The Commentariat -- Feb. 4, 2014
Peter Beinert in the National Journal on "The End of American Exceptionalism."
David Nakamura of the Washington Post: "New momentum in Congress for a sweeping overhaul of border control laws has prompted White House allies to demand that President Obama halt deportations of millions of illegal immigrants, many of whom would be allowed to remain in the country under a legislative deal. The advocates, including the AFL-CIO and pro-immigration groups, argue that Obama should use his executive authority to expand a 2012 decision that halted deportations of young people brought to the United States illegally by their parents. The administration's aggressive approach to enforcement -- which has resulted in nearly 2 million deportations during Obama's tenure -- makes little sense at a time when Congress could be on the verge of providing legal relief, advocates say." CW: Gee, these people seem to want the President to become "increasingly lawless" (see yesterday's Commentariat).
Chuck Grassley Is Not Dead. Ben Goad of the Hill: "The top Republican on the Senate Judiciary Committee called Monday for the Obama administration to lay clear its legal case in defense of the president's plan to tackle policy goals through executive actions. Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) is asking the Justice Department to disclose by Valentine's Day all of its 'opinions, analyses and conclusions' in support of the president's authority to rely so heavily on the power of his office." CW: Holder should skip the paperwork & just send Grassley a nice Valentine's card.
Hostage Takers in Search of a Ransom Demand. Sahil Kapur of TPM: "Republicans want something in return for acting to avert a self-inflicted default on the country's debt, but they can't figure out what. House Republicans discussed the issue last Friday at their annual all-member retreat in Maryland. As of Monday afternoon, they still hadn't come up with a ransom demand in order to free the proverbial hostage ahead of a late February deadline."
John Cassidy of the New Yorker: "... if the Obama Administration is able to bring about transformative change during the remainder of its existence, John Kerry, rather than the President, is likely to be its agent. In seeking diplomatic settlements to the standoffs in Syria, Iran, and Israel-Palestine, Kerry has become, perhaps, the most important Secretary of State since Henry Kissinger."
Steve Benen: "A month ago, proponents of a bipartisan bill on new Iranian sanctions had reason to be optimistic.... This week, supporters effectively shelved the entire bill.... Obama wanted some breathing room for the international negotiations. As of yesterday, that's exactly what he's earned."
** Kerry Sheridan of AFP: "The amount of harmful pollutants released in the process of recovering oil from tar sands in western Canada is likely far higher than corporate interests say, university researchers said Monday. Actual levels of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon (PAH) emissions into the air may be two to three times higher than estimated, said the findings in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, a peer-reviewed US journal. The study raises new questions about the accuracy of environmental impact assessments on the tar sands, just days after a US State Department report said the controversial Keystone pipeline project to bring oil from Canada to Texas would have little impact on climate change or the environment." ...
... CW: This seems like a pretty big deal to me, yet the only major news organization to report it -- as far as I could tell -- was Agence France Presse.
Alexei Oreskovic of Reuters: "Facebook, Microsoft, Yahoo and Google on Monday began publishing details about the number of secret government requests for data they receive, hoping to show limited involvement in controversial surveillance efforts. The tech industry has pushed for greater transparency on government data requests, seeking to shake off concerns about their involvement in vast, surreptitious surveillance programs revealed last summer by former spy contractor Edward Snowden."
American "Justice." Timothy Williams of the New York Times: "The number of exonerations in the United States of those wrongly convicted of a crime increased to a record 87 during 2013, and of that number, nearly one in five had initially pleaded guilty to charges filed against them, according to a report to be released on Tuesday as part of a project led by two university law schools."
** Jonathan Alter in the New Yorker: Former Defense Secretary Robert "Gates was ... one of the shrewdest public servants of his generation -- which helps to explain why his many failures and missed calls have been all but air-brushed out of accounts of his career." CW: Alter's observations about Obama's relationship with the military brass are instructive.
Natalie Villacorta of Politico: The Obamas & Bidens pay tribute to Joan Mondale, who died Monday.
Melissa Eddy of the New York Times: "The Chaos Computer Club, a leading hacker organization based in Germany, filed a criminal complaint against Chancellor Angela Merkel and members of her government on Monday, accusing them of violating the law by helping intelligence agencies in the United States and Britain to spy on German citizens. The move comes days after Secretary of State John Kerry visited Berlin to try to smooth over relations that have been strained by revelations of the extent of the National Security Agency's surveillance activities in Germany."
Congressional Elections 2014
Rebecca Leber of Think Progress: "The National Republican Congressional Committee has set up a number of websites that look like they could be a Democratic candidate's campaign page, unless you read the fine print. They may even violate a Federal Election Commission regulation.... The NRCC has set up these pages for various congressional opponents, including Amanda Renteria (CA), Martha Roberston (NY), Kyrsten Sinema (AZ), Ann Kirkpatrick (AZ), Alex Sink (FL), and John Tierney (MA). Each follow a similar format; they list the candidate's name 'for Congress' to ask for donations."
Aaron Blake of the Washington Post: "Women's rights activist Sandra Fluke appears to be moving forward with a run for Congress. Fluke has filed with the California state Democratic Party to seek its endorsement in the race for retiring Rep. Henry Waxman's (D-Calif.) seat, according to the state party Web site."
Outside the Beltway
Darryl Isherwood of NJ.com: "Gov. Chris Christie confirmed tonight that his office has been subpoenaed by the U.S Attorney in the ongoing investigation into politically motivated lane closures at the George Washington Bridge. Christie revealed the subpoena during the 'Ask the Governor' program on New Jersey 101.5 radio." ...
... Geoff Mulvihill & Angela delli Santi of the AP: "Christie's office initially denied that he knew about the traffic problems until after they were over, pointing to several statements from the governor. But on TownSquare Media's 'Ask the Governor' on Monday, Christie acknowledged for the first time that he may have been aware of the closures at the time. But he said that if he was, they did not get his attention.... Christie said what he learned when is not important. He dismissed the scrutiny over that detail as 'a game of gotcha.'" ...
... Curiouser & Curiouser. Steve Benen: "Christie said during the radio interview last night that he's 'curious' about 'what happened here' and remains 'really anxious to find out.' It's unclear, however, why he didn't ask Bridget Ann Kelly why the scheme was hatched before her dismissal." ... Here's a piece of the interview:
... Jason Grant of Star-Ledger: "Bridget Anne Kelly, considered a crucial figure in unraveling the George Washington Bridge lane closures, is refusing to produce documents and information requested under subpoena by the state legislative committee investigating the controversy, The Star-Ledger has learned. In a letter issued today by the lawyer for Kelly, who last month was fired as Gov. Chris Christie's deputy chief of staff after emails emerged showing she had apparently orchestrated the lane closures, Kelly cited both her Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination and Fourth Amendment right against wrongful search and seizure."
... Mark Lagerkvist of New Jersey Watchdog: "A state police bodyguard to Chris Christie is facing criminal charges in Pennsylvania -- despite his attempt to use his ties with the New Jersey governor to avoid arrest. Trooper William A. Carvounis, 35, is accused of stealing $267 in gun supplies and other goods from a Cabela's store near Hamburg. His arraignment is scheduled for Feb. 10 in Berks County Court of Common Pleas.... New Jersey pays Carvounis a base salary of $95,198 a year -- plus roughly $16,000 for meals, uniform cleaning and other allowances, according to a state payroll database. That does not include his overtime pay, exempt from public disclosure by state regulation" CW: Are all of Chris Christie's staff scum?
Margaret Sullivan of the New York Times: Times "reporter Kate Zernike broke a story based on a letter from David Wildstein's lawyer saying that the former ally of Gov. Chris Christie of New Jersey 'had the evidence to prove' that Mr. Christie knew about the now infamous lane closings at the George Washington Bridge in real time last September.... Later, within the hour, the story was changed to soften the wording from 'had the evidence' to 'evidence exists.'" Sullivan says the Times should have issued a correction or at least an explanatory note. ...
... Brett Logiurato of Business Insider: "For the second time in three days, New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie (R) slammed The New York Times for the paper's report Friday on claims made by former Port Authority official David Wildstein. In a memo circulated to allies and friends on Monday..., Christie's office characterized the report as 'sloppy' and 'misleading.' It uses critical tweets from reporters, as well as a critical column from New York Times public editor Margaret Sullivan, to hammer home its point." CW: Christie doesn't mention that his own evolving Bridgegate story has been "sloppy" & "misleading."
Nullification. Ian Millhiser of Think Progress: "The Missouri Senate's General Laws Committee voted 5-1 last week in favor of a bill that purports to make it a crime for federal law enforcement agents to enforce the nation's gun laws. Under the bill's terms, these agents could be imprisoned for up to a year and be fined up to $1,000. Much of this unconstitutional legislation mirrors a bill Gov. Jay Nixon (D) vetoed last year.... Few principles are more clearly established in American constitutional law than the prohibition on states nullifying federal laws. "
Superbowl Detritus
Jonathan Capehart of the Washington Post: "The pre-Super Bowl interview with President Obama conducted by Bill O'Reilly [Sunday] was not only notable for the Fox News anchor's constant interruptions, but also for his harping on old news.... But the president successfully avoided the rhetorical traps ... and he respectfully stood up to the disrespect ... by giving as good as he got.... Neither the station nor its anchor has shown Obama or his office the respect both deserve. And that 10-minute interview was a perfect illustration of it." ...
... The Washington Post's media blogger Erik Wemple thought O'Reilly did a great job. Which is a good example of why media bloggers should STFU about politics. They don't know what they're writing about.
Matt Flegenheimer of the New York Times: "Billed by organizers as the first 'mass-transit Super Bowl,' Sunday's game drew many visitors to the area's labyrinthine transportation network for the first time. Reviews were decidedly mixed,and there were occasional scenes of large-scale confusion at some of the region's transit hubs."
David Porter of the Bergen Record: "The head of New Jersey's transit agency on Monday defended the response to delays for thousands of fans leaving the Super Bowl by train, as officials sought to understand how ridership estimates could have been so far off base. About 33,000 people took the 7-mile ride between MetLife Stadium and the Secaucus rail transfer station, more than double the highest estimates made by organizers and transportation experts before the game."
News Ledes
Reuters: "Joan Mondale, the wife of former U.S. Vice President Walter Mondale and a champion of the arts, died on Monday, her family said in a statement. She was 83." ...
... Update. The Washington Post's obituary is here. The New York Times' obituary is here.
New York Times: "President Hamid Karzai of Afghanistan has been engaged in secret contacts with the Taliban about reaching a peace agreement without the involvement of his American and Western allies, further corroding already strained relations with the United States."
Share Article
Reader Comments (9)
There's been lots of talk about the Democrats winning senate seats in Georgia and Kentucky, but nobody's talking about Maine. Susan Collins should look out -- Shenna Bellows is young, smart, progressive, and starting to raise some money.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2014/02/03/susan-collins-shenna-bellows_n_4717480.html
Re:"Are all Christie's staff scum?"
Christie already answered that with the screed against Wildstein. Reading between the lines "I knew Wildstein was scum way back. Ergo he wss qualified."
@Barbarossa. Thanks for explaining. Actually, I think you have a point. There are some people who won't hire anyone who seems smarter or cooler than they. Christie may be that type of boss.
Marie
Re: revenge is served best cold. I haven't heard this from any source but could be young nerd Wildstein promised himself, "one day, you bully" after the fifth day of wedgies from B.M.O.C. Christie during P.E. lo those long years ago. That's a attempt at humor; but I do get the feeling that Christie was "one of those guys" we all knew in high school and Wildstein was "one of those guys that got pushed around by "those guys.""
I wasn't cool at school but I wasn't any body's fool at school either.
If you think you are Tony Soprano, aides-de-scum are the obvious choice. Ba Da Bing!
Via Benen, this Politico piece is a desperate stab at trying to rehabilitate Ted Cruz. Its just plain laugh out loud Monty Python revisited. The GOP are sweating like stevedores and desperately wringing their hands as they cast about for a 2016 candidate. Its a tall order to find a GOP candidate who has learned to tie their shoes, can be taken into public without fear of flatulence, doesn't wear diapers as part of foreplay or hasn't gotten caught with their hand in the cookie jar. Its a cluster out there right now. Tee Hee.
http://www.politico.com/story/2014/02/ted-cruz-republicans-103052.html#ixzz2sLn5K9sN
What with illegal bridge closures for political payback that resulted in at least one death, cover ups, lies, corruption, political blackmail, cronyism, "whacking" of liabilities, thieving bodyguards and who knows what all else, it sounds like the Christie administration operates as more of a criminal enterprise than a public service.
RICO anyone?
Good news for wingnuts tired of pretending that Henry Waxman may not have been the Son of Satan (he is), now get to unleash their inner whackadoodle (like they haven't already?) and go full-on insane.
It seems Sandra Fluke has filed to run for the seat being vacated by Waxman.
Can't you hear the panicky slurs already? Mike Fuckabee and Anal Cyst Limbaugh will be in extra high dudgeon.
Unchecked Libido Plans Attack on Defenseless GOP Macho Men.
" CW: Alter's observations about Obama's relationship with the military brass are instructive." Roger that. I just can't believe these intelligent men simply think more warm bodies/warm red meat will solve Afghanistan. People have been fighting over this barren, arid, divided region and our leaders think we'll waltz right in for the first time since recorded history began and solve everything in a timely manner? What the hell are they teaching at the military universities in this country; is this grade inflation writ large?
I can't help but think about my old, Mr. Emerson, "A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesmen and philosophers and divines."