The Commentariat -- July 25, 2020
Late Morning Upate:
The New York Times' live updates of coronavirus developments Saturday are here.
Tal Axelrod of the Hill: "A longtime staffer for Rep. Vern Buchanan (R-Fla.) died from the coronavirus on Friday, the congressman announced, becoming the first known congressional aide to die from the illness. Buchanan said in a statement that he was 'devastated' by the death of Gary Tibbetts, a field representative who had been a member of the congressman's staff since 2011."
Piper McDaniel of the Oregonian: "Thousands of Portlanders amassed late Friday downtown and witnessed another tense face-off with federal officers, who used tear gas and shot impact munitions toward protesters.... At least 4,000 people poured Friday night into the city's core. It was the largest crowd since early weeks of the protests that started 58 days ago.... By 10:30 p.m., a line of veterans stood in front of the federal courthouse, preparing for the looming confrontation. A row of women tied to the Wall of Moms group also staged near the courthouse." As unwashed points out in today's Comments, both sides were using leaf blowers! to throw the gas back on the other side. ~~~
~~~ Mrs. McCrabbie: Obviously, Trump has sent troops (or whoever they are) in with the purpose of making the situation worse, not better. He wants the news to lead with his dytopian shows of force against Americans. "There's nothing more important in our country than keeping our people safe," Trump said this week. That's true; that's his main job. And he is wantonly doing the opposite.
Kim Chandler of the AP: "Civil rights icon and longtime Georgia congressman John Lewis was remembered Saturday -- in the rural Alabama county where his story began -- as a humble man who sprang from his family's farm with a vision that 'good trouble' could change the world. The morning service in the city of Troy in rural Pike County was held at Troy University, where Lewis would often playfully remind the chancellor that he was denied admission in 1957 because he was Black, and where decades later he was awarded an honorary doctorate."
~~~~~~~~~~
The Trumpidemic, Ctd.
The New York Times' live updates of coronavirus developments Friday are here: "The top U.S. public health agency issued a full-throated call to reopen schools in a package of new 'resources and tools' posted on its website Thursday night that opened with a statement that sounded more like a political speech than a scientific document, listing numerous benefits for children of being in school and downplaying the potential health risks. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention published the new guidance two weeks after President Trump criticized its earlier recommendations on school reopenings as 'very tough and expensive,' ramping up what had already been an anguished national debate over the question of how soon children should return to classrooms. As the president was criticizing the initial C.D.C. recommendations, a document from the agency surfaced that detailed the risks of reopening and the steps that districts were taking to minimize those risks." Mrs. McC: This is a straight news report that rightly fingers the CDC for putting Trump before science. It's appalling. Here's hoping some CDC scientists will cry foul. (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~
~~~ ** Laura Meckler & Rachel Weiner of the Washington Post: "The leader of the nation's premier public health agency Friday amplified President Trump's call for schools to reopen, releasing new documents edited by the White House that gloss over risks and extol the benefits of in-person learning. Still, Robert Redfield, director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, said there should be exceptions for 'hot spots,' and he used a metric that would include parts of at least 33 states. The mixed messaging was another indication of how public health officials at the CDC have been squeezed between Trump's demand for a normal school year and an out-of-control virus.... On Friday, Redfield told reporters the new documents were cleared by the White House, and officials familiar with them, speaking on the condition of anonymity..., said at least one was substantially edited by White House officials. The opening statement was written at the Department of Health and Human Services, Redfield said." Emphases added. ~~~
~~~ Mrs. Bea McCrabbie: I wonder if Redfield is aware he has turned the CDC into a second- or third-rate public health agency, an agency that until recently was considered the best in the world. Those "suburban housewives" who don't want to send their children to school are better at public health policy than the CDC.
Erika Edwards of NBC News: "The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention acknowledged Friday that a significant number of COVID-19 patients do not recover quickly, and instead experience ongoing symptoms, such as fatigue and cough. As many as a third of patients who were never sick enough to be hospitalized are not back to their usual health up to three weeks after their diagnosis, the report found."
Bill Saporito of the New York Times: "... with the president trying to distance himself from responsibility for the coronavirus crisis, and Southern governors amplifying the damage with their flawed reopening strategies, the nation's retailers have become the first line of defense against the pandemic. From the headquarters of Walmart (which includes Sam's Club) and Starbucks came the directive that all customers must wear masks. The conservative Southeasterner and liberal Northwesterner were followed by other national retailers, including Kohl's, CVS, Walgreens, Publix and Target.... [A] vacuum of responsibility ... is compelling the businesses that are expert at selling coffee, underwear and groceries to manage the pandemic across their swath of the economy. That they are doing a better job than the Trump administration is beyond pathetic." (Also linked yesterday.)
Jeff Stein & Erica Werner of the Washington Post: "With days to go before enhanced jobless benefits expire, the White House and Senate Republicans are struggling to design a way to scale back the program without overwhelming state unemployment agencies and imperiling aid to more than 20 million Americans. The hang-up has led to an abrupt delay in the introduction of the GOP's $1 trillion stimulus package. The White House and Democrats have said they want a deal by the end of the month, but Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.) suggested Friday that reaching an agreement could take several weeks, a timeline that could leave many unemployed Americans severely exposed." Emphasis added. Mrs. McC: House Democrats passed a bill extending the coronavirus stimulus package in mid-May. So that's more than two months that Republicans have left Americans twisting, twisting slowly in the wind.
Texas. Paging Sarah Palin. Chacour Coop of the Fort Worth Star-Telegram: "The situation [in Starr County] was not always as dire in this rural South Texas county.... In April, its aggressive and successful approach to beating the coronavirus was spotlighted by NBC News.... But after Gov. Greg Abbott issued orders for the reopening of the state, overriding local control and decision-making, COVID-19 cases surged.... Now Starr County is at a dangerous 'tipping point,' reporting an alarming number of new cases each day, data show. Starr County Memorial Hospital -- the county's only hospital -- is overflowing with COVID-19 patients. The county has been forced to form what is being compared to a so-called 'death panel.'... A committee will deem which COVID-19 patients are likely to die and send them home with family[.]" --s (Also linked yesterday.)
Adam Liptak of the New York Times: "The Supreme Court on Friday rejected a request from a church in Nevada to block enforcement of state restrictions on attendance at religious services. The vote was 5 to 4, with Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. joining the court's four more liberal members to form a majority. The court's brief order was unsigned and gave no reasons, which is typical when the justices act on emergency applications. The court's four more conservative members filed three dissents...."
Severely Fake News Coming to a TV Station Near You. Oliver Darcy of CNN: "Local television stations owned by the Sinclair Broadcast Group are set to air a conspiracy theory over the weekend that suggests Dr. Anthony Fauci ... was responsible for the creation of the coronavirus. The baseless conspiracy theory is set to air on stations across the country in a segment during the program 'America This Week' hosted by Eric Bolling. The show, which is posted online before it is broadcast over the weekend, is distributed to Sinclair Broadcast Group's network of local television stations, one of the largest in the country. A survey by Pew Research Group earlier this year showed that local news was a vital source of information on the coronavirus for many Americans, and more trusted than the media overall."
U.K. Peter Walker of the Guardian: "Boris Johnson has labelled people opposed to vaccinations 'nuts' as he urged the public to use an expanded flu jab programme to ease pressure on the NHS if there is a second wave of coronavirus this winter. Visiting a doctor's surgery in east London to promote the extension of free flu jabs to more people, Johnson told staff: 'There's all these anti-vaxxers now. They are nuts, they are nuts.' The prime minister's comments highlight the worries in government and among NHS leaders that a potential rise in Covid-19 infections in the coming months, coupled with a bad winter flu season, could overwhelm health services." (Also linked yesterday.)
Trump's Stormtroopers, Ctd.
Rebecca Ellis of Oregon Public Broadcasting: "U.S. District Judge Michael H. Simon has temporarily curbed the use of force by federal officers deployed to Portland, restricting their interactions with legal observers and journalists observing nightly protests against police violence. On Thursday afternoon, Simon issued a temporary restraining order on officers from the U.S. Department of Homeland Security and the U.S. Marshals Service sent to Portland to guard federal buildings. The restrictions will last for two weeks. The judge is still considering a longer-lasting injunction against federal law enforcement. The order comes as part of a lawsuit filed by the American Civil Liberties Union in Oregon, alleging law enforcement has been targeting and attacking journalists at the protests." (Also linked yesterday.) ~~~
~~~ Zoe Tillman of BuzzFeed News: "A federal judge on Friday denied a request by the Oregon attorney general's office for an order that would require federal law enforcement officers in Portland to identify themselves when making arrests and place limits on the detention and arrests of protesters. US District Judge Michael Mosman found that state Attorney General Ellen Rosenblum lacked standing to bring a lawsuit on behalf of Oregon residents because her office hadn't articulated any specific state interest beyond the constitutional rights of individuals." That is, Mosman ruled that the issue was one of "standing" and he did not address the meat of the suit.
No, They're Not Merely Protecting Federal Property. Mike Baker, et al., of the New York Times: "The aggressive incursion of federal officers into Portland has been stretching the legal limits of federal law enforcement, as agents with batons and riot gear range deep into the streets of a city whose leadership has made it clear they are not welcome.... [In one instance,] they moved down Main Street and continued up the hill, where one of the agents announced over a loudspeaker: 'This is an unlawful assembly.' By the time the security forces halted their advance, the federal courthouse they had been sent to protect was out of sight -- two blocks behind them.... The arrival of the federal agents caused the protests to swell and focused the ire of protesters onto the Mark O. Hatfield U.S. Courthouse, across from a park shaded by mature trees. What began as a movement for racial justice became a broader campaign to dislodge the federal forces from the city.... More than 40 protesters have been arrested, and dozens now face federal criminal charges."
How to Get Around a Supreme Court Decision: Ignore It. Andrew Crespo in a Washington Post opinion piece: 'The deputy director of President Trump's new federal police force does not know what the word 'arrest' means." Richard Cline claimed at a news conference this week that grabbing an individual off the street & holding him in a van was not an "arrest" and therefore not subject to Fourth Amendment probable cause requirements. Cline is wrong. According to a 1979 Supreme Court decision, "such conduct is 'indistinguishable from a traditional arrest,' which need not be accompanied by bureaucratic processes like fingerprinting, booking or a formal arrest record to count as an arrest for purposes of the Fourth Amendment."
Siobhán O'Grady of the Washington Post: "The United Nations human rights office called on U.S. security forces to limit their use of force against peaceful protesters and journalists Friday, as clashes between federal agents and demonstrators continue in Portland, Ore.... In June, the U.N. Human Rights Council decried violent police tactics and called for an inquiry into systemic racism in the United States. The resolution came after an unusual debate on 'systemic racism, police brutality and violence against peaceful protests' in the United States, requested by all 54 countries in Africa. It was adopted unanimously by the 47 countries that belong to the council.... The United States withdrew from the council in 2018." Mrs. McC: So in case you're one of those American "patriots" touting "American exceptionalism," the U.N. is here to remind you that you live in an exceptionally violent, racist nation. (Also linked yesterday.)
How to Get Around a Supreme Court Decision: Ignore It. Emily Davies of the Washington Post: "Trump administration officials said during a federal court hearing Friday that they have not 'granted nor rejected' any applications for a program designed to protect young undocumented immigrants from deportation, but rather have put them 'on hold' as the government discusses the future of the program. The virtual hearing in the U.S. District Court in Maryland was the first time the administration addressed reports that the Department of Homeland Security was not accepting applications for the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program -- despite a recent Supreme Court ruling and a federal judge's order requiring the government to resume accepting applications." Mrs. McC: It appears the Trumpies are following John Yoo's advice.
Keith Bradsher & Steven Myers of the New York Times: "As the United States lashed out against the 'new tyranny' of China, Beijing on Friday ordered the closure of the American consulate in Chengdu, a retaliatory move that threatens to drive the two powers into an even deeper divide. Beijing blamed the Trump administration for the deterioration in relations, calling its own action justified after Washington told China this week to shutter its consulate in Houston and accused its diplomats of acting illegally. A Chinese official, in turn, denounced American diplomats in Chengdu, a southwestern city, for interfering in China's affairs." (Also linked yesterday.)
Joseph Rich of Bloomberg: "On July 22, 27 distinguished District of Columbia attorneys, including former bar presidents and a former senior lawyer in the D.C. Bar disciplinary office, filed a comprehensive D.C. Bar complaint detailing the pattern of Attorney General William Barr's ethical violations over the last 16 months. The meticulously researched, 37-page complaint details how Barr has continuously violated the D.C. Bar Rules of Professional Conduct prohibiting deceitful and dishonest conduct, interference with the administration of justice, conflicts of interest and a failure to support the Constitution.... Over the last several months, up to 2,500 former Department of Justice attorneys have strenuously objected on three occasions to Barr's unethical actions and political interference in the DOJ';s law enforcement decisions. Our democracy depends on a Department of Justice that acts as an independent arbiter of equal justice, not as an arm of the president's political apparatus." --s (Also linked yesterday.)
Jeremy Stahl of Slate: "On Thursday, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez addressed retiring Republican Rep. Ted Yoho's nonapology for calling her a 'fucking bitch' earlier in the week. In 10 devastating minutes, Ocasio-Cortez shamed the Florida congressman as emblematic of a culture of misogyny and workplace harassment, tied the Republican Party to that abuse, and once again demonstrated that she is one of the most impactful voices in the House Democratic Caucus.... The speech linked her political opponents directly to crudely sexist language, attitudes, and culture, which has been turning a critical swing-voting bloc of college-educated white women away from the Republican Party in droves." (Also linked yesterday.)
Presidential Race
Annie Karni, et al., of the New York Times: "Mr. Trump ... attributed ... [his] abrupt cancellation of the Republican National Convention in Jacksonville, Fla..., to Florida's soaring rate of coronavirus cases.... But the timing ... was influenced by the imminent need for the Republican Party to book an enormous number of hotel rooms in Jacksonville and sign other costly service agreements.... There were other urgent factors involved in the decision, including the health of party officials and delegates coming from across the country, and Mr. Trump's sinking political standing, which was largely attributable to months of inattentiveness to the virus.... Jacksonville organizers were facing open resistance from local officials.... Faced with all that tumult, Mr. Trump chose instead to cancel the convention in an effort to cast himself as putting safety first. But many of Mr. Trump's top political advisers had already become convinced that the convention stood a better chance of generating embarrassing news stories -- like his recent, unsuccessful rally in Tulsa, Okla. -- than a bounce in the polls." ~~~
But I looked at my team, and I said, 'The timing for this event is not right. It's just not right with what&'s happened recently -- the flare up in Florida -- to have a big convention.... I have to protect the American people. That's what I've always done. That's what I always will do. That's what I'm about. They said, 'Sir, we can make this work very easily. We have great enthusiasm. Incredible enthusiasm. Even the polls say about the most enthusiasm they've seen. We can do this safely, and we can do it responsibly.' And I said, 'There's nothing more important in our country than keeping our people safe.... So, I told my team, 'It's time to cancel the Jacksonville, Florida, component of the GOP Convention.' -- Donald Trump, Thursday, claiming it was his idea to cancel the GOP convention (includes "sir" tell) ~~~
~~~ Michael Scherer, et al., of the Washington Post: "Advisers convinced Trump that canceling the convention could help him politically ... as he tries to pay closer attention to the coronavirus, show that he cares about the health of Americans and improve his sagging poll numbers.... The president publicly mocked former vice president Joe Biden on Twitter for planning a virtual convention 'where he doesn't have to show up.' He accused Democratic governors of denying him rally permits for political advantage and dismissed the warnings against mass gatherings."
"One of the Great Memories of All Time" Didn't Happen. I was going into a thing called the Robin Hood Foundation. I'll never forget it. It was just about the night I announced [I would run for president] or whatever. My wife looked at me, she said, 'You know, I hear people booing.'... You know, it's the first time in my life I was ever booed. -- Donald Trump, in an interview this week
This story could not possibly be true: Trump has not attended the Robin Hood Foundation gala since 2011. Also, the 2015 gala was held in May, a month before Trump announced his candidacy. Also, Trump had been booed in public on multiple occasions before 2015.... [Trump] has previously called [the incident] 'one of the great memories of all time.' --Daniel Dale of CNN
News Ledes
Weather Channel: "Hurricane Hanna's eye is now coming ashore in South Texas ahead of landfall later today, with the potential for dangerous rainfall flash flooding extending well inland into northeast Mexico. Sustained winds have increased to 85 mph according to the Hurricane Hunters. The hurricane's eyewall is moving inland south of Corpus Christi. Some areas between Corpus Christi and Brownsville will get a break in the wind and rain as Hanna's eye moves ashore. Conditions are deteriorating in much of South Texas, with increasing rainfall and wind gusts, as Hanna intensifies. A 79 mph gust has been reported in Laguna Madre, Texas."
Honolulu Star-Advertiser: "A hurricane warning has been issued for Oahu, while Hawaii County and Maui County remain under a hurricane watch.... As of 11 a.m., the storm was located about 325 miles east of Hilo and about 520 miles east-southeast of Honolulu with maximum sustained winds of 90 mph. Douglas was moving toward the west-northwest near 18 mph and expected to continue in the same motion over the next couple of days with a slight decrease in forward speed today, forecasters said. Douglas is forecasted to be near the main Hawaiian islands late tonight and move over the other islands Sunday and Monday."
New York Times: "Regis Philbin, the talk- and game-shows host who regaled America over morning coffee with Kathie Lee Gifford and Kelly Ripa for decades, and who made television history in 1999 by introducing the runaway hit 'Who Wants to Be A Millionaire,' died on Friday night. He was 88.”"