The Commentariat -- Dec. 4, 2012
Cliff Notes
Jackie Calmes of the New York Times (post time Dec. 4, 3:09 am): "Democratic luminaries with ties to the Obama and Clinton administrations, including two former Treasury secretaries and two former White House chiefs of staff, on Tuesday will enter the tax debate with an overhaul plan that would raise an additional $1.8 trillion in the first decade. That is $200 billion more than President Obama has proposed and $1 trillion more than Republicans in Congress support. It would mostly result from a simplification of the tax code that produces higher taxes from the wealthy, but would also involve higher taxes on cigarettes, alcoholic beverages and Internet gambling that would hit people of all incomes." Here's the plan (pdf). CW: Maybe they could have submitted it a tad sooner.
White House Hits the Reject Button. Michael Memoli of the Los Angeles Times: "Dan Pfeiffer, the White House communications director, said in a statement that what congressional Republicans had billed as a 'good-faith effort' to move toward compromise contained 'nothing new' and offered no specifics on how they'd achieve revenue targets included in the plan. Until the Republicans in Congress are willing to get serious about asking the wealthiest to pay slightly higher tax rates, we won't be able to achieve a significant, balanced approach to reduce our deficit,' Pfeiffer said in the statement, released two hours after details of the GOP offer emerged."
Jonathan Karl of ABC News: "Republicans are seriously considering a Doomsday Plan if fiscal cliff talks collapse entirely. It's quite simple: House Republicans would allow a vote on extending the Bush middle class tax cuts (the bill passed in August by the Senate) and offer the President nothing more: no extension of the debt ceiling, nothing on unemployment, nothing on closing loopholes. Congress would recess for the holidays and the president would face a big battle early in the year over the debt ceiling." ...
... Because Doomsday Plan Sounds More Badass than Capitulation Plan. Jonathan Chait of New York: "The evolving Republican position appears to be a response to the recognition that the [Republican] party doesn't have any leverage to fight Obama over the Bush tax cuts and doesn't seem to know what it wants to do on spending."
While I'm flattered the Speaker would call something 'the Bowles plan,' the approach outlined in the letter Speaker Boehner sent to the President does not represent the Simpson-Bowles plan, nor is it the Bowles plan. -- Erskine Bowles ...
... New York Times Editors: "Republicans didn't even bother to assemble their own package of spending cuts and revenue increases; they did a simple copy and paste of a few proposals made extemporaneously at a hearing last year by Erskine Bowles.... Mr. Bowles quickly disavowed" authorship of the GOP proposal. "The offer was a transparent attempt to appear responsive to Mr. Obama's detailed proposal from last week, without doing any actual math or hard work."
Paul Krugman: "... the Republican 'counteroffer' is basically fake. It calls for $800 billion in revenue from closing loopholes, but doesn't specify a single loophole to be closed; it calls for huge spending cuts, but aside from raising the Medicare age and cutting the Social Security inflation adjustment -- moves worth only around $300 billion -- it doesn't specify how these cuts are to be achieved. So it's basically the Paul Ryan method: scribble down some numbers and pretend that you're a budget wonk with a Serious plan.... [See definition of 'Serious' below.] Oh, and for all the seniors or near-seniors who voted Republican because you thought they would protect Medicare from that bad guy Obama: you've been had." ...
... ** Krugman on controlling healthcare costs to rein in the deficit. Bottom line: "... pay no attention when [Republicans] talk about how much they hate deficits. If they were serious about deficits, they'd be willing to consider policies that might actually work; instead, they cling to free-market fantasies that have failed repeatedly in practice."
Josh Barro of Bloomberg News: "House Republicans are out with their response to the President's opening bid on the fiscal cliff, and it's not very impressive. Here are three big problems with the letter they sent to the White House: 1. It's not really a proposal -- it's just a set of headline numbers without specific policies.... 2. The description of tax reform makes little sense.... 3. The proposal does not fully avert the fiscal cliff.
Steve Benen: "Under the GOP plan, Republicans get the more than $1 trillion in spending cuts Obama already gave them; Republicans get the entitlement cuts they want; Republicans get hundreds of billions of dollars in additional cuts to programs they haven't identified; and Republicans get all of the Bush-era tax rates they've prioritized. This isn't a 'counteroffer'; it's a Christmas wish list written by kids without access to calculators."
Kevin Drum of Mother Jones updates his dictionary to define the latest meanings of "serious" and "unserious" proposals:
Serious (ser’ ee uhs) adj. any of a group of proposals that immiserates large numbers of ordinary people, either immediately or in the future, via cuts to broad-based social welfare programs.
Unserious (un ser’ ee uhs) adj. any proposal that slightly inconveniences rich people via modest tax increases or annoys military contractors via small cuts to the Defense Department.
CW: As Congressional Republicans continue their fight to protect the rich (their so-called counter-proposal actually lowers the top marginal tax rate) & undermine the government, keep this Think Progress headline in mind: "Corporate profits hit record high while worker wages hit record low." Pat Garofalo has the story.
** Frank Bruni: "There’s something rotten in the N.F.L., an obviously dysfunctional culture that either brings out sad, destructive behavior in its fearsome gladiators or fails to protect them and those around them from it. And while it's too soon to say whether [Jovan] Belcher himself was a victim of that culture, it's worth noting that the known facts and emerging details of his story echo themes all too familiar in pro football over recent years: domestic violence, substance abuse, erratic behavior, gun possession, bullets fired, suicide." ...
... AP: "Bob Costas'; 'Sunday Night Football' halftime commentary supporting gun control sparked a Fox News Channel debate Monday on whether NBC should fire him and a Twitter storm involving Ted Nugent, Rosie O'Donnell, Herman Cain and many more." CW: Costas' remarks should not be controversial. And the AP should not bother to report what Nugent, O'Donnell & Cain have to say about anything -- especially Nugent. ...
... NEW. Charles Pierce: "That what Costas said is reckoned to be brave -- and it was, especially judging by the hysteria it set off on the gun-happy right -- is a measure of how truncated our national discussion has become."
Louise Story of the New York Times: Pontiac, Michigan, tries to go Hollywood, but there is no happy ending -- just a lot of lost tax revenue. "Hollywood may make movies about the evils of capitalism, but it rarely works without incentives, which are paid for by taxpayers. Nationwide, about $1.5 billion in tax breaks is awarded to the film industry each year...."
Dana Milbank: Obama's "transparent" presidency has become increasingly -- and ominously -- opaque.
Jonathan Capehart of the Washington Post: "... what is not in doubt to me is Ann Romney's strong belief that not only was she going to be first lady but also she deserved to be first lady. The presidency and the role of first lady are earned. They are neither a matter of whose turn it is nor destiny. Like so many others, Ann Romney apparently had to learn this the hard way." ...
... Mitt Gets a Job. Samantha Bomkamp of the AP: "... Mitt Romney is rejoining Marriott International's board of directors."
In our continuing He-Might-Have-Been-President series, Bob Woodward of the Washington Post writes that "in spring 2011, [Fox "News" chief Roger] Ailes asked a Fox News analyst" to tell David Petraeus that Ailes advised Petraeus to "turn down an expected offer from President Obama to become CIA director and accept nothing less than the chairmanship of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the top military post. If Obama did not offer the Joint Chiefs post, Petraeus should resign from the military and run for president, Ailes suggested." The audio (top of the page) is interesting. Petraeus uses the interview to try to get Fox "News" to be more supportive of the Afghanistan war & complains -- evah so politely -- that as Fox goes after Obama they're also "unduly undermining" the war effort.
Oh, Heartbreak All Around. David Corn & Andy Kroll of Mother Jones: Dick Armey, the former House Majority Leader (RTP-Texas) "has resigned as chairman of FreedomWorks, one of the main political outfits of the conservative movement and an instrumental force within the tea party." The break-up was definitely not amicable.
Rebecca Schoenkopf of Wonkette writes a terrific retort to the latest outraged reaction to whatever the Obamas are doing. The Horror This Time: the White House has 54 Christmas trees at a time the entire nation is about to go over the fiscal cliff! So sez Andrew Malcolm, who must have got booted from the L.A. Times because he's writing about the outrageous Obamas someplace else now. Here was Alex Pareene's take on Malcolm in 2010.
News Ledes
AP: "The Palestinians will ask the U.N. Security Council to call for an Israeli settlement freeze, President Mahmoud Abbas and his advisers decided Tuesday, as part of an escalating showdown over Israel's new plans to build thousands more homes on war-won land in and around Jerusalem."
AP: "Kansas City Chiefs linebacker Jovan Belcher told officers who found him sleeping in his car outside an apartment complex hours before he committed a murder-suicide that he was there to visit a woman he described as his 'girlfriend,' but that she wasn't home. The apartment complex is about 10 miles from the Kansas City home Belcher shared with 22-year-old Kasandra Perkins, the mother of their 3-month-old daughter Zoey."
Washington Post: "The Senate has failed to ratify an international treaty intended to protect the rights of those with disabilities, as a bloc of conservatives opposed the treaty believing it could interfere with U.S. law. The Senate voted 61 to 38 to ratify the Convention on the Rights of Persons With Disabilities, a tally that fell short of the two-thirds needed to sign on to an international treaty."
Washington Post: "Thousands of protesters massed outside the presidential palace and in Tahrir Square in Cairo on Tuesday, as Egyptians voiced their opposition to President Mohamed Morsi for a 12th straight day."
New York Times: "Calling a California law that bans gay 'conversion therapies' for minors an unconstitutional infringement on speech, a federal judge blocked the law's enforcement late Monday."
New York Times: "Fierce fighting on the battlefield and setbacks on the diplomatic front increased pressure on the embattled Syrian government as fresh signs emerged on Tuesday of a sustained battle for control of the capital.... The latest reports followed developments on Monday when a senior Turkish official said that Russia had agreed to a new diplomatic approach to seek ways to persuade President Bashar al-Assad to relinquish power...."
Star Ledger: In a "meeting with White House officials and Congressional leaders in D.C. today," New Jersey Gov. Chris "Christie asked that the federal government reimburse 100 percent of costs related to Sandy recovery, beyond the usual 75 percent or the 90 percent President Obama can authorize."
AP: "Iran claimed Tuesday it had captured a U.S. drone after it entered Iranian airspace over the Persian Gulf -- even showing an image of a purportedly downed craft on state TV -- but the U.S. Navy said all its unmanned aircraft in the region were 'fully accounted for.'"
AP: "NATO foreign ministers are expected Tuesday to approve Turkey's request for Patriot anti-missile systems to bolster its defense against strikes from neighboring Syria, NATO's top official said." ...
... Washington Post Update: "NATO agreed Tuesday to send new American-made air defenses to Turkey's volatile southern border with Syria, a boost to an alliance member on the front lines of the civil war and a potential backstop for wider U.S. or NATO air operations if Syria deteriorates further."