The Commentariat -- Jan. 18, 2013
My column in today's New York Times eXaminer is on Paul Krugman's takedown of Tom Friedman.
To find out how you can participate, CLICK ON THE IMAGE.President Obama in a Yahoo! op-ed: "Each January as we celebrate the legacy of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., we are called not just to pause and reflect, but to act.... This Saturday, we're continuing that tradition with another National Day of Service. Michelle, the girls and I will be volunteering in our community, and we're asking all Americans to join us."
Michael Cooper & Dahlia Sussman of the New York Times: "The massacre of children at an elementary school in Newtown, Conn., appears to be profoundly swaying Americans' views on guns, galvanizing the broadest support for stricter gun laws in about a decade, according to a New York Times/CBS News poll.... The poll found that a majority of Americans -- 54 percent -- think gun control laws should be tightened, up markedly from a CBS News poll in April that found that only 39 percent backed stricter laws. The rise in support for stricter gun laws stretched across political lines, including an 18-point increase among Republicans. A majority of independents now back stricter gun laws." ...
Michael Cooper: "... as mayors from around the nation gathered [in Washington, D.C.,] on Thursday for the 81st winter meeting of the United States Conference of Mayors, many said they were heartened by President Obama's call for new laws to curb gun violence, which included several measures that the conference had sought for decades. Many said they planned to urge Congress to enact them."
... Dave Weigel of Slate: "Gun massacre trutherism isn't tied to election results. It bubbles over after every massacre.... The theories ... spread in part because of the confirmation bias of worried gun owners. And that's actually been egged on, multiple times, by the National Rifle Association.... The idea that the government is one short step away from a gun ban is actually integral to the lobby's pitch."
Susan Eisenhower in the Washington Post: "For the eight years that my grandfather, Dwight Eisenhower, was president of the United States, I had Secret Service protection.... These armed agents protected my sisters, brother and me from potential kidnappings or other targeted attacks.... Any thinking person has to be disgusted by the National Rifle Association ad ... suggesting that the president is an 'elitist hypocrite' because his children have the benefit of armed protection at school and the nation's children as a whole do not. This is absurd. The nation's children are not individually at risk the way the Obama children are.... The NRA's attack ad should be condemned for exacerbating the dangers faced by the president and his family...." ...
"The Dwindling Deficit." Paul Krugman: "Even without [taking specific action to reduce the deficit], however, the budget outlook for the next 10 years doesn't look at all alarming. Now, projections that run further into the future do suggest trouble, as an aging population and rising health care costs continue to push federal spending higher. But ... why, exactly, should we believe that it's necessary, or even possible, to decide right now how we will eventually address the budget issues of the 2030s?"
Navel-Gazing, GOP Edition
Rosalind Helderman & Ed O'Keefe of the Washington Post: "House Republicans are cloistered at a tony golf resort [in Williamsburg, Virginia,] for three days hoping to resurrect their battered political brand, as they prepare for what could be another damaging confrontation with President Obama over federal spending.... Although there was some urgency for a change, the consensus was that the change was about how to communicate, not about rethinking core policy positions." CW Trans.: "We are still greedy, misogynistic, sociopathic martinets, but we're looking at ways to Stockholm-Syndrome you into liking it."
The Vote No/Hope Yes Caucus. Ashley Parker of the New York Times: the Vote No/Hope Yes Caucus is "the small but significant number of Republican representatives who, on the recent legislation to head off the broad tax increases and spending cuts mandated by the so-called fiscal cliff, voted no while privately hoping -- and at times even lobbying -- in favor of the bill's passage, given the potential harmful economic consequences otherwise.... The Vote No/Hope Yes group is perhaps the purest embodiment of the uneasy relationship between politics and pragmatism in the nation's capital and a group whose very existence must be understood and dealt with as the Republican Party grapples with its future in the wake of the bruising 2012 elections."
Actually, They're All Wingers. Ed Kilgore: "I would object to the neat characterization of House GOPers as falling into three equivalent baskets of 'moderates, pragmatic conservatives, and hard-core conservatives.' ... Calling any House Republican in a competitive district a 'moderate' is both dangerous and wrong.... As for the 'pragmatic conservatives' (presumably led by John Boehner), exactly how much pragmatism can be attributed to the decision not to blow up the economy? ... The temptation to treat the two parties as composed of balanced groups of ideologues and 'pragmatists' or 'moderates' is at the very center of the false-equivalency meme.... There is an extremist ideology that unites most Republican pols...." ...
Charles Pierce. Paul "Ryan has a brand-new shiny idea that he's out in the yard playing with. It's called 'prioritization,' and it's the latest thing in zombie-eyed granny starving. By this theory, which is the brainchild of Pennsylvania Senator Pat Toomey, himself an economic extremist..., we hit the debt limit and then the government 'prioritizes' its spending, beginning with interest on the debt, because that's what most Americans are sweating in their shoes about, and then skipping right to veterans benefits, because cutting them would cause actual political problems for hacks like Toomey and Ryan.... It seems to me that the American people gave Ryan a 'crystal clear' indication what they thought of his ideas..., but that's just me.... It really is time to stop taking this guy seriously." ...
... UPI Update: "U.S. House Budget Committee Chairman Paul Ryan said Republicans may back a short-term debt-ceiling increase -- a notion the White House immediately rejected.... White House spokesman Jay Carney rejected the notion of raising the $16.4 trillion debt ceiling in the short term, saying postponing Congress' responsibility would create drama in Washington that will hurt the U.S. economy." ...
... Steve Benen on the debt ceiling war: "It would probably be an overstatement to say Republicans are already surrendering, but let's just say they've taken the white flag off the shelf, even if they're not yet ready to wave it."
Jamelle Bouie, in the Washington Post: "On issues that don't obviously relate to the party's long-term survival, [Sen. Marco] Rubio [RTP-Fla.] is a conventional conservative, responding to a base that remains far to the right of the average American. To wit, Rubio's response to President Obama's gun safety measures -- which are modest in scope and broadly popular -- is nothing short of hysterical.... Republican lawmakers -- even so-called reformers -- must still respond to their supporters. And by and large, the GOP remains committed to the values of its right-wing base."
Here's why Republicans have become ever so self-aware. Henry Decker of the National Memo: "According to a new ABC News/Washington Post poll, President Barack Obama's approval rating is near an all-time high, and the public is on his side in the upcoming debt ceiling debate. The poll finds Obama's approval rating at 55 percent, his highest level since November, 2009 (excluding a brief bump up to 56 percent after the president ordered the raid that killed Osama bin Laden in 2011) 61 percent view Obama as a strong leader -- his highest level in three years -- and 53 percent say they're optimistic about the policies he'll pursue in his second term. By contrast..., Congress has just a 19 percent approval rating; 37 percent approve of House Democrats, and 24 percent approve of House Republicans."
Jonathan Bernstein on the Separation of Powers That Isn't. "You won't hear it from House Republicans and other conservatives, who are talking impeachment over the prospect that Obama might use executive orders as part of his gun-safety initiatives (this notwithstanding that, by one count, Obama uses executive orders less frequently than most presidents), but executive orders save Congress from passing laws that would have to be far more detailed and complex than they currently are. Not only that: sometimes the easiest way to get a bill over the finish line is to leave the specifics up to the regulators over in the executive branch. So often the path of least resistance for Congress is to pass vague legislation and leave it to the executive branch to fill in the details."
Rigging the 2016 Presidential Election. Erik Loomis of Lawyers, Guns & Money: "Why this story isn't getting more attention, I don't know.... Rather than broaden their message to appeal to young and non-white voters, Republicans are looking to commit the greatest suppression of votes since the Voting Rights Act of 1965 passed.... It is entirely possible that a Democratic candidate could win 55% of the vote in 2016 and lose the election."
** "A Tale of Two Dead Girls & Notre Dame Football." Amanda Marcotte of Slate: "Lizzy Seeberg was a real person and she really did kill herself in 2011, at age 19, after accusing a football player of sexual assault." People harassed her, the campus police investigated her but not the accused, who -- once "investigated" after Seeberg's death, was immediately cleared. "Te'o's story has been all over the news today -- and with good reason. It's nuts. But what's also nuts is that the story of Lennay Kekua -- the dead girl who never lived -- is a bigger deal ... than the story of Lizzy Seeberg, whose real life ended in real tragedy.... Beautiful, selfless, perfect woman does not exist? Now that's a story. The horrors faced by women trying to find justice for sexual violence? Sorry, ladies, that's just boring old everyday life." ...
... ** Melinda Henneberger of the Washington Post: "... evidence that the University of Notre Dame covers up for sexual predators on the football team in hopes of winning some games has been mostly ignored.... We know for sure that Notre Dame collaborated with at least one story, on Charlie Rose's CBS morning show, that told the phony boohoo tale after the school knew no such woman had ever walked the earth." ...
... Tim Egan: "The Internet is the cause of much of today's commitment-free, surface-only living; it's also the explanation for why someone could tumble head-over-heels for a pixelated cipher. Online dating was only the start of what led us down this road."
Josh Gerstein of Politico: "President Barack Obama's Jobs Council hit a notable milestone on Thursday: one year without an official meeting. The 26-member panel is also set to expire at the end of the month.... Politico caused a stir last July by reporting that the panel had not convened officially for six months. The story noted some simmering tension between the slew of business executives on the board and a pair of labor leaders who are also members of the group. The report also said that some CEOs were reluctant to appear with Obama at the height of the presidential campaign...." CW: the less Obama talks to those scheming reprobates, the better.
"Les Insufferables." Nicholas Beaudrot of Donkeylicious: "There is plenty to mock in the Wall Street Journal's profile of some hypothetical households that will see tax increases.... A huge chunk of the tax increase on the fake single mom and fake single can be chalked up to the lapse of the payroll tax holiday [which Republicans demanded].... Perhaps the most laughable part ... is that all of these households realize a substantial portion of their income through taxable investment income.... Given the WSJ's insistence on including an absurdly large amount of investment income in their hypotheticals, it's quite possible that there are zero households that come close to matching these characteristics. They might as well be reporting on how the tax changes will affect Elvis Presley, JFK, and Sasquatch...." Via Jonathan Bernstein. CW: Here's some mockery, courtesy of Charles Pierce, which includes a comment from me.
News Ledes
New York Times: "C. Ray Nagin, the former mayor of this city who fulminated against the federal government's response to Hurricane Katrina but became for many a symbol of the shortcomings of government himself, was indicted by a federal grand jury on Friday on 21 counts including conspiracy, bribery and money laundering." CW: presumed innocent, but, um, what a surprise.
** AP: "A federal appeals court on Friday upheld Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker's contentious law stripping most public workers of nearly all of their collective bargaining rights in a decision hailed by Republicans but not undoing a state court ruling keeping much of the law from being in effect."
New York Times: "Gussie Moran, who as a ranked American tennis player in 1949 caused an international stir and gained worldwide fame for competing at Wimbledon wearing a short skirt and lace-trimmed underwear, died on Wednesday at her home in Los Angeles. She was 89."
New York Times: "... some of the hundreds of workers who managed to escape the national gas field on the eastern edge of Algeria that had been stormed by Islamist militants two days before" told "chilling tales" of their ordeal. "The gunmen, fighters with a group called Al Mulathameen, said they were acting to avenge the French intervention in nearby Mali, Algerian officials said. But there were indications that the attack had been planned long before the French military began its offensive to recapture the northern half of that country from Islamist insurgents." ...
... New York Times: "Britain said on Friday that an Algerian military operation against kidnappers in the Sahara was not over and the fate of some captives remained unclear a day after Algeria mounted an assault on heavily armed fighters holding American and other hostages at a remote gas field facility." ...
... Reuters: "Hundreds of workers from international oil companies have been evacuated from Algeria on Thursday and many more will follow, BP said on Friday following the al-Qaeda-linked attack on a major gas facility."
New York Times: "The discovery by American intelligence agencies that North Korea is moving mobile missile launchers around the country, some carrying a new generation of powerful rocket, has spurred new assessments of the intentions of the country's young new leader, Kim Jong-un, who has talked about economic change but appears to be accelerating the country's ability to attack American allies or forces in Asia, and ultimately to strike across the Pacific."
New York Times: "In a televised interview with Oprah Winfrey, Lance Armstrong admitted to using banned substances but did not say how he did it or who helped him."
AP: "The former Century 16 [in Aurora, Colorado], now renovated and renamed the Century Aurora, opened its doors to victims of the July 20 attack on Thursday night with a somber remembrance ceremony and a special showing of 'The Hobbit.'"