The Commentariat -- Nov. 27, 2012
My column in the New York Times examiner is on Frank Bruni's love letter to "responsible" Republicans like Lindsey Graham & John McCain who have supposedly distanced themselves from Grover Norquist. My column is kind of a rehash of what we've been saying on Reality Chex, with a little from Marvin Schwalb, a little from Akhilleus, etc.
Robert Pear of the New York Times on the conflicting positions of various parties to the deficit reduction talks. "Mr. Obama and some Democrats in Congress say they are willing to squeeze savings from Medicare by trimming payments to drug companies, hospitals and other health care providers. They have generally ruled out structural changes that would increase costs for a typical beneficiary." CW: let's hope that's right. ...
... Igor Volsky of Think Progress: "... while the GOP's rhetorical shift [on raising tax revenues] represents a break from their dogged opposition to revenue increases during previous budget negotiations, their public 'concessions' closely mirror the kind of policies voters overwhelmingly rejected: tax reform that does not increase marginal tax rates on the richest Americans, but includes eliminating tax loopholes and steep entitlement cuts that closely mirror the policies included in Rep. Paul Ryan's (R-WI) budget.... The pitch is very similar to the plan presented by Romney, which was supposed to boost growth while lowering taxes and making up the revenue from closing loopholes...." ...
... Steve Benen: "... on the one hand, Republicans would get the tax rates they want. On the other hand, Republicans would also get the entitlement changes they want. And because Grover Norquist doesn't like it, this is considered the reasonable GOP offer. Democrats, after a very successful election cycle, are being asked to accept a deal in which Dems concede on tax rates, concede on entitlements, and accept the reward of Romney's revenue plan? This is what passes for bipartisan compromise in late 2012?" ...
... Leigh Ann Caldwell of CBS News: "White House spokesman Jay Carney said [Monday] that Social Security is one entitlement program that should be addressed on a 'separate track.' ... It's a similar position taken by Sen. Richard Durbin, D-Ill, the number two Democrat in the Senate, on Sunday.... But Republicans have insisted that reforming entitlement programs, including Social Security, which constitute more than one-third of federal spending, must be part of the equation...." ...
... BUT, if we're to believe David Plouffe, we're also going to have to assume that President Obama dismisses Keynesian economic theory. Zeke Miller of BuzzFeed: "Obama senior adviser David Plouffe ... [says] President Barack Obama is committed to achieving the elusive 'big deal' on taxes and spending he and Speaker of the House John Boehner have tried to strike for more than 18 months." ...
... Peter Baker of the New York Times (Nov. 27 @ 6:09 am): "Mr. Obama will meet with carefully selected small business owners, middle-class taxpayers and corporate leaders over the next couple days, then fly to Pennsylvania on Friday to tour a toy manufacturer that he argues will be hurt if automatic tax increases take effect at the end of the year." ...
... More from Ken Thomas of the AP on Obama's PR tour. ...
... CW: last week I linked to a story that mentioned a proposed "tax bubble" that -- by removing the marginal tax system -- would hit the moderately wealthy but not the super rich. Frankly, I don't see this as a real problem because I can't imagine even this Congress would be stupid enough to enact such a tax structure. Nate Silver explains how it would work in detail (with charts!). "It is hard to see the economic rationale for creating a bubble in the middle of the tax code." ...
... Dean Baker follows up on Silver's post. And Baker nails Republicans for their hypocrisy on proposing this plan: "The Republicans had highlighted the fate of small business owners who they like to call 'job creators.' This policy would imply a higher tax rate on the vast majority of the job creators, while leaving the very rich little affected.... This proposal would seem to imply that the Republicans were willing to nail the job creators to benefit the very wealthy." CW: Who could have guessed all that talk about helping "job creators" was a ruse? ...
... David Corn of Mother Jones tells the story of what really happened in the Bush tax-cuts showdown of 2010. CW: Corn is right: Obama got more out of the Republicans than he lost even though he was in a much worse bargaining position than he is today. At the time, I ran links to a couple of stories on how the numbers actually worked out, but the narrative was always "Obama caved."
Today's Edition of Corporations Are People, My Friend
Another Reason Not to Shop at Wal-Mart. Laura Clawson of Daily Kos: "Two days after Saturday's fire at a Bangladeshi garment factory that killed at least 112 people, Walmart was neither confirming nor denying that the factory was one of its contractors.... But pictures taken after the fire showing clothes from Walmart's Faded Glory label appear to settle that question.... The Bangladeshi factory lacked enough emergency exits, and some of the 112 people ... died ... jumping out of the eight-story building.... Walmart had given the factory an 'orange' safety rating in May 2011, which means that even by Walmart's low standards, there were significant risks." In an update, Clawson writes, "Walmart is now claiming that it had severed ties with Tazreen, only to have a supplier with whom they had contracted subcontract to this factory in violation of Walmart policies, and that the supplier has been terminated." CW: allow me to remind you that the Walton family owns as much wealth as the lower 40 percent of Americans. Up with how much of this will we put?
Michael Hiltzik of the Los Angeles Times: "Hostess ... failed because the people that ran it had no idea what they were doing. Every other excuse is just an attempt by the guilty to blame someone else." An excellent, brief rundown of Hostess management's epic failures & their depraved indifference to their obligations to their employees.
Brian Montopoli of CBS News: "United Nations Ambassador Susan Rice will meet with senators on Capitol Hill Tuesday to answer questions about the Sept. 11 attack in Benghazi, Libya. CBS News has learned her appearance will include a morning meeting with Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., who has been among her biggest critics since her initial remarks on the attack." ...
... UPDATE. Mark Landler & Jeremy Peters of the New York Times: "Susan E. Rice, the ambassador to the United Nations, conceded on Tuesday that she incorrectly described the attack on the American mission in Benghazi, Libya, in September as following a spontaneous protest, rather than being a terrorist attack. But she said she based her statement on the intelligence available at the time and did not intend to mislead the American public. Ms. Rice's acknowledgment, in a meeting on Capitol Hill with three Republican senators who had sharply criticized her earlier statements in a series of television interviews after the attack, seemed to do little to quell their anger." ...
... NEW. Charles Pierce: Graham & McCain "are a pair of cowards, with a feckless rookie in train, and they are playing dangerous games with the country's security. They hereafter should be ignored and, if Graham goes through with his threat of putting a hold on Rice's nomination, Harry Reid should move his desk out onto Constitution Avenue, and no Democrat should cooperate with this clown ever again." ...
... NEW: Jonathan Capehart of the Washington Post: "Instead of focusing their needed attention on the deadly security lapses at the consulate in Benghazi, McCain and crew continue their petty nitpicking of Rice's statements."
... Pierce didn't take to MoDo's advice to President Obama any more than I did. ...
... Andrew Rudalevige in the Monkey Cage on the value of schmoozing with the enemy. Also read the comment by Norm Ornstein.
... AND Pierce throws Young Douthat to the gray wolves. ...
... CW: I'm with P. D. Pepe. If had listened to Greggers instead of letting Charles Pierce do it for me, there would be a stylish pump sticking out of my busted teevee. The American tragedy is that millions of Americans don't understand that that Greggers' Gang are nothing but shills for the suits in the suites upstairs.
Voter Suppression
Dara Kam & John Lantigua of the Palm Beach Post: "A new Florida law that contributed to long voter lines and caused some to abandon voting altogether was intentionally designed by Florida GOP staff and consultants to inhibit Democratic voters, former GOP officials and current GOP consultants have told The Palm Beach Post.... Former GOP chairman [Jim Greer] and former Gov. Charlie Crist, both of whom have been ousted from the party, now say that fraud concerns were advanced only as subterfuge for the law's main purpose: GOP victory." ...
... Charles Pierce: "OK, Eric Holder, it's time.... Ball's in your court."
Right Wing World
Bruce Bartlett's confessions of a reformed supply-sider is getting a lot of attention & is an interesting read, particularly because of his claims about the right's reactions to his "evolution." ...
... Krugman gives him kudos.
CW: In case you think Republicans aren't really racists but just exploit the racism of their despicable constituents, Jamelle Bouie of American Prospect highlights a piece by David Brooks' favorite "conservative intellectual" Charles Murray. Murray "reasons" that Asian-Americans are all alike & blacks & Latinos don't have desirable values.
Evan McMorris-Santoro of TPM: Birther-in-Chief "Donald Trump says the Republican Party needs to be more appealing to minorities if it wants to survive into the future." CW: to my great surprise, the Donald blamed the negative tone on Mitt Romney & took no responsibility for his own racist antics. ...
... Jamelle Bouie: "... in case you've forgotten, this is the same Donald Trump whose demagoguery compelled President Obama to reveal his birth certificate in a press conference, and who offered to give $5 million to charity if Obama would release his college transcripts and prove that he is 'qualified' (read: not an affirmative-action beneficiary) to be president."
News Ledes
New York Times: "With public pressure mounting, President Mohamed Morsi appeared to pull back Monday from his attempt to assert an authority beyond the reach of any court. His allies in the Muslim Brotherhood canceled plans for a large demonstration in his support, signaling a chance to calm an escalating battle that has paralyzed a divided nation." CW: hmm. The headline in this Guardian liveblog is "Morsi refuses to back down." ...
... Washington Post Update: "Egyptian opposition forces rallied across the country Tuesday in the biggest show of dissent against the country's first democratically elected leader since he precipitated a political crisis last week with an apparent bid to assume near-absolute power."
Reuters: "New York state and New Jersey need at least $71.3 billion to recover from the devastation wrought by Superstorm Sandy and prevent similar damage from future storms, according to their latest estimates."
New York Times: "Finance ministers from the euro zone and the International Monetary Fund patched up their differences over a bailout for Greece early Tuesday with a spate of measures bringing closer the release of long-delayed emergency aid. The parties reached the deal after their third meeting in three weeks aimed at finding alternative ways of giving Greece relief in light of opposition by creditors like Germany and the Netherlands to so-called haircuts that would involve forgiving some Greek debt."
New York Times: "Two of the most senior figures at the British Broadcasting Corporation said on Tuesday that there had been 'basic' and 'elementary' failures of the organization's journalism when it wrongly implicated a former Conservative Party politician in sexual abuse, compounding a scandal that cost the BBC's director general his job and plunged the organization deeper into crisis."
Guardian: "Europe's debt crisis remains a far bigger threat to the world's economy than the 'fiscal cliff', according to the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). In its latest report the economic think tank says an escalation in the ongoing European crisis could drag Europe into a deep recession in the next two years and the US along with it."
Reuters: "Online sales jumped on Cyber Monday, sending e-commerce retailers' shares higher and suggesting strong growth from earlier in the holiday shopping season is continuing for now. Sales on eBay Inc's online marketplace were particularly strong and Amazon.com Inc continued its rapid holiday shopping season growth, according to early Cyber Monday data...."
Reuters: "Forensic experts took samples from Yasser Arafat's buried corpse in the West Bank on Tuesday, trying to determine if he was murdered by Israeli agents using the hard-to-trace radioactive poison, Polonium."