The Commentariat -- Oct. 17, 2013
This victory for common sense is a testament to his profound tenacity, the trust his colleagues have in him and his ability to lead. And it is clear it would not have happened without him. -- Neera Tanden, President of the Center for American Progress, on Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid
P.S. Nancy Pelosi did some mighty fine cat-wrangling, too. -- Constant Weader
... Erin McClam of NBC News: "President Barack Obama said Thursday, as the federal government blinked back to life, that the 16-day shutdown and threat of national default had inflicted 'completely unnecessary damage on our economy.'" CW: AND he took a shot at me! It's at 5:45 in that the POTUS calls me a piece of dirt. I'm going to have to think about that:
... Tom Cohen, et al., of CNN: "President Barack Obama signed a bill that ends the 16-day partial government shutdown and raises the debt ceiling, the White House said early Thursday morning." ...
... Russell Berman of the Hill: "Rep. Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) split with his party's leadership and voted against the Senate fiscal agreement on Wednesday night.... Shortly after the House vote, Boehner announced four Republican appointees to the conference committee: Ryan, Rep. Tom Cole (R-Okla.), Rep. Tom Price (Ga.) and Rep. Diane Black (Tenn.). Price and Black also voted against the Senate bill." CW: So, one semi-normal ultra-conservative (Cole) and three crazed ideologues. This should work well. ...
... CW: Boehner's continued support for the Tea Party crazies, as evidenced by his budget conference nominees is a terrible sign of times to come. Not only did he not listen to the so-called moderates who urged him to distance himself from the wingnuts, he eschewed advice like this from William Galston, writing in the Wall Street Journal on Tuesday: "It's hard to see how the U.S. can govern itself unless corporate America pushes the Republican establishment to fight back against the tea party -- or switches sides." It would be a mistake to think Boehner somehow redeemed himself by consenting to allow Democrats & some Republicans to spare the nation from default & re-start the government. He is just as horrible a hack today as he was on Tuesday. ...
... Alex Altman of Time: "... while the shutdown fight may be the nadir of congressional dysfunction, things aren't getting better anytime soon." ...
... ** Jonathan Cohn of the New Republic on why Democrats prevailed. ...
... While for Republicans, writes Molly Ball of the Atlantic, "it was basically for nothing."
... If you thought things couldn't get more bizarre.... Politico: "A House floor stenographer was abruptly hauled out of the chamber after charging the dais and screaming during Wednesday's late night vote on raising the debt ceiling and funding the federal government. As the bill sailed toward final passage, the presiding lawmaker suddenly began pounding the gavel. Witnesses on the floor said the woman, identified as Dianne Reidy, seized a microphone and began yelling during the vote." ...
... Geoff Earle of the New York Post has more, with video. Thanks to James S. for the link. ...
... David Nakamura, et al., of the Washington Post: "Sixteen days after a federal shutdown began and one day before the United States would have exhausted its ability to borrow money, Congress approved a bill to reopen the government and raise the debt ceiling until Feb. 7. President Obama has promised to sign the legislation immediately, meaning hundreds of thousands of federal workers could be back at work Thursday." ...
... CW: The House is now expected to vote tonight. ...
... Update: The house voted on a voice vote; the chair declared the "yeas" won; i.e., the Senate bill passed. There was a call for a recorded vote & a 15-min. vote is ongoing at 9:57 pm ET. ...
... Update 2: The vote has passed the 220 mark, with 60 Republicans voting yea at this point. Final vote: 285 to 144; all 198 Democrats in attendance voted "yea"; 87 Republicans also voted "yea" to 144 "nays." President Obama to speak at 10:30 am Thursday.
... Jonathan Weisman & Ashley Parker of the New York Times: "... the Senate voted overwhelmingly, 81-18, on Wednesday evening to approve a proposal hammered out by Republican and Democratic leaders after the House was unable to move forward with any resolution. The House was expected to follow suit within hours and approve the Senate plan, which would finance the government through Jan. 15 and raise the debt limit through Feb. 7. Shortly after the vote, Mr. Obama praised Congress for action and said the vote cleared the way for substantive budget negotiations." ...
... CW: In the Senate the motion to invoke cloture on the bill to re-open the government & raise the debt ceiling passed 83-15 (I think). Update: The bill itself passed 81-18. ...
... Jonathan Weisman & Jennifer Steinhauer of the New York Times: "Speaker John A. Boehner ... said that the House would not block a bipartisan agreement reached in the Senate that yielded virtually no concessions to the Republicans.... The Senate is expected to vote on the bill Wednesday evening, with final passage coming late Wednesday or early Thursday. ...
... David Nakamura, et al., of the Washington Post: "Boehner, House Majority Leader Eric Cantor (R-Va.) and Majority Whip Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) told Republicans at a closed-door afternoon meeting that they all plan to vote for the deal, said Aaron Schock (R-Ill.).... [Boehner] told conservative radio host Bill Cunningham that he would encourage his caucus to support the Senate measure.... Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) has pledged the support of all 200 Democrats, meaning Boehner would have to supply at least 17 votes." ...
... Here's the full text of the bill. ...
... Joan McCarter of Daily Kos has a rundown of the key provisions. As contributor Dave S. points out, "It also includes language allowing President Obama to waive the debt ceiling, which could be overridden by a vote of disapproval by Congress that could then be vetoed by the president." CW: This provision begins on Page 24 of the bill, linked above. As I read it, this presidential privilege expires February 7, 2014. In addition, Rachel Maddow pointed out this evening that the "modification" to the ACA -- verifying income eligibility for ACA subsidies -- is something that's already in the Affordable Care law. So Republicans got nothing, & giving the President the ability to raise the debt ceiling (which I think is an old idea of Mitch McConnell's) is a big plus for the economy. ...
... CW Update: Okay, I read the bill right, but I didn't consider this significant wrinkle: Jack Lew can still use "extraordinary measures" after February 7. Ergo, Lori Montgomery & Rosalind Helderman write in the WashPo: "Enforcement of the debt limit is suspended until Feb. 7, setting up another confrontation over the national debt sometime in March, independent analysts estimated." So whether or not there's another debt ceiling debacle in March could depend upon whether or not House Republicans think it's a good for their re-election. However, since the government is funded only till January 15 under the bill, the Next Big Crisis will likely occur in the dark days of winter, & maybe the debt ceiling issue will be worked out then. Democrats probably will demand it as part of the budget deal. ...
... Pete
authorization for spending on construction on the lower Ohio River in Illinois and Kentucky." ...No one should be surprised that this is the response of the Washington establishment. The American people rose up and spoke with an overwhelming voice and at least at this stage Washington isn't listening to them. The House listened, but the Senate has not.... [I] never had any intention to delay this vote. -- Sen. Ted Cruz (RTP-Texas), who yesterday would not say whether or not he would delay the vote
(The dream of keeping poor people from seeing a doctor must never die. -- Ted Cruz [paraphrase by Andy Borowitz])
For the party, this is a moment of self-evaluation, we are going to assess how we got here. If we continue down this path, we are really going to hurt the Republican Party long term.... This has been a really bad two weeks for the Republican Party. -- Sen. Lindsay Graham (R-S.C.)
Let's just say sometimes learning what can't be accomplished is an important long-term thing, and hopefully for some of the members they've learned it's impossible to defund mandatory programs by shutting down the federal government. -- Sen. Richard Burr (R-N.C.)
... Jonathan Strong of National Review about the last House Republican conference before the vote. Boehner received a standing O. CW: Maybe because he didn't "disrespect" the kidnappers. Or maybe because that "respect" cost billions of dollars & untold hardship. Whatever. "Representative Aaron Schock of Illinois said the lesson of the episode was that Boehner should cut out the far-right flank and work with centrist Democrats. Most of the top conservatives who pushed the House GOP into an Obamacare fight weren't very introspective, offering positive words about the fight and hope for victories to come." ...
... M. J. Lee of Politico: "Wall Street cheered a long-awaited deal to re-open the government and increase the nation's borrowing cap that emerged Wednesday, as Congress is poised to end a government shutdown now in its third week and squash fears that the United States may default on its financial obligations. The Dow Jones industrial average, which climbed quickly after the opening bell and remained steady throughout the day, closed 205.82 points higher. The Nasdaq also shot up 45.42 points, while the S&P 500 was up 23.48 points." ...
Something has gone terribly wrong when the biggest threat to our American economy is the American Congress. -- Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.V.), December 31, 2012, after the fiscal cliff deal
... Annie Lowrey, et al., of the New York Times: "... the cost of Congress's gridlock has already run well into the billions, economists estimate. And the total will continue to grow even after the shutdown ends, partly because of uncertainty about whether lawmakers might reach another deadlock early next year." ...
... Gail Collins: "... it's fair, if you have the urge, to say that this whole ordeal has been for nothing whatsoever." ...
Jeanne B. writes, "Republicans have too many masters":
... Daniel Strauss of TPM: Mike Kibbe, "the President and CEO of the tea party group Freedomworks, predicted that House Republicans who vote in favor of the latest plan to avert a debt default and re-open the federal government, will face primary challengers." ...
... Igor Bobic of TPM: "Heritage Action announced Wednesday that it will include the Senate deal to avert default and reopen government as a key vote in its scorecard, urging members to vote oppose the measure." ...
... Caitlin MacNeal of TPM: "The U.S. Chamber of Commerce announced Wednesday that it supports the new Senate plan to end the shutdown and raise the debt ceiling, and it will include the measure as a key vote."
David Corn of Mother Jones: "About two weeks ago, as tea partiers in the GOP-controlled House were forcing a government shutdown, some House Democrats sent a private and informal message to House Speaker John Boehner: If you need to break with the die-hard conservatives of your caucus to keep the government running and avoid a debt ceiling crisis, we might be able to try to help you protect your speakership, should far-right Republicans rebel and challenge you."
Thanks to contributor Roger H. for this (see yesterday's thread). Speaking of education, you've educated MAG & me:
... BTW, wingers repeatedly attribute the saying to Joe Biden; also found one kid-you-not claim it came from Keith Ellison (D-Minn.).
Sarah Kliff of the Washington Post reports on her experience shopping for health insurance on Healthcare.gov
** Beth Reinhard of the National Journal: "Twelve states, as well as the House of Representatives, have voted to outlaw abortion after 20 weeks -- the exact moment when some parents are just learning about severe or even fatal defects. Only Georgia, Louisiana, and Texas include exceptions for fetal impairment.... These 20-week bans...predominantly target women who are carrying gravely impaired babies or whose pregnancies are putting their own health at risk.... The overlap between states with tougher abortion restrictions and lower standards of living is rarely mentioned...."
Dylan Byers of Politico: "James Risen, the New York Times investigative reporter who has refused to testify against his alleged CIA source, has pledged to take his case to the Supreme Court following a federal appeals court decision not to reconsider his case."
Senate Race
Jonathan Tamari of the Philadelphia Inquirer: "Gov. [Chris] Christie [of New Jersey] has until Nov. 13 to certify the results of the special Senate election, though he doesn't expect to take that long. 'The winner of (Wednesday's) election will be sworn in as quickly as possible after the results have been verified and certified. We fully anticipate this to happen before the Nov. 5th election day,' said a statement from Gov. Christie's office." Cory Booker's win means Democrats pick up another Senate seat, which Christie filled shortly after Sen. Frank Lautenberg's (D) death with Republican Jeff Chiesa.