an] opportunity ... fraught with pitfalls, none bigger than having to choose between improving his party's fortunes in Washington and furthering his own political ambitions at home." ...
... Rachel Maddow on yesterday's news, Doonesbury, Frank Lautenberg, & Chris Christie's choice:
Adam Liptak of the New York Times: "Police may take D.N.A. samples from people arrested for serious crimes, the Supreme Court ruled on Monday in a 5-to-4 decision. 'When officers make an arrest supported by probable cause to hold for a serious offense and they bring the suspect to the station to be detained in custody,' Justice Anthony M. Kennedy wrote for the majority, 'taking and analyzing a cheek swab of the arrestee's D.N.A. is, like fingerprinting and photographing, a legitimate police booking procedure that is reasonable under the Fourth Amendment.' Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. and Justices Clarence Thomas, Stephen G. Breyer and Samuel A. Alito Jr. joined the majority opinion." ...
... The Supremes. New York Times Editors side with Nino & his backup group. CW: yes, a sexist remark, but this is an OTO (One Time Only): Scalia writes an opinion in which only Ginsberg, Sotomayor & Kagan concur.
Paul Kane of the Washington Post on the House GOP -- hey, it's in disarray, broken into warring factions! Ya gotta love sentences like this: "The cabal quickly fell apart when several Republicans, after a night of prayer, said God told them to spare the speaker." Can they govern? No, they can't. ...
... OR, as Barbara Morrill of Daily Kos puts it: "John Boehner can thank God for his job. Literally." ...
... ** Dana Milbank: "A third House committee joined the stampede to examine the IRS on Monday, and its chairman did exactly what you would expect somebody to do before launching a fair and impartial investigation: He went on Fox News Channel and implicated the White House.... [The] approach by House Republicans ... seems to follow the Lewis Carroll school of jurisprudence. Not only are they placing the sentence before the verdict, they're putting the verdict before the trial." ...
... Lauren French of Politico: "Daniel Werfel..., the man President Barack Obama tapped to fix the scandal-scarred IRS, is moving aggressively to restore some measure of credibility there." ....
... MEANWHILE, Jonathan Weisman of the New York Times: Some powerful House Republicans, e.g., Dave Camp, chairman of the House Ways & Means Committee, think they can gin up such public anger at the IRS that they can translate it into significant public support for a tax code overhaul that "would mean sacrificing or curtailing some politically popular tax breaks, like education tax credits and the mortgage interest deduction." So, anger at this ...
... will cause taxpayers to think that raising their personal tax obligations (by losing popular deductions & taking advantage of other tax breaks) is a great idea. It could work!
Jay Carney's non-response response to Darrell Issa's calling him a "paid liar":
... Sabrina Siddiqui of the Huffington Post: "Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) on Monday became the latest Republican to reject Darrell Issa's comments that White House press secretary Jay Carney is a 'paid liar' in relation to the IRS controversy. But Graham went further than his Republican colleagues, saying there's no evidence that the White House ordered the tax agency to target conservative groups.... Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.) also pushed back on Issa's 'liar' charge during a TV appearance Monday morning." ...
... MEANWHILE, Jonathan Easley of the Hill: "Sen. Ted Cruz (R-Texas) on Monday accused the Justice Department (DOJ) of targeting reporters who are critical of the Obama administration. 'We have seen a consistent pattern in this administration, and the pattern is a willingness to use the machinery of government to target those they perceive as their political enemies,' Cruz said on Fox News." ...
... Not that Tailgunner Ted doesn't have a teensy credibility problem:
The Obama Justice Department has decreased the prosecution of violent gun crimes by 30 percent. -- Sen. Ted Cruz (RTP-Texas)
Cruz is comparing Obama's performance against a high that even the Bush administration achieved only once. Moreover..., the numbers depend in part on decisions by non-federal prosecutors. In cases when federal prosecutors have decided whether to act on a referral, the data show that Obama's record actually is better than Bush's. -- Glenn Kessler
Jordy Yager of the Hill: "The Justice Department on Monday said Attorney General Eric Holder did not lie to Congress in his testimony about a national security investigation involving Fox News reporter James Rosen. Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General Peter Kadzik said DOJ never intended to prosecute Rosen, but was merely investigating him as part of a broader probe against a State Department employee believed to have leaked information to the reporter."
Andrew Rosenthal reviews the newest 2012 GOP post-mortem on "why young people don't vote Republican": when young people "were asked what words came to mind when they heard 'Republican Party,' the results 'were brutal -- closed-minded, racist, rigid, old-fashioned.'"
Ezra Klein debunks conservative Forbes columnist Avik Roy's pretend comparison-shopping for health insurance. CW: are conservatives "paid liars" or are they just pathetic ignoramuses? ...
... Okay, at the state level, legislators are just pathetic ignoramuses -- and vindictive ideologues. Klein again: A "study by the Rand corporation looks at the 14 states that have said they will opt out of the new Medicaid funds. It finds that the result will be they get $8.4 billion less in federal funding, have to spend an extra $1 billion in uncompensated care, and end up with about 3.6 million fewer insured residents. So then, the math works out like this: States rejecting the expansion will spend much more, get much, much less, and leave millions of their residents uninsured. That's a lot of self-inflicted pain to make a political point."
Frederic Frommer of the AP: " A Tampa, Fla., socialite and her husband claimed in a lawsuit Monday that the government willfully leaked false and defamatory information about them in the scandal that led to the resignation of Gen. David Petraeus as CIA director. Jill Kelley and Scott Kelley filed the lawsuit in federal court against the FBI, Pentagon and unidentified officials in the government, claiming the couple's privacy was violated."
The largest tornado ever recorded in the U.S.:
News Ledes
Russian Guards Nab Feline Smuggler! Raw Story: "The Russian prison service said Monday it had caught a cat being used as a courier to smuggle banned cell phones and chargers into a prison camp in the country's remote far north."
NBC News: "An American woman was gang-raped after accepting a ride in India, where previous sex attacks have sparked angry protests and scared off female tourists. Police said three men were being questioned Tuesday about the attack in a resort town in the foothills of the Himalayas, which is certain to focus new attention on the plight of women in India."
Reuters: "The court-martial of a soldier charged with using the WikiLeaks website for the biggest leak of classified information in U.S. history heads into a second day on Tuesday, with a cyber crime investigator the day's lead-off witness. At the start of the trial on Monday, military prosecutors said Private First Class Bradley Manning, 25, had been driven by arrogance to leak more than 700,000 documents, combat videos and other data to the anti-secrecy website, hurting U.S. interests."
New York Times: "Reporting 'new levels of brutality' in Syria's more than two-year-old conflict, United Nations investigators said on Tuesday they believed chemical weapons and thermobaric bombs were used in recent weeks and urged the international community to cut off supplies of weapons that could only result in more civilian casualties." ...
... NBC News Update: "Russian President Vladimir Putin on Tuesday defended a scheduled arms sale to Syria after the United Nations released a scathing report citing 'new levels of cruelty and brutality' by the regime of President Bashar Assad and calling for a halt to all arms transfers to the embattled country. Putin said any attempt to intervene militarily in Syria would be 'doomed to fail' and echoed the UN call for restricting arms sales -- but only to rebel forces trying to overthrow Assad."
Reuters: "China and Russia are expected to join four Western powers in voicing deep concern about Iran's atomic activities this week and pressing it to cooperate with a stalled inquiry by the U.N. nuclear agency, diplomats said on Tuesday."
AP: " A 22-year-old man died during an anti-government protest in a [Turkish] city near the border with Syria and officials gave conflicting reports on what caused his death, as hundreds of riot police backed by water cannons deployed around the prime minister's office in the capital Tuesday."